Stunning New Twist: Savannah's Sister's Car Seized, Cameras Smashed | Nancy Guthrie Missing Update

Summary

---

Podcast Summary

Podcast: Drop Dead Serious with Ashleigh Banfield
Episode: Stunning New Twist: Savannah's Sister's Car Seized, Cameras Smashed | Nancy Guthrie Missing Update
Date: February 4, 2026
Host: Ashleigh Banfield
Special Guest: Brian Enten (NewsNation Correspondent)

---

Overview

This episode delves into the rapidly developing and unsettling disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie, in Tucson, Arizona. Ashleigh Banfield provides exclusive new law enforcement insights and on-site reporting, including evidence of forced entry, blood inside and outside the home, smashed Nest security cameras, and a critical update that Savannah’s sister’s car has been seized. The episode explores the clues, family dynamics, and investigative challenges at play, with NewsNation’s Brian Enten joining to discuss his live observations from the scene.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Crime Scene Evidence and Developments

• Smashed Cameras:
  • Nancy Guthrie had multiple Nest security cameras at her home. These were smashed, strongly suggesting a premeditated action by someone familiar with the property layout. (Banfield: "Whoever did this knew there were two smashed them." [27:05])
  • Police have seized the destroyed cameras as evidence.
• Blood at the Scene:
  • Blood has been confirmed both inside and outside of the home.
  • Brian Enten observed blood right outside the front door, near the doormat. (Enten: "You could see that there was blood right outside the front door on the ground..." [26:12])
  • Banfield’s law enforcement sources confirm blood inside the property as well, suggesting a violent struggle and forced abduction.
• Forced Entry, Ransacked Back Door:
  • Definitive reporting confirms forced entry into the home, with the back door found wide open after the incident. It is unclear whether it was used for entry or exit.
• Critical Digital Clue – Pacemaker Disconnect:
  • Nancy Guthrie’s pacemaker was paired by Bluetooth to her Apple Watch and iPhone. All devices separated from each other at 2:00 am, creating a precise timeline for the abduction.
    (Banfield: "The 2am separation...is the time they are narrowing down this kidnapping to." [09:45])
• House and Surrounding Area:
  • The home is in a rural, unlit, non-gated area with 1–4 acre lots, making visibility and surveillance difficult.

2. Family Under Scrutiny & New Suspect Focus

• Annie Guthrie’s Car Seized:
  • Police have impounded and taken as evidence the vehicle belonging to Annie Guthrie, Nancy’s daughter and Savannah’s sister. Annie was the last known person to see Nancy alive, dropping her off at 9:45 pm. [24:15]
• Prime Suspect – Son-in-Law Tomaso Sione:
  • Law enforcement sources indicate a sharp focus on Annie Guthrie’s husband, Tomaso Sione, as a potential prime suspect.
  • Banfield underscores this is standard investigative procedure but acknowledges the gravity, given the family ties and the level of focus:
    • "Thomas Oscione is the prime suspect in this case...law enforcement source tells me." [24:17]
  • The possible motive discussed includes insurance, financial difficulty, or debts—though these are musings, not confirmed facts.
• Family Dynamics and Public Silence:
  • Banfield remarks on Savannah Guthrie’s silence and absence from media, attributing it to shock, grief, possible police advice, and the need to avoid hindering the investigation. [43:01]

3. Ransom Notes and Media Attention

• Suspicious Ransom Notes:
  • Reports have surfaced of two "ransom notes," one sent to TMZ (email) and another to Tucson’s KOLD TV.
  • The notes included purported details about what Nancy was wearing and inside information, but authorities believe they are likely hoaxes from outsiders trying to insert themselves into the case.
  • Authorities are investigating all leads and have urged the public to send tips via a special QR code.
• Media & Community Role:
  • The case has attracted intense media attention and community response. Neighbors and work crews have been canvassed for information and possible security footage from the area.

4. Law Enforcement Operations and Challenges

• FBI Involvement:
  • The FBI is now officially involved, signifying the case’s complexity and seriousness.
• Helicopter and Search Efforts:
  • A sheriff’s helicopter and search/rescue vehicles were deployed over and around the property, searching fields and cactus-dense rural land after a potential tip.
• Difficulties in Obtaining Evidence:
  • Police are frustrated at delays in obtaining cloud footage from the Nest camera company, emphasizing how crucial this evidence is.
  • The absence of street lighting and the large, spread-out lots compound the challenge for investigators.
• Digital Forensics:
  • Investigators are pinging cell phones and geofencing electronic devices to identify anyone who was present in the area during the key window (around 2:00 am).
    (Enten: "That is the number one thing the FBI is doing right now..." [40:45])

5. Impact on Savannah Guthrie and Emotional Resonance

• Savannah’s Statement:
  • Savannah posted a heartfelt request for prayers to her Instagram, emphasizing her mother’s faith and the family’s hope.
  • (Savannah Guthrie via Instagram, as read by Today Show: "We believe in prayer...raise your prayers with us and believe with us that she will be lifted by them in this very moment." [16:47])
• Personal Toll:
  • Savannah has withdrawn from the Winter Olympics assignment, a major career event, to remain with her family during the crisis.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the Timeline for Abduction:
  • Banfield: "The 2am separation when the pacemaker stopped responding to the devices...is the time they are narrowing down this kidnapping to." [09:45]
• On the Nature of the Crime:
  • Banfield: "Whoever smashed those cameras, what will we see?...This isn't some random drug addict looking to rob a house. This is something far more premeditated." [11:36]
• On Law Enforcement’s Focus:
  • Banfield: "...my law enforcement source tells me that...Thomas Oscione is maybe a prime suspect in this case at this point." [24:17]
• On the Forensics & Search:
  • Enten: "You could see that there was blood right outside the front door on the ground...not a ton of blood, but it was definitely blood." [26:12]
• On Investigative Realities:
  • Enten: "This isn't like a normal neighborhood...it's pitch. We've got our lights on, but it's pitch black out here...it's a ways to the next house." [31:03]
• On Digital Forensics:
  • Enten: "They can literally narrow it down in such a way through the cell phone towers to who was right in this area and then try to follow that device...that's really what's going on behind the scenes." [40:45]
• On Family Impact:
  • Banfield: "Would you tow and impound the car of Savannah Guthrie's sister, of Nancy Guthrie's daughter, if there weren't something bigger to it? I mean, it's very loud. It's a very big move." [42:22]
• On Community Search:
  • Enten: "Police have been to all the neighbors' houses...even talking to the landscapers...people have been cooperating with the police for sure." [44:42]

