444 Days: The Iran Hostage Crisis - Everything Everywhere Daily: History, Science, Geography & More

Summary

Everything Everywhere Daily Podcast: Episode Summary

Episode Title: 444 Days: The Iran Hostage Crisis
Release Date: January 28, 2025
Host: Gary Arndt
Executive Producer: Charles Daniel
Associate Producers: Benji Long & Cameron Keever

Introduction to the Iran Hostage Crisis

In this episode of Everything Everywhere Daily, host Gary Arndt delves deep into one of the most pivotal events in modern U.S. and Iranian history: the Iran Hostage Crisis. Kicking off at [00:00], Gary sets the stage by highlighting the gravity of the event:

Gary Arndt ([00:00]): "On November 4, 1979, a group of Iranian revolutionaries stormed the American Embassy in Tehran, Iran, and took 66 American diplomats and citizens hostage."

This event not only captivated global attention for 444 days but also left a lasting impact on international relations between the United States and Iran for over four decades.

Historical Roots Leading to the Crisis

Gary meticulously traces the origins of the hostage crisis back to the early 20th century, providing listeners with a comprehensive background to understand the complexities involved.

Reza Shah and Modernization Efforts ([01:51])

Gary begins by discussing Reza Shah's ascent to power in 1925 after overthrowing the Qajar dynasty. His administration focused on modernizing Iran and reducing foreign (particularly British and Soviet) influence. However, his refusal during World War II to expel German advisors led to British and Soviet intervention:

Gary Arndt ([02:15]): "In August of 1941, Britain and the Soviet Union invaded Iran to secure oil supplies and establish supply routes for the Soviet war effort."

Under this pressure, Reza Shah was exiled, and his son, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, took the throne, albeit with limited power during the Allied occupation.

Nationalization of Oil and Operation Ajax ([04:30])

The crux of U.S.-Iran tensions began with the oil industry. Gary explains how the Anglo Persian Oil Company (later British Petroleum) dominated Iran's oil sector, leading to resentment and calls for nationalization led by Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh.

Gary Arndt ([05:45]): "In 1951, Mosaddegh nationalized the Anglo Persian Oil Company, expelling British oil interests and taking control of Iranian oil."

This move provoked Britain to impose an oil embargo, crippling Iran's economy and escalating tensions between Mosaddegh and the Shah. The situation culminated in the CIA and British Intelligence orchestrating Operation Ajax in 1953, overthrowing Mosaddegh and reinstating the Shah's autocratic rule.

The Shah's Reign and Rise of Khomeini ([08:20])

Under the Shah's increasingly authoritarian regime, supported by the CIA-established SAVAK (the secret police), dissent grew. Religious opposition coalesced around Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who was exiled in 1964. By the late 1970s, widespread discontent due to economic struggles, political repression, and Western influence led to mass protests.

Gary Arndt ([10:05]): "In January 1979, the Shah fled Iran and Khomeini returned in February to lead the Islamic Revolution."

The establishment of the Islamic Republic of Iran marked a significant shift in U.S.-Iran relations, setting the stage for future conflicts.

The Hostage Crisis Unfolds

Carter's Decision and Immediate Fallout ([13:30])

A pivotal moment occurred when President Jimmy Carter allowed the Shah into the United States for medical treatment, despite opposition from his own advisors.

Gary Arndt ([13:50]): "Carter felt it would be morally wrong to deny a sick man medical care."

This decision was perceived by Iranian revolutionaries as U.S. interference, igniting anti-American sentiments and leading to the seizure of the American Embassy in Tehran on November 4, 1979.

Life of the Hostages ([16:00])

Gary provides harrowing details about the hostages' experiences:

Gary Arndt ([16:20]): "The hostages were subject to isolation, blindfolded interrogations, and threats of execution."

Conditions were dire, with limited communication, inadequate food, and constant psychological torment through mock executions and propaganda efforts aimed at humiliating the United States.

U.S. Response and Operation Eagle Claw

Diplomatic and Military Efforts ([20:15])

President Carter faced immense pressure both domestically and internationally. In an unprecedented move, he authorized Operation Eagle Claw, a daring military rescue mission.

Gary Arndt ([21:00]): "Operation Eagle Claw was a daring but ultimately disastrous US military operation launched on April 24, 1980, to rescue the American hostages."

The mission faced insurmountable challenges, including severe dust storms and mechanical failures, leading to its abortive end and the tragic loss of eight American servicemen.

Impact on the 1980 U.S. Election ([23:45])

The failure of the rescue mission severely undermined Carter's presidency, contributing to his loss to Ronald Reagan in the subsequent election.

Negotiations and Resolution: The Algiers Accords

Mediation by Algeria ([27:30])

After multiple failed attempts by intermediaries like the United Nations and European nations, Algeria stepped in as a neutral party to mediate the crisis.

