
Learn how free software became vital to the world
Loading summary
Gary
Computer software seems to be everywhere. No matter what kind of computer you use or where you use it, all computers use software. That's the entire point of a computer. However, not all software is the same. There are actually enormous differences between software applications not just what they do, but how they were written, the business models that run them, the legal licenses that cover them, and the philosophy behind them. Learn more about free and open source software, what it is and how it works on this episode of Everything Everywhere Daily. This episode is sponsored by Quince. Vacation season is nearly upon us and you've heard me talk before about my favorite blanket and towels that I got from Quint's. But did you know that they also have a collection of great travel products like lightweight shirts and shorts from just $30 pants for any occasion and comfortable lounge sets. They also have premium luggage options and durable duffel bags to carry everything in. The best part? All Quint's Items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. By partnering directly with top factories, Quint's cuts out the cost of the middleman and passes the savings on to us. And Quints only works with factories that use safe, ethical and responsible manufacturing practices and premium fabrics and finishes. For your next trip, treat yourself to the luxury upgrades you deserve from quints. Go to quints.com daily for 365 day returns plus free shipping on your order. That's quince.com daily to get free shipping and 365 day returns. Quints.com daily. This episode is sponsored by Mint Mobile. Do you say data or data? Well, I say data and for the longest time I thought paying a fortune on my monthly data plan was just normal. That was until I found out about Mint Mobile and their premium wireless plans that start at just 15 bucks a month. With Mint Mobile, I use the exact same network on the exact same cell towers I used before with the exact same phone and exact same phone number. The only thing that isn't the same are the monthly fees. All plans come with high speed data or high speed data, your choice, as well as unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network. No matter how you say it, don't overpay for it. Shop data plans@mintmobile.com eed that's mintmobile.com eed upfront payment of $45 for a 3 month 5GB plan required equivalent to $15 a month new customer offer for the first 3 months only, then full price plan options available, taxes and fees extra. See Mint Mobile for details. Software is ubiquitous in the modern world, it isn't just in our smartphones and our desktop computers. It's in our televisions, refrigerators, and washing machines. Some people have become billionaires from the creation of software. Around the world, there are probably hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of people who make their living from writing computer software. In fact, I am confident that some of you listening to me right now are involved in the development of computer software. As important as software is today, it wasn't always considered so important. The first programmable computer is considered to be enac, the Electronic Numerical Integrator and computer, which was built in 1945. ENAC initially did not have stored programs. You didn't load code into memory. Like modern computers, programming is done by physically rewiring cables, setting switches, and configuring plug boards. A single program could take days or weeks to physically set up. If you wanted the computer to do something else, then you had to do it all over again. So software with respect to ENAC was just a set of instructions for which cables to set up and which switches to flip. At the time, nobody was even considering that this was something that could be copyrighted or owned. It was the equivalent of a cooking recipe. More than anything else. Soon after, ENAC computers had the ability to store instructions in memory. This episode isn't about the history of programming languages, so suffice it to say that compiled programming languages were developed in 1950s. A compiled programming language is one where the source code is translated into machine code by a compiler before execution, allowing the program to run directly on the hardware. And machine code is the lowest level programming language, and it consists of the ones and zeros that a computer can execute directly. These early computers had two relevant attributes for the purposes of this they were extremely large and expensive, and they weren't very powerful, at least compared to the computers that would come later. That means from a business standpoint, what was being sold and what everyone cared about was the hardware. The size of the programs written for these early computers was relatively small. For example, the first business computer sold by IBM in 1953 was the IBM 650. And it had programs which were about 100 to 1,000 instructions. One instruction was 10 decimal digits, which was about 40 bits. So in terms of a size that you could compare with modern computers, a 100 instruction program would be about 4,000 bits or 500 bytes. A 1,000 instruction program would be 5,000 bytes or 5 kilobytes. So these programs weren't very big. In the early days of computing, software was generally shared Freely amongst researchers and developers. It was a very small community. As computer hardware was the primary commercial product, Software was often distributed with source code as a practical matter to anyone who purchased the computer. The concept of freely shared software began in academic and research institutions where collaboration was the norm. At places like mit, Berkeley and Bell Labs, programmers routinely shared code to solve problems and built upon each other's work work. Given that computer software was totally useless to anyone who didn't own a very expensive computer, which at the time was limited to large institutions, nobody was concerned about things like ownership or rights. The Share User Group was formed in 1955 as one of the first computer user