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [01:05] – Ashleigh Banfield introduction and breaking information
• [07:30 – 10:40] – Pacemaker & digital forensics (Firm 2am timeline)
• [12:12 – 13:13] – Return from ad, focusing on key law enforcement moves
• [16:30 – 17:25] – Savannah Guthrie’s statement via Today Show
• [24:15 – 25:00] – Annie Guthrie’s car impounded; suspect focus on son-in-law
• [26:12 – 32:10] – Brian Enten on-site: Blood evidence, camera locations, and house description
• [32:47 – 35:30] – Law enforcement helicopter search and ransom notes discussion
• [40:45 – 42:00] – Digital forensics and police investigative strategies
• [44:42 – 46:37] – Community involvement; DNA evidence update
• [50:47 – 51:51] – Closing reflections on search difficulties and the investigation’s intensity

---

Conclusion

This episode is a gripping, minute-by-minute account of the Nancy Guthrie abduction case, full of breaking details and emotional resonance. Through expert analysis and first-hand observations, Ashleigh Banfield and Brian Enten uncover significant new clues and contextualize the investigative stakes. The focus on family, digital evidence, and the significance of premeditated actions makes for a tense and revealing update, with the investigation expected to evolve rapidly in the days ahead.

---

Transcript

[A]

The number one resolution for people last year was to save more money, but nearly half gave up by February. Don't let that be you. Download Rocket Money to reach your financial goals this year. Track your spending, cut waste and automate savings in one simple app. Rocket Money shows you all your expenses and categorizes them so you know exactly where your money's going and where you're overspending. From there, the app cuts waste by canceling your unused subscriptions and lowering your bills. No customer service needed. With that money freed up, the app will automatically set some cash aside for your goals. Whether it's an emergency fund, paying off debt or saving for vacation, Rocket Money's got you covered. Users love the app, with over 186,000 five star ratings, and on average, users can save up to $740 a year when using all of the app's premium features. Make saving money a priority this year. Go to rocketmoney.com cancel to get started. That's rocketmoney.com cancel rocketmoney.com cancel.

[B]

