Episode Summary: "This or That: Dynasty Edition + Buy or Sell, Reactions!" | Fantasy Footballers Podcast

Release Date: January 7, 2020

In this engaging episode of the Fantasy Footballers Podcast, hosts Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike "The Fantasy Hitman" Wright navigate through a mix of dynasty league decisions, buy/sell debates, and gripping reactions to recent NFL playoff games. Packed with insightful analysis, spirited debates, and entertaining banter, this episode serves as a comprehensive guide for fantasy football enthusiasts looking to optimize their strategies for the upcoming season.

1. Introduction and Off-Season Banter (00:00 - 04:22)

The episode kicks off with the hosts exchanging light-hearted comments about black shirts slimming down and reminiscing about receiving Goo Goo Clusters from a supporter, Chris Howell [00:57]. They delve into Jason Moore's recent trip to New York, taking children to museums and musicals, showcasing their diverse interests beyond fantasy football.

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [00:54]: "That just tells you exactly what you need to know about the dietary choices that have been made in 20."

2. Show Schedule and Promotions (04:39 - 12:57)

Jason Moore outlines the podcast's evolving schedule, mentioning bi-weekly releases from January through June, with plans to ramp up frequency during the regular season [03:12]. The hosts promote their sponsor, Pristine Auction, sharing personal anecdotes about acquiring sports memorabilia and highlighting exclusive offers for listeners [11:53].

Notable Quote:

• Andy Holloway [12:57]: "They’re slimming. That's my entry."

3. Buy or Sell Debate: Miles Sanders (04:39 - 12:57)

Presented by Pristine Auction, the hosts engage in a thorough debate over whether to buy or sell Miles Sanders in dynasty leagues. Jason Moore expresses skepticism about Sanders securing a top 12 running back spot next year, citing potential depth in the Eagles' backfield and Sanders' opportunity limitations [05:28].

Notable Quotes:

• Jason Moore [05:28]: "...I think he's going to be right on that razor's edge. But here's what I know..."
• Mike Wright [08:01]: "I'm going to buy."

4. NFL Playoff Reactions (12:13 - 17:16)

The hosts dissect recent playoff games, highlighting key performances and surprising outcomes:

• Buffalo vs. Houston: Mike Wright vents frustration over Buffalo's collapse despite leading [15:00].
• Tennessee vs. New England: Andy Holloway affirms that the Patriots' dynasty remains intact, countering doubts about their future [13:45].
• Minnesota vs. New Orleans & Seattle vs. Philadelphia: Discussions revolve around player performances and coaching decisions, emphasizing unpredictability in playoff outcomes [16:15].

Notable Quote:

• Mike Wright [16:44]: "I hate, like Sean McDermott. I hate you again."

5. Coaching News: Mike McCarthy and Jason Garrett (21:36 - 25:38)

The conversation shifts to coaching changes, particularly the hiring of Mike McCarthy as the new head coach of the Dallas Cowboys. The hosts analyze McCarthy's potential impact, referencing his offensive expertise and previous tenure with the Packers [22:50]. They also discuss the unconventional firing of Jason Garrett with the New York Giants, highlighting the team's strategic maneuvers [21:36].

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [23:16]: "Is it Wrong. That I feel like that's like my grandpa going to the iPad classes. I mean, I just don't know."

6. Dynasty "This or That" Segments (30:03 - 49:56)

The heart of the episode features a series of "This or That" segments, where the hosts debate dynasty league preferences between closely ranked players:

a. Joe Mixon vs. Leonard Fournette (30:58 - 35:23)

• Andy Holloway and Mike Wright advocate for Joe Mixon due to his youth and recent surge in performance with the Bengals.
• Jason Moore leans towards selling Mixon, questioning his long-term potential amidst team dynamics.

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [32:00]: "I think Mixon's a great dynasty for me."

b. Cortland Sutton vs. Stefon Diggs (35:25 - 38:25)

• Andy Holloway prefers Cortland Sutton for his clear role and younger age.
• Mike Wright concurs, citing Stefon Diggs' inconsistency despite his elite separation skills.

Notable Quote:

• Andy Holloway [36:18]: "From a dynasty perspective, I am definitely on the Cortland Sutton side."

c. Hunter Henry vs. Darren Waller (38:39 - 45:11)

• The debate revolves around consistency and touchdown potential.
• Andy ultimately favors Darren Waller for his reliability and consistent target volume.
• Mike expresses confidence in Hunter Henry's touchdown upside but acknowledges his injury concerns.

Notable Quote:

• Andy Holloway [44:52]: "I think I am on the Darren Waller side... I just want it to be safer."

d. Baker Mayfield vs. Jared Goff (45:25 - 49:55)

• Andy Holloway opts for Jared Goff due to his proven performance and stability under McCarthy.
• Mike Wright champions Baker Mayfield, excited about his potential with a new offensive scheme.

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [46:10]: "I don't think he's going to be that top five guy on a weekly basis."

7. Mailbag: Listener Questions (50:03 - 56:23)

The hosts address listener-submitted questions, providing tailored advice and insights:

a. Devonte Parker Draft Strategy (50:42 - 52:15)

• Discussion centers on drafting Devonte Parker, contingent on Fitz Magic remaining the starting quarterback. The consensus leans towards holding Parker if Fitz is uncertain, advocating for trust in the current quarterback dynamics.

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [51:46]: "Trust the process, get to a healthy, get him a year of experience on an NFL bench slash practice field."

b. Emerging Elite Talent (52:15 - 55:39)

• Topics include potential breakout players like Devonta Singletary, Debo Samuels, and Robbie Anderson who could ascend to elite status with the right opportunities and team support.

Notable Quote:

• Andy Holloway [53:22]: "I think Robbie Anderson is sure."

c. Optimal Number of Owners for Dynasty Leagues (55:53 - 56:23)

• Andy Holloway recommends 10-12 committed owners to maintain league stability and depth, crucial for dynasty formats.

Notable Quote:

• Andy Holloway [56:46]: "12 is the best number because I think that's the context in which all the shows that you're listening to are talking about."

8. Conclusion and Call to Action (56:23 - 58:13)

The episode wraps up with the hosts encouraging listeners to participate in their Thursday AMA sessions by submitting questions via social media or their website [56:03]. They also mention ongoing giveaways and invite fans to join their fantasy football community for exclusive content and interactions [58:10].

Notable Quote:

• Jason Moore [57:41]: "Hope you enjoyed today's episode."

Key Takeaways:

• Dynasty League Focus: Emphasizes the importance of youth, consistency, and clear roles in player selection. Preferences lean towards younger, reliable players with high upside.

• Buy or Sell Insights: Evaluates players like Miles Sanders by considering team dynamics, injury history, and future opportunities within the team's roster.

• NFL Impact on Fantasy: Highlights how coaching changes and playoff performances can significantly influence fantasy league strategies and player valuations.

• Engaging Listener Interaction: Encourages active participation through mailbag segments and AMA sessions, fostering a community-driven environment.

This episode serves as a treasure trove of strategic advice and entertaining discourse, equipping fantasy football managers with the knowledge to make informed decisions and stay ahead in their leagues.