The Enemy Upstairs

Summary

Fear Thy Neighbor: "The Enemy Upstairs" – Episode Summary

Podcast: Fear Thy Neighbor
Host: ID
Episode Title: The Enemy Upstairs
Air Date: May 11, 2026
Main Story Location: West Harlem, New York City

---

Episode Overview

This chilling episode of Fear Thy Neighbor explores the escalation of a neighborly dispute in a tightly-woven Harlem apartment building that ends in a lethal confrontation. Through intimate testimony from residents, the story chronicles how a newcomer's personal grievances—jealousy, loneliness, and perceived slights—unravel into harassment, violence, and ultimately, a tragic double homicide. The episode deeply examines the thin line between ordinary neighborly conflict and catastrophe, asking: What happens when an obsession goes unchecked, and cries for help go unheard?

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Harlem’s Close-Knit Community (01:31–03:47)

• Setting the Scene:
  • The episode opens in West Harlem, characterized as "a classic Manhattan neighborhood" where "deep friendships have formed between several tenants over the years." (Narrator, 01:31)
  • Hampton "Smitty" Smith: Building superintendent, beloved and called "the Watchman." Known for his caring Southern demeanor and community involvement. (Dolores Nettles, 04:08)
  • Ronnie Mitchell: Smitty’s best friend, super of the building across the street. They’re regarded as "brothers from a different mother." (Mary Hall, 04:39)

2. Arrival of Bruce Anderson & First Friction (04:55–06:11)

• Bruce Anderson: Moves in with his sister Rosetta, is initially welcomed for his politeness and is often seen riding his bike to ease his hip pain.
  • "Some neighbors described him as a little bit shy, a little bit quieter." (Alan Thomas, 05:13)
  • Warmly received due to Rosetta’s popularity in the building.
• Noise Complaints Begin:
  • Bruce is particularly irked by noise from the apartment above, later revealed to be Smitty and his partner, Yvette Rivera.
  • "That person upstairs is—it's a racket at night, man. I can't get no sleep." (Bruce Anderson, 07:17)
  • Smitty responds calmly to Bruce’s first complaint, indicating neighborly goodwill. (Bruce Anderson & Smitty exchange, 08:12)

3. Bruce’s Obsession with Yvette Rivera (06:20–10:57)

• Yvette Rivera: Described as the "life of the party," vivacious and warm.
• Bruce quickly becomes infatuated and misconstrues Yvette’s friendliness for romantic interest.
  • "Oh, Bruce, I'm sorry, I'm taken." (Yvette Rivera, 09:02)
  • Even after rejection, Bruce persists: "I'm a patient man." (Bruce Anderson, 09:15)
• Underlying Jealousy:
  • Realizing Smitty and Yvette's relationship intensifies Bruce’s resentment and noise fixation.
  • "He didn't understand why a young woman would want an old man and not him." (Narrator/Rebecca Rosenberg, 10:51)

4. The Spiral: From Grievance to Harassment (13:06–17:04)

• Escalating Complaints:
  • Bruce's annoyance grows, especially after his sister Rosetta moves out, removing his main source of emotional stability.
  • "When his sister lived with him, things were pretty calm… When she moved out, that's when… strange behavior started cropping up." (Alan Thomas, 15:53)
• Harassment of Smitty and Yvette:
  • Bruce’s complaints focus solely on the upstairs noise, which is perceived by others as minor or even nonexistent.
  • "Any little thing bothered him. It wasn't the noise. It was not knowing that he couldn't have Yvette." (Dolores Nettles, 17:09)
  • Yvette ceases to open the door for Bruce, feeling uneasy.

5. Confrontation & Involvement of Authorities (17:23–20:30)

• Physical Altercation:
  • Bruce shoves Smitty, an elderly man, escalating the conflict.
  • "He actually physically assaulted this old man. And I think then the trains were coming off the track." (Mary Hall, 18:10)
• Police Get Involved:
  • Smitty files a report after prompting from neighbors and advice to establish a "paper trail."
  • "The pen is mightier than a sword. If anything had occurred, she can always go back." (Dolores Nettles, 20:30)
• Bruce Feels Victimized:
  • Bruce calls 911 claiming Yvette threatened him with a gun, but his story is unconvincing and the police take no action. (21:13–21:49)

