Fantasy Footballers Podcast Summary
Episode: Buy or Sell + Knuckle Cracking Questions
Release Date: June 4, 2020

Introduction

Fantasy Footballers kicked off the episode with their characteristic banter, setting a lively tone for the discussions ahead. Hosts Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike "The Fantasy Hitman" Wright dive straight into the content, bypassing lengthy intros to deliver actionable fantasy football insights.

Buy or Sell Segment

Leonard Fournette: Buy or Sell as a Top 20 RB?
Timestamp: 03:40 - 09:16

The segment opens with a critical analysis of Leonard Fournette's value as a top 20 fantasy running back for the 2020 season. The hosts express skepticism about Fournette's consistency and team dynamics in Jacksonville.

• Jason Moore highlights the uncertainty around Fournette's usage:

  “...he is going to be one of those flag planting players where many of your league will just be out.”
  (04:23)

• Andy Holloway emphasizes the regression expected in Fournette’s touchdown production:

  “...he would have been a top running back last year with that target volume. But I do not see him as a top 20 back this year.”
  (04:47)

• Kenyon Drake adds concerns about Jacksonville's overall team performance:

  “...they have a defense that is a shadow of the past... it's debt. It's scary.”
  (06:08)

Despite the reservations, Andy Holloway ultimately decides to buy Fournette as a running back 18, acknowledging the potential upside but cautioning about the risks:

“...I am buying, but obviously not with, like, a heart full of hope.”
(08:54)

Mailbag: Listener Questions and Discussions

1. Dynasty Rookie Drafts: Snake vs. Linear Order

Timestamp: 10:03 - 17:22

Lou from Charlotte inquires about the optimal draft order for dynasty rookie drafts. The hosts advocate for a linear (non-snake) draft beyond the startup year to maintain fairness and competitive balance.

• Andy Holloway explains the rationale:

  “...if you finished in last place, you would get the first pick in each rookie round.”
  (10:03)

2. Impact of a Shortened Offseason on Player Rankings

Timestamp: 17:22 - 28:05

The discussion centers on how the lack of a traditional offseason affects player evaluations, particularly rookies and those returning from injuries.

• Jason Moore notes the challenges rookies face in adjusting to NFL game speed:

  “...those are the players who really need to get in there, learn the system...”
  (11:45)

3. Dynasty Trade: Adam Thielen vs. J.K. Dobbins

Timestamp: 28:05 - 35:23

A viewer asks whether to trade Adam Thielen for J.K. Dobbins in a dynasty league. The consensus leans towards prioritizing youth and future potential with Dobbins, especially for non-immediate contention teams.

• Andy Holloway shares his strategy based on team competitiveness:

  “...if I am a contender right now in need of maybe wide receiver help... I would trade J.K. Dobbins for Adam Thielen.”
  (13:39)

• Jason Moore emphasizes the long-term value of Dobbins:

  “...next year it's going to be J.K. Dobbins as the main runner...”
  (14:48)

4. Free Agent Acquisition Budget (FAAB) Settings

Timestamp: 35:23 - 46:08

Jace asks whether to adjust the FAAB from $150 to $200 or lower it to $100. The hosts discuss the flexibility of FAAB and its impact on waiver strategies.

• Andy Holloway highlights the strategic depth FAAB adds:

  “...it adds a new element of strategy... and adds fairness and adds a bunch of fun.”
  (16:08)

5. Cam Akers’ Potential as a Top 15 RB

Timestamp: 46:08 - 56:08

ATM1523 questions whether Cam Akers can break into the top 15 running backs, assessing his floor and ceiling.

• Jason Moore envisions Akers as a potential RB1 if he secures a leading role:

  “...there's a world where Cam Akers is the best rookie running back of this season...”
  (21:11)

• Andy Holloway sets realistic expectations:

  “...the odds on highest probability is that he is a solid to low end RB2...”
  (22:08)

6. Drafting Jared Cook vs. Noah Fant in PPR Leagues

Timestamp: 56:08 - 65:31

Colton seeks advice on whether to draft Jared Cook or Noah Fant in a PPR format. The hosts recommend Jared Cook due to his touchdown potential and involvement in the offense.