Hey everyone, I'm Ashley Banfield and this is drop dead serious. I have some breaking information on the kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie, Savannah Guthrie's mother, in Tucson, Arizona. I have spoken with an impeccable law enforcement source who has informed me with his knowledge of the investigation of some extraordinarily serious pieces of information about this crime scene. I can tell you that Mrs. Guthrie had cameras plural at this home and that they were smashed. You may have heard Brian Enten from News Nation talking earlier and asking Sheriff Chris Nanos a question in the news conference. And again today I'm recording on February 3rd, it's a Tuesday, the press conference. That was early in the day. Brian asked the sheriff, the camera on the front of the house is missing, and the sheriff said, we are trying to get into the companies that, you know, are proprietors of this kind of cloud information to get that, and said by today he did not have that information, did not have whatever was recorded. But I can tell you they are Nest cameras. They are Nest cameras, plural, and that whoever did this may have smashed those cameras, plural. So they're not there, presumably because law enforcement took those smashed cameras as evidence. I can also tell you I've got information about which door in the house was actually left open. There's been some erroneous reporting about some things. I now have the information about that I can tell you about blood in the house. I can confirm Brian Entin has some incredible reporting and pictures of blood outside the house. He's going to join me in a moment. We're going to talk about that. I can also take you whose car has been towed into evidence, and I can tell you that there is a family member who is being heavily looked at right now as a potential suspect. I'm going to bring that all to you in a moment. There's more information about Nancy's pacemaker. You probably have heard up until now that Nancy Guthrie had a pacemaker and it disconnected from her Apple devices, her Apple Watch, her Apple phone, which were left in the home at about 2 o' clock in the morning. And that is a significant time. And I will tell you why that it is extraordinarily instructive to this investigation in terms of narrowing to a window. I'll explain why in a moment. Don't think that the pacemaker stopped working because she died. That's not it. The separation of Bluetooth between the things that the pacemaker was linked to, the Apple watch and the phone, when they get out of range, you take your AirPods, you walk out, you leave an airtag behind, you get a notice, you, you're disconnected. That's more what this is about. But the timing of it is specific to narrow down the investigative window. So I'm going to get into all the details of all of these little pieces of information that I told you because I've just touched the tip of the iceberg. But I also want to get you up to speed on all the information that came out today from a few different sources. Number one, from the sheriff himself who held a news conference and answered questions, and then also from Brian Enten because he got some great information. And as I mentioned, he's going to be up in just a moment with me. We're going to talk about all his findings. So John Edwards is the assistant special agent in charge of the FBI in Tucson. He joined Sheriff Chris Nanos for the news conference today. Again, it's February 3rd, Tuesday, they held this update, but they didn't give a lot of information. They just said, basically this is to answer your questions in the press. And I can tell you that we found out this is not a gated community. Okay, that was one report that came out. It's not a gated community. It's also very dark and there are no street lights. So very hard to see anything that might have been driving up and down those roads. The properties are huge, right? They're anywhere between one and four acres each. So more rural. Think, don't think. City lit up. Neighbor to neighbor sees everything. Your ring Cam can see the street. It's not like that. Not everybody's ring. Cam can actually see the street from where they are on these big properties. The sheriff today said Nancy Guthrie's life is in jeopardy. Could be a couple reasons. He said that, number one, medications were left behind in the home. Medications that she would need within 24 hours could be fatal. And it's now 72 hours since the last time she was seen. So that could be why he said her life's in jeopardy. Or he could have said it because I now have definitive source information saying that there was in fact blood inside and outside the home. So blood inside the home is scary because we now know she was taken against her will. Kidnapped was what the sheriff told me last night when I did my episode before. So blood inside the home, kidnapped forcefully, taken forcefully. That could probably be part of the reason why her life is in jeopardy. And Brian Enten is going to show you the pictures of the blood outside the home that he discovered today as well. The media has helped generate a lot of leads. The sheriff said that's really important. He said if you've got any information, 1-800- call FBI. 1-800- call FBI if you know anything, even if it's tiny, the tiniest thing can lead to the biggest thing. Sheriff has said it's been helpful. They do not know what she was wearing when she was abducted, when she was kidnapped and taken from that home. They don't know if there were one or more kidnappers. Any indications she's still alive? Sheriff said, no idea. Can't tell you that. Is there a threat to the public? We were a little confused by the answer before. I think what he was trying to say was that we feel like this is an unusual circumstance. We don't think that this is going to be a serial kidnapping or whatever else has happened to Mrs. Guthrie. But there's someone out there that. That did this. So, yeah, the threat is out there. He's not going to go as far as they did in Idaho early on and say there's no threat to the public because Brian Coburger was out there for, you know, over six weeks, and he's a threat to the public. But it didn't feel like that. It didn't feel like there was no threat. It didn't feel like there was a big threat. So take that the way you will. Were there any valuables taken? ATM cards? Sheriff would not say. Sheriff wouldn't say. Was there forced entry? I can tell you definitively there was absolutely forced entry. The pacemaker information. They didn't want to talk a lot about it. But I will tell you my reporting. My source says that the 2am separation when the pacemaker stopped responding to the devices it was connected to the Apple phone, the Apple Watch. That is the time they are narrowing down this kidnapping to. Yes, she was Last seen at 9:45 but the kidnapping, they are pegging it to that moment because that is when the pacemaker that's inside the girl, the woman, the elderly mother who was taken out of that house, it's separated. And so that is what they are now narrowing the disappearance time down to. According to my law enforcement source with knowledge of this investigation. Pacemaker separates 2am that's when they believe the actual kidnapping happened. The house was turned back over to the family yesterday after 6pm Again that would be Monday, February 2nd. They processed everything. Crime scene tape went up, done with the residents turned back over to the family. But nobody washed the blood off the front steps up to the front door. And Brian Enten was able to go up and and look at it because it's not a crime scene anymore. You're going to talk to Brian in a moment about that. I think I mentioned this before but if I didn't. They are waiting for the camera information and very frustrated. Police are very frustrated by how long it's taking to get the Nest Company. I learned that it is the Nest Company. It's not Ring Cam. It's not. It's not Ring.com. it's Nest cameras that were out front that were smashed. They are waiting for, for the corporate Nest executives to yield that information back to the sheriffs. Listen, 72 hours. It's been a long time. I can understand why the sheriff would be frustrated that it's taking this long. This was at again 1:30 today. It's about seven hours ago. So that might have happened in the last seven hours. Maybe the sheriff has that camera information now and with those cameras being smashed. Right. That's evidence. All of that is evidence. Right. What was the tool used to smash them? What did it look like? All of that. And so when Brian Entin asked the sheriff the cameras are missing and the sheriff wouldn't go there. Clearly the police have taken those cameras smashed as evidence and those are now in in evidence lockup as part of this investigation. But again I can't reiterate enough how to dark this area is no street lights, dark and rural. Whoever smashed those cameras could very well have been completely cloaked and that may not help a lot. Maybe you'll See someone's gate? Maybe the exterior lights were off on the home. Who knows? Depends on what kind of nest cam she has. Does it show night vision? I mean, there's lots of different levels that you can get. Who knows what information that will yield. Whoever smashed those cameras, what will we see? What kind of, you know, right handed, left handed, walking up, what was the gait? Does it look like a man? Does it look like a woman? Hopefully. Hopefully that could have been ascertained before the cameras actually ended up being smashed. It's very, very disturbing because that is so completely planned, right? This isn't some random, you know, drug addict who's just looking to rob a house. This is something far more premeditated. If the cameras, plural, are smashed, whoever did this knew there was more than one. I am going to have all of this for you in exquisite detail in just a minute. I do have to just tell you this. I have sponsors that make this podcast possible. And I just want to tell you a little bit about my latest one because lately everything is feeling extraordinarily expensive and stressful. Air travel, gas, food, day to day life. But I've been getting a lot smarter about this. I'm fighting back. And if you're like me, I know you're watching your money a little more carefully. You've signed up for free trials and then you forgot about them until, boom, you get all these bills months later. Not good. That's why my new sponsor, Rocket Money, it's got your back. It's a personal finance app that helps you manage all of your money in one place. It tracks all the spending. It creates budgets that are yours for your life. And the fact that Rocket Money tracks my subscriptions so I can cancel them when I don't use them. It's been a lifesaver. Also tracks my spending habits so I can see where I'm wasting way too much money and then put it into that. And Rocket Money is free. Thank you. You can free free download. You can get started today. Just go to rocketmoney.com drop dead serious again, rocketmoney.com drop dead series and guess what? You can get the premium trial for absolutely free if you use my link, Rocketmoney.com drop dead series. Use that link, you get the premium for free. Again, premium rocketmoney.com drop deadserious. The link is down below as well. Get smart about your money.

[A]

The holidays are expensive. You're paying for gifts, travel, decorations, food, and before you know it, you've blown way past what you were planning to Spend don't start the new year off with bad money vibes. Download Rocket Money to stay on top of your finances. The app pulls your income, expenses and upcoming charges into one place so you can get the clearest picture of your money. It shows how much to set aside for bills and how much is safe to spend for the month so you can spend with confidence, no guesswork needed. Get alerts before bills hit. Track budgets and see every subscription you're paying for. Rocket Money also finds extra ways to save you money by canceling subscriptions you're not using and negotiating lower bills for you. On average, Rocket Money users can save up to $740 a year when using all of the app's premium features. Start the year off right by taking control of your finances. Go to rocketmoney.com cancel to get started. That's rocketmoney.com cancel rocketmoney.com cancel okay, back.