6. Escalation & Red Flags (20:44–29:26)

• Aggression Increases:
  • Bruce's anger becomes physical—swinging a cane at Yvette and pounding on ceilings and buzzers.
  • "He had a hammer and it's going bang, bang, bang... Like he was actually going around in a circle." (Mary Hall, 31:48)
• Neighbors’ Fear Grows:
  • "He was a ticking time bomb, but the law and state says they can't do anything to him until he does something." (Mary Hall, 30:33)
  • Bruce’s online activity is increasingly violent and disturbing, featuring photos of bondage and comments about weapons.
  • “What are you gonna do when Mr. Cuckoo gets one of these?” — Facebook post flagged by Alan Thomas (30:07)

7. Deadly Boiling Point (34:44–42:22)

• Premeditation & Murders:
  • On Oct 18, 2019, Bruce waits for Smitty, confronts him, stabs him 11 times, and shoots him in the head.
    • “He got stabbed 11 times... That’s built up rage.” (Ronnie Mitchell, 36:14)
  • Bruce then forces his way into Yvette’s apartment, shoots her, and starts a fire in an attempt to destroy evidence or himself.
  • "Police descend on the building. Within minutes, they start pushing all the apartment buzzers, just trying to get somebody to open up. And Bruce answers: Come on in and get it over with." (38:24, Bruce Anderson)
• Aftermath:
  • Bruce barricades himself and commits suicide; Yvette and Smitty do not survive.
  • “One sick mind can destroy so many lives.” (Mary Hall, 41:12)
  • The grief-stricken community rallies to support each other and arrange funerals.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• The Roots of Tragedy:

  • "How do you kill two people over noise? And how do you kill a woman because she's not attracted to you?" (Mary Hall, 41:12)

• On Bruce's Mental State:

  • "His darkness just got darker and darker… He was just becoming increasingly more isolated." (Rebecca Rosenberg & Alan Thomas, 27:11–27:23)

• Chilling Premonition:

  • “What are you gonna do when Mr. Cuckoo gets one of these?” (Alan Thomas reading Bruce's Facebook, 30:07)

• Lingering Aftermath:

  • “The havoc that one sick mind can do. One sick mind can destroy so many lives.” (Mary Hall, 41:12)
  • “He eliminated his infatuation and his competition. He took two good people from a community that loved him.” (Dolores Nettles, 41:51)

---

Timeline of Major Events

• [01:31–04:55] – Introduction to Harlem neighborhood and main characters
• [05:08–07:44] – Bruce’s arrival, integration, and first noises
• [09:02–10:57] – Bruce’s infatuation and realization
• [13:06–15:28] – Noise complaints escalate
• [18:02–20:19] – First physical confrontation; police are involved
• [21:13–27:11] – Retaliation, false 911 calls, increasing isolation
• [31:48–34:44] – Violent ceiling banging; Bruce’s unraveling
• [35:17–36:49] – Fatal encounter with Smitty; Yvette shot
• [36:49–39:55] – Barricading, fire, police standoff, Bruce’s suicide
• [40:28–42:22] – Aftermath, neighborhood in mourning

---

Closing Thoughts & Takeaways

This episode serves as a potent reminder that sometimes the people you fear most aren’t strangers but live just beyond your walls. Amid the everyday challenges of urban life, unchecked mental health struggles and unrequited obsession can be catalysts for unfathomable violence. The central lesson resounds clear: communities must not ignore red flags or escalating conflict—lives depend on early, collective intervention.

---

Transcript

[Commercial Narrator]

Graduation season is around the corner and Michaels has everything you need. Whether you're throwing the party of the year or just celebrating your grad's achievement. Start with a class of 26 banner. Then add party supplies and frame photos that'll have everyone remembering when. Then bring the wow factor with balloons. Order ahead for delivery or in store pickup. Shop now to create a celebration as special as they are.

We asked you here because we care

[Bruce Anderson]

and your car insurance doesn't.

[Commercial Narrator]

They've raised your rate every year and you haven't even checked.

I thought that was normal.

A lot of people do. That's why there's Jerry. Jerry pulls up to 20 quotes from top insurers in minutes, shows them side by side and lets you switch in the app. No jumping sites, no re entering info, no spam calls. It helps you cancel your old policy and keeps checking for better rates.

[Bruce Anderson]

We want better for you.

[Commercial Narrator]

Jerry does too.

Don't settle. Visit Jerry AI Acast security program on spreadsheets.

New regulations piling up an audit dread. It's time for Vanta. Vanta automates security and compliance, brings evidence into one place, and cuts audit prep by 82%. Less manual work, clearer visibility, faster deals, zero chaos. Call it compliance or call it compliance.

Get it?

