Everything Everywhere Daily: The Invention of the Telephone

Host: Gary Arndt
Release Date: March 16, 2025

Introduction

In the episode titled "The Invention of the Telephone," host Gary Arndt delves deep into the intricate history of one of the most transformative inventions of the 19th century. While Alexander Graham Bell is widely celebrated as the inventor of the telephone, Gary uncovers the multifaceted narrative that involves numerous inventors, patent disputes, and the profound impact on global communication.

Early Attempts at Long-Distance Communication

Gary begins by setting the stage with the challenges of long-distance communication before the telephone. He states:

“Long distance communications had been a challenge humans sought to solve for centuries. In ancient civilizations, communication systems like smoke signals, drumbeats, and messenger services allowed limited information exchange.” (04:30)

He highlights the limitations of these methods, emphasizing that information often traveled "as fast as a horse could run." The advent of optical telegraph systems in the 1790s, such as France's CHAP telegraph, marked the first telecommunications networks utilizing semaphore signals.

Moreover, Gary acknowledges early scientific explorations:

“The first person to think about communications along a wire was the English physicist and biologist Robert Hooke, who in 1667 demonstrated that sound could travel along a wire.” (06:15)

Hooke's experiments, though primitive, laid the foundational principles behind wired communication, reminiscent of the tin can telephones familiar from childhood.

Pioneers Before Bell: Meucci and Reiss

Gary sheds light on Antonio Meucci, an Italian American inventor whose contributions often go overshadowed:

“In 1856, Antonio Meucci created an early working telephone prototype called the telotrophono, primarily to communicate with his bedridden wife.” (08:50)

Despite demonstrating his invention multiple times and filing a patent caveat in 1871, financial constraints hindered Meucci from securing a full patent, diminishing his recognition in the annals of telephone history.

Similarly, Johann Philipp Reiss from Germany made significant strides:

“In 1861, Reiss built the first device to carry the name telephone, known as the Reiss telephone. While it could transmit musical tones and some speech sounds, it struggled with continuous and clear speech.” (11:20)

Reiss's efforts produced the memorable transmission of “das furd frist kleinen girkensalat” (“the horse doesn't eat cucumber salad”), a phrase chosen for its phonetic complexity in German. However, his lack of pursuit in commercial development and patenting kept his contributions relatively obscure.

The Race to the Telephone: Bell vs. Gray

As the narrative progresses to the 1870s, Gary introduces other key players vying to revolutionize communication. Among them are Alexander Graham Bell and Elijah Gray, both independently working on transmitting speech electronically.

“By the 1870s, many were addressing the challenge of sending speech over wires via electrical signals, including Bell, Edison, and Gray.” (14:05)

Alexander Graham Bell's background as an educator for the deaf and his family's involvement in speech education provided him with unique insights. Collaborating with Thomas Watson, Bell pursued the concept of "undulating current," a continuous electrical current that mirrored the variations of sound waves, unlike the intermittent currents others were experimenting with.

Concurrently, Elijah Gray, co-founder of the Western Electric Manufacturing Co., explored harmonic telegraphy, enabling multiple messages via different tones over a single wire. His breakthroughs in controlling electrical circuit sounds led him to a liquid transmitter design, crucial for voice transmission.

The Patent Controversy

The heart of the episode centers on the contentious patent battle between Bell and Gray. Gary meticulously outlines the timeline:

“On February 14, 1876, Gray filed a patent caveat for a telephone using a water transmitter. Remarkably, Bell filed his patent on the exact same day.” (18:40)

This simultaneous filing sparked debates over priority and originality. Further complicating matters, the patent examiner, Zenisk Fiske Wilbur, had ties with Bell’s attorney, Marcellus Bailey, raising suspicions of bias.

“Years later, Wilbur testified about his alcoholism and indebtedness to Bailey, Bell’s attorney, casting doubt on the integrity of Bell’s patent approval.” (22:10)

Bell's patent was granted swiftly on March 7, 1876, just before his iconic "Watson, come here" transmission, which Gary describes as a pivotal moment:

“Three days after receiving the patent, Bell transmitted the first intelligible words using a liquid transmitter, cementing his place in history.” (24:55)

Despite Gray’s innovative liquid transmitter concept, Bell’s patent, bolstered by legal victories and strategic company acquisitions, including the purchase of Western Electric, established his dominance in the telephone industry.

Implications and Legacy

Gary emphasizes the monumental impact of Bell’s patent:

“Patent number 174465 has been called the most valuable patent in history, leading to the formation of the Bell Telephone Company, which eventually became AT&T.” (29:30)

AT&T's monopoly over the U.S. telephone system persisted until the 1980s, underscoring the long-term economic and societal implications of the patent dispute. The episode also touches on the broader system that emerged around the telephone, transforming global communication networks.

Conclusion

In wrapping up, Gary reflects on the collaborative and competitive nature of technological innovation:

“While Alexander Graham Bell was awarded the patent and is largely credited with inventing the telephone, he was one of many contributors whose collective efforts made the telephone possible.” (33:20)

The episode serves as a testament to the intricate web of invention, highlighting lesser-known figures like Antonio Meucci and Elijah Gray, and underscores the importance of recognizing the multifaceted journey behind groundbreaking technologies.

Final Thoughts

Gary Arndt's comprehensive exploration of the telephone's invention not only recontextualizes a familiar story but also celebrates the diverse minds that collectively advanced human communication. For the intellectually curious, this episode offers a compelling blend of history, innovation, and the complexities of technological progress.

Executive Producer: Charles Daniel
Associate Producers: Austin Oatken and Cameron Kiefer

Notable Listener Reviews:

• Edmonton Oilers Hockey (Canada): "Fantastic. This podcast is so fantastic. I've learned so much on stuff from turf to rockets. This is most definitely the best podcast I've ever listened to."

• Pandamoo 2011 (United States): "Love it love your show. Have told so many about it. So fun to listen to."

Gary extends his gratitude to all listeners for their support and feedback.