[B]

To the information on the case. The investigation is not yielding enough money for the sheriff to feel as though he needed to give more regular updates because he said, I'm not giving another one for two days. Not until Thursday, February 5th. Today's the Tuesday the 3rd, unless warranted. Unless something happens. Something happened today when Brian Enten was standing right out inside, outside in front of Nancy Guthrie's house. That was unique and interesting and may have been information tipped. I'll tell you that in a moment and I'll show you the pictures from the sky. There was a chopper up ahead, so I'll tell you that in just a moment. But it was super fascinating that the sheriff wouldn't confirm blood evidence, but Brian Enten confirmed it outside and I have confirmed it inside. There was blood inside the home. There was blood outside the home. So let me get to some of Brian Enten's amazing reporting as well before I give you a little bit more of what my law enforcement source has told me, especially about the prime suspect and the car that was towed. That's very, very distressing, Brian. Brian also learned about forced entry into the house and he learned of the two alleged ransom notes. We're going to talk at length about that. One went to tmz. One went to a local TV station in Tucson. We have thoughts. Lots of people have thoughts. The sheriff has some thoughts, apparently. But I'll talk to Brian about that in a moment and I will read for you what those are. I'm also going to tell you this, that the sheriff was concerned enough that he put out a statement with a QR code. Okay, let me read this Sheriff said, we are aware of reports circulating about possible ransom notes. Plural. It's ransom note, parentheses, S. So a note or notes. Regarding the investigation into Nancy Guthrie. We are taking all tips and leads very seriously. Anything that comes in goes directly to our direct. Our detectives who are coordinating with the FBI. We encourage anyone who may have information, any information or tips to share via this QR code. So he answered the question too, during the press conference when he was asked about, you know, were there ransom notes? Has anybody reached out to Savannah Guthrie or her family who takes an 84 year old woman? What's the point? It would seem like they'd want something. And he didn't say no. He just said the same thing that you just heard. We're looking at all leads. So they may have looked at the TMZ lead right before that press conference and they weren't ready to say whether the they thought it was legit or just some hoaxer. And maybe the Tucson TV station got one as well. I was a scam artist, born every day. So by the way, very illegal, very traceable. We'll get to that. Okay. Savannah put out a post today and the Today show. Obviously. This is their colleague. I'm a colleague of Savannah's. I worked with Savannah for years. We've been friends for years. We've done charity events together. She's dear, you know, she's very dear to me. And it's breaking my heart that she is down there where she grew up in Tucson, trying to find her mom. And she gave the Today show a statement about where they stand at this point. This is how the today show aired it.

[C]

Chanel is in for Savannah once again, who remains with her family in Arizona.

[D]

Good morning. And that is where we begin this morning, the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, Savannah's mother, beloved part of our Today family. Authorities in Arizona now saying the 84 year old appears to be the victim.

[B]

Of an abduction overnight.

[C]

Savannah posting this image on Instagram. Please pray. She went on to write, we believe in prayer. We believe in voices raised in unison, in love, in hope. We believe in goodness. We believe in humanity. Above all, we believe in him.

[D]

She added, thank you for lifting your prayers with ours for our beloved mom, our dearest Nancy, a woman of deep conviction, a good and faithful servant. Raise your prayers with us and believe with us that she will be lifted by them in this very moment. She goes on to say, we need you bring her home.

[B]

And obviously, Savannah's not on the Today show. She wasn't on yesterday either. And she will not be Going to Italy to do the Winter Olympics, this is huge for Savannah. This is every four years. It is one of the biggest assignments. The amount of prep that it takes to do the Olympics. It's weeks and weeks and weeks of work. And she is not going. And someone is going to have to take her place and get up to speed and cover for her. But how heartbreaking that is that she's not going to be able to do that and she will not be at the Winter Olympics at all for that coverage. Helicopters showed up above Brian Enten while he was doing a live report today above Nancy Guthrie's house. And it was the sheriff's helicopter. And there was a guy hanging out of it. And it was low. It was low enough to see him hanging out of it and looking around. And that wasn't the only emergency vehicle either. I'm going to tell you about that when I talk to Brian. It was another vehicle that was law enforcement related. And it does speak volumes to what might have happened that sent those. Those two vehicles out. The helicopter and the. And the pickup truck. Tell you that in a moment. First, let me tell you some devastating stuff. So my law enforcement source tells me that the back door of the Guthrie home was the door that was left wide open. Was it the point of entry? Was it the point of egress? Don't know that. But it was open, wide open. And it was in the back, not the front. Brian Enten saw blood at the front door. So did a struggle happen at the front door? Was there a doorbell rung at 2am why was the back door open? A lot of questions there. But the back door, according to my law enforcement source, was left wide open. I told you already, 100% blood inside the house. My law enforcement source told me that police have now towed and impounded the vehicle belonging to Nancy Guthrie's daughter, Annie Guthrie. This is important because you've heard that the last point of contact with Nancy Guthrie was when she was dropped off by her daughter at 9:45 ish at night on Saturday night. So Annie Guthrie and possibly her husband as well, Tomaso Sioni, were the last people to see her at 9:45 at night. Saturday night, Sunday morning, 11:00am, church members reached out to the family. Hey, your mom wasn't in church. Not normal. She's always there. What's up? Family member goes over, calls family member or members, goes to the house, calls 911 and the investigation begins. But they have towed Annie Guthrie's car and there is some connection to Annie Guthrie's Car. And Nancy Guthrie's son in law, that would be Annie's husband, Tomaso Sione, age 50, from Tucson, Arizona, married to Annie P. Guthrie, Savannah's sister. And my law enforcement source tells me that Thomas Oscione is the prime suspect in this case. Again, law enforcement source tells me that Nancy Guthrie's son in law, married to Annie Guthrie, Savannah's sister, is maybe, maybe a prime suspect in this case. At the very least, let me tamp that down because sometimes it's the first person you're looking at, not prime as in there's no one else. Okay, so let's be really mindful of that. Families are always looked at first as well. It doesn't mean right away. Listen, Ed Smart was targeted for weeks as without question, somebody they needed to look at. Possible suspect. Right? Heartbreaking for Ed and Lois Smart because it wasn't them who took Elizabeth. Right. But that's what happens when anything happens like this. Familial abductions the families looked at first. And Annie and or Thomas Oscione were the last people to see Nancy Guthrie at 9:45 at night. The night before she disappeared. Abducted. Kidnapped. Kidnapped was the word that the sheriff used with me. But it's very distressing to think that they. That this law enforcement source is telling me that Thomas Sione is maybe a prime suspect in this case at this point. And that the car belonging to Annie has been towed and impounded and is in evidence. That's the word that was used with me. This law enforcement source also said to me, who has the motive to kidnap an 84 year old woman? The way it was described to me is that's a burden. Right? It's a burden to kidnap an 84 year old woman with mobility issues, needing medication. That is a burden. And then this law enforcement source said. So you look at people who would have a benefit to an 84 year old woman going away, disappearing or dying. Sometimes it's somebody who has an insurance benefit from that. Sometimes it's somebody who may benefit because there's a debt. And that may be helpful. These are just musings. They are not evidence. Okay, but they are musings from people I trust implicitly due to their longevity in the business of investigating this exact kind of thing. I told you already about the pacemaker information. The law enforcement sources have narrowed it down to the kidnapping happening at 2am based on the pacemaker stopping at 2am that's when they believe Nancy was taken from that house. All forms of DNA were submitted. Right, but the sheriff himself Said that it came back, like. So far, the details that have come back have not pointed to a suspect, which tells them that it was likely Nancy's blood. Not a suspect. Or at least nothing has come back yet to point to a suspect. Regarding the blood, my law enforcement source said that they will be searching every single cell phone, ping the geofencing, all the rest of the. This source told me that this is someone who knew where the cameras were. Somebody who was familiar with this home, this premises, this woman. They knew where the cameras were in order to smash those nest. Cameras. Plural. Okay. And as far as the TMZ ransom note, my source says that they don't believe that this is real. They think it's just troublemakers trying to insert themselves into this story. Could that change? Yes. I just want to give you a little bit of information on Thomas Thomas Oscone, Annie Guthrie's husband, whom at this point I am told again, may be a prime suspect in this case. He's 50, from Tucson. His bio from a website that's an Italian website, an official Italian website for the Tapirulan Society Cultural Association. The Tapirulan Cultural Association, a nonprofit focused on promoting contemporary artists. His bio says, I was born in San giovanni Valdo on June 18, 1975. Since 2006, I have lived in Tucson, Arizona. I write when I have the chance. I study lizards, I play the electric bass, I make homemade pasta. LinkedIn reports that Thomas Oscione is a teacher at Basis Oro Valley School from 2007 until present. Says he's a primary instructor for 6th grade science and AP biology. Reverb Nation, that's a music website, says that he put out an album with a three man music group called Early Black Music is apparently available. But that's all I know about Annie Guthrie's husband, who again, one law enforcement source, very connected, highly regarded, impeccable credentials. Knowledge of this investigation says that Tomaso Sione, Annie P. Guthrie's husband, may be the prime suspect in this case. And Annie's vehicle has been towed, impounded, and is now in evidence. Very distressing. So Brian Enten is with me from News Nation. He's been doing some incredible work since landing on the ground in Tucson. Brian, you have done again, some outstanding reporting out in front of Nancy Guthrie's home when the crime scene was turned over to the family. You found a blood trail.