Gary Arndt ([28:10]): "Algeria was chosen as an intermediary because it had diplomatic ties with both the United States and Iran and had maintained a neutral stance throughout the crisis."

Terms of the Accords ([30:50])

Negotiations, intensified post-election, culminated in the Algiers Accords on January 19, 1981. The agreement entailed:

Unfreezing $8 billion in Iranian assets
Lifting economic sanctions
Pledging non-interference in Iran's internal affairs
Granting Iran immunity from lawsuits related to the crisis

Gary Arndt ([31:25]): "Just minutes after Ronald Reagan was sworn in on January 20, 1981, the hostages were released."

The hostages were freed as a symbolic gesture of defiance by the Iranian leadership against the Carter administration.

Long-Term Impacts of the Hostage Crisis

Gary concludes by examining the enduring ramifications of the crisis:

Diplomatic Severance:
- Severed U.S.-Iran relations remain unresolved to this day, with ongoing economic sanctions hindering Iran's global financial interactions.
Military and Counterterrorism Evolution:
- The failure of Operation Eagle Claw led to a heightened focus on counterterrorism and the establishment of the U.S. Special Operations Command in 1987.
Media and Public Perception:
- The crisis set a precedent for 24-hour news coverage and crisis-focused journalism, embedding the hostage situation deeply in American consciousness.
Cultural and Political Legacy:
- Symbolized broken diplomacy and fostered longstanding distrust and animosity between the two nations, shaping geopolitical dynamics in the Middle East.

Gary Arndt ([35:10]): "The distrust and animosity it created remains unresolved, ensuring that the hostage crisis is remembered not just as a historical event, but as an enduring symbol of broken diplomacy."

Conclusion

Gary Arndt's comprehensive exploration of the Iran Hostage Crisis offers listeners an in-depth understanding of the event's historical context, unfolding, resolution, and lasting significance. Through meticulous research and engaging narration, he paints a vivid picture of a moment that reshaped international relations and left an indelible mark on both American and Iranian societies.

This episode was produced by Charles Daniel, with associate producers Benji Long and Cameron Keever. Special thanks to the Patreon supporters whose contributions make such in-depth explorations possible.

Transcript

Host (0:00)

On November 4, 1979, a group of Iranian revolutionaries stormed the American Embassy in Tehran, Iran, and took 66American diplomats and citizens hostage. Over the next 444 days, the hostage crisis dominated the news and became the single biggest foreign policy issue for both the United States and Iran. Even after the crisis ended, it affected Iranian US relations for the last 45 years. Learn more about the Iran hostage crisis, its causes, and how it was resolved on this episode of Everything Everywhere Daily.

Advertiser (0:48)

Yeah, sure thing. Hey, you saw that car yet? Yeah, sold it to Carvana. Oh, I thought you were selling to that guy. The guy who wanted to pay me in foreign curr. No interest over 36 months. Yeah, no. Carvana gave me an offer in minutes, picked it up and paid me on the spot. It was so convenient. Just like that. Yeah. No hassle? None. That is super convenient. Sell your car to Carvana and swap hassle. For convenience. Pickup fees may apply. Welcome to Nadia Yada island, next on Metro's Nadia Yada island podcast. I almost fainted when the four new bombshells arrived. Four free Samsung Galaxy A16 5G phones at Metro. No way. And finding out the fourth line is free. Thanks God Heated. That's wild. Join Metro and get four free Samsung 5G phones only at Metro plus tax. Bring four numbers and an ID and sign up for any Metro Flex plan not available currently AT T Mobile or been with Metro in the past 180 days.

Host (1:51)

