FantasyPros NFL Draft Show — Top 5 Rookie Prospects You're Too Low On (Ep. 1965)

Release Date: February 18, 2026
Hosts: Seth Wilcock & Derrick Brown

Episode Overview

In this special sleepers episode, Seth Wilcock and Derrick Brown spotlight the most underrated rookie prospects heading into the 2026 NFL Draft. With the public focused on flashy, big-school names, the hosts dig deep—analyzing players overlooked by most fantasy managers, including prospects from smaller schools, less hyped programs, and unconventional backgrounds. The episode aims to equip dynasty fantasy football managers with the edge needed to target value picks in rookie drafts and better understand the changing landscape of college-to-NFL player development.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

[03:37] — 1. Jacoby Lane, WR, USC

• Profile: 6'4", 200 lbs; former four-star recruit.
• Production:
  • Sophomore: 12 TDs (top five nationally).
  • Junior: 49 catches, 745 yards, 4 TDs—showing an expanded "move the chains" role.
• Strengths:
  • Reliable in high-leverage situations, especially against tough competition (e.g., vs. Oregon: 6 receptions, 108 yards).
  • Big catch radius, excels in contested situations.
  • Route-running: “He adds all those intricacies into his route running where he’s inviting indecision in a cornerback’s head. And that’s how you create separation outside of just raw athleticism and footwork.” — Derrick Brown [05:33]
• Limitations:
  • Deceleration, hip fluidity; some physical ceiling.
  • Not currently a consensus top-20 rookie pick in dynasty.
• Draft Value:
  • “Right now, I think you can get him for an easy second round price tag in Dynasty rookie drafts, a late second, and sometimes he’s going in the third… I think it’s too late.” — Seth Wilcock [07:42]

[07:44] — 2. Ted Hurst, WR, Georgia State

• Profile: 6'3", 185 lbs; made Bruce Feldman’s Freak List.
• Production:
  • 127 catches, nearly 2,000 yards, 15 TDs over past two seasons for a team that cycled five QBs.
• Strengths:
  • Play strength and fluid speed.
  • Downfield weapon: 12.6 ADOT, 24th in missed tackles forced (among FBS WRs, minimum 50 targets).
  • Effortless mover with strong testing potential (“I won’t be surprised if he runs in the 4.3s… probably more of a 4.4 guy.” — Derrick Brown [09:59])
• Outlook:
  • Likely Day 2 (3rd round) pick, with “small school” bias possibly limiting his buzz.
  • Historical comps to past successful small-school NFL receivers noted.
• Quote:
  • “It’s just… effortless speed. The play strength at that frame… this dude can fly.” — Derrick Brown [09:04]

[17:16] — 3. Omar Cooper Jr., WR, Indiana

• Profile: 6'0", 200 lbs; four-year player, primary deep threat turned versatile slot.
• Production:
  • Junior season: 61 catches, 849 yards, 12 TDs (third nationally).
  • Made clutch plays in high-stakes games, including toe-tapping TD vs. Penn State.
• Strengths:
  • Elite body control: “[Made] one of the best catches you will see in all of college football.” — Derrick Brown [18:26]
  • Per-route production: 2.55, 2.52, 2.14 YPRR over three years (top 40 FBS each year).
  • Power slot/outside experience, highly efficient in missed tackles forced.
• Concerns:
  • Lacks elite athleticism, but compensates with technical polish and play strength.
• Quote:
  • “If anybody wants to stand in front of me today and say I fully believe Omar Cooper is a better prospect than Elijah Surrat, I’m not going to fight with you.” — Derrick Brown [21:37]