Join the 15,000 companies using Vanta to prove trust. Go to vanta.com calm.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Most violent crimes that capture the public's imagination are about serial killers, mass shooters, or crimes of passion. Yet some of the most shocking conflicts we encounter are between everyday neighbors in ordinary neighborhoods. What makes a good neighbor go bad? We may never truly know, but heed this warning about the terrible things that can happen when even the pettiest disagreements pass the point of no return. We're in an apartment building in the storied Harlem neighborhood of the Big Apple, New York City. This building is on a street so beautiful that director Steven Spielberg filmed some of his west side Story remake. Here, residents of all ages and backgrounds mingle effortlessly and deep friendships have formed between several tenants over the years. When a new tenant arrives with an insatiable infatuation, the stage is set for a deadly conflict. This is fear thy neighbor. The enemy upstairs. West Harlem is the definition of a classic Manhattan neighborhood. Many families in the neighborhood have called it home for generations. It's a perfect community where the young and elderly coexist well together.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

West Harlem is a really beautiful neighborhood. The streets are lined with gorgeous brownstones, beautiful trees. It's a very family oriented neighborhood. Everybody knows each other. People often have lived here for 20, 30 years. People say hello to each other on the street. You really have the feeling of a community, a tight knit community.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

That's New York Post journalist Rebecca Rosenberg. Now here's a neighbor at the heart of this story, Dolores Nettles.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

You feel at ease. You can sit on the stoops or you could just pass by. It's always somebody outside. It's always lights there.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Today's story takes place in an apartment complex on 131st Street. Like many in the neighborhood, it is a five story walk up, covered in fire escapes and filled with friendly neighbors. Perhaps the most cherished resident of his complex is Hampton Smith, known to his friends as Smitty.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey, Jaden, how you doing?

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

The neighbors called Smitty the Watchman because he kind of looked out for everybody. You know, he looked out for the kids. He just was considered just a really loving guy.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Originally from South Carolina, Smitty has lived here for 25 years, working as the building superintendent and handyman.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He had all those aspects of Southern men. He was quiet. If you ask him to do something for you, he will do it without any hesitation.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty's not the only one keeping an eye out. His best friend, Ronnie Mitchell, is the super of the building across the street.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

I said, why are you bothering these kids? And, you know, we would just get a laugh out of it. We were playing just like kids would be playing.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey, Jaden, you don't have to hang around with this old man here. They know this thing. He a old man.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Alan Thomas and Mary hall are two more friends and neighbors who reside here.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Ronnie was the mayor, from what I understand, that Smitty was the watchman, I think they called him. They seem like, to me, brothers from a different mother.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

They always joked with each other and teasing each other and, you know, whatever men do.

[Bruce Anderson]

You take care now. Say hi to your mama, all right.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

A lifelong New Yorker, Bruce has just moved in with his sister Rosetta, who lives on the first floor of Smitty's building. As Alan Thomas and Rebecca Rosenberg explain, the neighborhood is initially quite taken with the new resident.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Bruce is a very nice looking guy, big and strong. He was so cordial to me.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Some neighbors described him as a little bit shy, a little bit quieter.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He had worked in construction for a long time, but he had a hip injury and was out of work.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And it makes sense. Bruce is so warmly received considering his sister Rosetta is also a favorite in the building.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Smitty, nice shirt.

[Bruce Anderson]

Very cute.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Always so stylish.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce's sister was this very sweet, petite woman. She was a bit chattier than he was.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce and his bicycle soon become well known throughout the block.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

98% of the time, he always had that bike with him.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He went on a bike ride every single day. He said it was to kind of help his hip.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey, man, looks like you got a little bit of problem there with your bike. I can take care of it for you.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Smitty helped Mr. Anderson with his bike because they both rode bikes. Smitty rode a bike everywhere. It was very rare that you would catch him walking.

[Bruce Anderson]

Serious? Yeah, it's not a problem. You know, give me a day.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

I had that done.

[Bruce Anderson]

Oh, man, I appreciate that, man.

[Commercial Narrator]

Hey, man, no problem.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Just when Bruce thinks he's hit the jackpot with his new community, things get even better when he catches of another tenant, Yvette Rivera.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Yvette Rivera was this really vivacious person. She just was a really good looking woman, a petite woman. She loved to dance. She was really, really friendly. Loved to socialize.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

When I first met Yvette, I said, she's a firecracker. Her mouth is not gonna stay closed. She was. Get the party started.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

All it takes is one look at Yvette for Bruce to fall head over heels. But not even a friendly building and the promise of meeting the potential woman of his dreams can distract Bruce from his one big complaint. Noise.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Definitely one of the downsides of city life and apartment living is how close you live together. You hear everything.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I think that's part of urban living. You're gonna have noise.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Specifically the commotion in the apartment directly above. Bruce is keeping him up at night. When Ronnie Mitchell drops by Bruce's place to fix a leaky faucet, Bruce confides his problem.