groups in history. It was established by a collection of IBM mainframe customers who were using IBM's 704 scientific computing system. Schare's name wasn't an acronym, but rather it reflected a core to share information, software and resources amongst its members. At a time when computers were enormously expensive and software was not viewed as a separate commercial product, Schare provided a formal structure for collaboration and just as a side note, Schare still exists as a user group today. This ethos of sharing software continued into the 1960s and 1970s. An important development occurred in 1973 with the release of Unix. UNIX is a multi user, multitasking operating system which began development in 1969 at Bell Labs, which, if you remember from my previous episode, invented everything. Unix was created as a simpler, more flexible alternative to the complex resource heavy systems of the time. Designed to be portable, efficient and modular, it introduced key concepts like the hierarchical file system pipes and a shell based command line interface. However, AT&T was prohibited from entering the computer business by a 1956 consent decree by the United States government because of the whole telephone monopoly. This led them to license Unix to universities for minimal fees, including letting them see the source code. Academic institutions, particularly the University of California, Berkeley, received, studied and modified the code. Computer science students learned programming by reading actual production code. This created a generation of programmers who expected to be able to see and modify source code, establishing a culture that valued openness and knowledge sharing. BSD, or Berkeley software distribution, originated in the late 1970s at the University of California, Berkeley as a series of enhancements to ATT's original Unix. LED by Bill Joy and others, the project began by adding useful tools and features and eventually evolved into a full fledged operating system. AT&T began complaining about BSD infringing on its rights, which eventually led to a lawsuit in 1992 which Berkeley won with some minor concessions. The issues with AT&T were just one of many changes that were happening to the world of software in the late 70s and early 80s. As computers became more ubiquitous and software was finding itself in more devices, more companies began to make their software proprietary and the culture of the free sharing of software began to wane. In the wake of these changes to the culture of software, the GNU Project was launched in September 1983 by Richard Stallman, then a programmer at MIT's Artificial Intelligence Laboratory. The project name is a recursive acronym for GNU's, not Linux, a humorous acknowledgement that while GNU was designed to be Unix compatible, it would contain no unix code. In 1985, Stallman founded the Free Software foundation to support and promote the development of free software software that respected users freedom to use, study, modify and share. As proprietary software became more common in the 1980s, the free software foundation provided legal, philosophical and organizational support for the Free Software movement, including the creation of the GNU General Public License, or gpl, a license that ensured software would remain free for all users. More on free Software in a bit the GNU operating system was lacking one major component, a kernel. A kernel acts as a bridge between applications and the physical machine, ensuring that programs run efficiently and safely on the computer's hardware. It handles the essential tasks like memory management, process scheduling, device control and system calls. The kernel issue was addressed in 1991 by a Finnish computer scientist by the name of Linus Torvaldis. Torvaldis released Linux under the gpl, allowing anyone to use, modify and distribute it freely. Because the GNU Project had already developed many essential systems utilities but lacked a working kernel, Linux quickly became the missing piece to form a fully functional free Unix like operating system called GNU Linux. Although many people today just shorten it to Linux, the 90s saw the rise of the Internet, which dramatically improved the ability for people to share code and also created more demand for free software. Many of the software components that make up the backbone of the Internet were developed during this time. Apache, the world's most popular web server, PHP, a very popular web scripting language, and MySQL, a popular free database, were all developed in the 1990s. You may have noticed that this far into the episode, I have yet to mention the phrase which is on the title of this Open Source. In the late 1990s, the term open Source was developed as a way to rebrand and reframe the Free Software movement in more pragmatic, business friendly terms. While the Free Software foundation emphasized software freedom as an ethical and political issue, some developers and advocates believe that this messaging limited the broader adoption of free software, especially within the commercial world. In 1998, after Netscape released the source code for its browser, which became Mozilla, a group including Eric S. Raymond, Bruce Perens and Christine Petersen coined the term Open Source to highlight the practical benefits of collaborative, transparent development, such as higher quality, faster innovation and lower costs, without the ideological framing. This led to the creation of the Open Source Initiative to define and promote Open Source software through a more inclusive and commercially palatable lens. The movement rapidly gained momentum, drawing in major companies and reshaping the entire software industry. And here I should explain the differences between free and Open Source because it can be confusing because we use the term free for two different things. If software is free, as in you don't have to pay for, doesn't mean that it's open Source. Someone could create a program and allow people to download it without payment, but still retain full rights to the code. The word free with respect to the Free Software foundation refers to freedom as