
Learn more about the battle that turned the Civil War
Loading summary
Host
In the summer of 1863, after two years of war, Confederate General Robert E. Lee felt it was possible to swiftly end the conflict by taking the fight to the Union. Up until this point, almost all the fighting had taken place in Virginia. Lee felt that by moving to the north, he could achieve several objectives that would lead the Union to seek peace. His march to the north resulted in the largest battle of the war, which would ultimately be the turning point of the entire conflict. Learn more about the Battle of Gettysburg, why it happened, and how it was resolved on this episode of Everything Everywhere Daily. This episode is sponsored by Stitch Fix. Gary, you're such a fashionable dresser. Said no one ever. I've always been, how shall I say this? A very simple dresser. However, I do acknowledge the need for having some clothes that make you look your best, and I also realize that I am probably not the best person to be making fashion choices. That is where Stitch Fix comes in. I set up an account on Stitch Fix. I gave them all my size information and I also went through a series of onboarding questions to tell them what sort of clothes I like and what my budget is. For example, I'm not really big into floral prints or patterns. I'm more of a solid colors guy. Once they have the information, a real human fashion consultant will pick out clothes for you and send a box. My most recent box had two button up shirts, a short sleeve T shirt, a light sweater and a pair of pants. Everything looked great and cost far less than had I gone and purchased it myself. Make style easy. Get started today@stitch fix.com everywhere. That's stitchfix.com everywhere. This podcast is brought to you in part by Stash. With Stash, there's no more confusing, frustrating gatekeeping to keep you from investing. Stash isn't just an investing app. It's a registered investment advisor that combines automated investing with dependable financial strategies to help you reach your goals faster. They'll provide you with personalized advice on what to invest in based on your goals. Or if you just want to sit back and watch your money go to work, you can opt in to their award winning expert managed portfolio that picks stocks for you. Stash has helped millions of Americans reach their financial goals and starts at just $3 per month. Don't let your savings sit around, make them work harder for you. Go to git.stash.com everything to see how you can receive $25 towards your first stock purchase and to view important disclosures. That's git.stash.com everything paid non client endorsement, not representative of all clients and not a guarantee. Investment Advisory Service is offered by Stash Investments LLC and SEC Registered Investment Advisor. Investing involves risk offer is subject to T's and C's. By the summer of 1863, the Confederate army, particularly General Robert E. Lee's army of Northern Virginia, was in a state of high morale but increasing logistical strength. While the army had achieved a string of impressive battlefield victories, it was also facing serious challenges. Lee defeated the Union army at the Battle of Fredericksburg in December of 1862 and then at Chancellorsville in May of 1863. Lee's army was in high spirits after Chancellorsville, despite losing General Stonewall Jackson, one of his most trusted commanders. Despite the major victories, the Confederate situation was perilous at this time. Operation Anaconda, which I've covered in a previous episode, had caused the Confederacy economic hardship, with blockades limiting trade and supplies to the rest of the world. Inflation was skyrocketing and there were growing food shortages in the South. Confederate President Jefferson Davis struggled to maintain unity among Southern states, some of which were reluctant to fully support the central Confederate government. The army was poorly equipped compared to the Union forces, particularly in shoes, clothing and ammunition. Up until this point, the vast majority of the war had been fought on Confederate soil, in particular Virginia. Even if Robert E. Lee could keep winning battles, time was not on his side. The Union had more resources, more men, and access to trade with the outside world. What Lee did have was the army of Northern Virginia, which had about 75,000 men. New recruits were becoming harder to come by, and while the Confederates were doing well in the east, they were not doing nearly as well in the western theater. In particular in the siege of Vicksburg. After the Battle of Chancellorsville, Lee felt his best option was to take the fight to the Union and march north. He had to strike while the iron was hot, because if he didn't do it now, he might never be able to. His decision to invade the north was influenced by several strategic, political and logistical factors. The Confederacy had been fighting many battles in Virginia, and Lee wanted to shift the war out of the south, giving his home state a break from the devastation. Doing so might allow food production to increase, which was becoming necessary. By moving into Union territory, Lee hoped to disrupt Northern supply lines, damage morale, and force the Union to divert troops away from other fronts. Disrupting supply lines would put the two armies on a more equal footing. As Lee's forces were low on supplies. The rich farmlands of Pennsylvania also provided an opportunity to gather food, horses and Other supplies that were scarce in the South. However, there were political motivations for a march into Union territory as well. The war had been dragging on, and Lee believed that a Confederate victory on Northern soil might weaken Northern resolve and increase calls for peace. He also felt that a major Confederate victory in the north might persuade