Podcast Summary: FantasyPros – Fantasy Football Podcast

Episode Title: Why Bhayshul Tuten is a Strong Buy! | Week 3 Buy Low + Sell High Running Back Targets (Ep. 1712)
Hosts: Ryan Wormley & Andrew Erickson
Release Date: September 16, 2025

Overview

This episode zeroes in on running back (RB) trade strategy and target recommendations for fantasy football Week 3. Ryan Wormley and Andrew Erickson break down RB-centric buy-low and sell-high candidates, analyzing recent games, player performances, and macro-level trade advice. There’s a pointed focus on early-season overreactions, situational usage trends, and which rookies and veterans are best positioned for the weeks ahead. The episode is practical, direct, and loaded with actionable insights—perfect for fantasy managers looking to trade smart after two weeks of data.

Monday Night Football: Game Reactions

Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Houston Texans
[00:00–05:54]

• Texans (0-2) vs. Buccaneers (2-0): The hosts agreed that the records don’t reflect the teams’ true abilities.

• Nico Collins:

  • Underwhelming start to the season despite being the clear alpha (9 targets, just 3 catches for 52 yards and a TD).
  • Quote – [01:57]
    "I still think big games are going to come for Nico Collins. I think the offensive line is still... a work in progress. But this is the first time they really had their guys up front that they wanted to have in week one."
  • Collins' big-play potential has yet to materialize, but the consensus is to be patient.

• Texans’ Offensive Woes:

  • Surprising minimal contributions from rookie receivers (Higgins, Noel).
  • Offensive play-calling and personnel choices remain questionable.

• Buccaneers Backfield (Rashad White & Bucky Irving):

  • White posted an efficient 10/65/1 line, demonstrating consistency.
  • Rashad White is a waiver wire target, especially given the uninspiring RB pool.

• Igbuka as a Red Zone Threat:

  • Egbuka continues to nab high-leverage opportunities, benefiting from coverage on Mike Evans.

Late Monday Night Game: Rookie RB Panic Meter

[06:27–10:41]

• Hampton vs. Genti Debate:

  • Erickson is more worried about Hampton:
    • Lacked explosiveness, failed at the goal line, put the ball on the turf. Missed opportunity with Najee’s early-season absence.
    • Limited passing game involvement—a Greg Roman trend.
  • Genti has flashed with broken tackles but is not a concern for Erickson.

• Charger Pass-Catching Pecking Order:

  • Keenan Allen remains the top target over Quentin Johnston, despite Johnson's spike weeks.

  • Ladd McConkey viewed as a buy-low after absorbing defensive attention but not yet scoring.

  • Quote – [09:30]:
    "It's still Keenan Allen for me. I just love the chemistry he has with Justin Herbert, especially in the red zone."

Macro-Level Trade Strategy Advice

[10:41–12:48]

• Evaluating Your Roster:

  • Determine if you’re a contender or pretender, but don’t just look at your record—consider points scored and allowed.

  • Injury Angle: Leverage injuries at other positions (notably QB) to create trade opportunities.

  • Quote – [11:19]:
    "Ask yourself: am I a contender or a pretender? Sometimes your record can lie... your point scored or points against can help dictate how aggressive you want to be with trades."

Running Backs to Buy

[13:10–18:46]

1. Breece Hall (Jets)

• Buy low after Jets’ Week 2 disaster.
• All concerns over RB committee have faded; Hall is clear RB1.
• Braylon Allen & Isaiah Davis not threats so far.
• Erickson says the time to buy is now, even if the matchup is tough in Week 3.
• "This week two dud gives you an opportunity to buy low on Breece Hall." [13:10]
• Consensus ROS Rank: RB12 – Both hosts agree that’s fair.

2. Travion Henderson (Patriots)

• Buy on talent and pass-game role—value will emerge as season progresses, reminiscent of Gibbs/Montgomery 2023 split.

• New England’s upcoming schedule is favorable for RBs (Steelers, Panthers, Bills, Saints).

• Managers are frustrated due to a down week – strike now for a discount.