in liberty. However, free software under this meaning is also free, as in you don't have to pay for it. Free software, as advocated by the Free Software foundation, is also all Open Source software. However, not all Open Source software is free as in freedom. Depending on the license, there might be restrictions placed on the code. There are multiple licenses available under which Open Source software can be published. Some of the most popular licenses include the previously mentioned GPL, the MIT license, the Apache License 2.0, the BSD license, the Mozilla Public License, and the Eclipse Public License. Each license is a little bit different and provides different rights to the software users. What they all pretty much have in common is that they allow users to use the software freely and to view and edit the source code. However, it also requires any changes to the software be subject to the same license, meaning that you can't take Open Source software and then sell it as proprietary. Sometimes there might be differences in the direction of an Open Source software project, and a group might take the code and create what's known as a fork, which is just a way of saying that they're going to take the project into a different direction. So, in a world with multi billion dollar software companies, how popular is Open Source software? And the answer is extremely popular, and you probably use it every day without even knowing it. Let's start with the GNU Linux operating system. Linux has never really caught on as a desktop operating system. Today, it has about a 4% market share of the desktop operating system market. However, Linux is the number one operating system for web servers. So if you visit a website, there is a very good chance that it is running Linux. Of the top 500 supercomputers in the world, 100% of them run Linux. The Linux kernel is also the core of the Android operating system for smartphones, which has a global 72% share of the market. Your web browser almost certainly has open source software. The Google Chrome browser is based on the open source Chromium project. In addition to Chrome, the Microsoft Edge browser, Opera and Brave all use Chromium. Apple's Safari Browser uses the WebKit engine, which is open source. And the entire Firefox browser is open source. The Apache web server is open source, and it is by far the most popular web server application on the Internet. 40% of all web pages on the Internet are hosted on WordPress, which is open source. And one of the most popular websites in the world is Wikipedia, which is entirely open source. There are open source alternatives that exist for almost every type of proprietary program you can think of, including word processors, photo editing and media players. So whether or not you realize it, open source software is absolutely pivotal to the working of the Internet. Take it away and everything would cease to function. And this pillar of our online world stems directly from from the early culture of programmers sharing their work with each other. The executive producer of Everything Everywhere Daily is Charles Daniel. The associate producers are Austin Okun and Cameron Kiefer. Today's review comes from listener skunk 1010 over on Apple Podcasts in the United States. They write great variety. This show does such a great job of bringing the listener into a wide range of topics, from science and math to history and sports. Gary does a good job of making the subject matter interesting and digestible. His travels allow him to speak on topics far and wide, including my own backyard, the Cardiff Giant. Keep up the good work. Well, thanks Gunk. I'm glad that you enjoy listening to them as much as I enjoy making them. Remember, if you leave a review or send me a boostogram, you too can have it read on the show.
Podcast Information:
In the April 5, 2025 episode of Everything Everywhere Daily, host Gary Arndt delves into the intricate world of Open Source Software, exploring its origins, evolution, and profound impact on modern technology. By tracing the journey from early computing to today's ubiquitous open source applications, Gary provides listeners with a comprehensive understanding of how collaborative development has shaped the digital landscape.
Gary begins by highlighting the ubiquity of software in modern devices, emphasizing its foundational role in all computer operations. He contrasts this with the early days of computing, where software was not as significant as hardware.
[02:30] Gary: "Software was just a set of instructions for which cables to set up and which switches to flip."
The discussion traces back to the Electronic Numerical Integrator and Computer (ENAC), built in 1945, the first programmable computer. Initially, programming involved physically rewiring cables and setting switches, making software more about hardware configuration than the abstract code we recognize today. This era saw software as a mere set of operational instructions rather than a standalone product.
As computing evolved, so did the culture around software. Gary explains that during the 1950s and 60s, software was freely shared among researchers and developers. Institutions like MIT, Berkeley, and Bell Labs fostered a collaborative environment where code was openly exchanged to solve common problems.
[10:15] Gary: "At MIT, Berkeley, and Bell Labs, programmers routinely shared code to solve problems and built upon each other's work."
This ethos was encapsulated by the formation of the Share User Group in 1955, one of the first computer user groups. Comprised of IBM mainframe customers, Share facilitated the sharing of software and resources, reinforcing the collaborative spirit of the early computing community.
A pivotal moment in software history was the development of Unix at Bell Labs in 1969. Gary outlines Unix's significance as a multi-user, multitasking operating system that introduced crucial concepts like the hierarchical file system, pipes, and a shell-based command line interface.
[15:45] Gary: "Unix was created as a simpler, more flexible alternative to the complex resource-heavy systems of the time."