If you weren't alive for it at the time, it would be hard to understand just how important the Iran Hostage Crisis was when it was unfolding. The crisis dominated the news for over a year. Every single day during the crisis, every evening news program counted the days since the hostages were taken. People all across the country tied yellow ribbons to trees outside their homes. It became a dominant issue in the 1980 election and arguably contributed to the fall of an American presidency. The hostage crisis wasn't something that happened spontaneously, although it did seem like it at the time. The origins date all the way back decades earlier, to the 1920s. Reza Shah came to power in 1925 after throwing the Qajar dynasty. He pursued modernization and sought to reduce foreign influence, particularly that of Britain and the Soviet Union. However, During World War II, Reza Shah refused to expel German advisors from Iran, alarming both the British and the Soviet governments. In August of 1941, Britain and the Soviet Union invaded Iran to secure oil supplies and to establish supply routes for the Soviet war effort. Under pressure from the Allies, Reza Shah was forced to abdicate on September 16, 1941 and was exiled to South Africa. With British and Soviet approval. Mohammad Reza Pavali, Reza Shah's son, was installed as the new Shah of Iran at the age of 21. His early reign was marked by limited power as British and Soviet forces occupied Iran until the end of the Second World War. Mohammad Reza, the Shah of Iran is really the key to this entire story. The Anglo Persian Oil Company, later called British Petroleum, dominated Iran's oil industry, which gave Britain control over Iran's oil revenues. Iranian politician Mohammad Mosaddegh led calls to nationalize the oil industry, arguing that Iran should control its own natural resources. In 1951, he was elected Prime Minister by the Iranian Parliament. With strong popular support, Mosaddegh nationalized the Anglo Persian Oil Company, expelling British oil interests and taking control of Iranian oil. Britain retaliated by imposing an oil embargo, blockading Iranian exports and crippling the economy. The Shah and conservative elements in Iran opposed Mosaddegh's policies. Fearing a shift toward socialism, Mosaddegh tried to reduce the Shah's power, creating further tensions. In 1953, the CIA and the British Intelligence orchestrated Operation Ajax, overthrowing Prime Minister Mosaddegh, who had nationalized Iran's oil industry. And this reinstated the Shah of Iran's autocratic rule. The Shah implemented Western friendly policies and rapid modernization. But his rule was increasingly authoritarian, relying on savak, his brutal secret police, to suppress opposition. SAVAK was the secret police, intelligence agency and security Organization of Iran under the shah. Established in 1957 with the help of the CIA, it was notorious for its brutal repression, using torture, surveillance and assassinations to silence political opposition, particularly nationalists and Islamists. The Shah was a brutal dictator who became hated by the vast majority of his people. However, he was also a staunch ally of the United States. In the Cold War, opposition to the Shah's rule began to organize around a religious leader named Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, a vocal critic who was exiled from Iran in 1964. By 1978, widespread discontent over economic struggles, political repression and Western influence led to mass protests. In January 1979, the Shah fled Iran and Khomeini returned in February to lead the Islamic Revolution. In April 1979, Iran officially became the Islamic Republic of Iran, led by the Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Khomeini. I'm skipping a lot of detail there, but at this point, In April of 1979, the Shah was out, the Ayatollah was in, and at this point the United States was intent on continuing their relations with Iran via the new government. Maybe they wouldn't be as close as they were before, but the US Would recognize the new government and they would trade ambassadors. When the Shah fled Iran, he was seriously ill. He had been diagnosed with leukemia in 1974 and had become gravely worse during the protests of 1978. After fleeing Iran, the Shah became an international hot potato. He went to Egypt, then to Morocco, then to the Bahamas and then to Mexico. During this time, the new Iranian government began to demand the extradition of the Shah back to Iran to stand trial. As the Shah was moving from country to country, his cancer continued to worsen. On October 22, 1979, President Jimmy Carter reluctantly allowed the Shah of Iran into the United States for medical treatment at the New York Cornell Medical Center. It was this decision that enraged the Iranian revolutionaries who saw it as U.S. interference and potentially the prelude for another U.S backed coup to put the Shah back in power. Large anti American demonstrations erupted across Iran, particularly in Tehran. Protesters demanded the Shah's extradition to stand trial for corruption, human rights abuses and crimes against the Iranian people. Ayatollah Khamenei and his followers denounced the United States, accusing Carter of interfering in Iranian affairs. Carter, for his part, seems to have allowed the Shah into the United States for purely humanitarian reasons. Carter felt it would be morally wrong to deny a sick man medical care. His advisors were split on the decision. His National Security Advisor, Zbigniew Brzezinski, pushed for allowing the Shah in, arguing that the United States should stand by its former ally. Meanwhile, Secretary of State Cyrus Vance warned that it could provoke crisis in Iran and advised against it. Regardless of the thinking behind Carter's decision, Carter totally underestimated the level of hostility in Iran towards the United States. Protests in Iran exploded and they were targeted at the focal point of the American presence in the country, the American Embassy in Tehran. On November 4, 1979, less than two weeks after the Shah arrived in the United States for medical treatment, a group of Iranian students aligned with Khomeini's revolutionary government stormed the US Embassy. As for the Shah, the center of the whole controversy, he was in the US for less than two months. On December 15, he left for Panama and then left for Egypt again in March of 1980. On July 27, 1980, the Shah died in Cairo at the age of 60. The students who stormed the embassy initially took 66 hostages, including diplomats, military personnel and civilians. Three were later released on November 19, 10 on November 20, and then one later in July leaving 52Americans held captive. The hostages were subject to