[Bruce Anderson]

Man, that person upstairs is niggas. It's a racket at night, man. I can't get no sleep.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

It's a bit of a shock when Ronnie informs Bruce who he's testy about.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Oh, man.

[Bruce Anderson]

You know who's upstairs? Smitty, man.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Really?

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Yeah.

[Bruce Anderson]

Let me talk to Smitty. You know, he's got some cats up there, you know, they play around, they knock things over.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

I didn't think it was a big deal. It's normal that people complain about noise. You get used to it.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

As if on cue, Smitty appears in the doorway with Bruce's repaired bicycle.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey, Ronnie. I didn't know your old lad was down here. Hey, hey, old Smitty. Hey, man.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Hey, Bruce.

[Bruce Anderson]

Got your bike, man. She's good as new. I know that. That's your wheels. Hey, man. I'm gonna say, oh, you don't have to worry about it, man. I got you. Appreciate that, man.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Ronnie tells Smitty about Bruce's noise. Complain is entirely conciliatory.

[Bruce Anderson]

North. Yeah, okay, man. I'm worried about it, man. I've been getting off work a little late, you know what I'm saying? But I got you, man. You know, I'll hold it down. Don't worry about it.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

All right, man.

[Bruce Anderson]

I appreciate that. Smitty, man, I didn't want to say nothing, you know what I'm saying?

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty's friend, Dolores Nettles tells us how the super took Bruce's issue in stride.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Smitty said, all right, all right, all right. Because he was a more seldom man, but he wouldn't sing you off, but he'd be like, okay, okay, no problem.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey, man, it's all good, man. It's all good. Here's your bike, man. Ronnie, man.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Both men are happy to resolve the problem. Bruce is even happier when he next spots Yvette Rivera. This time, he approaches her and makes his attraction known.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I'm Bruce.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Yvette.

[Bruce Anderson]

Pretty name. You live in this building?

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Second floor.

[Bruce Anderson]

I'm hoping to see you more often.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Oh, Bruce, I'm sorry, I'm taken.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He may have misconstrued her greetings, her niceties, as something, as a come on, but it wasn't Yvette.

[Bruce Anderson]

I'm a patient man.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

She was happily married, and it made her a little bit cautious.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Sorry, but you got to the starting gate too late, fella. Move on.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Despite the rejection, Bruce remains determined to win Yvette's heart.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Most women, when they tell a man, thanks and no thanks, I'm not interested, that man moves.

[Bruce Anderson]

But he kept.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Oh, boy. There was no no to him.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Later, Bruce runs into Yvette once again as she's heading home. And again he makes an attempt to approach her. But this time he's shocked to see the man that's been waiting for her.

[Bruce Anderson]

Oh, hey. What a coincidence.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Jamal, grasp.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Hola, Mommy.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Hampton. Smitty Smith.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty and Yvette had been together about 20 years. They were married maybe four years, five years. Connected at, you know, he'd run for her and she'd run for him.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Being that Smitty was in his 70s, close to 80, Mr. Anderson probably felt, how could he get this woman? And I can't cause jealousy. It can hurt you real bad.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Now that Bruce has learned, Smitty shares the apartment overhead with the woman he's been crushing on. The noise goes from annoying to agonizing.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Mr. Anderson was hearing a few things.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I believe he heard intimacy. I don't know. I think that ate him alive because in his head I wish it was me.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Anderson was infatuated and this older man is going home to be vet and he just, he couldn't handle it.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

He didn't understand why a young woman would want an old man and not him.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And after several nights of tortured sleep, Bruce is about to snap.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Traffic may be locked, but savings isn't.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Unlock the savings at Boost Mobile with unlimited wireless for just $25 a month.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Forever.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

No contracts, no hikes, and you keep your phone. Unlock the [e-mail] Unlock $25 forever requires customers to remain active on Boost Unlimited Wireless plan. For full offer details, visit boostmobile.com you're

