Loading summary
Transcript168 lines
- [00:01]
William Drimple
If you want access to bonus episodes.
- [00:03]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Reading lists for every series of Empire.
- [00:05]
William Drimple
A chat community, discounts for all the books mentioned in the week's podcast ad.
- [00:10]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Free listening and a weekly newsletter, sign up to empire club@www.empirepoduk.com.
- [00:22]
This episode is brought to you by the American Revolution on pbs. It began with voices carried on the wind, arguments in taverns, whispers at kitchen tables, the tramp of boots on muddy fields. From sparks kindled in America grew an upheaval that shook an empire, gave birth to a nation, and altered the course of history. Ken Burns landmark PBS series the American Revolution casts the familiar in a new light, illuminating stories left in shadow. The American Revolution is more than history. It's an exploration of the United States at its founding, its people, values, families and its place in the world. The choices of past and present are woven into the same fabric. As the United states nears its 250th year, these stories remind us that the revolution is not history pressed between pages, but a force still shaping the world today. The American Revolution premieres on Sunday, November 16th on PBS and the PBS app.
- [01:30]
This episode is brought to you by Spotify Portal for Backstage. But you're wondering, what's Portal? Well, it's an internal developer portal built to improve developer experience and boost productivity. All software components are centralized. Documentation is automated and easy to maintain. New projects and components just a few clicks. With your best practices already built in, think less friction, more innovation. Ready to double your productivity? Try Spotify portal at backstage.Spotify.com.
- [02:01]
When the holidays start to feel a bit repetitive, reach for a Sprite Winter Spiced Cranberry and put your twist on tradition. A bold cranberry and winter Spice Flavor Fusion Sprite Winter Spice Cranberry is a refreshing way to shake things up. This sip and season, and only for a limited time. Sprite obey your thirst.
- [02:33]
Anita Anand
Hello and welcome to Empire with me.
- [02:35]
William Drimple
Anita Arnand and me, William Drimple, who's very pleased not to be on my own anymore and able to talk to Anita about Kipling, which we've missed in the last two episodes.
- [02:44]
Anita Anand
I'm sorry about that. I had a little break at an NHS spa retreat. No, I was in hospital for a little while, but I'm all better now. Well done for carrying on without me.
- [02:53]
William Drimple
You're looking very perky.
- [02:55]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Oh, well, I'm glad.
- [02:56]
William Drimple
It was horrible. It was horrible not having you there, particularly for this episode, which is actually an episode that we have talked about since. Since the very days we were planning this podcast Three years ago, having to do it on my own. Felt very upset.
- [03:06]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Aw. Well, I'm here now.
- [03:08]
William Drimple
Very irritatingly, you're back at the episode, which actually proves your point rather than mine.
- [03:13]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Oh.
- [03:14]
Anita Anand
Oh, good. I feel better and better by the minute.
- [03:16]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Okay, good.
- [03:17]
Anita Anand
Tell me what I missed. What did I miss?
- [03:19]
William Drimple
So in the first part, we talked about young Kipling, and that's the one you really should have been there for, because you would have fallen for the young ruddy Kipling as he gets horribly abused by sort of imposed foster parents in a house in the southeast of England where he sells, sent back from his gorgeous childhood in India and is tortured by this horrible Dwardian couple. And he writes one of the most moving stories of abused childhood. Baba, Black Sheep. And that would have won my argument for me. Unfortunately, you're coming in now. Later in the story, we've moved through the period of him as a young journalist in India, learning his trade and writing his first satirical short stories about the British misbehaving in hill stations in India. And we've done this odd period when he moves improbably to Vermont in the US and it's there in America that he writes his two, in a sense, most famous Indian books, Kim and the Jungle Book, both of which are quite similar stories in that they both have these sort of Kipling inspired figures who are outsiders in India. Mowgli, the kid brought up in the jungle. And then we had the story of Kim, which is this gorgeous evocation of India and the Grand Trunk Road and all the different varieties of life of India, the great river of life written in his great masterpiece, Kim. But sadly, you're coming back for the bit which is the least defensible bit.
- [04:44]
Anita Anand
Of Kipling's life, the least edifying chapter in his story. Uh huh.
- [04:48]
William Drimple
When Kipling returns to England from Vermont and gets sort of recruited as, in a sense, the jingoistic pro empire, pro conquest, it's not too much to say white supremacist. He becomes the acolyte of Cecil Rhodes. And all the most indefensible bits of Kipling's life when he, for example, hates Mahatma Gandhi and supports General Dyer after the Gillian Waller massacre. Everything that would absolutely confirm every prejudice you've ever had against Kipling is to come in this episode. I'm not even going to attempt to defend him at all in this because this is the Kipling that future generations will abhor and dislike. But yet, even here, there is a moment of semi redemption at the end. And we will come to the Story of my boy Jack.
- [05:32]
Anita Anand
Well, we shall see how much redemption there is. Let's see.
- [05:36]
William Drimple
You don't seem to be in a very redeeming mood and I totally. I mean, this part of his life is not identified, but it's interesting and important and it shows Kipling as the laureate of empire. Actually, there's no other way for it. This was Kipling in middle age and later in life when he becomes the great defender and bard of British imperialism. And it's an episode that is very, very foreign to us today and we have to try and the world that created it while disliking everything really that it represents. There's many defences of Kipling as a writer one can make, but nothing much in this episode really is defensible other than my favourite of all, which is his just so stories, which I grew up on and still love his stories about, particularly the Cat that Walked On Its Own. And we'll read that as the one nice moment in this rather dark part of the story. Anyway, the story begins with Kipling leaving Vermont. We saw in the last episode how he fell out with his brother in law. He has an American wife and he falls out with his brother in law and things get a bit test in Vermont. So he decides to move back and of all places, improbably, Kipling moves to Torquay. Oh, which unsurprisingly so for those people.
