Fantasy Football Today: Consensus PPR Top 12 (Part Two) – Detailed Summary

Episode Release Date: June 24, 2025

Host: Adam Aizer
Analysts: Dave Richard, Jamey Eisenberg, Heath Cummings, and more.

Introduction

In this engaging episode of Fantasy Football Today, host Adam Aizer and his panel of analysts delve deeper into the Consensus Points Per Reception (PPR) Top 12 rankings. This segment focuses on the critical matchups: Malik Neighbors vs. Puka Nacua, Devon Achan vs. Ashton Gentry, and Nico Collins vs. Amon-Ra St. Brown. The team examines recent changes in player rankings, backed by thorough research and audience interactions, aiming to equip fantasy managers with the insights needed to dominate their leagues.

Rankings Overview

The discussion begins with an overview of the updated rankings for this week:

• 7. Malik Neighbors (WR)
• 8. Puka Nacua (WR)
• 9. Devon Achan (RB)
• 10. Ashton Gentry (RB)
• 11. Nico Collins (WR)
• 12. Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR)

Notably, Christian McCaffrey has dropped from 12th to 13th, and Nico Collins has climbed from 13th to 11th. The analysts emphasize the fluid nature of these rankings, influenced by ongoing research and player performance assessments.

In-Depth Analysis

Saquon Barkley’s Future as a Running Back

Dave Richard presents a compelling analysis of Saquon Barkley, highlighting the historical challenges faced by running backs who accumulate over 400 touches in a season. He states:

“[...] only three of the 24 running backs who reached 400+ carries outperformed their previous years, while 17 saw a significant drop in their PPR points per game.” ([06:20])

Richard concludes that while Barkley remains a valuable asset, his reliability as a RB1 is questionable based on historical trends.

Malik Neighbors vs. Puka Nacua: A Battle of Upsides

The core of the episode centers on the debate between Malik Neighbors and Puka Nacua. Adam Aizer cites Neighbors' impressive 11.3 targets per game, emphasizing his explosive playmaking ability:

“Neighbors has the highest upside of these running backs. [...] 11.3 targets per game, the best among everybody in the universe.” ([12:03])

Jamey Eisenberg counters with insights on Puka Nacua, highlighting his efficiency and potential to surpass Neighbors in PPR points:

“Puka Nacua might be better than Malik Neighbors... He averages over six yards after the catch per reception in both of his seasons.” ([17:36])

Despite current Twitter polls favoring Nacua (56% Nacua vs. 44% Neighbors at [17:12]), the panel remains divided, acknowledging both players' high ceilings and potential risks.

Devon Achan vs. Ashton Gentry: Evaluating Running Back Depth

Transitioning to the running backs, the analysts compare Devon Achan and Ashton Gentry. Dave Richard emphasizes Achan’s robust offensive environment with the Miami Dolphins:

“Achan last year, 17.6 PPR points per game... [...] expecting him to have a solid floor with potential for growth.” ([28:01])

Conversely, Heath Cummings raises concerns about Ashton Gentry’s opportunities given the Las Vegas Raiders' offensive line uncertainties:

“He worries about how much work Gentry will really get... and whether he can maintain his rookie production without established NFL experience.” ([33:44])

The consensus leans towards Achan as a safer first-round pick, with Gentry appealing to those seeking higher upside despite the associated risks.

Nico Collins vs. Amon-Ra St. Brown: Efficiency vs. Consistency

The debate shifts to wide receivers Nico Collins and Amon-Ra St. Brown. Dave Richard likens Collins to AJ Brown, praising his physicality and efficiency:

“Nico Collins and AJ Brown are the creme de la creme... Among the very best in the NFL.” ([52:00])

Jamey Eisenberg counters by highlighting St. Brown’s consistency and his role as a safe first-round selection:

“St. Brown’s just the safest one. He has a ton of red zone targets and feels like an easy auto-select when he's on the draft board.” ([47:00])

However, Nico Collins' high target share and recent performance post-injury offer him a compelling case, especially in leagues that reward efficiency and yardage over mere consistency.

Audience Interaction and Feedback

Throughout the episode, the hosts engage with their audience through Twitter polls and live comments. A pivotal poll presented:

• Puka Nacua: 56%
• Malik Neighbors: 44%

This data-driven interaction reflects the community’s leanings but also underscores the balanced nature of the debate.

Key Quotes with Timestamps

• Adam Aizer at [12:03]:
  “Neighbors has the highest upside of these running backs. [...] 11.3 targets per game, the best among everybody in the universe.”

• Dave Richard at [06:20]:
  “only three of the 24 running backs who reached 400+ carries outperformed their previous years, while 17 saw a significant drop in their PPR points per game.”

• Jamey Eisenberg at [17:36]:
  “Puka Nacua might be better than Malik Neighbors... He averages over six yards after the catch per reception in both of his seasons.”

• Heath Cummings at [33:44]:
  “He's going to have to do enough to warrant a top five or even a top ten pick.”

Conclusion

The episode concludes with a consensus that while all six players in the Top 12 PPR rankings possess significant fantasy value, their individual risks and rewards vary. Malik Neighbors and Puka Nacua stand out as premier wide receivers, each with unique strengths that cater to different fantasy strategies. Meanwhile, Devon Achan emerges as a reliable running back choice, whereas Ashton Gentry offers a high-risk, high-reward scenario. In the receiver category, Nico Collins presents an enticing upside, but Amon-Ra St. Brown remains the stalwart option for consistency.

As the fantasy season progresses, these rankings are expected to evolve, and the analysts tease future discussions to help managers stay ahead of the curve.

Next Episode: Tune in on June 30th for "Consensus PPR Top 12 (Part Three)" where the panel will cover players ranked 13 through 18, continuing their quest to provide the ultimate fantasy football insight.

For more expert analysis and updates, subscribe to Fantasy Football Today on your favorite podcast platform and follow us on Twitter @AskFFT.