Fantasy Football Today: NFL Draft Day Two Recap! Biggest Steals, Shocks & Veteran Impacts
Release Date: April 26, 2025
Hosts:
- Adam Aizer
- Dave Richard
- Jamie Eisenberg
- Heath Cummings
Episode Overview
In this episode of Fantasy Football Today, host Adam Aizer and analysts Dave Richard, Jamie Eisenberg, and Heath Cummings dive deep into the second day of the NFL Draft. They discuss the biggest steals, unexpected picks, and the impact of veteran players on fantasy football. The conversation is rich with insights on running backs, wide receivers, tight ends, and quarterback selections, providing listeners with actionable advice to enhance their fantasy teams.
Running Backs: Prospects and Fantasy Implications
True or False Segment: The panel begins with a true or false question about the second-day running backs being compelling first-round fantasy picks. All agree it’s true, citing:
- Quinte Judkins (Cleveland Browns): Drafted 36th overall, sharing the backfield with Travion Henderson.
- Travion Henderson (Patriots): Picked 38th, pairing with Ramandre Stevenson.
- RJ Harvey (Broncos): Selected 60th overall, benefiting from Denver's pass-heavy offense.
- Caleb Johnson (Steelers): Taken 83rd, positioned alongside Jalen Warren.
Notable Quote:
Jamie Eisenberg [03:21]: “Dallas is never going to draft a running back ever again.”
Fantasy Winners:
-
RJ Harvey: Positioned in a pass-friendly Broncos offense, Harvey is expected to excel in PPR formats. His previous performance included over six yards per carry and consistent touchdown scoring near the goal line.
Adam Aizer [09:23]: “RJ Harvey going to the Broncos, they throw to their running backs so much. That's going to give him a big edge in PPR.”
-
Quinte Judkins: With a clear path to the starting role in Cleveland, Judkins is projected to secure around 215 carries and 22 catches, making him a valuable RB2 with potential upside.
Dave Richard [23:01]: “Judkins landed in as good a spot as any of these guys...”
Fantasy Losers:
-
Caleb Johnson: Despite increasing carries, concerns about his pass-catching ability limit his upside compared to peers.
Jamie Eisenberg [18:16]: “Caleb Johnson is not going to sniff 36 receptions.”
Wide Receivers: Day Two Gems and Concerns
Key Picks:
-
Jaden Higgins (Texans): Drafted 34th overall, Higgins brings size and reliability, potentially mirroring JuJu Smith-Schuster’s role with Ben Roethlisberger.
Adam Aizer [33:31]: “Jaden Higgins opportunity with the Texans reminds me a little bit of JuJu Smith Schuster...”
-
Trey Harris (Chargers): Viewed as a versatile option, Harris leads Twitter polls and is praised for his route-running and speed.
Jamie Eisenberg [32:03]: “I’m hopeful that Trey Harris can be a helpful part of fantasy teams.”
-
Jack Besh (Raiders): Despite sharing targets with others, Besh’s placement in a revamped Raiders offense under Chip Kelly offers potential for significant fantasy production.
Dave Richard [35:29]: “I think this is a great spot for Harris to be in.”
-
Kyle Williams (Patriots): An intriguing pick with solid college performance, Williams could thrive if Stefon Diggs isn’t dominating the target list.
Jamie Eisenberg [59:31]: “Kyle Williams certainly deserves to be drafted in redraft in that same late round pick range as Harris Golden Bash.”
Fantasy Winners:
-
Jaden Higgins: With a high target volume anticipated, Higgins could emulate the success of second-round WRs who finished in the top 24 over the past decade.
Dave Richard [54:15]: “He's going to be one of those guys that when we talk about at the end of the season, is he approaching 900 yards?”
Fantasy Losers:
-
Luther Burden (Bears): Despite strong college stats, Burden's role in Chicago’s offense may limit his fantasy potential, especially with the presence of DJ Moore.
Adam Aizer [55:51]: “Luther Burden will not have much on his shoulders this year.”
Tight Ends: Analyzing Day Two Selections
Key Picks:
-
Mason Taylor (Jets) vs. Elijah Arroyo (Seahawks): A Twitter poll showed a split preference, with Jeff leaning towards Arroyo for his potential mismatch capabilities.