- [06:45]
Anita Anand
Who don't know Britain and we've got many listeners in the United States and our struggle.
- [06:50]
William Drimple
Explain Torquay, Anita.
- [06:51]
Anita Anand
Well, I can explain it in two words. Basil and Fawlty.
- [06:54]
William Drimple
Very neatly done.
- [06:55]
Anita Anand
So Fawlty Towers is set in Torquay. It's a seaside town with, yes, lots of little hotels in it. It's picturesque. It's Little England. I mean, is that fair to say, Willi?
- [07:06]
William Drimple
It is the embodiment of Little England. And even Kipling, who you might have thought would have had some sympathy with the Basil Fawltys of this world, or Basil Fawlty would certainly have had sympathy for Kipling thought the town was so smugly British that it made him want to dance naked through it with pink feathers.
- [07:24]
Anita Anand
Pink feathers in his stern, sort of lodged firmly in his area. He was even ruder than that, didn't he say? It was a society that was filled with ponderous fat old ladies living in villas with clipp hedges and shaved lawns. And although it was good to be back in the beautiful fatted and washed English scenery, he wished that this place, and these are his words, wasn't quite so infernally respectable. So he's a grumpy Kipling. Grumpy Ruddy is back in the UK.
- [07:51]
William Drimple
Grumpy ruddy, exactly that. So 1896, he moves back and in Torquay, improbably, he writes two of his most famous poems, which are two of the most famous poems in the English language, for better or worse, whether we like them or not. And he begins them, I think, within a fortnight of each other, and he doesn't think either of them are any good initially, and he has both of them sitting unfinished on his desk at the same time. But they are the White Man's Burden and Recessional. And both these poems, which, although they're written together, are released slightly apart and are published in the Times, and they completely change Kipling's profile. He'd been a famous figure in India as a young man, talking to this very small, limited audience of the British civil service and army in India. The Jungle Book, now so famous because of Disney, and even Kim came and went without an enormous fanfare. But it's these two poems which somehow just capture the high imperial mood of the 1890s. And they're slightly different from each other, although they're written initially at the same time, they have a very different mood. And Recessional is him slightly saying, we've overdone the empire, which is not a normal Kipling response. And it's him looking slightly skeptically. Is that the word?
- [09:07]
Anita Anand
Well, I think, yeah, we're seeing wistfully.
- [09:09]
William Drimple
Wistfully, yes. That's a better word.
- [09:11]
Anita Anand
There's a sympathy and sadness to it. Shall I read a few lines of it? So, God of our fathers known of.
- [09:18]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Old, Lord of our far flung battle.
- [09:20]
Anita Anand
Line Beneath whose awful hand we hold dominion over palm and pine Lord God of hosts, be with us yet Lest we forget. Lest we forget.
- [09:31]
William Drimple
Now, the background to this is Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee in 1897. And the poem Recessional, which is published very much as the poem of this moment in the times, seems to sort of grasp the fact that the great days of Britain as the sole power of the world as viewed. For Britain, of course, as far as the British were concerned, the great moment of imperial climax had been and gone. America is rising. Germany, more to the point, is rising as a rival European power. This is something new. Germany had been, of course, a collection of little princely states, and now they're united under Bismarck. They've defeated the French at the Franco Prussian wars, and suddenly they become a problem and they're beginning to rearm and they're beginning to threaten Britain.
- [10:17]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
It's the almost twilight of the empire, if you like, you know, sort of the sun setting on this enormous empire. That's certainly the feeling you get from Recessional, but also it's a feeling that's in Britain itself, because 1897 is a really important date for Queen Victoria, for whom this poem is written, because it is almost towards the end of her life. And you remember how the nation convulsed at the death Queen Elizabeth ii. The nation is braced again for a failing monarch who has always been there, you know, has been as reliable as sunrise and sunset.
- [10:47]
Anita Anand
So there is this sort of mood.
- [10:49]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Of change, you know, again, as you say, sort of, you know, the Irish nationalists, Indian nationalists, you know, this flux, but also that things are changing. This is not what we thought we had before. And that's when Recessional gets published in the Times.
- [11:02]
William Drimple
It's published in the Times in 1897. And the other poem that he'd written at the same time is not published until, I suppose, two years later, 1899. And this is the White Man's Burden. And now this is, of course, something we talked about very much with Daniel Immewar and when we were talking about Roosevelt invading the Philippines and the beginnings of American imperialism and the white man's Burden is this poem full of lines that are, to our eyes impossibly racist and in many ways utterly reprehensible. Doing this double thing of not only applauding the fact that America is taking on this job of imperialism, in other words, crushing, but in the eyes of Kipling, leading and educating the other races of the world and the second string of it, which is saying, you know, today we would mostly look at imperialism as the west conquering, exploiting and looting other countries, taking them over for the benefit of the colonizer. But Kipling, of course, looks at it quite differently as the white man's burden, as this duty that the white man has to take over civilize the world, to civilize an idea which does not fly very high today. And again, this sort of language is very difficult for us today. Take up the white man's burden, Send forth the best ye breed. Go bind your sons to exile to serve your captives need to wait in heavy harness on fluttered folk and wild your new caught sullen peoples, half devil and half child. Now, whatever your defense of Kipling, to regard the conquered peoples who have been conquered by America in this instance as half devil and half child is of course just straightforwardly racist. To look on it as a benign duty rather than as something exploitative, just shows the distance, in a sense, between his period and ours.