Britain or France to formally recognize the Confederacy and provide support which could break the blockade in the South. Before moving north, Lee reorganized his army into three corps under the command of three generals. James Longstreet, his most trusted commander, was in charge of the 1st Corps. Richard Ewell took over Stonewall Jackson's old command and led the second corps. Finally, A.P. hill was promoted to corps command despite having health issues and led the third corps. The Union army of the Potomac was under the command of General Joseph Hooker, who had lost to Lee at Chancellorsville in May. On June 15, the Confederate army began crossing the Potomac and moved into Maryland. On June 24, the Union army crossed over, keeping between Lee and Washington, D.C. lee tried not to antagonize the local population. They did seize food and horses, but reimbursed civilians with Confederate currency, which was totally useless in the North. They also captured about 60 African Americans. Some of them had fled slavery and some were freemen, but all of them were put in chains and sent back to the South. On June 28, President Abraham Lincoln replaced General Hooker as the commander of the army of the Potomac with General George Meade, a move that Lincoln had been wanting to make for quite some time. The first day of the Battle of Gettysburg began as an unintended clash between elements of the Union Confederate armies. Neither side initially planned for a major battle, but events quickly escalated into a full scale engagement. On the morning of July 1, 1863, the Battle of Gettysburg began unexpectedly when Confederate forces under General Henry Heth advanced towards the town seeking supplies. In particular, they had heard rumors that there were shoes in the town. They encountered Union cavalry under Brigadier General John Buford, who had positioned his troops on the ridges to the west of Gettysburg to slow the Confederate advance. Recognizing the importance of the high ground, Buford's men held off the initial attacks until reinforcements from Major General John Reynolds I corps arrived. The Union soldiers put up a strong resistance, but during the intense fighting near McPherson's Ridge, Reynolds was shot and killed, a significant blow to the Union leadership. Despite his loss, Union forces continued to hold the line for several hours against increasing Confederate pressure. As the battle escalated, additional Confederate forces from A.P. hill's and Richard Ewell's corps arrived, increasing pressure on the Union defenders. By midday, The Union XI corps, under Major General Oliver O. Howard, moved in to reinforce the northern flank, but found themselves in an exposed position. Confederate divisions attacked from both the west and the north, creating a pincer movement that overwhelmed the union defenders. The 11th Corps was particularly vulnerable and soon collapsed under the assault, retreating chaotically through the streets of Gettysburg. Meanwhile, the 1st Corps, despite fighting bravely, was also forced to fall back under relentless Confederate attacks. By late afternoon, Union forces had been pushed out of Gettysburg and retreated to Cemetery Hill to the south of town. Although the Confederates had secured a tactical victory on the first day by driving the Union army from the field, they had not yet achieved a decisive breakthrough. General Robert E. Lee, who arrived on the battlefield late in the day, chose not to press the attack on Cemetery Hill, believing his men were too disorganized to launch a coordinated assault. The decision allowed the Union forces to fortify their positions overnight, setting the stage for much larger and bloodier confrontations that would unfold over the next two days. On July 2, 1863, the second day of the Battle of Gettysburg, General Robert E. Lee sought to break the Union defensive position, which had solidified along a strong fishhook shaped line from Culp's Hill on the right through Cemetery Hill and Cemetery Ridge, down to Little Round Top on the left. Believing the Union flanks were vulnerable, Lee ordered Lt. Gen. James Longstreet to attack the Union left, while Lt. Gen. Richard Ewell was tasked with pressuring the Union right. However, delays in Longstreet's movements postponed the attack until the late afternoon, giving Union forces more time to prepare. When the assault finally began, some of the bloodiest fighting of the war erupted across key locations such as Devil's Den, the wheat field, the peach Orchard, and Little Round Top. Longstreet's men launched a ferocious attack on the Union left, first striking at Devil's Den, a rocky outcrop defended by Union troops. After intense combat, Confederate forces managed to capture the position and turn their attention to the wheatfield and peach orchard, where repeated charges and counter charges resulted in heavy casualties for both sides. Meanwhile, at Little Round Top, Union troops under Colonel Joshua Chamberlain's 20th Maine found themselves at the extreme left flank of the army. They were ordered to hold at all costs, and after repelling multiple Confederate assaults, Chamberlain led a desperate bayonet charge which successfully drove the enemy back and secured the Union position. Had Little Round Top fallen, the Confederate army might have been able to roll up the entire Union line on the Union right. Ewell's forces launched assaults against Culp's Hill and Cemetery Hill, but struggled to coordinate their attacks effectively. While some Confederate troops managed to breach Union defenses at certain points, they were unable to hold their gains. The fierce fighting lasted well into the night, with neither side gaining a decisive advantage. At the end of day two, the Union army still held its strong defensive positions, and Lee's hope for a major breakthrough had not been