[22:40] — 4. Cole Payton, QB, North Dakota State

• Profile: Dual-threat, FCS prospect; 6'3"+, athletic, one year as full-time starter.
• Production:
  • 2025: 2,700+ passing yards, 16 TDs, 800 rushing yards, 13 rush TDs.
  • Prior: Primarily used as Wildcat QB/wild package.
• Strengths:
  • Arm talent: “He has the arm talent, he has the easy arm strength. This dude’s ripping 40 yard outs like it’s nobody’s business.” — Derrick Brown [24:39]
  • Anticipation, reading defenses, athleticism.
  • Compares traits favorably to previous NDSU QBs (Trey Lance, Carson Wentz) and other “tools-y” prospects.
• Concerns:
  • Single year of starting experience.
  • Level of competition jump (FCS to NFL).
  • Needs to sit for a year at the NFL level to develop.
• Quote:
  • “There is no way in hell… I would be drafting freaking Diego Pavia over Cole Payton 10 times out of 10, 10 feet down, 10 toes down.” — Derrick Brown [27:23]

[33:56] — 5. Mike Washington Jr., RB, Arkansas

• Profile: 6'2", 223 lbs; two-star recruit, transferred from Buffalo to New Mexico State to Arkansas.
• Production:
  • 2025: 1,000+ rushing yards (fifth in SEC), 6.4 YPC (second in SEC), high explosive run rate behind a poor Arkansas OL.
• Strengths:
  • “Size, speed, tackle breaking ability and the ability to at his size, Seth, to hit home runs. You don’t see that all the time, man.” — Derrick Brown [34:22]
  • Breakaway % (17th among FBS RBs), yards after contact per attempt (33rd).
  • Underutilized, not discussed among top 4 RBs in class despite elite traits.
• Concerns:
  • Stiff hips, limited short-area agility (expected for build), but overall athletic skill set strong.
• Outlook:
  • Day 2/3 pick, potentially RB2 in class by final rankings.
  • “The fact that he is not firmly in that conversation and mentioned in the same breath as the other three guys above him… it’s an honest travesty.” — Derrick Brown [36:46]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Jacoby Lane’s Route Running:
  • “He’s inviting indecision in a cornerback’s head. That’s how you create separation outside of just raw athleticism and footwork.” — Derrick Brown [05:33]
• On Ted Hurst’s Rise:
  • “I think he’s going to get drafted higher than people think… you hear his name called in the third round and everybody’s like, who the heck is this guy?” — Derrick Brown [11:31]
• Iconic Catch Recap:
  • “Just go out there, get on the YouTubes and Google Omar Cooper, Penn State and you will see one of the best catches you’ve ever seen in your life. The toe tapper, the back of the end zone, that body control that plays, dude, for days.” — Derrick Brown [18:36]
• On Overlooked QBs & Draft Bias:
  • “The echo chamber of the NFL draft consortium gets really, really loud… when the reality is a lot of times, the smartest person in the room isn’t the person kicked up to 11 and it’s not the person with the biggest microphone.” — Derrick Brown [29:56]
• Mike Washington Jr. Hype:
  • “Order them however the hell you want, but [Jadarian Price, Jonah Coleman, Emmett Johnson and Mike Washington] — that’s tier two for me.” — Derrick Brown [39:13]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 03:37 — Jacoby Lane, WR, USC
• 07:44 — Ted Hurst, WR, Georgia State
• 17:16 — Omar Cooper Jr., WR, Indiana
• 22:40 — Cole Payton, QB, North Dakota State
• 33:56 — Mike Washington Jr., RB, Arkansas

Conclusion

This episode is a must-listen for dynasty managers seeking actionable deep-dive analysis on rookie sleepers, especially those outside the Power 4 pipelines. Derrick Brown and Seth Wilcock argue passionately that these five prospects are priced too low in early drafts, and their arguments draw on both production context and film study. With NFL Combine and Pro Day workouts set to reshape draft boards, expect these names—especially Hurst, Payton, and Washington—to rise in value.

For full rookie tiers, sleepers, and more, subscribe to the new FantasyPros Dynasty YouTube channel and stay tuned to the FantasyPros NFL Draft Show for expert coverage and actionable fantasy advice.