- [13:02]
Anita Anand
That's what makes him sort of out of all imperial writers, the most imperialist of all, if you like.
- [13:08]
William Drimple
And this is his most imperialist poem.
- [13:10]
Anita Anand
Yes. This is the absolute zenith of his defence of empire. Is British public opinion changing at this time? Because it's interesting at the same time as he's writing this spirited defence and, you know, and also melancholy about the fact, you know, we don't want to do this, it's quite hard, but we have to do this. It's our duty. We have to civilize the savages. The mood is sort of on a shift in Britain, would you say? Because I know newspapers are certainly covering in Britain, the other side, if you like, sort of Indian nationalists, people like George Bernard Shaw are being won over to the argument of really prominent members of British society are questioning, what are we doing over there? Why are we there? Who are we helping? So that is something as well, that is new in these sort of newspapers that people are opening up and reading with their breakfast cereal every morning.
- [14:01]
William Drimple
This is what Kipling is, in a sense, voicing. There is this growing awareness among liberals that a lot of what has been done during the Queen Victoria's reign needs reform, is how I think they'd put it. You need to educate and bring forward and prepare for the day when the British can step back. That's the attitude of the liberals. And Kipling is not a liberal. Kipling is, by any standards, the bard who addresses in the Times those conservative Brits who still think the empire is the great achievement and Britain's gift to the world, rather than how we would normally look at it in this podcast, as looting the world to enrich Britain. And we have, at the same time, Kipling's own life. He has. His son Jack. John is born at this point, the same year that he's writing these two poems, but he's also writing other poems where he's sort of setting himself up as the sort of bard of progress and technology, because for him, and again, this is something we have to sort of struggle to imagine, because the Victorian Empire seems to us something impossibly dated, but for Kipling, it's the cutting edge. It's the AI of its day. And he sees it not only as a civilizing force in the world, but as a sort of wonderfully professional technical consultancy, building splendid bridges, laying wonderful roads and railway tracks. He is a great fan of trains and motor cars and locomotives and steamships. And he writes these odd poems like MacAndrew's Hymn, where the hero is sort of machinery from coupler flange to spindle guide. I see thy hand, O God. Predestination in the stride of yon connecting rod.
- [15:40]
Anita Anand
You're right. I mean, he's so enthralled to the technology of the time. He wrote a poem which is called the Deep Sea Cable, Just an ode to deep sea cables.
- [15:50]
William Drimple
I love that. Isn't that great? No one else has written an ode to deep sea cables ever.
- [15:54]
Anita Anand
No, I think he's on his own on that shelf. And, you know, he says they have awakened the timeless things. They have killed their father. Time joining hands in the gloom A league from the last of the sun Hush, hush, men talk O the waste of the ultimate slime. And a new word runs between, whispering let us be one. A cable under the water.
- [16:18]
William Drimple
This is not the sort of thing which many other poets have sung.
- [16:22]
Anita Anand
No, but I love that he loves it so much. I just want to flag up another thing which you've sort of said in passing, but it's going to be really.
- [16:28]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Important in this episode, and it is.
- [16:29]
Anita Anand
The birth of his third child, John Jack Kipling. Does he ever write an ode to my newborn son that is even vaguely as lyrical as his ode to the Deep Sea Cables?
- [16:40]
William Drimple
Well, he does write eventually an ode to Jack, but that is at a different phase of his life.
- [16:44]
Anita Anand
Oh, no, that's a sad one. That's my boy, Jack. Oh, that is very, very sa. One thing that's moved my dial on Kipling.
- [16:51]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
It is that terrible tragedy. But we'll come to that. Let's not blow that now.
- [16:53]
William Drimple
It's getting worse at the moment, because what he's actually about to do, having written these two great patriotic odes to empire, he now is falling in love with another figure that we struggle to understand today. And many people are revolted by, which is Cecil Rhodes, the father of British imperialism in Africa, the man who believes that British commerce and drilling into diamond mines and taking the raw materials of Africa will. Will do good to Africa, will bring it forward. And these two become great allies.
- [17:25]
Anita Anand
Allies and friends.
- [17:26]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
I mean, they're actually personal friends, aren't they? They sort of eat together, they go out together, they muck around together, don't they?
- [17:31]
William Drimple
So much so that Rhodes actually gives Kipling a winter house called the Woolsack in Cape Town. I think he goes out every winter and spends the winter there at this point. So much so that he spurns the offers of Lord Curzon, who at this point is the Viceroy in India. And he was trying to get him to the Delhi Durbar. And he says no, no, I'm cozying down with my friend Cecil in the woolsack in Cape Town. And the two, well, I mean. So Kipling falls in love with him, I think. They meet in 1891 at a sort of jolly in the Athenaeum Club in Pall Mall in London. And Kipling lunches with Rhodes the day after he accepts the invitation from Rhodes to go for the first time to South Africa. And the two fall into each other's arms. Cause they both have very similar ideas about empire and imperialism. And both have incredibly positive views of white rule in Africa. There's no other two ways of putting it. And what is your dream? Rhodes asks him, provoking the response that the questioner was part of it.