[E]

Yeah, we did. And I was kind of surprised, Ashley, that it was not a crime scene anymore. I don't know why. I just expected that they would still have some tape Outside, you know, when you cover these things, they'll have, like, one police car that stays behind. Everybody left. I mean, it was just empty, except there were some. What I thought were family members coming and going today. I don't know who they were. So we decided, like, let's just go knock on the door and see if anybody is home. You know, just kind of see what's going on. Since it's not a crime scene, it's all open back up. And so walking up to the front door, you could see that there was blood right outside the front door on the ground, like on the stoop right there, right near the front mat going in. Just, you know, not a ton of blood, but it was definitely blood. It was all right there. And then when you looked up, you could see where the. The camera was right by, like, almost like where it looked like a doorbell, but it was a camera, and the camera was. Was gone.

[B]

Well, and my information from my source is that those cameras were smashed. Not just the front one, there was a second one. Whoever did this knew there were two smashed them. So presumably the fact that you saw that they're gone means that they. The police took them for evidence.

[E]

Yeah. Well, what's interesting, though, is when I asked the sheriff, I was at the press conference, and I asked the sheriff, we noticed that the camera is gone in the front. Do you think the perpetrator took the camera? He said, we noticed that too. And all of that is under investigation. So it was kind of strange. Like, I don't. He didn't give me an answer, like, was it the perpetrator who took the camera? Was it the police who took the camera? He just. But he acknowledged that they also noticed that the camera was gone.

[B]

I think he's having to answer in real time to, you know, investigative information and evidence that he doesn't want out there, probably. And having to, you know, tap dance in front of live cameras, which is really hard. I mean, this is a small place. Tucson has barely had, you know, massive crime. I think one of the biggest things was Gabby Giffords, like, what, 15, 20 years ago. So it's been. This is a lot. This is a big crime for them to process. And the media attention is sort of stifling. You know, it's really, really hard. Let's just talk a little bit about that blood trail a little bit before we go more into the cameras. But you find the blood trail at the front door. The front door is closed. At least it is now. My law enforcement source has told me the back door Was wide open, which sort of gives you just so many questions. Is that where perpetrator came in? Is that where the perpetrator went out with Mrs. Guthrie? Did Mrs. Guthrie answer the front door at 2am and there was a pitched fight and that's why the blood is there? Because I think you mentioned the blood doesn't go further out along the stones to the driveway.

[E]

Yeah, that's right. We looked and it was just in that area near the door. It's not like there were droplets that went out to where the driveway is or even in the driveway, which made me think. I mean, did they take Ms. Guthrie out the front and like you said, the back door being open, Maybe they came in the back and took her out the front and into a car, and maybe that's why the blood just stopped right there. We just don't know.

[B]

I will tell you this. In my half hour long conversation with the sheriff last night, he said. I said, so you think that perhaps when you say Mrs. Guthrie was taken out of that home, she did not walk out of that home. Are you telling me she was carried over the threshold of the front door? And he said, I did not say the front door. So that was a clue to me. Wait, okay. Not the front door. And then I learned today that the back door is open. So I am very curious. There were some erroneous reports about Mrs. Guthrie was dragged from her bed. The sheriff actually put out a statement saying, that is not what I said. So we, you know, at this point, the sheriff was walking back. Anybody who reported she was dragged from her bed. We don't know if the bedroom was, you know, the epicenter of this crime yet. We don't know if there's ding dong, ding dong, ding dong. And Mrs. Guthrie comes down at two in the morning. What's going on? And so something happens at the front. But why then would the back door be wide open? It's just. It's very, very confounding. Why would the blood be in the front but the back door's open? Or did they, like you said, come in the back door, go up to the bedroom, but then take her out the front?