Jamie Eisenberg [41:11]: “Elijah Arroyo is more like a move tight end and a guy that brings some speed and a mismatch problem.”
-
Harold Fannin Jr. (Browns): Noted for leading the country in receptions and yards, Fannin Jr. is seen as a long-term asset if he can share the target load effectively.
Jamie Eisenberg [64:01]: “He is potentially the long term replacement for David Najoku...”
Fantasy Winners:
-
Elijah Arroyo: His speed and ability to create mismatches make him a desirable late-round pick with upside potential.
Adam Aizer [41:37]: “I am drafting this year Elijah Arroyo over Mason Taylor.”
Fantasy Losers:
-
Terence Ferguson (Rams): Despite being drafted four picks after Taylor, concerns about target competition and offensive schemes limit Ferguson’s immediate impact.
Adam Aizer [43:40]: “I really don't know who my favorite is... very tough call for me.”
Quarterbacks: Evaluating Day Two Quarterback Selections
Key Picks:
-
Tyler Shuck (Saints): Drafted 52nd, Shuck faces competition from Derek Carr and needs to prove his efficiency quickly.
Jamie Eisenberg [65:43]: “If he's great, then great. Maybe they've got their guy long term...”
-
Jalen Milroe (Seahawks): Seen as a potential backup with dynasty league upside, Milroe's opportunity hinges on health and performance.
Dave Richard [45:19]: “These are all backups.”
-
Dylan Gabriel (Browns): Positioned to compete with Joe Flacco, Gabriel’s fantasy value is dependent on his performance and potential starting role.
Dave Richard [46:44]: “Dylan Gabriel can compete for the starting job in Cleveland...”
Fantasy Winners:
-
Limited immediate impact expected from second-day quarterback picks, but Dylan Gabriel holds dynasty value for future potential.
Dave Richard [46:44]: “He could be a really good long term situation, especially for dynasty managers.”
Fantasy Losers:
-
Shadow Sanders: Despite interest, Sanders remains undrafted in early rounds, indicating limited fantasy upside.
Jamie Eisenberg [68:48]: “He looked like he had no clue what he was doing out there.”
Twitter Polls Insights
The hosts conducted several Twitter polls to gauge listener opinions on draft picks:
-
First RB in Half PPR League:
- Quintin Judkins (Browns): 34%
- Travion Henderson (Patriots): 32%
- RJ Harvey (Broncos): 19%
- Caleb Johnson (Steelers): 16%
Jamie Eisenberg [21:54]: “Judge Henderson, but it's in pencil...”
-
First WR in Half PPR League:
- Jaden Higgins (Texans)
- Trey Harris (Chargers)
- Jack Besh (Raiders)
- Kyle Williams (Patriots)
Adam Aizer [33:31]: “Jaden Higgins opportunity with the Texans...”
-
First Tight End in Half PPR League:
- Mason Taylor (Jets): 54%
- Elijah Arroyo (Seahawks): 46%
Adam Aizer [41:56]: “As far as the offensive line goes...”
Concluding Thoughts
The panel emphasizes the importance of opportunity and team fit when evaluating second-day draft picks. While many players offer significant upside, their fantasy value largely depends on their roles within their respective teams' offensive schemes. The discussion underscores the need for fantasy managers to stay informed about roster movements and coaching strategies to maximize their draft selections.
Notable Quote:
Adam Aizer [33:51]: “If you thought Nico Collins and Stefan Diggs could have good seasons, why can't Jaden Higgins...”
Final Insights:
- Running Backs like RJ Harvey and Quintin Judkins are poised to become solid additions with clear usage paths.
- Wide Receivers such as Jaden Higgins and Trey Harris offer considerable upside, especially in PPR formats.
- Tight Ends like Elijah Arroyo present high-risk, high-reward scenarios, while Harold Fannin Jr. could emerge as a dependable option.
- Quarterbacks from Day Two are more suited for backup roles or dynasty leagues, with limited immediate fantasy impact.
Listeners are encouraged to monitor training camps and preseason performances to refine their draft strategies further.
Tune In Next Episode: The hosts tease discussions on additional draft picks, in-depth player analyses, and listener mailbags. Don’t miss out on expert fantasy football advice to dominate your league!