[Commercial Narrator]

a pro at running your life. At committing to your workout. At showing up every day. At Bombas, we're pros too. Pros at making socks. Our sport assortment has specialized socks for whatever sport you're committed to running, hiking, golf, Pilates, and so much more. Made with sweat, wicking yarns, blister fighting details and targeted arch support. Bombas Sport is pro level socks from the Pros of Socks. For another pro, you go to bombas.com audio and use code audio for 20 off your first purchase. That's bombus.com and use code audio

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

parliamento

[Commercial Narrator]

if you've used Babel, you would Babble's conversation based technique teaches you useful words and phrases to get you speaking quickly about the things you actually talk about in real world. With lessons handcrafted by over 200 language experts and voiced by real native speakers, Babbel is like having a private tutor in your pocket. Start speaking with Babbel today. Get up to 55% off your Babbel subscription right now at babbel.com acast spelled B-A B-B-E-L.com acast rules and restrictions may apply.

One second you're enjoying your day off. The next your phone buzzes. A window's been broken at home, you're miles away. In one second, everything can change. That's why ADT's professionally installed security systems monitor your home 24 7. They're backed by the most company operated monitoring centers in the industry, so you're always supported during an emergency. When every second Counts, count on ADT. Visit ADT.com to learn more.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

To Bruce Anderson, the noise coming from his upstairs neighbor's unit is just about unbearable. Thinking his civil requests won't get him anywhere. He decides to up the ante.

[Bruce Anderson]

Stop that racket. Fat globe.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

No idea.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Journalist Rebecca Rosenberg notes Yvette and Smitty's alarm.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Yvette and Smitty thought this was really strange behavior, and they were starting to wonder if there wasn't a little bit more going on with Bruce.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce is still out of work due to his hip injury, so he's stuck at home all day and night. It doesn't help his issues with the couple above him. And Smitty and Yvette's place isn't just above Bruce. Part of their unit also maps over top of Mary hall and her boyfriend Alan Thomas unit. Here they are now to explain their perspective on the noise complaints.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Bruce is always calling and complaining. Too much noise was coming from upstairs, and as I was telling Mary, I think there's more to it than that, my dear. The slightest noise would set him off.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce Anderson was my neighbor. Maybe four feet from my door would be his door, and he was complaining about the noise. He said that there was too much noise over his head, but I couldn't hear what he could hear.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Mary and I have been seeing each other for two years, and all the times I've been there, I've never heard anything. Something's wrong there. Maybe once or twice a week, max, you would hear something above her, and that was it. Clauses open and closing. Something being dragged across the floor like a dining room set. Nothing crazy.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

What's more, Mary shares a wall with Bruce when she plays her music. He never seems to mind.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

My living room wall attached to his, so my stereo is right there and the TV is right there. And he never complained. At times I've played it loud, but he never knocked on my wall.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Only the alleged noise from Yvette Rivera in Smitty Hampton's apartment seems to bother Bruce.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

When I found out that Bruce made a pass at Yvette, that sounds to me like it's a personal issue because she wouldn't accept his past.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Anderson complained because Pete couldn't have her himself. He was in love with her, and he didn't know how to go about it.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

He was seeing something or hearing something, feeling something that really wasn't there. And I don't think nobody had a solution for him because it was all in his brain.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce's woman trouble worsens when his sister Rosetta decides to leave, says Ronnie Mitchell.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

The more time went on, the more agitated he got with people around him, and she probably got tired of it and moved out.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

When his sister lived with him, things Were pretty calm. And when she moved out, that's when a lot of this strange behavior started cropping up. And all these conflicts in the building began.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I think she provided some form of stability as well as company, and female company at that. Maybe he felt abandoned. And I think that started his spiral downward.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He was lonely. He was in a house by himself. It wasn't nothing for him to do, no one to talk to.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Piling onto his stress is Bruce's hip pain, which is worsening by the day.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

All I know, it was a bad pain. It was a throbbing pain. Naturally. You know, you want solitude, peace and quiet.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce eventually hits his breaking point and storms upstairs to give the neighbors a piece of his mind.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He really harassed Yvette and Smitty. Smitty, if he had any kind of issues, he wouldn't really discuss it with, But Yvette's gonna let you know.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

What do you want?

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

We used to always say, you better not mess with Yvette.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

You can't speak.

[Bruce Anderson]

You gotta move.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

You gotta move. We've been here 20 years. We're not going anywhere.