[E]

Yeah, and I'm just looking behind me because there's. So there's more cars in the driveway now. Step out of the way. You see that white Volvo. And then there's a. There's a truck. I think they maybe brought security people in to just kind of keep an eye on the house. But one thing that you don't know until you're here I didn't realize is this isn't like a normal neighborhood, Ashley. It's right in the foothills. Every house is, I would say, is on at least an acre, maybe two, three or four acres. They're almost like little ranches. And it's pitch we've got our lights on for, you know, because we're doing our camera work. But it's pitch black out here. There is not one light out here. And, you know, it's a ways to the next house. So I'm just thinking if. If they came in through the back door.

[F]

Want to feel more confident with your finances this year? If you have 60 seconds, I can show you how quick and easy it is to start building healthy money habits that could last you the entire year just by using Rocket Money. Step one, download Rocket Money. Step two, link all your accounts and see your entire spending picture. Your subscriptions, your upcoming bills, your due dates, everything. Step three, tap a subscription you don't use and cancel it. Boom. That's money back every single month. Step four, create a financial goal for something you want to save for. Whether it be a vacation, a retirement account, or a pet's birthday. We don't judge. Now let the app automatically move small amounts of cash towards your goal. In a month, you'll see real dollars piling up. In a year, you'll be shocked at how much money you saved, similar to the over 10 million members on the app that have saved up to $740 a year. When using all of the app's premium features, use the savings challenge as one step closer to feeling better about your finances. [e-mail] Cancel. That's RocketMoney.com Cancel one more time, it's RocketMoney.com Cancel to leave to take her.

[E]

Out the back door, though, it's not like there'd be a little alley back there. I mean, there's like, cactus. This is not. It's like kind of wild land out here. You know what I mean?

[B]

Yeah. But whoever smashed the cameras maybe thought it would be an easier way to get in the back door to smash a camera without being seen. Go in the back and then maybe smash the front camera from the inside of the house coming out. Who knows? I mean, but whoever it was, my law enforcement source said they knew there were those cameras and where they were in order to smash them. We're getting to that in a bit, but helicopters overhead while you were doing your live shot earlier today. Talk to me about that.

[E]

Yeah, that kind of came out of nowhere. All of a Sudden, there was a sheriff helicopter that got very, very low over the house with two men looking out and down. And my first thought was, like, oh, sometimes they'll just kind of come by to come look real quick, and then they'll leave. But they stayed for over an hour over the house and then across the street and then in, like, kind of. Again, it's almost like fields out here, but with a lot of cactuses in the vicinity of the house. Very low. Looking around. And then we saw a search and rescue truck out here, which we hadn't seen all day. So I don't know if there was kind of like, hey, we left some stone unturned, and we just want to go back out and look one more time, or if there was a specific tip that came in, something specific that they were looking for. But it was very clear that they were looking for something again. At first I thought, like, oh, the helicopter's doing a pass. You know, the sheriff's office just wants to show that they're keeping an eye on the area. But, no, they were searching for something.

[B]

Yeah. And I think Jennifer Coffendoffer mentioned they might have gotten called a tip, and they were out trying to find whatever it was they thought might be within the vicinity of the house. Or maybe they thought whoever took her couldn't manage for too long. And maybe there was something in the wilds. Like you said, it's pretty rural out there. The other thing that's upsetting, and I don't want to think this, is that, you know, if you're going to leave a body somewhere, there are so many wild animals in that area at night, it's very, very hard to keep the integrity of a potential body, if there is one, you know, intact for a long time with all the wildlife. And let's hope that that's not the situation. The ransom notes. Let's talk a little bit about that one to tmz that was detailed about what she was wearing, details inside the house, and then asking for bitcoin, and another one to a local TV station. Let me see which one it is. I think it's KOLD TV in Tucson. Kold? Yeah. My law enforcement source says he's not putting a lot of stock in that. There's a lot of crazies out there that want to insert themselves. But what are you hearing from where you are? Yeah.

[E]

So you mentioned with the TMZ note, we learned that in the note there were some specifics about what Nancy was wearing and then specifics about the inside of the House. But we don't know if those are true. I mean, like, that was just coming from tmz. We don't know if it actually, you know, is gonna check out with what she was actually wearing.

[B]

Yeah, like, TMZ got it. Like, TMZ got that.

[E]

And it was an email, by the way.

[B]

In an email. Right, exactly. But is it just some, you know, lunatic who's gonna be traced to charged, you know? And also, the sheriff said that they don't know what she was wearing, so how could the. Anyway, that's part of the idea here is that emails can be traced.

[E]

Yeah, they can be traced. I don't know. I think the whole thing is a little weird. Like, why would the kidnapper reach out to tmz? And then I noticed that tmz, Harvey Levin, was saying they were having a hard time getting in touch with the sheriff initially, which I just found to be kind of strange if the sheriff was taking it that seriously. But the sheriff's office did put out a statement later saying. Acknowledging these and saying that they were investigating. Yeah, there it is. And when I was at the press conference earlier, we asked, have there been any ransom notes? And I thought it was interesting. Again, the sheriff didn't answer the question. He just said, we're looking into every. And yesterday, he was much more open, actually. I mean, you had him on your podcast. He was all over the place. He was answering every question. He was kind of, like, hard to follow it sometimes. And, like, he was talking about his gut feeling about things, and I'm like, is it really what he's saying actually factors? Anyway. But today he was much, much more careful.

[B]

Yeah. And obviously, like I said before, they're a little bit new at this. I mean, they don't get this kind of stuff going on in this rural in Pima county, but, you know, upsetting just to think that somebody, if it's true, may be trying to insert themselves. Let's get to some of the other breaking stuff that my source told me that's just kind of blood curdling, that they did indeed find blood inside the house. You found the blood outside the house. The confirmation from my law enforcement sources that there was blood inside the house as well, and that they have towed Annie Guthrie's car. Annie Guthrie being Savannah Guthrie's sister and the last person to have dropped Mrs. Guthrie off at 9:45 the night before, but that they have towed and impounded her car into evidence. That is sort of. The ground shook when I learned that.