- [18:28]
Anita Anand
Oh, so Rhodes, you are part of my dream.
- [18:31]
William Drimple
You are my dream.
- [18:31]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
It's quite flirty.
- [18:32]
Anita Anand
Does Rhodes ever offer up this idea that, you know, actually there will be a place called Rhodesia which will carry my name. How far are they going in their.
- [18:40]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Conversations about reforming Africa?
- [18:43]
William Drimple
Well, Rhodesia has just been formed at this point, 1890 and I think Kipling's first visit to South Africa is 1891 or something like that. So yes, this is very much in the air. Anyway, these two are having a very cozy time. And then Kipling decides he wants to go and revisit America. Now this is a family trip he and his wife have patched up with his brother in law. They haven't been to see the family for a bit since they left a decade earlier. But the trip proves a complete, an utter disaster. And it's an important moment in Kipling's emotional and family life because all three of his children become ill on this voyage. They go out in January, it's very cold and the seas are heavy and Kipling catches pneumonia. He's delirious for days and nearly dies. But Josephine, his daughter dies aged six on arrival. And Kipling is broken by this. He himself is very slow and weak.
- [19:40]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
They don't tell him, do they? Because he's so weak for such a long time that they can't even break the news about Josephine, who he refers to as his loveliest and favorite child.
- [19:50]
Anita Anand
So it takes a while even for the news to reach in.
- [19:53]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
He must have thought of, you know.
- [19:54]
Anita Anand
Delirium, I can't be real because it is such a blow to lose that.
- [19:59]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Six year old child that you love and adore so much. How does he bounce back? I mean, does he ever bounce back to his former self.
- [20:07]
William Drimple
He doesn't entirely bounce back, ever, and we will see there are further family tragedies to come, which also knocks him 46 recently, a first edition of the Jungle Book, complete with the handwritten inscription by Kipling to his youngest daughter, was discovered in a National Trust property in Cambridgeshire, and it's inscribed, this book belongs to Josephine Kipling, for whom it was written by her father, May 1894. And this is one of the great sort of sad moments of Kipling's life. And he returns to England, as we'll see in the next half after the break, very much less triumphant than his mood had been in the decade between arriving back from America after the Jungle Book and this disastrous trip when he loses his daughter.
- [20:56]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
This episode is brought to you by Attio the CRM for the AI Era Empires require a strong foundation to flourish. The Romans based theirs around the power of Rome. The British relied on the strong hand of Parliament and the monarchy. Attio understands that every business needs its own stable foundation. Instead of trying to build your business on top of generic tools, Attio's AI driven CRM means that anyone can build a CRM that works for their unique needs and purpose. Attio is built to support your business from day one. Empires also require efficiency. Rome would be nothing without its roads. Britain would just be an island without its sea power. Attio can give you real time customer insights and a platform that grows with you so you can finally stop wasting time trying to shape your business around somebody else's software and get on with what matters most your customers. With Attio, you can do the real work of building your own empire, whether it's that small business, a startup or an international corporation. Try Attio for free@attio.com empire.
- [22:13]
The Subaru Share the Love event is on from November 20th to January 2nd. By the end of this event, Subaru and its retailers will have donated over $350 million to charity. When you purchase or lease a new vehicle during the 2025 Subaru Share the Love Event, Subaru and its retailers will make a minimum $300 donation to charity. Visit subaru.comshare to learn more.
- [22:41]
Toast the holidays in a new way and raise a glass of Rumchata, a delicious creamy blend of horchata with rum. Enjoy it over ice or in your coffee. Rumchata, your holiday cocktail, just got sweeter tap or click the banner for more Drink responsibly. Caribbean rum with real dairy cream, natural and artificial flavors. Alcohol 13.75% by volume 27.5 proof Copyright 2025 Agave Loco Brands, Pojoaque, Wisconsin. All rights reserved.
- [23:14]
Anita Anand
Welcome back. Now, before we go back to this.
- [23:16]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Final chapter of Kipling's life, it's a.
- [23:18]
Anita Anand
Good time to tell you very quickly that we're doing a live show.
- [23:21]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Live show.
- [23:22]
Anita Anand
Saturday, 5th of September is the date. 2020 6th. We're going to be at the South.
- [23:26]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Bank Centre in London as part of.
- [23:28]
Anita Anand
A huge Goal Hanger takeover weekend from.
- [23:31]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
The 4th to the 6th of September.
- [23:33]
Anita Anand
We're even taking over a pub. It's going to become the reach of. This place is fabulous.
- [23:38]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
The Goal Hanger Arms, no less.
- [23:40]
Anita Anand
And we're welcoming you to come and pull up a seat at the bar because we'd love to see you.
- [23:45]
William Drimple
General sale for tickets goes live on December 11th at thesouthbankcentre.co.uk.
- [23:53]
Anita Anand
Yeah, so head over to southbankcentre.co.uk to buy your tickets. That's southbankcentre.co.uk. anyway, let's go back to Kipling because we left a very sad Kipling in part One, who has just lost his loveliest child in his own words, which is not very lovely for his other two children to grow up with. But there you are.
- [24:13]
William Drimple
First rule of any parent, never utter those words.