[Bruce Anderson]

Well, I can't sleep with all that noise.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

We're not noisy. Nobody has ever complained.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Any little thing bothered him. It wasn't the noise. It was no knowing that he couldn't have Yvette. I don't believe that she opened the door anymore after that. It was like, a little creepy for her.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Smitty, Bruce just came here.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Yvette would call him and say, well, Bruce is up here threatening me. And he would leave his job and

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

go home as a man and a husband. Then I'm gonna have to come to you and confront you. Cause I'm not gonna let my wife be unhappy because of you.

[Bruce Anderson]

You threaten my wife, man? I ain't threatening her, man. What you talking about?

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Smitty would go downstairs, confront Bruce, and say, you need to leave Yvette alone, man.

[Bruce Anderson]

She wouldn't lie about that. She did. Hell no. Seriously talking to you, man. What? I said beat him, man.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

On this occasion, Bruce becomes so furious that he shoves Smitty to the ground.

[Bruce Anderson]

What's wrong with you?

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And storms back inside his apartment.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Now, he actually physically assaulted this old man. And I think then the trains were coming off the track.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce's neighbor, Mary hall, has witnessed everything.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Are you okay, Smitty?

[Bruce Anderson]

Yeah. He came out of vet, but he's gonna have to go through me first.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty said to me, I'm not gonna let him hurt Yvette. I'm sure it bothered Smitty because all men want to protect their partners. And because Bruce was so much bigger than Smitty, he had to be intimidated.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

The vet told him, you're £150. You. You're 78 years old. Bruce is this huge guy, and it's just not safe to put yourself in that position.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Now that the conflict has escalated to physical violence, Smitty decides to play it smart.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Smitty called 911 and said Bruce had shoved him and threatened Yvette.

[Bruce Anderson]

I never threatened her. Never. Well, Ms. Rivera says you did. I should have called y' all first, man. They're the ones that's terming the peace. Ask her.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Mary being Mary, I went to listen, and the police officer was telling him, well, you know, y' all all got to live in the building and yada yada.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

But police aren't convinced Bruce is the victim, and that only escalates his anger.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

So the tensions were really rising between Yvette and Smitty and Bruce. All the neighbors could feel it. Yvette and Smitty were such beloved members of the community. So all the conflict in the building was making people very wary of br.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

When Yvette confides to Dolores Nettles that Bruce hit on her, her friend becomes even more worried. Here she is again, along with neighbor Alan Thomas and Rebecca Rosenberg, weighing in.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Michelle Smithy. Are you crazy?

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

From my experience, a woman would not tell her husband that because it would create unforeseen problems. It would make him more hostile to that man.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Yvette didn't want to Smitty to get into nothing with Bruce because he might have hurt him.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

I gotta keep them apart. Aw, I got a bad feeling about this. You gotta call the police. We did that already.

[Bruce Anderson]

Good.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

You need a paper trail.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Dolores encouraged her friend to not confront him. Just call the police. Make sure there's a paper trail to document, you know, these encounters.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

The pen is mightier than a sword. If anything had occurred, she can always go back.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Speak of the devil.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Eyvette tried to avoid Mr. Anderson because she didn't want anything else to escalate.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

But on this block, sometimes the only option is to face your problem head on. And when Bruce approaches her once again, Yvette decides to hold her ground.

[Bruce Anderson]

Hey.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

What do you want?

[Bruce Anderson]

I just wanted to fuck off, or

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

else

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

you don't know what a person might try. So she wanted to go.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

She knows how to handle herself. He felt threatened. He came up to her and approached her in a manner that was. Wasn't right.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Once again, Bruce walks Away rejected. And this time, he wants revenge.

[Bruce Anderson]

Look, she scare me, and I don't scare eazy.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce called 911 and told them that he had confronted Yvette in the street. And she put her hand in her pocket like she had a gun.

[Bruce Anderson]

She's definitely carrying a gun. And for all I know, he is, too.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He said that he felt very threatened by this.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

If you want the police to come that you'll say somebody has a gun, because they're gonna come right away.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

But Bruce's call doesn't go as planned.

[Bruce Anderson]

No, not. Not really.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He did admit that he never actually saw a gun.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I can picture Mr. Anderson lying to the police. Mr. Anderson was a troublemaker. He was a troubled man.