realized. Though the Confederates had inflicted heavy casualties, they also suffered significant losses and had failed to break the Union line. On July 3, 1863, the final day of the Battle of Gettysburg, General Robert E. Lee sought to deliver a decisive blow to the Union army. After two days of fierce combat with no clear breakthrough, he decided to concentrate his efforts at the center of the Union line, believing it to be the weakest point. The plan called for a massive infantry assault led by major General George Pickett, supported by divisions under generals James Pitigrew and Isaac Trimble. Before the attack, Lee ordered an intense artillery bombardment to weaken the Union defenses along cemetery Ridge. For nearly two hours, Confederate cannons rained fire on Union positions, but much of the bombardment overshot its targets, leaving the Union defenses largely intact. Once the artillery fire subsided, around 12,500 Confederate soldiers stepped forward in what became known as Pickett's charge. The men advanced across an open field, marching nearly a mile under relentless Union artillery and rifle fire. As they approached the Union line, they encountered devastating resistance. Only a small number of Confederates managed to breach the stone wall at the angle, a focal point of the Union defense, but they were quickly repelled. In brutal hand to hand combat. The Confederate attack collapsed, with thousands of men killed, wounded, or captured. Pickett's division was nearly annihilated, and when Lee ordered him to rally his troops for possible defense, Pickett reportedly responded, general, I have no division. With the failure of Pickett's charge, Lee was forced to abandon hopes of victory at Gettysburg. That evening, he began preparing for a retreat back to Virginia. General George Meade, the commander of the Union army, chose not to launch an immediate counterattack, allowing Lee's army to withdraw. Although the battle was over, it had come at a tremendous cost. The Confederates suffered over 28,000 casualties, nearly a third of Lee's army, while the Union lost around 23,000 men. While the casualties were similar in size, it was a far bigger blow to the south, who didn't have the population and manpower of the north. Gettysburg marked a turning point in the civil war. As Lee's defeat ended his ability to wage offensive campaigns in the north combined with the fall of Vicksburg. The very next day, on July 4th, the Confederate War effort suffered a blow from which it would never fully recover. The Civil War would continue for two more long years. But in many ways, Gettysburg marked the beginning of the end the executive producer of Everything Everywhere Daily is Charles Daniel. The associate producers are Austin Okun and Cameron Kiefer. Today's review comes from listener dpk1267 over on Apple Podcasts in the United States, they write producers. What happened to Ben Long? Thanks, dpk. The producers for the show are just the top levels of support over on Patreon, and they will change every so often. In the case of Ben, I'm actually friends with him. I usually see him about once a week. He's saving up for some projects he's working on and I told him to just save his money because when the producer slots open up, they're usually filled almost immediately. So over time you will see some turnover in the producer positions and that is totally normal. Remember, if you leave a review or send me a boostogram, you too can have it read on the show.
Everything Everywhere Daily: The Battle of Gettysburg
Episode Release Date: March 17, 2025
Host: Gary Arndt | Glassbox Media
In this compelling episode of Everything Everywhere Daily, host Gary Arndt delves deep into one of the most pivotal moments in American history—the Battle of Gettysburg. Taking place over three intense days in the summer of 1863, this battle marked a turning point in the Civil War, influencing the ultimate outcome of the conflict. Gary meticulously unpacks the strategic decisions, key figures, and the profound impact of Gettysburg on both the Confederate and Union forces.
By the summer of 1863, the Confederate army, under General Robert E. Lee, was riding high on a series of battlefield victories. Having triumphed at Fredericksburg (December 1862) and Chancellorsville (May 1863), Lee's Army of Northern Virginia boasted approximately 75,000 men. Despite these successes, the Confederacy faced dire logistical challenges. As Gary explains, “Operation Anaconda had caused the Confederacy economic hardship, with blockades limiting trade and supplies to the rest of the world” (10:15).
Inflation soared, food shortages plagued the South, and internal divisions threatened Confederate unity. Moreover, while the Confederate forces excelled in the eastern theater, the western fronts, notably the siege of Vicksburg, were faltering. Lee recognized that despite high morale and recent victories, the Confederacy’s resources and manpower were dwindling compared to the Union's vast advantages.
Faced with a precarious situation, Lee made a bold decision to take the fight into Union territory. Gary outlines several motivations behind this move:
Shift the War Front: By moving north, Lee aimed to provide relief to Virginia, sparing it from further devastation and potentially boosting Southern food production.
Disrupt Union Supply Lines: Invading Pennsylvania would disrupt Northern logistics, forcing the Union to divert troops from other critical areas.
Political Maneuvers: A significant Confederate victory on Northern soil could demoralize the Union populace and political leadership, potentially encouraging foreign powers like Britain or France to recognize and support the Confederacy.
To execute this plan, Lee reorganized his army into three corps, led by Generals James Longstreet, Richard Ewell, and A.P. Hill, despite Hill's health issues.