isolation, blindfolded interrogations, and threats of execution. Many were kept in solitary confinement for long periods, confined to small, dark rooms with little information of the outside world. Their captors frequently staged mock executions, pretending to prepare them for death, only to halt at the last moment and a tactic meant to break their spirit. They were also forced to participate in propaganda efforts, appearing in staged photographs and videos that the Iranian government used to humiliate the United States. Communication among the hostages was severely restricted, although some managed to pass messages or tap out Morse code on the walls. Basic hygiene was a struggle, and food was often inadequate or withheld as punishment. Medical care was inconsistent. Although some hostages received limited treatment when their health deteriorated, the United States had limited options with which they could respond. President Carter had imposed economic sanctions and froze Iranian assets in US Banks. He also expelled Iranian diplomats and attempted to pressure Iran diplomatically. 1980 was an election year, and the entire episode made the leader of the world's most powerful country look very weak. Also, in a highly unusual move, Carter had a primary challenge within his own party as an incumbent president. From Senator Ted Kennedy, the pressure to take action cumulated with Operation Eagle Claw. It was a daring but ultimately disastrous US military operation launched on April 24, 1980, to rescue the American hostages. The mission involved multiple phases, requiring U.S. forces to infiltrate Iran, rendezvous in the desert at a location known as Desert One, then proceed with an air assault on the US Embassy. However, the plan was complicated and risky, requiring helicopters and transport planes to work in perfect coordination. Shortly after launching, the operation faced serious issues, including severe dust storms that damaged equipment and impaired visibility. Mechanical failures resulted in three helicopters becoming inoperable, reducing the force below the minimum required for the mission's success. With the plan compromised, the mission was aborted before reaching Tehran. During the withdrawal, however, tragedy struck when a helicopter collided with a C130 transport aircraft, causing a massive fireball that killed eight US servicemen. The surviving personnel were forced to flee, abandoning equipment, vehicles, and classified documents, which the Iranians later seized. The hostage crisis became a story every night on the news. Every news broadcast would start with the number of days that the hostages had been held. The phrase America held hostage became a daily feature on ABC News, which later evolved into the program Nightline, hosted by Ted Koppel. The media's relentless coverage of the crisis kept the hostage's fate at the center of national consciousness, fueling a sense of helplessness and anger. Schools, businesses and communities organized yellow ribbon campaigns symbolizing hope for the hostage's Safe return. Public sentiment was overwhelmingly hostile towards Iran, with large scale protests erupting across the United States. Many Americans burned Iranian flags, chanted anti Iran slogans and called for further military action. The Carter administration desperately wanted to come to some sort of agreement before the election. However, with the failed rescue mission possible negotiations between Iran and the US were at an impasse. By mid-1980, efforts by intermediaries such as the United nations and various European countries had also failed. An intermediary was found in the nation of Algeria. The Algerians began their involvement in the Iran Hostage crisis in the latter half of 1980 with serious mediation efforts starting around September and October. Algeria was chosen as an intermediary because it had diplomatic ties with both the United States and Iran and it had maintained a neutral stance throughout the crisis. The Iranians had no incentive to hurry the negotiations because they didn't want to give Carter a win before the election. Negotiations intensified once the election was over and Jimmy Carter had lost to Ronald Reagan. The final agreement became known as the Algiers Accords. Under the terms of the Algiers accords, signed on January 19, 1981, the United States agreed to unfreeze $8 billion in Iranian assets, lift economic sanctions and pledge non interference in Iran's internal affairs. Additionally, Iran was granted immunity from lawsuits related to the hostage crisis, ensuring that the United States government and private citizens could not pursue legal claims against Iran for the incident. The Iranian leadership, particularly the Ayatollah Khomeini, delayed final approval of the deal until just after Ronald Reagan's inauguration, refusing to release the hostages while Jimmy Carter was still in office. As a symbolic act of defiance. Just minutes after Ronald Reagan was sworn in on January 20, 1981, the hostages were released, marking the official end of the crisis. The Iran Hostage Crisis had a series of wide ranging impacts, many of which can still be felt today. For Iran, the hostage crisis was a symbolic victory against the west, strengthening Ayatollah Khomeini's rule and entrenching the legitimacy of the new Islamic Republic of Iran. One of the most immediate and lasting effects was the severing of diplomatic ties between the United States and Iran, which remain broken to this day. The United States responded with economic sanctions that have only increased over the years, restricting Iran's access to global financial systems. The failure of Operation Eagle Claw resulted in a greater emphasis on counterterrorism and hostage rescue operations, including the creation of the U.S. special Operations Command in 1987. The continuous crisis coverage set the standard for the 24 hour news cycle and crisis focused journalism. The distrust and animosity it created remains unresolved, ensuring that the hostage crisis is remembered not just as an historical event, but as an enduring symbol of broken diplomacy. The executive producer of Everything Everywhere Daily is Charles Daniel. The associate producers are Benji Long and Cameron Keever. I want to give a big shout out to everyone who supports the show over on Patreon, including the show's producers. Your support helps me put out a show every single day, and also Patreon is currently the only place where Everything Everywhere Daily merchandise is available to the top tier of supporters. If you'd like to talk to other listeners of the show and members of the Completionist Club, you can join the Everything Everywhere Daily Facebook group or Discord server. Links to Everything are in the show. Notes.