- [24:16]
Anita Anand
Do not declare your favourite.
- [24:18]
William Drimple
Don't have a favourite.
- [24:19]
Anita Anand
But also, he's sort of physically depleted. He comes back to England.
- [24:23]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Does he?
- [24:24]
William Drimple
He comes back and at this moment he then discovers his dream house, which is Bateman's, which still there in Sussex and you can go and see, it's owned by the National Trust now and it is an absolutely gorgeous, perfect.
- [24:36]
Anita Anand
Describe why?
- [24:36]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Tell me.
- [24:37]
William Drimple
Oh, it's sitting amid perfect unspoiled Sussex countryside and it's got a wall garden and it's got these Lovely collection of 17th century or 18th century buildings and it's just, it's a heavenly spot and it's very well worth going to see. Inside is beautiful paneling and all his books are still there. So I highly recommend a trip to Bateman. And it's here that he really, for the first time, falls in love with England. Remember, his great love of his youth had been India and the colors and the warmth of India. He has this brief crush on Vermont and the American wilderness and he's become the great bard of the British Empire without ever really knowing England or Britain at all. Well, but Bateman's, he loves, and he loves the countryside around it and he discovers the motorcar. He gets his into Motoring, we said how he likes underground cables and pistons and this sort of thing, and steamships. Now he discovers motoring and he motors around England. And this is the period that he starts writing Puck, a Pook's Hill. I don't know whether you ever had that read to you as a child.
- [25:41]
Anita Anand
No, I don't.
- [25:41]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Tell me about Puck of Pook's Hill. What is that? Is it a children's story? It sounds like it should be.
- [25:45]
William Drimple
Oh, it's rather gorgeous. It's all about sort of English history and the Romans and the Normans and the Barons War and the Regency and all this sort of stuff. Stuff all Laird. And then he also writes, and this is still, I think, my favorite bit of Kipling and something I read to my kids, which is the Just so stories. And of the just so stories, my favourite is the Cat that Walked By Himself.
- [26:07]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Oh, yes.
- [26:08]
William Drimple
Hear and attend and listen for this befell and be happened and became and was O my best beloved when the tame animals were wild the dog was wild and the horse was wild and the cow was wild and the sheep was wild and the pig was wild as wild as wild could be and they walked in the wet wild woods by their wild lones but the wildest of all the wild animals was the cat he walked by himself and all places were alike to him. It's an absolutely wonderful poem, illustrated with his own pictures.
- [26:42]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Well, his father, he was sort of this great draftsman, wasn't he? But they did like to take to their sketchbooks, the Kipling family. Tell me one thing, though. I mean, there's sort of around about this time, though, you know, he's writing these sort of charming stories, but also he's spending a lot of the time in a bit of a rage, isn't he?
- [26:58]
Anita Anand
Because, you know, this is also, let's.
- [27:00]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Not forget, this is the time Irish nationalism is growing and you've got the ferment of Orange men against Nationalists. You've also got Germany rearming itself. You've got sort of dreadnoughts and battle cruisers. This is that time as well. So it is a time of great insecurity. And he lets his rage out about this because he declares sides quite early on, doesn't he, William? And they won't surprise anybody.
- [27:26]
William Drimple
So Kipling genuinely thinks to the core of his being that the British Empire is a major force for good in the world. He's convinced himself that this is what is keeping the world going, the world spinning on its axis. And by 1902, which is the year that he writes the just so stories or publishes the just so stories. Britain is clearly no longer the unrivaled top dog. America is now it's equal in economic terms and is soon going to bypass it, if it hasn't already by 1902. And Germany is rising and growing much faster than Britain, and that is now clearly a threat too. Germany, it's important to remember, has also showed its sympathy with the Boers and the Boer War, which is something that, with his love of South Africa and Rhodes that he's suspicious of. And he thinks that the Kaiser is a very bad thing. Although the Kaiser apparently sent him a get well telegram when he was apparently dying in New York, that still doesn't stop him coming up with lots of anti German verse in the years ahead. And as you say, he sees the end of the British Empire and one of the things he sees is Ireland. Ireland is in the process of beginning its struggle for independence. The Easter Rising that we dealt with in Ireland is on the horizon. Ulstermen are rearming, defending, as they see it, their place and defending themselves against the Fenians as they see it. Everything that he loves is cracking and he is seen widely at this period. Remember, this is 1902. Kipling is now seen as a figure that represents the Victorian period, which is receding into the past. He's now become a bit of a fossil. So in the Strul Peter Alphabet, which is a political satire published at this period in 1900, it has a drawing under the letter K of the Alphabet, K for Rudyard Kipling and Lord Kitchener, at that time the Commander in Chief in India.
- [29:36]
Anita Anand
So I mean, you've got sort of.
- [29:37]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
This Alphabet book for kids and K, you know, not for Kangaroo, but for Kipling and Kitchener.
- [29:42]
Anita Anand
And the picture that accompanies it is.
- [29:44]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Kitchener sort of ramrod straight with his huge handlebar moustache all waxed at the tips, carrying a sabre at his side, standing to attention. And then sort of a much smaller little Kipling with his thick bottle glasses and droopy moustache, with ink dripping out of his backpack and spilling across the floor. But it does, I mean, does tell you, you know, how mega famous Kipling is if he's being put on the same pedestal as Kitchener.
- [30:10]
Anita Anand
And it says underneath the picture, should.