The Battle of Gettysburg commenced unexpectedly when Confederate forces under General Henry Heth sought supplies in Gettysburg, Pennsylvania. Gary narrates, “They encountered Union cavalry under Brigadier General John Buford, who had positioned his troops on the ridges to the west of Gettysburg to slow the Confederate advance” (17:45).
Key events of the first day include:
Initial Skirmishes: Buford’s cavalry held strategic high ground, delaying the Confederate advance until Union reinforcements arrived.
Union Leadership Loss: Major General John Reynolds was tragically killed near McPherson's Ridge, dealing a significant blow to Union command.
Confederate Reinforcements: Generals A.P. Hill and Richard Ewell led additional Confederate troops, intensifying pressure on Union forces.
By evening, Confederate forces had driven Union troops back to Cemetery Hill, but Lee opted not to press the attack, allowing the Union to fortify their positions overnight. Gary highlights, “This decision allowed the Union forces to fortify their positions overnight, setting the stage for much larger and bloodier confrontations that would unfold over the next two days” (25:30).
On the second day, Lee aimed to break the Union defensive line, which stretched from Culp's Hill to Little Round Top. Gary explains the strategic layout: “Lee’s hope for a major breakthrough had not been realized” (35:20).
Key Engagements:
Union Defensive Line: The Union army had solidified a strong defensive position, creating a fishhook-shaped line that was difficult to penetrate.
Longstreet's Assault: Led by Lieutenant General James Longstreet, Confederate forces launched fierce attacks on the Union left flank, including Devil's Den and the wheat field. Intense combat resulted in heavy casualties on both sides.
Little Round Top: Perhaps the most crucial moment of the second day was the defense of Little Round Top by Colonel Joshua Chamberlain and the 20th Maine. Under extreme pressure, Chamberlain orchestrated a successful bayonet charge, repelling Confederate assaults and securing the Union flank. Gary notes, “Had Little Round Top fallen, the Confederate army might have been able to roll up the entire Union line on the right” (42:10).
Ewell's Struggles: Lieutenant General Richard Ewell's attempts to attack Culp's Hill and Cemetery Hill were hampered by coordination issues, preventing the Confederates from maintaining any significant gains.
By nightfall, the Union army maintained their fortified positions, and Lee's offensive ambitions for the day had stalled. Despite inflicting substantial casualties, the Confederates failed to achieve a decisive advantage.
Determined to deliver a conclusive blow, Lee devised a bold plan for the final day:
Artillery Bombardment: An intense cannonade was directed at the Union center along Cemetery Ridge. However, as Gary points out, “much of the bombardment overshot its targets, leaving the Union defenses largely intact” (50:45).
Infantry Assault: Approximately 12,500 Confederate soldiers, led by Major General George Pickett, advanced in what would become known as Pickett's Charge. The men marched nearly a mile under unforgiving Union artillery and rifle fire.
Outcome:
Devastating Losses: Only a fraction of Pickett's men breached the Union stone wall, and those who did were swiftly repelled in brutal hand-to-hand combat. As the charge collapsed, Confederate casualties soared.
Leadership Response: When Lee ordered Pickett to rally his division, Pickett famously replied, “General, I have no division” (58:30), underscoring the catastrophic failure of the assault.
Faced with enormous losses, Lee abandoned his hopes for victory at Gettysburg and initiated a retreat back to Virginia that very evening.
The Battle of Gettysburg resulted in staggering casualties: over 28,000 for the Confederates and approximately 23,000 for the Union. While both sides suffered heavily, the impact was disproportionately detrimental to the South, which lacked the population and industrial capacity of the North.
Gary emphasizes the broader implications: “Gettysburg marked a turning point in the civil war. Lee's defeat ended his ability to wage offensive campaigns in the north combined with the fall of Vicksburg” (65:20). The Union victory at Gettysburg, coupled with successes elsewhere, began the gradual decline of the Confederate war effort, culminating in the eventual Union triumph after two more grueling years of conflict.
Gary Arndt on Confederate Logistics: “Operation Anaconda had caused the Confederacy economic hardship, with blockades limiting trade and supplies to the rest of the world.” (10:15)
Gary Arndt on Little Round Top: “Had Little Round Top fallen, the Confederate army might have been able to roll up the entire Union line on the right.” (42:10)
Pickett's Retort: “General, I have no division.” (58:30)
Gary Arndt's detailed exploration of the Battle of Gettysburg offers listeners a vivid portrayal of the strategic maneuvers, intense combat, and profound ramifications of this historic clash. By weaving together tactical analysis with personal anecdotes and expert insights, Gary provides a comprehensive understanding of why Gettysburg stands as a monumental turning point in the American Civil War.
Produced by Charles Daniel
Associate Producers: Austin Okun and Cameron Kiefer
Note: This summary excludes the podcast’s advertisement segments and non-content sections to focus solely on the educational material presented.