Podcast Summary: Fantasy Football Today
Episode: "Guys Heath HATES! Players To Avoid When Drafting Dynasty"
Release Date: June 21, 2025

Introduction and Guest Appearance

In this engaging episode of Fantasy Football Today, host Heath Cummings delves into the often-controversial topic of undervalued players in dynasty leagues. Joined by recurring guest Kevin Coleman, the duo explores the rationale behind their "Guys Heath HATES," highlighting players they believe are overpriced or not worth the investment in dynasty drafts.

Understanding Dynasty Drafting Concerns

Heath begins by clarifying that his disdain for certain players is purely based on fantasy football valuations and not personal feelings. He emphasizes the importance of strategic drafting, especially in dynasty formats where long-term value is crucial.

Heath Cummings [04:02]: "Just because I have somebody on a bust list doesn't mean I think they're terrible. Let's have some fun today with guys I hate."

Insights on Future Rookie Classes (2026-2028)

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around upcoming rookie classes and their potential impact on dynasty drafts.

• 2026 Class: Kevin expresses skepticism, particularly about the quarterback position, citing players like Drew All and Leonard Sellers. He predicts uncertainty around the 2026 class's strength.

  Kevin Coleman [07:56]: "The 26 class is a big, giant question mark right now. The quarterback position could be a landmine."

• 2027 Class: Contrastingly, the 2027 class appears promising, especially with a deep pool of wide receivers such as Jeremiah Smith (Ohio State) and Ryan Williams (Alabama). Kevin highlights the potential value increase for this class.

  Kevin Coleman [08:30]: "The 27 class is deep at wide receiver, which is a cornerstone in Dynasty. These picks are going to increase in value."

"Guys Heath Hates" – Players To Avoid in Dynasty

Heath and Kevin meticulously analyze several players they deem overpriced or risky for dynasty drafts. Below are the key players discussed:

1. Saquon Barkley (RB)

• Overview: Despite a phenomenal last season, Barkley's value is questioned due to his age and injury history.

  Kevin Coleman [10:34]: "He’s just way too overpriced for the position he plays."

2. Brandon Aiyuk (WR)

• Overview: Valued at WR31 consensus but Heath places him at WR44. Concerns revolve around limited targets and offensive inconsistencies.

  Heath Cummings [16:54]: "It’s a low volume and not a concentrated target tree in San Francisco."

3. Terry McLaurin (WR)

• Overview: At WR34 in personal rankings, McLaurin faces age-related decline and potential touchdown regression.

  Heath Cummings [20:15]: "The age cliff is real. He turns 30, and nobody wants you."

4. Evan Ingram (TE)

• Overview: Currently TE12, Ingram's performance is hindered by a strong Denver defense and competition from emerging tight ends.

  Heath Cummings [22:10]: "He turns 31 before the season starts and hasn't scored more than four touchdowns since 2017."

5. C.J. Stroud (QB)

• Overview: Despite being QB7 in consensus, Heath rates him at QB12, citing lackluster fantasy output and offensive line issues.

  Kevin Coleman [26:31]: "He's amazing on the field, but his fantasy output doesn't help you win."

6. James Cook (RB)

• Overview: Rated RB41, Cook's role as a committee back with touchdown regression prospects makes him a risky pick.

  Heath Cummings [28:30]: "RB10 seems a little high for me. I prefer rookies over Cook."

7. Garrett Wilson (WR)

• Overview: Once valued as a top-tier wide receiver, Wilson's recent performances and offensive uncertainties have lowered his dynasty value to WR30.

  Kevin Coleman [32:10]: "He’s in the best offensive scheme he’s ever played in, which gives me hope."

8. DJ Moore (WR)

• Overview: Moore's struggles with the Chicago offense and personal performance dips result in a lower valuation at WR30.

  Heath Cummings [34:11]: "The vibes I'm getting from Chicago are not promising for DJ Moore."

9. Mark Andrews (TE)

• Overview: Once a top tight end, Andrews faces diminished usage and competition within a robust Baltimore defense, placing him at TE8.

  Kevin Coleman [37:09]: "He’s not elite anymore. His target share isn't what it used to be."

10. Justin Herbert (QB)

• Overview: Although Herbert is a skilled passer, his fantasy output doesn't justify a QB7 ranking. Heath rates him at QB12, emphasizing the static offensive scheme limiting his potential.

  Heath Cummings [40:37]: "He’s amazing on the field, but he doesn't put up fantasy points."

11. Baker Mayfield (QB)

• Overview: Currently QB15, Mayfield is viewed at QB21 by Heath due to inconsistent performance and potential regression.

  Kevin Coleman [43:22]: "He should be a little higher, but Dak Prescott might take that spot instead."

12. Isaiah Pacheco (RB)

• Overview: At RB28 consensus and RB41 personal ranking, Pacheco lacks a consistent role, making him a risky dynasty pick.

  Kevin Coleman [46:26]: "He's a dead asset to me all around."

13. Tyrone Tracy (RB)

• Overview: Ranked RB29, Tracy's unclear role and potential competition within the Chiefs' backfield lower his dynasty value.

  Heath Cummings [49:17]: "His role is just confused, making it hard to plug him into your roster."

Strategies for Managing Overpriced Assets

Heath and Kevin discuss potential strategies for dealing with these "hated" players:

• Trading Overpriced Players: Convert high-cost assets into valuable draft picks or other players.

  Kevin Coleman [15:56]: "If he's being priced at Dynasty running back four, I don't mind shipping him now."

• Focusing on Rookie Value: Emphasize drafting players from promising rookie classes (e.g., 2027 WRs) to maximize long-term value.

  Kevin Coleman [09:44]: "If you can get some of them now, they're just going to increase in value."

• Pivoting to Emerging Talent: Shift focus to younger, undervalued players with higher upside to build a competitive roster.

  Heath Cummings [20:15]: "If you’ve got him and you’re a contender, you could probably plug in wide receiver two numbers and be happy."

Conclusion and Guest Promotion

As the episode wraps up, Heath reiterates the importance of evaluating player value based on long-term dynasty potential rather than immediate performance. He also provides a platform for Kevin Coleman to promote his Substack and YouTube channel, The De Royale, encouraging listeners to engage and subscribe for more in-depth dynasty football insights.

Kevin Coleman [51:09]: "Check us out on Substack and YouTube. Dive in and see if you like it."

Heath thanks the listeners, acknowledges the production team, and signs off until the next episode.

Key Takeaways

• Evaluate Long-Term Value: In dynasty leagues, focus on players who offer sustained performance rather than short-term gains.
• Monitor Rookie Classes: Stay ahead by scouting promising rookies, especially from deep classes like 2027.
• Manage Overpriced Assets: Be proactive in trading or releasing players who no longer provide value.
• Stay Informed: Utilize resources like Substack and YouTube channels dedicated to dynasty football to enhance your strategy.

This episode serves as a crucial guide for fantasy football enthusiasts aiming to refine their dynasty draft strategies by identifying and avoiding overvalued players, thereby optimizing their long-term team performance.