- [30:12]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
I read you what it says? It says, men of different trades and sizes. Here you have before your eyes lanky sword and stumpy pen doing useful things. When the empire wants a stitch in her, send for Kipling and for Kitchener.
- [30:28]
William Drimple
So he is, as this indicates, slightly a Sort of figure of fun by this stage in that he represents this high noon of Victorian empire which is something that's clearly passing. All this culminates in the outbreak of World War I in August 1914. Britain goes to war. And no one, of course is more keen to whip up everybody for war than Kipling, who writes one of his jingoistic poems in the Times. And this is what he. For all we have and are, for all our children's fate, stand up and take the war. The Hun is at the gate. Our world has passed away in wantonness overthrown. There is nothing left to day but steel and fire and stone. So this is Kipling absolutely beating the drums of war. The rat, a tat of the marching drum is very much sounding out from Bateman's. The person who embodies this in the real sense in the Kipling household is his son John, who's known as Jack. And he is initially rejected from the army for having poor eyesight. He fails his test and Kipling Sr. Ruddy pulls strings in high places to get him into the Irish Guards, which is not at all the regiment I think that Kipling would have wanted him to go into, as it was considered the Irish Guards would not have been Kipling's idea of a gentleman's regiment. And so he takes whatever is available. The Irish guards. His 17th birthday.
- [32:00]
Anita Anand
It's just before.
- [32:01]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
He's not even 17. Yeah, just. He's a 16 year old callow youth. Have you ever seen the movie My Boy Jack? Have you seen it? It's Daniel Ramplin. Daniel Ramplin.
- [32:11]
William Drimple
I haven't seen it, no.
- [32:12]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
It's really very, very moving. It's utterly touching and delightful. And the way they portray Jack is that he is practically blind. And you know, when he loses his glasses, he is entirely blind. He can't see anything but this sort of blurred mess. But that he is entirely trying to fulfill the ambitions of his father. You know, his mother doesn't want him to go. He's scared. He's only little. He's scared but you know, because of his father. He wants to make his daddy proud. He's not fit for the front, but he's sent in September 1915 to the battle of Loos. And that is a horrific bloody churning of human life. And it turns out to be Jack Kipling's first and only battle, doesn't it?
- [32:55]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
Yep.
- [32:56]
William Drimple
He goes straight into battle and is killed almost immediately. But it isn't clear immediately that he is dead. There's this terrible period when they know he's gone or he's disappeared. And they're hoping that he might have been captured or is missing and will turn up, but no such land. He's been wounded and died slowly in Chalk Pit Wood, the building which he crawled into, subsequently occupied by German soldiers. And the presumption is that the soldiers found this dying man and finished him off. Kipling is completely broken by this. This is a moment of sort of terrible loss and guilt because he'd more or less drummed the poor boy off, blind as he was to the front. And when he would have been safe at home because of his near blindness, he's drummed out and is kidnapped almost immediately.
- [33:42]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
The portrayal on screen shows that absolute heartbreak of Kipling Sr.
- [33:48]
Anita Anand
But what it doesn't seem to convey.
- [33:50]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Is how actually the pair of them, you know, Carrie and Rudyard, send their child off to war kind of knowing he's gonna be killed.
- [33:59]
Anita Anand
Because there is this one quote which.
- [34:01]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
I find really kind of scary. You know, she's asked, why did you send Jack?
- [34:06]
Anita Anand
Why?
- [34:06]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
And she says, you know, one can't let one's friends and neighbors sons be killed in order to save us and our son. There is no chance Jon will survive unless he is so maimed from a wound as to be unfit to fight. We know it and he does. We all know it. But we all must give and do what we can and live on the shadow of a hope that our boy will be the one to escape. I mean, bloody hell, that sounds cold, doesn't it?
- [34:34]
William Drimple
What we're up against is that Kipling, the human being who loves his children, who's broken by his daughter's death, feels this very, very strongly, but also is the epitome of dulce decorum est, which the war poets write against this idea that it's good and great to die for your country. These are the notions that Kipling has helped inculcate into an entire generation which are being shown up for their madness, in a sense, in the slaughter in the trenches. The kind of poems that Wilfred Owen and Secrets as soon as in response to this massacre of millions of young men shows up the hollowness of the jingoism represented by Kipling. And Kipling feels it and knows that he's partly responsible, in a sense, must.
- [35:19]
Anita Anand
Be unbearable because he wasn't meant to go.
- [35:22]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
He wasn't fit to go. He does write this poem, actually, which is heartbreaking. And I actually get a bit tearful when I do read a Nativity. And it's a really interesting poem. I think it's one of the most interesting poems by Kipling.
- [35:34]
Anita Anand
It's a weaving together of his own.
- [35:37]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Family story, but also with the death of Christ and Mary despairing about what's happened to her son and where is her son's body in the verse I'll read to you. My child died in the dark. Is it well with the child? Is it well? There was none to tend him or Mark, and I know not how he fell. And that is a lot, isn't it? Isn't that just awful?
- [36:01]
William Drimple
And then there's another one. There's my boy Jack. Have you any news of my boy Jack? Not this time. When do you think that he'll come back? Not with this wind blowing and this tide. Oh, dear, what comfort can I find? None this tide nor any tide, except that he did not shame his kind, not even with that wind blowing and that tide. Now, this is a, you know, defiant, jingoistic response that he didn't shame his kind, that he died defending the Union Jack and the empire. But by the end of this year, Carrie records that Kipling looks exhausted, yellow and shrunken.