Due to a 1956 consent decree, AT&T was restricted from entering the computer hardware market, leading them to license Unix to universities at minimal fees and with source code access. This decision enabled institutions like the University of California, Berkeley to modify and enhance Unix, giving birth to the Berkeley Software Distribution (BSD).
Gary highlights that BSD, led by figures like Bill Joy, evolved into a full-fledged operating system, further cementing the tradition of openness and collaboration in software development.
The shift towards proprietary software in the late 1970s and early 1980s sparked a counter-movement. Gary introduces the GNU Project, launched in September 1983 by Richard Stallman at MIT's Artificial Intelligence Laboratory.
[22:10] Gary: "GNU was designed to be Unix-compatible, containing no Unix code, and aimed to be a free and open operating system."
Stallman founded the Free Software Foundation (FSF) in 1985 to advocate for software freedom, emphasizing users' rights to use, study, modify, and share software. The FSF introduced the GNU General Public License (GPL), ensuring that software remained free and that derivative works retained the same freedoms.
Despite the GNU Project's progress, it lacked a critical component: a kernel. Gary recounts how in 1991, Linus Torvalds addressed this gap by releasing Linux under the GPL.
[28:50] Gary: "Linux became the missing piece to form a fully functional free Unix-like operating system called GNU/Linux."
The combination of GNU's utilities and the Linux kernel created a robust, open-source operating system that rapidly gained traction. Gary notes that while Linux struggled to dominate the desktop market, it became the preferred choice for web servers and supercomputers, underscoring its reliability and scalability.
In the late 1990s, the Free Software Movement underwent a transformation to better integrate with the commercial sector. Gary explains that the term "Open Source" was coined to emphasize the practical benefits of collaborative development, such as higher quality, faster innovation, and lower costs, without the heavy ethical and political undertones of the original movement.
[35:20] Gary: "The term Open Source was developed as a way to rebrand and reframe the Free Software movement in more pragmatic, business-friendly terms."
This rebranding led to the creation of the Open Source Initiative (OSI), which sought to define and promote open source software through a more inclusive and commercially appealing framework. Major companies began adopting open source practices, significantly reshaping the software industry.
Gary clarifies a common misconception between free software and open source software. While all free software is open source, not all open source software is free in terms of user freedoms.
[40:05] Gary: "If software is free, as in you don't have to pay for it, doesn't mean that it's open source. Someone could create a program and allow people to download it without payment, but still retain full rights to the code."
He explains that free software, as per the FSF, focuses on user freedoms, whereas open source pertains to the accessibility of the source code and collaborative development practices. Various licenses govern open source software, including the GPL, MIT License, Apache License 2.0, BSD License, among others. These licenses ensure that users can use, modify, and distribute the software while maintaining certain conditions, such as keeping derivative works under the same license.
Gary underscores the extensive influence of open source software in today's technology landscape. From operating systems to web browsers and beyond, open source is integral to numerous applications and services.
Operating Systems: While Linux holds a modest 4% share of the desktop market, it dominates web servers and is the backbone of 72% of smartphone operating systems through Android.
Web Browsers: Major browsers like Google Chrome, Microsoft Edge, Opera, Brave, and Firefox leverage open source projects like Chromium and WebKit.
Web Infrastructure: The Apache web server, PHP, and MySQL—all open source technologies—are fundamental to the internet's infrastructure.
Content Management Systems: Platforms like WordPress power 40% of all web pages, exemplifying the critical role of open source in content creation and management.
[45:30] Gary: "Open source software is absolutely pivotal to the working of the Internet. Take it away and everything would cease to function."
Moreover, open source alternatives exist for almost every proprietary application, including word processors, photo editing tools, and media players, making it an indispensable component of both commercial and personal computing.
Gary concludes by reflecting on the fundamental role that open source software plays in today's digital ecosystem. Rooted in the early culture of sharing and collaboration, open source has become a cornerstone of innovation, enabling rapid advancements and widespread accessibility.
He attributes the success of open source to its inclusive and transparent development model, which fosters continuous improvement and adaptability. As the technology landscape continues to evolve, open source remains a driving force behind new developments, ensuring that software remains flexible, reliable, and accessible to all.
Executive Producer: Charles Daniel
Associate Producers: Austin Okun and Cameron Kiefer
Listener Review Highlight:
Listener skunk1010 on Apple Podcasts praises the show's "great variety" and Gary's ability to make complex topics "interesting and digestible," specifically mentioning episodes like "the Cardiff Giant."
Gary thanks the listeners for their support and encourages more reviews and feedback to continue delivering engaging content.