Fantasy Football Happy Hour with Matthew Berry

Episode: Eagles at Giants Reaction + Lamar Jackson, Kyler Murray injury updates
Date: October 10, 2025

Episode Overview

This episode recaps the Giants’ shocking win over the Eagles on Thursday Night Football, breaking down the fantasy football impact from both sides. Matthew Berry, Jay Croucher, and Connor Rogers analyze the rise of Jackson Dart and Cam Scadaboo for New York, the fantasy failings of Philadelphia’s stars, and dive into pressing injury updates around the league—including Lamar Jackson and Kyler Murray. Waiver wire suggestions, rankings, and trade questions round out the show, maintaining the energetic, irreverent tone that Fantasy Football Happy Hour is known for.

Key Discussion Points

1. Giants Dominate the Eagles: Fantasy Fallout

(03:19–18:00)

- Jackson Dart’s Breakout:
Matthew Berry doubles down on his preseason claim that Dart is a top-12 fantasy QB, highlighting his 50+ rushing yards in every start and his impact on the Giants’ energy and offense.

“He’s a top 12 fantasy quarterback. He is a QB1. The question is like, oh, is he now a QB1? [...] He’s been a QB1 this entire year.” (Matthew, 13:32-14:03)

- Cam Scadaboo’s Emergence:
Three straight games with 21+ touches; significant red zone and goal-line work. However, he’s considered a solid RB2, not RB1, due to heavy touchdown dependence and limited involvement in the passing game.

“He’s just a really good player. All the underlying stuff about Scadaboo has been great.” (Connor, 07:12-07:38)

- Giants Playmakers Stepping Up (Wandell Robinson, etc.):
Wandell posted a 27% target share with over 20 fantasy points—Berry credits Dart for elevating everyone around him.

- Coaching Praise for Brian Daboll:
Berry argues the Giants’ offensive turnaround under Daboll and Dart likely buys the coach more time, despite a rough start.

Memorable Moment

Jay jokes about “Bandwaggy J” for switching allegiances, with humorous ribbing throughout (e.g., “Never wrong, just early.” 03:18).

2. Are the Eagles Broken?

(20:22–27:17)

- Eagles Look Lost:
Connor calls the Eagles’ 4–2 record “fraudulent,” suggesting they should be closer to 2–4. He points to playcalling (“they only have 10 plays”) and lack of offensive creativity.

- Jalen Hurts Takes the Blame:
Hurts is candid in his postgame presser:

“I got to be better. I take ownership for it… [I’m] looking inward on the things I can control.” (Jalen Hurts, 22:08-22:50)

- Fantasy Underperformers:
Saquon Barkley and A.J. Brown both come under fire for disappointing returns.
Berry: “If [Barkley]’s not breaking up the long runs… he’s not really involved in the passing game, and he’s got competition at the goal line… They hate Saquon.” (24:43-25:17)

- Start/Sit Dilemmas:
Debate centers around Barkley, Derrick Henry, Cam Scadaboo as similar, fringe RB1/high RB2 options.

Notable Quote

“The Eagles offense is the most interesting unit in all of football right now—for all the wrong reasons.” (Connor Rogers, 20:56)

3. League Injury Roundup & Impact

(28:33–39:29)

- Lamar Jackson (Ravens, Hamstring)

• Expected out; Cooper Rush set to start. Confidence low for Ravens skill players; Zay Flowers still startable but downgraded.
• “Is anyone taking Cooper Rush plus seven and a half against [the Rams]?” (Jay, 29:47)

- Kyler Murray (Cardinals, Foot)

• Flirting with a game-time decision, but later in the show:
  “Kyler Murray will practice today. Barring any setbacks, he'll be the starter on Sunday versus the Colts.” (Jay quoting Mike Jarecki, 45:58)
• Marvin Harrison Jr. may benefit from Jacoby Brissett if Kyler can’t go, but ultimately, Murray likely plays.

- Other Headlines

• Chuba Hubbard (Panthers, calf) OUT; Rico Dowdle an RB1 start recommendation.
• Brock Purdy (toe), Chris Godwin (fibula), Bucky Irving, and multiple other starters discussed with actionable fantasy advice.

4. Waiver Wire & Start/Sit Advice

(38:37–39:35)

- Top Targets:

• Mac Jones (Kendrick Bourne stack), The Traveler, Kenneth Gainwell, Kymani Vidal, Trey Tucker, Jake Tongas, Mason Taylor.
• Mason Taylor labeled a “top 10 tight end rest of season” by Berry.

- Injury Replacements:
Recommendations are weighted by available opportunity; anticipate who’s in line for extra touches or snaps.

5. Flexual Frustrations: Your Toughest Flex Calls

(39:36–44:20)

Guest Dr. Denny Carter joins for fun, tongue-in-cheek flex start discussions.

- Kendrick Bourne:

• Denny: “I think Kendrick Bourne is a legit 12 team flex option this week.” (41:09-41:39)

- Travis Hunter:

• Primarily playing offense, operates from the slot—great matchup vs. Seattle.