[E]

That's interesting, because we had heard that the FBI was at the sister's house, the Savannah sister's house, earlier tonight. In terms, I hadn't heard the towing of the car and I just kind of assumed like they were over there talking to them, trying to get more information about, you know, what was going on in Nancy's life in the days up to this. But yeah, the towing of the car. I'm trying to sort of wrap my mind around the reasons that they may have done that.

[B]

I mean, I guess I can understand. I'm trying to think of all the reasons why it's not a big deal. And it's the last person to have seen Nancy Guthrie, my law enforcement source says, who takes an 84 year old woman with limited mobility, it's a burden for the kidnapper to do so. Unless someone has a vested interest in gaining something from it like insurance benefits or a family debt that needs paid off, anything like that. This was just the musings, not the evidence of this investigator. But the other sort of earth shattering information that this source told me is that Nancy Guthrie's son in law, Annie's husband Thomas Oscione, is now may be considered prime suspect in this case.

[E]

Wow. Yeah. So I haven't heard the most, like I said, the most I heard was that the FBI was at their house earlier today. I haven't heard, heard that at all. I don't know much about them. I mean, I think they were the last ones with her. Right. On Friday night two or four, Annie.

[B]

Dropped her off or that Annie and Tomaso dropped her off. It's a little unclear but, but this law enforcement source specifically pointed to her car being towed, impounded and in evidence. And the son in law, Tomaso Sione, age 50, may be the prime suspect in the case.

[E]

Well, and it would make sense even if they hopefully did absolutely nothing wrong. And this is their mom. And it's like makes your heart hurt. I mean I feel terrible for everyone in the family, but it would make sense that they don't want to leave any stone unturned. So even if investigators are thinking like we don't think these people had anything to do with it, but the fact that they were the last ones with her, she was in that car the night before. You know, like maybe they're just going to check everything regardless and that, you.

[B]

Know, they, you know, my, my source said there's a lot of familiarity. This, this, this kidnapper had a lot of familiarity with this home, with the two different nest cams that were smashed and you know, that they said an 84 year old woman with limited mobility is not an easy person to kidnap. There has to be a benefit in some way. You think about a break in. No, you've, you've caught me breaking into your house now you've seen me. Well, you don't typically kill someone and take the body or take the live person with you. That's not usually how a burglary that's foiled ends. It's, it's far more complicated and odd. The mystery is, is more is more. It just takes you in a different direction. Your thoughts? Anyway, the other thing is that my source said they are obviously looking at all cell phone pings and geofencing to find out what was in that neighborhood. This is the kind of thing that, you know, trips up just about anybody. It may have tripped up Dr. Michael McKee in the TEPE murders. He left his phone in the hospital, but the car was seen. You know, Bryan Coburger shuts his phone off right as he's leaving and shuts, puts his phone back on right as he's returning home. Right around the times of the murders. These are things that some people just don't think about.

[E]

Yeah, and it's not just phones. I was talking to a FBI agent who just retired actually from this area earlier and he was reminding me that, you know, it's iPads, it's like all sorts, it's iWatch, it's all sorts of electronics now. Yeah. That can, that can track you. And he was emphasizing to me that that is the number one thing that the FBI is doing right now and that they can literally like narrow it down in such a way through the cell phone towers to who was right in this area and then try to follow that device. And he thinks that's really what's going on behind the scenes right now. And there's also just like questions about do they have a suspect that we just don't know about. I mean, I was thinking back to Bryan Coburger earlier when you and I were talking every night and it was like, gosh, these police, they don't seem like they know anything and then come to find out they knew a lot. You know, are they just. Do they just have their poker face on in these press conferences and they.

[B]

Actually know a lot and, and it's true, they do. I mean that, that has to be. We, we have to be kept in the dark about things because they've got to keep the suspect in the dark about a lot of things. You know, super interesting though. You know, just about the fact that family members are always number one. Like I. I mentioned earlier in the podcast, Ed Smart. Ed smart was like, one of the number one, you know, suspects in the disappearance of his daughter Elizabeth, because does the boogeyman really come into your house and steal your daughter out of her bed beside her little sister? I doubt it. Well, he did. You know, the. The boogeyman did come in. Brian David Mitchell did come in and steal Elizabeth, and it wasn't that smart. But the way law enforcement works is you have to start from the inside of the concentric circles and then work out to any potential other suspect. So if. If this ends up being prime suspect, but not the only one, and we're just eliminating him. Eliminating him, that. That could definitely be the case. But I also feel like. Like, would you tow and impound the car of Savannah Guthrie's sister, of Nancy Guthrie's daughter? And if there weren't something bigger to it? I mean, it's very loud. It's a very big move.

[E]

Do you think it's strange? And you're more. I mean, you've been in the bigger media world more than I have. Like, do you think it's strange that Savannah Guthrie hasn't said anything? I mean, could that be an indication of maybe some drama in the family behind the scenes?

[B]

You know, so many things could be happening there. If I were in Savannah shoes, I would be mute. I would be, you know, catatonic. You're a big media person. This massive thing is swirling around you. You don't even know what to say and what not to say. You have a million friends in the media business. Everybody wants a comment from you. And the police may have just said, we'd like you not to say anything. And I know Savannah. Savannah is a lawyer. She is a long studied crime reporter. I met her at Court tv. We worked together at Court tv. She is brilliant. And so Savannah will be doing the smartest things to aid in this investigation. She will do everything that the police are asking her to do, and she will not go rogue. I know that. And I don't know, the other aspect of that is that if the FBI was over at Annie's house. House, They've towed her car. They're looking at her husband. If I were Savannah. Yeah, that would be enough for me to just say I need to just stay out of the limelight. I need to stay out of everything.

[E]

Yeah, it makes sense. I was just wondering about that because if. If there is a family dynamic here, might be a reason for her to like you. Said just sort of stay quiet. Although I hate to even think that. I mean, I hope that's not the case. I know you have your source, but it's like, you know, gosh, that's just terrible.

[B]

I was interviewing Ed Smart and Lois and having to ask them about that, it was. It was awful and so awkward and so uncomfortable. But I do understand it's how law enforcement has to work. They can't ignore that or they wouldn't be doing their jobs. What about the neighbors? Have you heard from anybody out there?