• Andy Holloway states:

  “...by the end of the year, the touchdowns are going to be more on the Jared Cook side.”
  (23:40)

7. Dynasty Half-Point: Terry McLaurin vs. Mark Andrews

Timestamp: 65:31 - 82:37

A dynasty league member debates choosing between Terry McLaurin and Mark Andrews for a half-point PPR format. The discussion underscores the value of Andrews as a tight end versus McLaurin’s versatility.

• Kenn Holloway prefers Terry McLaurin for his young age and potential:

  “...I will take Terry McLaurin over Mark Andrews because I think I can piece together...”
  (24:41)

• Jason Moore leans towards keeping Andrews for his positional scarcity:

  “...Mark Andrews, like you said, he's the difference maker out of position in a dynasty league.”
  (26:36)

8. Dropping Gus Edwards or Justice Hill in Dynasty

Timestamp: 82:37 - 93:12

Gus Busanuski questions whether to drop Gus Edwards or Justice Hill. The hosts advise against dropping them, considering their potential as valuable assets if injuries occur.

• Andy Holloway emphasizes holding onto running backs due to their unpredictable value:

  “...they run the ball so much, it's really hard to just completely give up on those guys.”
  (33:33)

9. Drafting Justin Jefferson vs. Jerry Jeudy

Timestamp: 93:12 - 101:43

Joseph Flanagan asks if it’s advisable to draft Justin Jefferson over Jerry Jeudy. The hosts favor Jerry Jeudy based on his better team situation and immediate impact potential.

• Andy Holloway explains:

  “...I would take Jerry Jeudy because of the talent, but the situation is far better for a very good Justin Jefferson.”
  (37:16)

10. Starting Players: Kareem Hunt with Dalvin Cook

Timestamp: 101:43 - 117:08

Stephen explores whether to start both Kareem Hunt and Dalvin Cook when drafting a first-rounder like Christian McCaffrey or Tony Pollard. The consensus is to avoid starting both to maximize roster flexibility and potential points.

• Jason Moore advises against holding both:

  “...you're limiting your upside doing that...”
  (37:08)

11. Wide Receiver Preference: Robert Woods vs. Calvin Ridley

Timestamp: 117:08 - 129:47

A listener asks whether to prefer Robert Woods or Calvin Ridley as a second wide receiver on the roster. Both Andy Holloway and Kenyon Drake opt for Robert Woods due to his consistent target volume and reliability.

• Andy Holloway states:

  “...Robert Woods is very, very safe to me.”
  (38:57)

12. Drafting Kerryon Johnson

Timestamp: 129:47 - 151:43

Garrett Johnston inquires about taking a chance on Kerryon Johnson in the draft. The hosts express hesitancy due to his uncertain role and team situation.

• Andy Holloway refrains from endorsing Johnson, citing his inconsistent usage:

  “...I actually don't want the lead dog if I think the lead dog is Swift.”
  (40:31)

Knuckle Cracking Questions

Throughout the episode, the hosts intermittently engage in light-hearted "knuckle cracking" moments, adding humor and camaraderie to the discussions. These segments, while brief, contribute to the podcast's engaging and entertaining atmosphere.

Conclusion

Wrapping up the episode, the Fantasy Footballers reinforce their commitment to providing high-quality analysis and actionable advice. They encourage listeners to engage via social media and participate in ongoing giveaways, ensuring the community remains vibrant and interactive.

• Kenyon Drake concludes:

  “...thank you for tuning in, supporting the podcast. We’ll be back with you on Tuesday next week.”
  (47:42)

Notable Quotes

• Jason Moore on Leonard Fournette’s potential risk:

  “If you are wrong about this, you will look the fool.”
  (03:52)

• Andy Holloway on FAAB’s strategic depth:

  “It adds a new element of strategy to the game of adding players off the waiver wire.”
  (16:08)

• Andy Holloway on dynasty rookie drafts:

  “...you want snake a startup, but year in and year out... linear draft.”
  (10:03)

• Kenyon Drake on Robert Woods’ consistency:

  “...he's getting all the work, getting all the goal line carries.”
  (34:10)

Final Thoughts

This episode of The Fantasy Footballers delivers a comprehensive exploration of key fantasy football strategies, player evaluations, and dynasty league management. Whether you're a seasoned manager or new to fantasy football, the hosts' insightful discussions and practical advice are invaluable for navigating the complexities of the game.

Stay tuned for more episodes and join the Fantasy Footballers community for ongoing tips and discussions to elevate your fantasy football experience!