- Olamide Zacchaeus:

• Viable flex as the Bears’ main slot guy vs. Washington, but flag on slot opportunity if Luther Burden plays.

Light banter about going “both ways,” as is tradition in the segment.

6. Fantasy Power Rankings & Listener Q&A

(44:43–51:04)

- Regulars’ Power Rankings:
Inside jokes and playful jabs as the show shouts out their most engaged online community members.

- Listener Mailbag:

• Trading Zay Flowers & Travis Etienne for Josh Jacobs?
  “Josh Jacobs is the best player in that trade and I think I want the best player.” (Berry, 48:13)
• Whom to trade for RB help: Keenan Allen, Xavier Worthy, or Marvin Harrison Jr.?
  “Whichever one of the three gets you the most in return… I have no problem dealing any of them.” (Berry, 49:34)
• Start/Sit: Rashad White, Sutton, or Keenan Allen?
  “Rashad White… No Bucky Irving, no Chris Godwin, no Mike Evans—they’re going to lean heavily on Rashad White.” (Berry, 50:27)

7. Pickup Lines – Best Bets of the Week

(52:03–54:03)

- Jay’s Pick:
Rams -7.5 vs Cooper Rush and depleted Ravens: “The Ravens are playing third and fourth stringers across this defense right now. I think the Rams are going to line them up.” (Jay, 52:33)

- Connor’s Pick:
Mahomes over 257.5 passing yards: “This offense is back... I think Patrick Mahomes, in a game with the Chiefs’ season on the line… gets at least 258 passing yards.” (Connor, 52:48)

Berry sides with Jay and the Rams bet—“I like the Rams over 7 and a half. Getting the 7 half. I agree… closes closer to eight and a half or nine.” (Berry, 53:30)

Memorable Quotes & Moments

• “Never wrong, just early.” (Jay, on switching teams, 03:18)
• “Kids, make this last because Daddy has no more money to feed you.” (Matthew, 02:46)
• “Bandwaggy J is in on the Colts.” (Matthew, 01:43)
• “Cam Scadaboo, it’s not just that he’s like a novelty, he’s just a really good player.” (Connor, 07:12)
• “Dart’s going to be a top 12 guy as soon as he gets an opportunity.” (Matthew, 08:32)
• “If [Barkley]’s not breaking up the long runs… they hate Saquon.” (Berry, 25:05)
• “Faith in five—that’s where the whole thing comes from with Jayden Daniels… there are quarterbacks like that that just galvanize a team.” (Berry, 16:52)

Timestamps for Important Segments

| Topic | Timestamp | |---------------------------------------------------|-------------------| | Giants/Eagles Game Reaction | 03:19 – 18:00 | | Eagles’ Offensive Woes & Hurts Owning Blame | 20:22 – 24:09 | | Start/Sit: RB Debate (Scadaboo, Barkley, Henry) | 25:15 – 26:24 | | Ravens & Lamar Injury Discussion | 29:06 – 31:35 | | Cardinals QB Situation (Kyler/Brissett) | 32:45 – 34:51 | | Panthers Backfield: Rico Dowdle Talk | 36:15 – 37:10 | | Waiver Priorities/Depth Options | 38:37 – 39:35 | | Dr. Denny’s Flexual Frustrations | 39:36 – 44:20 | | Power Rankings, Listener Q&A | 44:43 – 51:04 | | Pickup Lines (Betting Picks) | 52:03 – 54:03 |

Summary Table: Key Fantasy Takeaways

| Player / Topic | Advice/Insight | |---------------------------------|--------------------------------------------------------| | Jackson Dart (NYG) | Locked-in fantasy QB1, must-start; high rushing floor | | Cam Scadaboo (NYG) | Safe RB2, very TD-dependent, not used in passing game | | Saquon Barkley (PHI) | Still low-end RB1/high RB2 but disappointing, limited upside | | A.J. Brown & DeVonta Smith (PHI)| Startable but expectations must be lowered | | Kenny Gainwell (PHI) | Potential waiver add depending on injury status | | Lamar Jackson (BAL) | Out; downgrade to all Ravens, Zay Flowers remains flex| | Rico Dowdle (CAR) | Must-start RB1 with Chuba out | | Marvin Harrison Jr. (ARI) | Solid play regardless of QB | | Kendrick Bourne (SF) | Legit 12-team flex due to target share | | Mason Taylor (NO) | Top-10 TE going forward, lots of snaps |

Final Word

This episode balances sharp fantasy football strategy with playful banter and inside jokes, offering clear, actionable advice for both weekly start/sit dilemmas and big-picture roster decisions. The analysis on emerging players like Jackson Dart and Cam Scadaboo is especially valuable, as is the honest discussion regarding Philadelphia's slide and what to truly expect from fantasy “studs” who are underperforming. Injury updates are seamlessly integrated with advice on how to pivot, making this a must-listen for any engaged fantasy manager.

Catch Matthew Berry, Jay Croucher, and Connor Rogers daily for similar breakdowns.