[Bruce Anderson]

Y' all ain't helping nobody, man. Y', all, man.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce clearly thinks he's the victim here, that his neighbors upstairs are terrorizing him, and he's really distraught about this.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He had no way to turn the sister, never came back. He didn't have any friends or family or woman in his life.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

As Bruce's behavior continues to intensify, many in the neighborhood feel on edge. One day, on an outing, Delores Nettles again cautions her friend Yvette.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

I've seen how Bruce looks at you away all day.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Something could happen.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Like what? Like rape.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I was a little scared for her, and I was letting her know that Mr. Anderson can overpower her.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Do I look scared? You should be scared of me.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

She was saying, oh, you know, I'll start screaming and hollering. The whole building gonna wake up when I get through, because, you know, my mouth is big.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

When the two women suddenly encounter Bruce on the street, Yvette's resolve is tested.

[Bruce Anderson]

You stop making all that damn noise.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

We don't make any noise. It's all in your head.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Yvette had had enough, and she just grew so frustrated.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Do you want noise? Huh? You want noise? This is noise.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

She got tired of the harassment. It will drive a person insane a little bit.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Everyone shut the hell up. Guys, take the kid up. Shut the hell up.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce has taken to using a cane for his sore hip, and he swings it at her.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Anderson tried to hit Yvette with her with a K. Guy tried to kid us.

[Bruce Anderson]

Shut the hell up.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He couldn't catch her because Yvette can move. She dodged him running from him.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

I'm calling the cops, you big jerk. Come on.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce's outbursts towards Yvette have escalated from threats to violence, and she won't stand for it, sir.

[Bruce Anderson]

This is the second time You've been reported as a threat. She was screaming at me. They're the ones making all that noise. Look, one way to end this is you move, okay?

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Me move?

[Bruce Anderson]

You gotta be kidding.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Naturally, you get upset about that. Why do I have to move? They're making the noise.

[Bruce Anderson]

Sir, there's going to be consequences if you can't resolve this. Get real. Are we done here?

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

When Yvette and Smitty started calling the police on Miss Anne the smoke, I believe they turned the tables.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

With the police firmly on their side. Hampton, Smitty Smith and Yvette Rivera hope Bruce Anderson will finally leave them alone.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

So it's like, okay, we still gonna live our life like we've been doing because we know we're not doing anything.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

But in truth, the position the authorities take has only fueled Bruce's sense of persecution. And his neighbors, Alan Thomas and Mary hall shared it only worsens his behavior.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I think he was so pissed off. She doesn't want me. I can't get no satisfaction from the police.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Whatever was going on in his head was just getting worse, and he couldn't control it anymore. Bruce started knocking on the ceiling. I could hear him tapping. Tap, tap, tap, tap, tap.

[Bruce Anderson]

Stop making all that damn noise.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Stop it.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Dolores Nettles and Ronnie Mitchell tell us how this time Bruce takes his retaliation one step further.

[Bruce Anderson]

Stop it. Stop it. Get out here now.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

He came upstairs and he was threatening somebody.

[Bruce Anderson]

Bring your ass up, sir, so I

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

can whoop your ass, old man. No, it's me.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He was frightened. Two older people up there in this mountain of a man wanting to get in.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

The commotion is so loud, it brings out neighbor Ronnie Mitchell.

[Bruce Anderson]

What's going on? They keep stomping on my ceiling on purpose, man.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

You're saying that they're doing it on purpose? Naturally, you feel victimized. That's what he felt.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty.

[Bruce Anderson]

Yeah?

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Are you okay, man?

[Bruce Anderson]

Yeah, man, I'm okay. This dude is tripping, man. Tripping, tripping. They keep screaming at me, man. I said, get out of here now.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Chill now. It's not just the response from police that's fueling Bruce's sense of persecution.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He's pissed off at Ronnie for siding with Smitty.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He didn't want to be friends with Mr. Ronnie if he was friends with the person that I disliked the most.

[Bruce Anderson]

I'm waiting for you outside, Smitty, so we can end this.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He wanted Smitty to come downstairs to fight, and he went downstairs and waited for him.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Yet Bruce has no intention of waiting. Silently, he pounds on his upstairs neighbor's lobby buzzer.

[Bruce Anderson]

I said, get down here now.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And in doing so, he discovers another piece of arsenal in his ongoing war with his upstairs neighbors.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

That bus is extremely loud. It's like a foghorn out at sea on a ship, and it will drive you insane. For them to negate it and ignore it, since they had a lot of fortitude, I couldn't have done it.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce had rung their doorbell so many times that the buzzer burnt out. It was just really compulsive behavior.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Anderson was unraveling. He was unraveling all over the place.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Over the next weeks, Bruce's state of mind continues to deteriorate.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

The man had mental health issues. He lived in the dark. He stayed to a. His darkness just got darker and darker.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He was just becoming increasingly more isolated.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He was becoming totally unhinged.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

In the midst of their neighbor dispute, Yvette Rivera decides it's time to confess her secret to her husband.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

He made a pass on me.