- [36:39]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Can I ask you a question? Because, I mean, you know, this life so well. During the war and after the war, there were a lot of people who questioned the terrible actions of those in command. Lions led by donkeys. And, you know, the horrific sacrifices that people like Earl Haigh were willing to make by just sending these young lives over the top, over these trenches that had been dug into certain and death, this kind of mowing down that would grant them only 2 inches more of land. Did he ever look at all of that and think actually wasn't worth it? Was it worth it? I mean, were they the right people in charge? Someone who's had such unshakable faith in those who run Empire? Did it shake at all at this time?
- [37:27]
William Drimple
So how he explains it to himself is that, no, he doesn't think that it's all stuff and nonsense. He still believes in patriotism. He still believes in the Empire. He still believes in the kind of jingoistic pro Empire beliefs that had propelled him to this point. But also, yes, he believes that the generals are idiots. And he's very much the kind of man who does indeed harbour deep distrust and anger towards all the British military elite, particularly Haig. He blames Haig for the disastrous planning at Lewes. It isn't that he's rejected the empire and the military might that he's dedicated his life to. He's always been singing the song of the common soldier. And he still has that very much with him. But he has personal grief and guilt, self recrimination. He knows that he sent his son to slaughter. He deeply distrusts the generals, but he supports the war. He continues pro war work. He uses his talents to write propaganda and writes his dullest of all his books and the least read of all enormous bibliography is his two volume Regimental History of the Irish Guards, which characteristically mentions his son's death only very briefly. It's a footnote amid all the rest of the slaughter. And he gets involved in the Imperial War Graves Commission after the war and he writes the famous epitaph known unto God.
- [38:55]
Anita Anand
So just for those who don't know.
- [38:57]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Can I explain the Imperial Wargraves Commission of, I mean, just enormously important work for grieving families who needed some kind of closure. It's now, I mean it still exists, but its name is now the Commonwealth War Graves Commission.
- [39:11]
Anita Anand
The point of it was to ensure.
- [39:12]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
That every fallen soldier was commemorated with dignity because so many bodies did not come back. I mean you can just see why he would throw himself, body and soul into supporting that and raising money for that particular organization. Because they don't ever get Jack's body back, do they? They just have to come to terms with the fact that he's not coming back.
- [39:32]
William Drimple
So this idea of the unknown soldier, the soldier known only unto God is his phrase and it's one of these many phrases that he gives to the English language. So his position is that he kind of loses this romantic love of war. He's been writing all this stuff about scrimmages on the northwest frontier all his life, since his teens that goes. He doesn't have a romantic view of war, but it doesn't this death convert him into opponent of empire or questioning the strategic necessity as he sees it, of the First World War. And so he then has this final period of his life of another 19 years before he dies when he's increasingly a fossil, he's still Kipling, knocking out these linguistic poems. The real action in poetry is Sassoon and Wilfred Owen. And he says at one point, I hate your generation, when he's introduced to.
- [40:34]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Well, that's funny.
- [40:35]
Anita Anand
I tell you what else he hates.
- [40:36]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Because sort of at the end of the war, by the way, let's not forget how many Indian troops were fighting on the front in France as well. Not very far from where Jack fell, in fact. And he absolutely despises the, as Churchill called him, the half naked Indian Fakir. Mahatma Gandhi and the Indian National Congress.
- [40:56]
Anita Anand
Really, really loathed and would write and.
- [40:59]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
You know, sort of like his little tuppence worth about what was going on in India. And after the Jallianwalabadh massacre, there is this very controversial but huge fundraising effort for General Dyer, who is the man who orders the troops in and orders them to fire on this group 1,600 bullets. I still remember how many fired into the depths of the crowd.
- [41:20]
William Drimple
Including friends of your grandfather.
- [41:22]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Exactly. He is one of those sort of most famous donors to the fund to reward Dyer. And they call themselves the Die Hards, who say, you know, we are treating him, we put him through a court martial, he's a hero. He should be lifted on high on a palanquin.
- [41:38]
William Drimple
But as your wonderful book shows, this world is changing. Not only are the days of the Raj now clearly numbered as Congress and Gandhi are seizing the moment and rising to enormous popularity and gaining massive followings across India. Even among the British who have been to India and grown up there, none other than George Orwell, who we started the series with. So we're coming a full circle. Orwell at this period, writes a kind of bitter attack on Kipling's writing. He says his work is that of a jingo imperialist who sold out to the British government. Crude, vulgar, a patriotic music hall turn. Morally insensitive and aesthetically disgusting. Kipling has this unfortunate last 15 years when he's not just a fossil, he's reviled as everything that the new generation dislikes about the old generation. All that flag waving, all that barrack room ballads, all that stuff that Kipling represents is now massively out of fashion. It's a joke. But even worse than a joke, it's morally insensitive and aesthetically disgusting. So Kipling lives to see his world disintegrate and his values questioned. And everything that he believe in falls apart as he's watching. And I mean, he has a perfectly comfortable old age in this lovely house, Bateman's, he continues to write and he's considered to be one of the great pillars of the nation. He wins the Nobel Prize at this point, but he is aware that he is a fossil. And his end comes as late as 1936, 12th of January, he has an ulcer. He has lunch with his son in law. Then that evening his ulcer bursts and he's rushed from his Piccadilly Hotel to the Middlesex Hospital. In the small hours, 13th, he tells the surgeon that something has come adrift inside. He deteriorates, he loses consciousness. And the following day at midnight, he dies. That's his 44th wedding anniversary, even though.
