Fantasy Footballers Podcast Summary

Episode: 2019 Rookie Review Show + MAN LUNGS
Release Date: February 6, 2020
Hosts: Andy Holloway, Jason Moore (absent), Mike "The Fantasy Hitman" Wright

Introduction

In this episode of the Fantasy Footballers Podcast, hosts Andy Holloway and Mike Wright delve into an extensive review of the 2019 rookie class, analyzing their performances and projecting their potential impact in dynasty and keeper leagues. Although Jason Moore was absent, the dynamic between Andy and Mike ensured a comprehensive and engaging discussion, filled with expert insights and strategic advice for fantasy football enthusiasts.

Tight Ends: The Hunter Henry Conundrum

Andy and Mike kicked off the discussion by addressing Hunter Henry, a tight end whose performance has been inconsistent due to persistent injury issues.

• Hunter Henry’s Performance:
  Hunter Henry played 12 games in the past season, recording 55 receptions for 652 yards and five touchdowns. While he had a strong stretch from Week 6 through 11, his overall reliability has been questionable.
  Andy: “Is there a point where you're just moving on from Hunter Henry?” [04:25]

• Injury Concerns:
  Henry's injury history is a significant deterrent for fantasy owners. Mike highlighted, “But the hard part gauging the truth though is just he's a good player, he's a great tight end... but you don't know where he's going to be next year.” [07:23]

• Dynasty Decision:
  The hosts debated whether to retain Henry in dynasty leagues. While Andy was skeptical, Mike leaned towards retaining him at a low cost, acknowledging his potential if he finds a stable team environment.
  Mike: “If I could buy Hunter Henry low in a Dynasty league, I would 100% be doing that right now.” [10:26]

Quarterbacks: Rookie Potential and Projections

The quarterback position saw limited standout rookie performances over the past five seasons, with only three rookies finishing as top-tier fantasy quarterbacks.

• Historical Context:
  Only Jameis Winston (2015), Dak Prescott (2016), and Kyler Murray (2019) have finished as top 15 fantasy quarterbacks in their rookie seasons.
  Andy: “Over the past five seasons, only three rookie quarterbacks have finished as a top 15 fantasy quarterback.” [13:00]

• Kyler Murray’s Bright Future:
  Kyler Murray was highlighted as a promising quarterback with substantial rushing yards, making him a safe pick for future fantasy success.
  Mike: “I 100% see a bright future for Kyler...” [14:00]

• Other Rookies:
  Daniel Jones and Gardner Minshew were discussed regarding their potential, with Andy expressing concerns over Jacksonville’s quarterback situation impacting fantasy projections.
  Andy: “I'm taking Nick Foles as the starter... making Gardner a very, you know, difficult proposition for fantasy owners.” [18:02]

Running Backs: Promising Rookies and Reliability

The running back position offers more consistent rookie performances, with notable mentions including Josh Jacobs and Miles Sanders.

• Josh Jacobs:
  Despite an injury-shortened season, Jacobs showed potential with 19 attempts and 88 rushing yards per game.
  Mike: “Josh Jacobs had a very, very solid season...” [23:38]

• Miles Sanders vs. Josh Jacobs:
  While Sanders is talented, Mike preferred Jacobs due to his workload and potential for consistent performance.
  Andy: “I don't disagree. There is a situation there in Philadelphia...” [25:16]

• David Montgomery:
  Andy expressed caution about Montgomery’s inconsistent production despite high usage, suggesting the possibility of offloading him in dynasty leagues.
  Andy: “Yeah, yeah, I would probably try to offload him because the risk is very high.” [29:17]

• Devin Singletary:
  Recognized for his efficiency and big-play ability, Singletary was touted as a solid pick for the upcoming season.
  Mike: “He doesn’t make sense. He’s small... Devin Singletary feels like an outlier...” [34:12]

Wide Receivers: A Boon for Fantasy Owners

The rookie wide receiver class of 2019 was robust, with five rookies making it into the top 36 for fantasy points over the past five years.

• Top Performers:
  A.J. Brown, Terry McLaurin, Deebo Samuel, DK Metcalf, and Darius Slayton were spotlighted for their significant contributions.
  Andy: “This past year, it was a big year for rookie wide receivers... A.J. Brown, Terry McLaurin...” [40:03]

• Terry McLaurin’s Potential:
  McLaurin was particularly praised for his speed and intelligence on the field, despite being hampered by quarterback inconsistencies.
  Mike: “Terry McLaurin has completely won me.” [43:42]

• Hidden Gems:
  Deontay Johnson emerged as a sleeper candidate with impressive stats, while Noah Fant was noted for his big-play potential.
  Mike: “Deontay Johnson... incredibly on my watch list...” [53:09]
  Andy: “Noah Fant from a yards after the catch perspective...” [62:05]

Tight Ends: Rookie Struggles and Future Outlook

Rookie tight ends historically struggle to make a significant impact, with Evan Ingram being the only one to have a standout season since 2011.

• Evan Ingram:
  Ingram’s performance was lauded as the best among rookie tight ends, finishing with 173 PPR points.
  Mike: “Evan Ingram has the best rookie tight end season since 2011.” [62:05]

• Noah Fant and T.J. Hockenson:
  Fant was highlighted for his potential in the Denver Broncos’ offense, while Hockenson showed promise despite playing in a challenging Arizona Cardinals offense.
  Andy: “I like Noah Fant... Athletic profile next year has me interested.” [62:32]

• Kaden Smith:
  Smith’s late-season performance made him a noteworthy tight end for fantasy consideration.
  Mike: “Kaden Smith... ok, we're good.” [63:24]

Conclusion

Andy and Mike wrapped up the episode by reiterating the importance of understanding rookies' potential in different positions and how their situations can drastically affect fantasy outcomes. They emphasized the value of perseverance and strategic drafting in dynasty and keeper leagues, providing listeners with actionable insights to bolster their teams for the upcoming season.

Notable Quotes

• Andy: “Is there a point where you're just moving on from Hunter Henry?” [04:25]
• Mike: “If I could buy Hunter Henry low in a Dynasty league, I would 100% be doing that right now.” [10:26]
• Mike: “Evan Ingram has the best rookie tight end season since 2011.” [62:05]
• Andy: “I like Noah Fant from a yards after the catch perspective...” [62:32]
• Mike: “Deontay Johnson... incredibly on my watch list...” [53:09]

Final Thoughts

This episode serves as an essential guide for fantasy football managers aiming to navigate the complexities of rookies' performances. Through in-depth analysis and candid discussions, Andy Holloway and Mike Wright provide listeners with the knowledge needed to make informed decisions, ensuring a competitive edge in their respective leagues.

Tune into the Fantasy Footballers Podcast for more expert advice, strategic insights, and entertaining discussions to elevate your fantasy football game.