[E]

Yeah, we've talked to several neighbors. You know, people loved Nancy. We're hearing a lot of that. I mean, she lived here since the early 90s. I think 1992 is when she moved in, which a lot of people were saying, oh, Savannah probably bought her the house. It's a really nice house. I mean, apparently not because she's lived here for a long time. So a lot of people know her and people are on edge about the whole thing. The police have been to all of the neighbors houses. There was one neighbor who told me police had been there twice looking for videos. So it seems like we've done other stories where you show up and you're kind of surprised. Gosh, how are we the first ones here? That doesn't seem like the case here. People have been going to all the different neighbors houses. There was one neighbor who told me that they were even trying to talk to the landscapers because there's a lot. I mean, they're really nice houses out here and there's a lot of like landscape crews and stuff. So they were talking to them because they kind of know the area. So yeah, it's. People have been cooperating with the police for sure.

[B]

Well, I remember a case, Nancy Woodrum in Paso Robles, California, well over a decade ago, elderly woman disappeared from her home. It was very. This sort of freaked me out a little because it seemed so similar. But it ended up being a painter that worked at the house. So they will be canvassing and I think the sheriff. Sheriff did say that to me. They're canvassing every single person from caretakers to landscapers, to pool, you know, service contractors, etc. Anybody who had any kind of connection at that house, that would be absolutely number one. They would do that right away and get alibis and check for DNA. The other interesting thing is, Brian, that the sheriff today said that they have tested some of the DNA that was discovered at the house, but that nothing that's come back so far has indicated a suspect effect.

[E]

Right they confirmed that the DNA connected back to Nancy, which I guess is no real surprise. She lived in the house. But they wouldn't say what if it was that blood that was tested? Was that blood outside that was tested? I do, too. I do, too. But they didn't confirm it.

[B]

I mean, you're seeing blood outside that's fairly. It's still red. I could see your video still red. You're testing that. You're testing that right away. Because what if there was a pitched fight and a knife was being used and, you know, the assailant was cut? There'd be mixed blood. So that would be the first thing that. But it was devastating to hear that. So far, nothing's come back indicating a suspect. This is going to be a hard one. This will be a really, really hard one. Like you said, it's so dark out there and so rural, and it's not like a lot of ring cameras and license plate readers are going to lead to whatever vehicle. And I do say vehicle. Nancy Guthrie couldn't move more than 50 yards on her own. She needed to be conveyed in some kind of a vehicle.

[E]

I wonder if they already have a vehicle description, because, you know, with the FBI being involved so early, and there are traffic cameras out, like, on the main road out here, and they're just not giving it to us at this point for a specific reason.

[B]

I wouldn't doubt it. I mean, they're going to look at every single vehicle that was in that area and find out who they were, where they were, who they were with. You know, that's not tricky. That's what led us to Dr. Michael McKee in the TEPE murders. You know.

[E]

Yeah.

[B]

What am I missing?

[E]

I think you covered it pretty well. I mean, we hit the ransom. You know, the blood is really alarming. The cameras, which you had new information on. You know, I don't know if you caught the press conference, Ashley. It was.

[B]

I did.

[E]

It was a little strange. I mean, there was not a lot of new information. The FBI was there for the first time. They had the special agent in charge of Tucson who was there along with the sheriff. The FBI was not there yesterday. I thought it was. I don't know. I thought it was interesting. The sheriff started by saying, well, I said some things maybe I shouldn't have said yesterday. And, you know, I had to do all these interviews as kind of. It was just kind of strange. I thought, like you said, I guess they don't deal with that a lot here. And then I thought it was interesting that he Said next press conference will be Thursday.

[B]

That's right, yeah. No updates unless needed.

[E]

Correct. And I was just like, okay, like kind of like, kind of like nothing to see here, everybody. It's just a little odd.

[B]

I thought, you know what, I thought it was strange when he said no updates until Thursday and like unless and until something happens. And then when I got my information from my law enforcement source, I thought, oh yeah, maybe it's because you do have your prime suspect and that's why you're saying we don't need to do any updates right now. I, I don't know. Again, it's a great, impeccable source that I have. Extraordinarily connected to this. So. And, and somebody who's very high in law enforcement too, so I don't have any reason not to not to believe that. Oh, I do want to mention that there was dispatch, which was super interesting dispatch audio that was like dispatch talking to responding units. Nancy, a white female, 84 years of age, 5C, medium build, fiber blue. Nancy, has high blood pressure, pacemaker and cardiac issues, saying that there was high blood pressure medication, a pacemaker and cardiac issues. So they seemed to know right away, even as they. Before they got there, that there was some medical issue with this missing person. Maybe that came from family. Yeah, really interesting.

[E]

You've heard, right, about the pacemaker connecting to the iWatch and she was charging her iWatch in the room and they were able to review the data in the iWatch and the last time the pacemaker connected to the iWatch was at 2am so that's sort of how they've been able to. I just want to look again and see what it.

[B]

Yeah, it's interesting.

[E]

This must be security out here and.

[B]

Taking pictures just to say what things look like out there. The. My source said to me that the separation from the pacemaker at 2am is the time of abduction. That's what the police believe. They, they would. They refused to narrow the window for us in the press conference today, but my law enforcement source said, yes, it's 2:00am that's when they believe she was abducted, slash kidnapped. The sheriff said kidnapped. To me, I don't think there's a big difference. And that they believe that it absolutely happened at 2:00 in the morning.

[E]

Yeah, which would make sense. And again, just as dark as it is out here, I'll just show you like if I pick up my camera, my phone or my. I mean we have all our lights but look like down the street. Ashley, it's like you can see what it's like out here. It's like, totally pitch black.

[B]

So only thing you can see are the vehicle. That's it?

[E]

Yeah, that's it. Yeah.

[B]

Makes it real hard for an investigation. Brian. My God. Well, listen, you were unbelievable today in what you were able to. I mean, I think the blood trail is some of the biggest news that's come out of this, as well as the notion that Annie and Tomaso's vehicle is being, you know, has been impounded, is in evidence, and that they may be considering him a prime suspect. It's just. It's very disturbing. It's very distressing. But listen, thank you, because I know you're so busy. Every single show on News Nation you've been on and updating them all and just getting that. Your crew out there, fantastic. Dave and Mo, congratulate them for the work they're doing as well. Thank you, Brian. I appreciate this.

[E]

Yeah. It's always good to see you, Ashley. I'll see you soon. Probably tomorrow. All right.