• Quote – [16:04]:
  "Henderson is just a buy on the talent, especially in full PPR... he's never going to be a bellcow, but that's going to make him volatile just from week to week."

• Trade Suggestion:

  • Swap a steady veteran (like James Conner) for Henderson, focusing on second-half upside.

Running Backs to Sell

[22:46–28:55]

1. Chase Brown (Bengals)

• Sell due to Bengals’ shift from Joe Burrow to Jake Browning (likely ROS).
• Offensive line woes have tanked Brown's efficiency.
• Regression expected due to defensive attention and poor line play.
• Brown is RB23 in consensus, but Erickson sees him outside top 20.
• "Everything Bengals related has to be with the idea that Jake Browning is going to be the quarterback... that's what has me concerned about Chase Brown." [23:02]

2. James Conner (Cardinals)

• Production buoyed by TDs in easy matchups (Saints, Panthers), but efficiency down and Trey Benson’s involvement is increasing.
• Cardinals' schedule toughens considerably (49ers, Seahawks).
• "Time is ticking to sell high on James Conner... your bet was early-season production, but the schedule is about to get tough and he hasn't looked great." [27:11]

Buy, Sell, or Hold – Running Back Trios

[28:55–34:02]

Trio 1: Jonathan Taylor / Josh Jacobs / Devon Achan

• Buy: Jonathan Taylor ("operating as a full-blown bell cow")
• Sell: Devon Achan (injury/usage risk, despite efficiency and receiving work)
• Hold: Josh Jacobs ("feels so safe," Packers will keep featuring him.)
  • Quote – [29:18]:
    "I'm gonna buy Jonathan Taylor... sell Achan... and hold Jacobs."

Trio 2: Javonte Williams / DeAndre Swift / Jordan Mason

• Buy: Javonte Williams (clear bell cow on the Cowboys)
• Sell: DeAndre Swift (unlikely to keep feature role, possible RBBC looming)
• Hold: Jordan Mason (stand-alone value with Aaron Jones' injury; high-upside stash)

Trio 3: Jalen Warren / Cam Scadabo / Bhayshul Tuten

• Buy: Bhayshul Tuten (emerging explosive playmaker; checks every box for RB breakout)

  • Quote – [32:10]:
    "I'm buying all the Bhayshul Tuten stock. If he's not already on my team, I'm trying to get him on my team."

• Hold: Cam Scadabo (just overtook Tracy; solid role)

• Sell: Jalen Warren ("You can get a lot for [him] right now," but eventual competition could cut into work.)

Notable Quotes & Moments

• On Trade Timing:
  • "You could wait till week four, but the other manager might know that too... So I just want Breece Hall on my roster." – Andrew Erickson, [15:17]
• On Overreacting Early:
  • "We're not playing just to win week three. We're playing to win the second half of the season during the fantasy playoffs." – Andrew Erickson, [18:46]
• On Rookie RBs:
  • "A lot of rookie backs haven't fired out of the gates, but they'll improve as the season progresses." – Andrew Erickson, [18:46]

Key Takeaways

• Don’t overreact to two weeks—rookies and talent will often win out given time.
• Prioritize acquiring upside (Tuten, Henderson, Hall) over early-season floor, particularly with rookie RBs.
• Be proactive in trading away backs on shaky teams or with inefficiency/usage red flags (Chase Brown, James Conner).
• Use your league’s unique landscape—injury fallout, transaction history, and points scored/allowed—to inform trade strategy.
• For roster depth, now is the time to buy low on explosive rookies and talented pass-catching RBs; pursue trades for players with uncertain short-term value but high rest-of-season upside.

Next Steps

• Tune in to part two for wide receiver, quarterback, and tight end trade candidates.
• Don’t miss the FantasyPros live streams every Wednesday at 3pm ET for direct trade Q&A.

Fantasy managers looking to trade smart in Week 3 should prioritize patience with proven talent, buy low on rookie running backs, and strategically move on from inefficient starters whose roles or situations are already deteriorating.