Fantasy Footballers Podcast: Episode Summary Title: Player Price Check + We Have Liftoff! Release Date: June 2, 2020

1. Addressing Social Issues (00:52 - 05:11)

In a heartfelt segment, the hosts—Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike "The Fantasy Hitman" Wright—pause their usual fantasy football discourse to acknowledge and condemn the racial injustices prevalent in the United States, particularly following the tragic death of George Floyd.

• Andy Holloway (00:52):

  "My daughter is five years old. She is black. This is not the world that I want for my daughter."

• Jason Moore (03:52):

  "Our hearts have truly been broken this last week, and they really do go out to everyone listening, everyone going through this."

• Mike Wright (04:08):

  "I need to do better, and I can do better, and we can do better."

The hosts emphasize their commitment to educating themselves and their communities, reflecting a collective responsibility beyond their podcasting roles.

2. Player Price Check Segment (06:44 - 41:07)

The core of the episode revolves around the "ADP (Average Draft Position) Price Check," where the hosts analyze various NFL players' draft values compared to their consensus rankings. Utilizing data from Best Ball tournaments, they provide insights into whether players are being drafted too high, too low, or appropriately.

a. Michael Gallup (06:44 - 13:01)

Consensus Ranking: 26th Overall Wide Receiver
Current ADP: 33rd in the Draft (7th Round, 8th Pick)

• Andy Holloway (06:53):

  "Michael Gallup is a good option this year. Should be drafted as, you know, a high end three."

• Jason Moore (08:30):

  "Michael Gallup is a good option this year. Should be drafted as, you know, a high end three or a low end two."

Discussion Highlights:

• Gallup's performance last season showed potential with 66 receptions for 1,106 yards in 14 games.
• The drafting dynamics in Dallas, especially with CD Lamb and Amari Cooper, create a complex environment for Gallup.
• The consensus is that Gallup offers significant value at his current draft position, making him a worthwhile pick in the mid to late rounds.

b. Rob Gronkowski (13:02 - 20:32)

Consensus Ranking: Top 10 Tight End
Current ADP: 9th Overall Tight End (8th Round)

• Jason Moore (13:36):

  "Rob Gronkowski is being drafted as a top 10 tight end, which is way too high."

• Mike Wright (16:08):

  "He's a bit too high right now. I would project him to be late five, early six."

Discussion Highlights:

• Gronkowski's recent performance and injury history raise concerns about his reliability.
• While his name carries significant value, the hosts caution against overvaluing past glory.
• The consensus leans towards drafting Gronkowski in the later rounds if at all, preferring emerging tight ends with higher upside.

c. Tevin Coleman (23:37 - 29:38)

Consensus Ranking: 33rd Overall Running Back
Current ADP: 41st Overall (9th Round)

• Jason Moore (25:04):

  "Tevin Coleman has the opportunity and the ability and the system to perform if Shanahan chooses to make him the first of the timeshare."

• Andy Holloway (28:15):

  "Tevin Coleman could be a can start, not a must start."

Discussion Highlights:

• Coleman’s inconsistent usage in the previous season, coupled with injury concerns, affects his draft stock.
• Despite potential upside, his injury history and competition in the backfield make him a risky pick.
• The hosts agree that while Coleman might not be a top-tier RB, he can serve as a valuable late-round option for depth.

d. Cortland Sutton (29:38 - 35:44)

Consensus Ranking: 25th Overall Wide Receiver
Current ADP: 41st Overall

• Jason Moore (31:20):

  "There's a lot of hype for a guy who is, you know, he was drafted to be a star last year. He did everything in his power to show that he is for real."

• Andy Holloway (35:11):

  "Cortland Sutton is a great wide receiver. Broke the most tackles amongst all wide receivers in football last year."

