Economic Update with Richard D. Wolff: Episode Summary
Title: Unlearning Market Idolatry
Release Date: April 8, 2025
Host: Richard D. Wolff
Produced by: Democracy at Work
Introduction
In the episode titled "Unlearning Market Idolatry," Richard D. Wolff delves into the pervasive reverence for market systems in contemporary economic thought. He challenges the notion that markets are infallible institutions, arguing that this idolization hampers rational discourse and effective problem-solving regarding economic issues.
Unlearning Market Idolatry
Wolff begins by defining "market idolatry" as the uncritical celebration of markets as the ultimate economic institutions. He draws a parallel with religious idolatry, suggesting that markets are venerated beyond reason, which obstructs meaningful debates on economic reforms.
"By idolatry, I mean what that word means in religion when you are quote, unquote, praying to false gods."
— Richard Wolff [00:20]
He asserts that this glorification is detrimental, preventing society from addressing real economic problems and exploring viable solutions.
Historical Perspective: The Keynesian Period
Wolff provides a historical overview, highlighting the shift from market orthodoxy to Keynesianism during the Great Depression and extending into the 1970s. He credits John Maynard Keynes for challenging the notion that markets, left unchecked, lead to prosperity.
"John Maynard Keynes ... wrote it all down and said it's not true, the market, left to itself, produces the depression we're in."
— Richard Wolff [01:30]
Keynes advocated for government intervention to stabilize the economy, addressing issues like unemployment and business failures. This period saw diminished discussions on the "perfect market" as government policies took precedence in economic planning.
Resurgence of Market Idolatry: Reagan and Thatcher Era
Wolff traces the resurgence of market idolization to the policies of Ronald Reagan in the United States and Margaret Thatcher in the United Kingdom during the 1970s. This era marked a return to celebrating markets as superior institutions, sidelining Keynesian interventions.
"For some reason, and that's what I'm going to get to in a moment, it came back with Reagan and Thatcher in England."
— Richard Wolff [07:45]
This shift re-emphasized the market's role in driving economic growth and prosperity, a stance Wolff critiques as flawed.
The Enterprise-Market Relationship
Wolff examines the relationship between private enterprises and markets. He explains that businesses operate primarily to generate profit, interacting with markets through production and consumption dynamics.
"They interact in a market with one another and with all of us. They interact with us because we buy what they produce."
— Richard Wolff [08:50]
He highlights that only a small fraction (3%) of the population owns and runs businesses, while the majority (97%) are employees. This imbalance raises concerns about whose interests markets truly serve.
"Once according to the US Census, the number of employers ... is 3% of our people."
— Richard Wolff [13:20]
Wolff argues that markets inherently favor the wealthy, leading to increased inequality and favoritism towards the rich in allocating scarce resources.
Critique of the 'Free Market' Myth
A significant portion of the episode dismantles the myth of the "free market." Wolff contends that truly free markets have never existed; instead, governments have always influenced market operations through regulations and interventions.
"You never have. Governments have always shaped markets, always, one way or another, openly, secretly, both, usually."
— Richard Wolff [20:15]
He uses relatable analogies, such as a Thanksgiving dinner, to illustrate how non-market values like love override market transactions within families, suggesting that markets are unsuitable for all aspects of life.
Government Interventions and Market Imperfections
Wolff discusses how government interventions are not anomalies but integral to market operations. He points out that regulations like minimum wage laws and safety standards exist because unfettered markets can lead to detrimental outcomes.
"There's a reason why we have a minimum wage ... you were buying bad meat and taking dangerous drugs. They were profitable and that's why they were being produced."
— Richard Wolff [26:55]
He warns against deregulation efforts, citing current political figures like Donald Trump, who advocate for reduced government oversight. Wolff argues that such moves could reverse the protective measures that prevent market excesses and ensure fair treatment.
The Illusion of the Free Market Among Conservatives
Wolff critiques conservatives who advocate for free markets while simultaneously supporting government interventions like tariffs, which contradict the free market ideology.
"The very Republicans in power now ... they want the market. And yet what is a tariff? ... they're not free market."
— Richard Wolff [33:40]
He highlights the hypocrisy in advocating for market purity while engaging in protective government policies that distort market dynamics.
Advertising and Market Manipulation
The role of advertising is scrutinized as a tool for market manipulation. Wolff explains how advertising shapes consumer behavior and creates artificial demand, benefiting businesses rather than genuinely serving consumer needs.
"The whole industry of advertising is there to manipulate the market."
— Richard Wolff [28:30]
This manipulation perpetuates the illusion that markets are self-regulating and beneficial for all, when in reality, they often prioritize corporate profits over consumer welfare.
Conclusion: Towards Democratic Enterprises
Wolff concludes by envisioning an alternative economic system where workplaces are democratized. He advocates for "democracy at the workplace," where employees have equal say in decision-making processes, production choices, and profit distribution.
"Have democracy at the workplace. Everybody who works at the factory or the office or the store ... decides what we produce, how we do it, ... and what we do with the proceeds."
— Richard Wolff [40:05]
He posits that such a system would address the systemic issues perpetuated by market idolatry, fostering a more equitable and just economic landscape.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
"Celebrating the market is a terrible mistake and it's costly."
— Richard Wolff [00:58] -
"Markets are for them. They are not for you."
— Richard Wolff [17:35] -
"The free market is a phantom. The whole industry of advertising is there to manipulate the market."
— Richard Wolff [28:30] -
"Our problems are right here at home in our economic system. We don't need it, we shouldn't want it, and we can do better."
— Richard Wolff [39:50]
Final Thoughts
Richard D. Wolff's "Unlearning Market Idolatry" offers a critical examination of the entrenched belief in market supremacy. By tracing historical shifts, exposing inherent inequalities, and challenging the legitimacy of the free market myth, Wolff urges listeners to reconsider the foundational structures of their economic system. He advocates for democratizing workplaces as a pathway to a more equitable and responsive economy, encouraging a move away from profit-driven market ideologies towards collective decision-making and ownership.
For more insights and detailed discussions, listeners are encouraged to access the Economic Update with Richard D. Wolff series and explore Wolff's companion book, Understanding Capitalism, available through Democracy at Work's website.