Fantasy Footballers Podcast Summary Episode: The Overreaction Episode + High Class Canned Food
Release Date: March 26, 2020

Introduction and Banter (00:00 - 02:21)

The episode kicks off with light-hearted conversation among the hosts—Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Christian Kirk. Jason humorously inquires about Andy's consumption of canned goods amidst the pandemic, leading to playful exchanges about stocking up and the healthiness of canned food.

Notable Quotes:

• Jason Moore (00:58): "Have you eaten through your canned goods?"
• Andy Holloway (01:35): "From my understanding, canned food is the healthiest food."

The discussion swiftly transitions to celebrating Andy's birthday, with Jason extending his well wishes and Andy teasing about gifting canned food, further emphasizing the ongoing theme of pantry stocking.

Canned Food Game Segment (03:55 - 07:56)

In a fun and interactive segment sponsored by Brooks, the hosts engage in a "Who Am I?" game centered around NFL wide receivers. Clues are provided to identify a specific player, with initial guesses pointing towards Michael Gallup.

Notable Quotes:

• Jason Moore (04:35): "I know the answer, but after reading clue one, I feel like it's wrong."
• Andy Holloway (05:35): "And the thing is, A.J. brown is basically, I don't know if you guys know this. He is Randy Moss meets Jerry Rice, reborn..."

This segment not only entertains listeners but also subtly integrates fantasy football insights by discussing player performances and potential.

Podcast Promotion and Sponsorship (07:15 - 22:50)

The hosts take a moment to promote their website, fantasyfootballers.com, highlighting the daily rookie profile articles. Andy likens these profiles to "high-end canned food," praising the quality and thoroughness of the content.

Notable Quotes:

• Andy Holloway (07:50): "Equivalent of high end canned food, which I can't give a higher praise."
• Jason Moore (09:01): "All right, let's get into some news."

Following this, sponsorship segments feature Zoom and Omaha Steaks. The hosts humorously discuss their overstocked freezer of Omaha Steaks products, tying it back to the earlier canned food conversation.

Notable Quotes:

• Andy Holloway (20:29): "Don't overact people. Unless it's canned food. And then you buy so much."

News and Analysis (08:57 - 22:16)

Delving into recent NFL news, the hosts discuss significant player movements and team strategies:

1. Cam Newton's Release and Robbie Anderson's Signing:

   • Jason Moore (09:01): Highlights Cam Newton's release by the Carolina Panthers and Robbie Anderson's two-year, $20 million contract.
   • Andy Holloway (10:48): Positively views the addition of Robbie Anderson, praising his skill set and potential impact on Teddy Bridgewater's performance.

2. Jets' Acquisition of Rashad Perryman:

   • Christian Kirk (12:18): Approves of the Jets' decision to sign Rashad Perryman as a low-risk replacement for Robbie Anderson, deeming it a smart move with minimal fantasy value impact.

3. Tight Ends and Other Offseason Moves:

   • Andy Holloway (14:03): Discusses the high value and hype around tight end Tyler Eifert, cautioning against overreliance based on past performance.
   • Christian Kirk (15:28): Briefly mentions the Seahawks' signing of DeVante Parker without delving deep into analysis.

4. Devin Funchess and Aaron Rodgers:

   • Jason Moore (16:50): Talks about Devin Funchess's performance and future potentially diminished by team changes and Aaron Rodgers' involvement.

Notable Quotes:

• Andy Holloway (08:43): "They've done a ton of work behind the scenes, but they're not giving you all of that work. They're breaking it down to a consumable, easy to digest piece..."
• Jason Moore (24:36): "I don't think Tannehill is a top 12 lock. If you look at the playoffs, which, you know, are not part of that projection, passing yardage in the playoffs."

Overreaction Segment (22:50 - 53:57)

The heart of the episode focuses on "Overreactions" within the fantasy football community. The hosts identify and dissect specific instances where player performances or team changes may have led to exaggerated expectations or unwarranted pessimism.

1. Ryan Tannehill as a Top 12 Quarterback:

   • Jason Moore (23:28): Expresses skepticism about Ryan Tannehill being viewed as a top 12 quarterback lock, citing concerns over his playoff performance and sustainability.
   • Andy Holloway (24:36): Acknowledges the debate but emphasizes A.J. Brown's rising value, urging listeners to consider dynasty drafts and long-term potential.

2. Julian Edelman's Fantasy Value:

   • Christian Kirk (32:00): Defends Julian Edelman's consistency despite his age and absence of Tom Brady, predicting he will outperform his ADP (Average Draft Position).
   • Andy Holloway (34:20): Agrees, suggesting Edelman will be a "massive draft steal" due to his reliable target volume in PPR (Point Per Reception) leagues.

3. David Johnson vs. DeAndre Hopkins Trade:

   • Jason Moore (36:34): Analyzes the trade of DeAndre Hopkins for David Johnson, arguing that Johnson will offer better fantasy reliability than Carlos Hyde, contrary to popular sentiment.
   • Andy Holloway (39:58): Prefers Gurley over Johnson but recognizes Johnson's potential value in the new offensive setup.

4. Pittsburgh Steelers' Offensive Outlook:

   • Christian Kirk (46:00): Discusses the Steelers' disappointing offensive metrics and the uncertainty surrounding Ben Roethlisberger's future, urging caution due to high risk despite potential value.
   • Jason Moore (49:17): Highlights the uncertainty of Ben's performance post-injury and the offensive system's instability.

Notable Quotes:

• Jason Moore (23:28): "Is the back half of last year a true reflection of the fantasy value of Ryan Tannehill?"
• Christian Kirk (32:24): "Julian Edelman is likely going to be underdrafted..."
• Andy Holloway (34:20): "He's going to be a same old Steelers, but I'm going to have a much higher risk rating."

Final Remarks and Closing (53:57 - 54:08)

The episode concludes with a return to sponsor mentions, specifically Pristine Auction, and a reminder to listeners not to overreact—except when it comes to stocking canned food, humorously tying back to the episode's opening themes.

Notable Quotes:

• Andy Holloway (53:51): "Don't overact people. Unless it's canned food. And then you buy so much."
• Jason Moore (54:05): "Don't hoard the canned food. We're gonna be all right."

Conclusions and Key Takeaways

• Avoid Overreactions: The hosts emphasize the importance of not succumbing to overhyped narratives or undervaluing players based on short-term performances. They advocate for a balanced approach, considering long-term potential and underlying statistics.

• Player Value Assessment: Through discussions on players like Ryan Tannehill, A.J. Brown, Julian Edelman, and David Johnson, the hosts provide nuanced insights into their fantasy football value, urging listeners to look beyond surface-level performances.

• Strategic Drafting: Emphasis on dynasty drafts and understanding ADP trends to make informed decisions, especially concerning players with high upside but potentially volatile performances.

• Humor and Relatability: The episode weaves in humor and everyday experiences (like stocking up on canned food) to create an engaging and relatable atmosphere for listeners.

Follow the Fantasy Footballers: Join the fantasy football community at jointhefoot.com and follow them on Twitter @theffballers for more insights and updates.