Discussion Highlights:

• Sutton’s impressive final stretch in the previous season raised expectations, but his overall consistency remains in question.
• The addition of Jerry Jeudy poses competition, further complicating Sutton's role.
• The consensus suggests that Sutton is being overvalued at his current ADP, recommending robust favorites like Calvin Ridley and DK Metcalf over him.

e. Drew Brees (36:22 - 41:07)

Consensus Ranking: 6th Overall Quarterback
Current ADP: 10th Overall Quarterback (Middle of 9th Round)

• Jason Moore (37:00):

  "I'm all about that. If he's the 10th quarterback off the board, I'm all in."

• Mike Wright (38:33):

  "Can he sustain that touchdown rate? That’s been the problem."

Discussion Highlights:

• Despite his age, Brees’s consistent yardage makes him a valuable QB option.
• Concerns revolve around his ability to maintain his touchdown production.
• The hosts are cautiously optimistic, with Moore fully endorsing drafting Brees at his current ADP given his potential to break records.

3. Listener Mailbag and Questions (41:07 - 50:23)

The hosts engage with listener-submitted questions, providing personalized advice and insights.

a. Best Rookie Wide Receiver for 2020 in Half PPR Leagues

• Participant Suggestions:
  • Andy Holloway: Michael Pittman Jr.
  • Jason Moore: Jerry Jeudy
  • Mike Wright: Jalen Reagor

Jason Moore (42:24):

"I think Jerry Jeudy would be the guy I would put the highest odds on at finishing as the wide receiver one from this year's rookie class."

Discussion Highlights:

• Moore favors Jeudy for his potential high target volume and established talent.
• Holloway and Wright offer alternative recommendations based on team needs and situational advantages.

b. Dynasty League Trade: Acquiring Saquon Barkley

• Trade Details: Giving up Derek Henry and a 1.01 pick for Saquon Barkley.

• Jason Moore (44:57):

  "I don’t think he's an idiot. I believe Saquon Barkley is worth more than Clyde Edwards-Helaire or Derek Henry individually."

• Andy Holloway (45:13):

  "I think Saquon will be relevant a lot longer than Derek Henry will be for sure."

Discussion Highlights:

• The trade is deemed fair by the hosts, recognizing Saquon’s higher ceiling and potential longevity.
• They advise considering team depth and specific needs when making such moves.

c. Best Quarterback Scoring Format

• Isaiah's Question (46:54): "What is the best quarterback scoring format?"

• Jason Moore (47:02):

  "I prefer 6 point per passing touchdown."

• Andy Holloway (47:34):

  "You would say, fix it."

Discussion Highlights:

• The hosts advocate for awarding 6 points per passing touchdown and 1 point per 25 passing or rushing yards.
• They discuss the implications of different scoring formats on quarterback valuations and game strategies.

d. Origin of the Fantasy Footballers Podcast

• Andy Holloway (48:37):

  "What made you guys start a podcast was a love for our league of record and a love for talking trash."

• Jason Moore (48:45):

  "I wanted to talk about fantasy football, and writing is just not my bag."

Discussion Highlights:

• The podcast originated from the desire to enhance their private league experience, allowing for more interactive and entertaining discussions.
• The hosts emphasize the fun and engaging nature of their show, built upon camaraderie and shared passion for fantasy football.

4. Conclusion (50:23 - 51:33)

The episode wraps up with mentions of giveaways and promotions, encouraging listener engagement and participation in ongoing contests. The hosts reiterate their commitment to providing insightful and entertaining content to help listeners succeed in their fantasy leagues.

Notable Quotes:

• Jason Moore (00:52):

  "We know that this is not okay, that what happened to George Floyd is not okay."

• Mike Wright (04:08):

  "I need to do better, and I can do better, and we can do better."

• Andy Holloway (12:01):

  "Despicable. Me Reference. Jason."

This episode of the Fantasy Footballers Podcast skillfully balances important societal issues with in-depth fantasy football analysis, offering listeners both empathy and expert advice to navigate their fantasy leagues effectively.