- [43:51]
Anita Anand
In 1936, I guess, you know, his.
- [43:53]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Opinions are being challenged and he's pretty despondent about Britain's hold on the world. Britten still respects Stroke, reveres him even at the end because he gets his burial place in Westminster Abbey, Poets Corner, so there he rests. Anyone who does, you know, come as a tourist to London in Poets Corner in Westminster Abbey, and he's surrounded by the most illustrious writers that Britain has ever created. What should we think about him now? And this is a conversation we've had.
- [44:23]
Anita Anand
In pubs over the years and. Okay, I mean, do you want to go first?
- [44:27]
William Drimple
I've changed my views on him.
- [44:28]
Anita Anand
You have?
- [44:29]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Oh, gosh. Okay. All right, tell me.
- [44:31]
William Drimple
Yeah, I've changed my views on him in that I agreed with you all during my 20s and regarded him as this fuddy duddy bearer of Victoriana. But as so often in this podcast, two things are true simultaneously. And the two things which are true is that he is a white supremacist. He believes in the conquering of what he regards as lesser races. He is the embodiment of racism. He's the embodiment of imperialism. He's the embodiment of jingoism. He is also a great writer, and some of his short stories, his novel Kim, his poems and. And the poem that is still voted the nation's most popular poem if remain great works of literature. There are the most extraordinary list of Kipling fans out there, the oddest and most improbable of all being Edward Said, the father of Orientalism, who you might imagine to be the man leading the charge. And he writes, which is correct, that Kipling would no more have questioned the right of the white European to rule than he would have argued with the Himalayas. Yet he says Kip is a major artist, and his masterpiece, Kim is a remarkable, complex novel belonging to the world's very greatest literature. And there are, you know, so many people like that. Craig Raine, the modernist poet, thinks he's our greatest short story writer. He's our Chekhov, he's our Turgenev. Rushdie, who we started the first episode with when you were very sadly in hospital, has this wonderful line, and he says Kipling is such a complicated writer because he's a writer at war with himself. Just to return to the words, we open there this with. Kipling is a writer with a storm inside him, and he creates a mirror storm of contradictory responses in the reader. I've never been able to read Kipling calmly. Anger and delight are incompatible emotions. Yet his stories do indeed have the power simultaneously to infuriate and to entrance.
- [46:33]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
So, I mean, I'll tell you, my position has moved a little. So my resistance to Kipling, it's not fuddy Daddy, because the writing and, you know, because we were doing this, this. I've had opportunity to revisit some of the writing. It's beautiful. You know, his turns of phrases are elegant, his imagery is gorgeous, but at the end of the day, I can't love somebody who would have hated me and hated, you know, everyone I know and care about, because I'm exactly the kind of character who he loathed and was his worst nightmare.
- [47:05]
Anita Anand
To me, that is very, very difficult.
- [47:07]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
And I've just about managed it with Orwell, who is, as we discovered in our Orwell season, just thoroughly shit as a husband and as a man towards women. But with Kipling, he loved India, he hated Indians, which is such a mark of people who did really cruel, terrible things under the Raj that I still, I struggle with him much more. So where I can, I suppose, recognize that Rushdie, where Rushdie's coming from, you know, where you give yourself a punch up while reading him, I think I'm there. I can sort of, you know, I can. I can appreciate the words, but it doesn't make me cut him any more slack, if you see what I mean.
- [47:45]
William Drimple
Fair enough. Fair enough.
- [47:46]
Anita Anand
He wouldn't have cut me any. You know, I think. I think maybe it's that.
- [47:50]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Isn't that petty? Maybe it's petty.
- [47:52]
Anita Anand
Discuss on our discord empirepod uk.com if you are a member of our club.
- [47:56]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
You can get involved in this conversation and have a chat about it and, you know, we might even read out some of your submissions.
- [48:02]
Anita Anand
Anyway, what are we doing next? We're doing Naipaul.
- [48:05]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
That's exciting.
- [48:06]
William Drimple
Equally complicated figure. I have to say that I have been reading all weekend the lamented Patrick French's book on Naipaul, which, weirdly enough, I never read at the time for some reason, although it did so well that I read every review as it came out and was there with him when he was shortlisted for the Samuel Johnson, and very much sort of saw that book coming together and I never actually read it. It's a complete masterpiece. We're going to talk about it with another of my friends who also has very complicated views about Naipaul, but ultimately is on the defense team, and that is Ben Moser.
- [48:40]
Co-host/Guest (possibly a historian or literary expert)
Oh. Who himself is a sublime writer. Writes so beautifully. Yeah. Winner of a Pulitzer and many other things. So, yes, join us for that. Till the next time we meet, though, it's goodbye from me. Anita On.
- [48:53]
William Drimple
And goodbye from me. William durandpool.
- [49:02]
Sponsor/Advertisement Voice
The Uniswap wallet makes crypto easier and safer to own and use. Discover new tokens, research confidently, swap instantly and manage it all securely in one place. The Uniswap trading protocol has powered over $3 trillion in volume and it's trusted by millions worldwide. Worldwide? Buy your first crypto assets in a few taps and experience the freedom of decentralized finance. With Uniswap. Tap the banner to get started.