Podcast Summary: "Fantasy Football Today"

Episode: 11 Dynasty Players to Trade NOW + Rookie Takes w/ Adam Pfeiffer
Release Date: March 21, 2025
Hosts: Heath Cummings & Adam Pfeiffer

Introduction

In this episode of Fantasy Football Today, host Heath Cummings is joined by Adam Pfeiffer to discuss crucial strategies for dynasty leagues, focusing on players to trade, rookie evaluations, and potential buys and sells. The conversation delves deep into player valuations, draft strategies, and positional analyses to help listeners gain an edge in their leagues.

Rookies Analysis

Top Running Backs in the 2025 Draft Class

Heath and Adam discussed their top running back prospects, emphasizing the importance of understanding player potential beyond last season's performance.

• Amari and Hampton: Positioned as top-tier running backs, both are seen as ideal Dynasty buys due to their combine performances and projected workload.

  Adam Pfeiffer [03:58]: “He’s got the size, he has everything you want. He's got the potential to have 20 carries per game.”

• Quinshawn Judkins vs. Trayvon Henderson: Adam leans towards Judkins for his consistent carry potential and goal-line usage, while Trayvon offers upside in the passing game.

  Adam Pfeiffer [05:57]: “Judkins is someone that projects more to get 18 to 20 carries per game and goal line work.”

• Caleb Johnson: Despite a slower 40-yard dash time, Caleb's on-field performance suggests higher speed and potential, making him a valuable third option.

Wide Receiver Prospects

The discussion highlighted the challenges of identifying top dynastic wide receivers, with few rookies expected to crack the top 12.

• Deebo Samuel & Luther Burden: Both have high ceilings but come with varying degrees of risk related to their usage schemes.

  Adam Pfeiffer [07:57]: “Debo taking the underneath stuff... I think this could be a nice bounce back year for Debo Samuel.”

Dynasty Buys

Heath and Adam identified several undervalued players currently priced low on consensus rankings, presenting lucrative opportunities for savvy managers.

1. Justin Fields (QB) & Anthony Richardson (QB)

   • Fields: Despite volatility, Fields offers high upside with a potential floor around QB15.

     Adam Pfeiffer [14:13]: “Fields I think was like QB12 for me. So I just don't see him being worse than like QB15 if he starts a majority of the season.”

   • Richardson: Positioned similarly, Richardson's potential to break into top five quarterbacks makes him a prime buy.

     Heath Cummings [13:05]: “Richardson might be the best player in fantasy.”

2. DeAndre Swift (RB)

   • Swing between RB18 and RB35 depending on the Bears' offensive decisions.
   • Adam appreciates his efficiency and potential in a revamped Bears offense.

     Adam Pfeiffer [16:42]: “I don't see a scenario... Swift can kind of be one of those underrated kind of roster players.”

3. Debo Samuel (WR)

   • Moving to a more offense-focused team, Samuel's target volume is expected to rise.

     Heath Cummings [18:21]: “He could give you a decent floor and there's still some upside weeks.”

4. Travis Kelsey (TE)

   • Despite age, Kelsey remains a top-tier tight end due to his consistent performance and potential to solve positional scarcity.

     Heath Cummings [22:32]: “Kelsey... can still be top five PPR points per game.”

5. Romeo Dunz (WR)

   • Elevated role in a new offensive scheme makes Dunz a promising option.

     Adam Pfeiffer [26:28]: “Everything should be better for Romeo Dunz... I'm all in on Romeo.”

Dynasty Sells

Identifying overvalued or high-risk players is crucial for maintaining a competitive edge in dynasty leagues. Heath and Adam highlight several players to consider selling.

1. Tyrone Tracy (RB)

   • Current valuation at RB23 is deemed too high given his inconsistent performance and competition for carries.

     Heath Cummings [32:14]: “Tyrone Tracy has to be a sell this year.”

2. Brian Robinson (RB)

   • Despite decent performance, Robinson's role may diminish, making him a risky hold.

     Heath Cummings [36:05]: “Brian Robinson is RB27... not a real difference maker on your team.”

3. Brandon Iuk (WR) & Mike Evans (WR)

   • Both veterans are aging and may no longer provide the reliable production needed in dynasty formats.

     Heath Cummings [44:34]: “Mike Evans is currently wide receiver 36... I prefer Deebo Adams.”

4. Devonta Smith (WR)

   • Recent offensive scheme changes have reduced his target share, lowering his fantasy value.

     Heath Cummings [49:21]: “Devonta Smith is behind A.J. Brown... moving him could be beneficial.”

5. Evan Ingram (TE)

   • Inconsistent performance and inefficiency in turning targets into fantasy points make Ingram a candidate for selling.

     Heath Cummings [53:46]: “Evan Ingram... is one of the worst in the NFL at turning targets into fantasy points.”

Quarterback Discussion

A significant portion of the conversation focused on quarterback rankings, particularly Justin Herbert versus Kyler Murray.

• Justin Herbert (QB): Valued highly but may not sustain top-tier fantasy production due to offensive scheme limitations.

  Heath Cummings [40:03]: “Justin Herbert... he's not at the point where... he's not getting a discount any longer.”

• Kyler Murray (QB): Presents a higher upside but with greater volatility compared to Herbert.

  Heath Cummings [44:10]: “I have Kyler at 10, I have Herbert at 12..."]

Adam suggests that while Herbert remains a reliable option, Kyler Murray offers potentially greater returns for those willing to take the risk.

Adam Pfeiffer [43:26]: “I'll lean Kyler... It's a good deal if you get Kyler plus for Herbert.”

Mailbag Questions

Listeners submitted questions regarding specific trades and player valuations:

• Trade Decision: Should a manager accept a second-round pick in Super Flex leagues for Anthony Richardson or Justin Fields?

  Adam Pfeiffer [14:13]: “If you told me Justin Fields plays the majority of the season... his floor is quarterback 15.”

• Player Valuations: Insights on whether to hold or trade certain players based on their current rankings and future potential.

Conclusion

Heath and Adam wrap up the episode by reiterating their top dynasty buys and sells, emphasizing the importance of value-based trading and strategic roster management. They encourage listeners to leverage their insights to optimize their teams ahead of the upcoming draft.

Heath Cummings [24:23]: “So that's my dynasty buys... Justin Fields, Anthony Richardson, DeAndre Swift, Debo Samuel, Travis Kelsey.”

They also remind listeners to visit FTNFantasy.com for more content and strategies to dominate their fantasy football leagues.

Notable Quotes

• Adam Pfeiffer [03:58]: “He’s got the size, he has everything you want. He's got the potential to have 20 carries per game.”

• Heath Cummings [14:13]: “Neill Peterson [interpreted as Richardson and Fields]. I recommend accepting those high-upside quarterbacks.”

• Adam Pfeiffer [16:42]: “I don't see a scenario... Swift can kind of be one of those underrated kind of roster players.”

• Heath Cummings [22:32]: “Kelsey... can still be top five PPR points per game.”

• Adam Pfeiffer [26:28]: “Everything should be better for Romeo Dunz... I'm all in on Romeo.”

• Heath Cummings [53:46]: “Evan Ingram... is one of the worst in the NFL at turning targets into fantasy points.”

Final Thoughts

This episode provides a comprehensive analysis of dynasty fantasy football strategies, highlighting undervalued players ripe for trading and those whose value may be declining. Through detailed discussions and expert opinions, Heath Cummings and Adam Pfeiffer equip fantasy managers with the knowledge needed to make informed decisions and gain a competitive advantage in their leagues.

For more insights and detailed rankings, visit FTNFantasy.com.