Fantasy Footballers Podcast Summary: "What Went Wrong? + MORE Free Agent Frenzy!" (03/13/2025)

Hosts: Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike "The Fantasy Hitman" Wright

On March 13, 2025, The Fantasy Footballers delivered an insightful episode titled "What Went Wrong? + MORE Free Agent Frenzy!", blending in-depth analysis of underperforming fantasy players with a comprehensive overview of the recent free agency landscape. Hosted by the expert trio—Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike Wright—the episode delves into the disappointments of the previous fantasy season and anticipates the moves that could shape the upcoming league.

1. Introduction and New Series Launch

Jason Moore kicked off the episode with enthusiasm, highlighting the continuity of the show:

Jason Moore [00:54]: "Welcome in Thursday, March 13, the Fantasy Footballers. Back with you. Jason Moore, The Cal Ripken Jr. Of the podcast flew in at 4am today just to make sure he didn't miss this episode."

The hosts introduced a new segment titled "What Went Wrong?", aimed at dissecting high-draft-pick players who failed to meet fantasy expectations.

2. "What Went Wrong?" Segment: Dalton Kincaid's Disappointment

The focal point of the segment was Dalton Kincaid, an early fifth-round pick who failed to live up to his high draft position.

Jason Moore outlined Kincaid's faltering performance:

Jason Moore [04:12]: "Dalton Kincaid, an early 5th round fantasy draft pick as the tight end 5 coming off of a tight end 11 season in 16 games played with 91 targets, 73 receptions, 673 yards."

Despite initial excitement surrounding his potential to replace Stefan Diggs and elevate to a top-tier fantasy tight end, Kincaid's 2024 season was underwhelming:

Andy Holloway [05:25]: "He was dealing with some injuries but I mean he was, you know, he caught 80% of his passes as a rookie and last year was 59% of the passes. He just wasn't good on film. He wasn't that. He wasn't producing. He wasn't breaking tackles. He wasn't getting open the same."

Jason Moore projected a conservative outlook for Kincaid's future:

Jason Moore [06:30]: "I would say a realistic expectation for Kincaid is probably around 75 receptions next year."

The hosts analyzed the strategic missteps, pointing out Kincaid's over-reliance on deep routes without yield:

Jason Moore [07:15]: "He ran the second most go routes. So there was the attempt to... he didn't connect on the deep throws."

Concluding the discussion, Mike Wright and Andy Holloway expressed skepticism about Kincaid's future value, suggesting that fantasy managers might regret their investment.

Andy Holloway [10:42]: "You're just hoping something clicks as he gets older."

3. Free Agent Frenzy: Key Signings and Their Fantasy Impact

Transitioning from player disappointments, the hosts delved into the free agency period of 2025, assessing notable signings and their implications for fantasy football managers.

Amari Cooper's Retirement

A significant topic was Amari Cooper's unexpected retirement after eight seasons with the Los Angeles Rams:

Jason Moore [16:43]: "Amari Cooper... the problem with this list is they're interesting names because they once upon a time were top-tier NFL players and now it's... are they anywhere close?"

The hosts debated the rarity of seasoned receivers finding success post-retirement, drawing parallels to Adam Thielen.

Aaron Rodgers' Decision Dilemma

Aaron Rodgers became a central figure as his future remained undecided, prompting frustration from both the hosts and the fantasy community:

Jason Moore [24:35]: "If one is washed and 10 is the MVP season of Cooper Cup, what number do you think he is at going into next year?"

Mike Wright criticized the mishandling of Rodgers' free agency:

Mike Wright [25:04]: "He could go to the Pittsburgh Steelers because you're 40 something years old and you have a year or two left. You're not winning a Super Bowl with the Giants."

The discussion highlighted the complexities of Rodgers' potential destinations and their respective fantasy impacts.

Broncos Sign Evan Ingram

The signing of Evan Ingram by the Denver Broncos was examined for its potential upside:

Jason Moore [26:54]: "I think this is a huge move for the offense."

Andy Holloway praised the Broncos' strategic acquisition:

Andy Holloway [27:07]: "This is about as good of a destination as possible."

The hosts concurred that Ingram's versatility could bolster Denver's offensive dynamics, making them a formidable playoff contender.

Saints Re-signing Juwan Johnson

The re-signing of Juwan Johnson by the New Orleans Saints was discussed, albeit with caution regarding his fantasy relevance:

Mike Wright [28:31]: "Juwan Johnson is... good player. You got 21 guaranteed to come back for the Saints."

While acknowledging Johnson's capabilities, the hosts advised fantasy managers to view him as a punt option rather than a primary target.

Carolina Panthers Acquire Rico Dowdle

Rico Dowdle's move to the Carolina Panthers sparked analysis on his role and fantasy value:

Mike Wright [30:08]: "Rico Dowdle will be way up there because if Chuba goes down with the run scheme... Rico would do work if he were given the job."

The discussion underscored Dowdle's potential as a valuable backup and insurance option in dynasty leagues, contingent on his utilization and team strategy.

4. Additional Free Agency Movements

The episode further explored miscellaneous free agents and their standings:

• Nick Chubb remained a point of interest, with debates on his potential resurgence.
• DeAndre Hopkins' move to the Ravens was analyzed, though consensus was that his fantasy impact would be minimal.
• DeMarcus Robinson's acquisition by the 49ers was deemed a sensible move to fill gaps in their wide receiver lineup.
• Mac Jones’ hypothetical signing by the 49ers was criticized, questioning his viability as a game-winning quarterback.

5. Closing Remarks and Future Content

As the episode neared its conclusion, the hosts teased upcoming segments:

Jason Moore [46:24]: "We'll talk about them because speculating on them is more interesting."

They also promoted their next episodes, including Trending or Ending and Mailbag segments, encouraging listeners to engage with additional content via jointhefoot.com.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Jason Moore [04:12]: "Dalton Kincaid... tremendous excitement for Dalton Kincaid."
• Andy Holloway [05:25]: "He just wasn't good on film. He wasn't that. He wasn't producing."
• Jason Moore [07:15]: "He ran the second most go routes."
• Mike Wright [10:42]: "You're just hoping something clicks as he gets older."
• Jason Moore [24:35]: "If one is washed and 10 is the MVP season of Cooper Cup..."
• Andy Holloway [27:07]: "This is about as good of a destination as possible."
• Mike Wright [30:08]: "Rico Dowdle will be way up there because if Chuba goes down..."

Conclusion

This episode of The Fantasy Footballers provided a balanced mix of retrospective analysis and forward-looking projections. By dissecting the reasons behind certain players' underperformance and evaluating the landscape of free agency signings, the hosts equipped fantasy football enthusiasts with the knowledge to make informed decisions for the upcoming season. Whether grappling with the fallout of high-draft picks like Dalton Kincaid or navigating the murky waters of player movements like Aaron Rodgers and Amari Cooper, The Fantasy Footballers continue to be an indispensable resource for winning fantasy leagues.

For more insights and to join the Fantasy Football community, visit jointhefoot.com and follow The Fantasy Footballers on Twitter.