[Bruce Anderson]

Who made a pass on you?

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Bruce.

[Bruce Anderson]

Bruce, why didn't you tell me?

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

I didn't want to worry you.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Worry me?

[Bruce Anderson]

Damn right I'm worried.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

She had to come out and tell because what if Mr. Anderson would have came out and just told Mr. Smitty what happened, and he might have. Wouldn't have told him the right way.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Cap, I'm sorry. Nothing happened.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I'm not gonna tell my husband. Cause that's gonna open up a can of worms we don't need. As any man, you would confront an

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

aggressor when it comes to protecting his wife, nothing will hold Smitty back.

[Bruce Anderson]

Yo, man, you made a pass at my wife. You better beat it, old man.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce came after him with a stick and was threatening to beat him with it. It just became so intense that people had to come in and break them apart.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Anderson just snapped. But I never thought it would have came to blows the way it did.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce Anderson's violence leaves the entire building concerned for Smitty and Yvette's safety.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Bruce was twice the size of Smitty. Bruce could have beat Smitty up. One, two, three.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I believe he was going to pummel him or just beat them right there in that lobby or in front of that building. That's what I thought was going to happen.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

More neighbors begin keeping their distance from Bruce.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

If he's not controlling that anger and he's just letting that anger continue, it's like a pressure cooker. You know, if it's building, it'll boil up.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I think this forced A siege mentality. It's me versus them. People saw the ugliness in him and avoided him.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

It just escalated out of control and something should have been done about it before it escalated.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Nothing worked, and this situation just continued to avalanche. His world was just becoming smaller and closing in.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Burning with resentment, Bruce turns to social media to venture. Dolores Nettles and Alan Thomas are horrified at some of the photos they encounter.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

When I saw Bruce's Facebook, it was a lot to take in. Bondage and things that torture. Like he wanted to torture women.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And not only that. Many of the disturbing photos Bruce posts allegedly have one thing in common.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

All the women looked like Yvette. That's what bothered me. If Yvette had seen those pictures, she would have been terrified to death of Bruce.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

But the photos are hardly the most distressing thing on Bruce's page, says New York Post journalist Rebecca Rosenberg in one Facebook post.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He puts up an article about a new machine gun and puts this really disturbing comment underneath it. What are you gonna do when Mr. Cuckoo gets one of these? This post almost seemed like a premonition.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I believe Anderson was letting you know on his Facebook what was transpiring, what was gonna trickle down.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Mary hall grows increasingly wary of her next door neighbor.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

The more I find out about this man, the more dangerous he becomes. He was a ticking time bomb, but the law and state says they can't do anything to him until he does something to somebody.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Bruce fed on that fear that they were afraid of him, because once you let a bully know that he can piss on you, he'll do it every time.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

In the midst of this nightmare, Smitty and Yvette try to carry on with their lives as best as possible.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

They were being incredibly careful and just really trying to appease Bruce.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

They tried to defuse the situation. They went to management, they went to the police. They tried to do everything that they they could do.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Yet their downstairs neighbor's decline continues.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I just think his brain told him that, you know, Yvette was in love with him and he could see them together. Like he could visualize it actually.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He was becoming so irrational to the point where he could not decipher reality from fantasy.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

If he got rid of Smitty, he could have had Yvette to himself.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

In his rage and frustration, Bruce launches his worst assault yet on his bedroom ceiling.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I could not believe it. He had a hammer and it's going bang, bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. Like he was actually going around in a circle.

[Bruce Anderson]

Get on now. Get on.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Yvette and Smitty don't know what's going on, and it's really terrifying.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Should we call the police? No, no, no, no.

[Bruce Anderson]

I think that'll make it worse.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

People were scared. Neighbors said that some people just didn't really want to go outside anymore.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He was just irrationally so far gone he didn't give a damn. That scared me.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He's like a train that's getting ready. You know the train's gonna crash. You just don't know when the impact is coming.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And on October 18, 2019, that crash is imminent.

[Commercial Narrator]

Support for this podcast is brought to you by Walden University. Ever catch yourself thinking, what if I could go after what I actually want and really make a difference? You're not alone. And that's exactly why I want to tell you about Walden University. For over 50 years, Walden has helped working adults like you get the W with the knowledge and skills to build the future you want and make a difference where it matters most. If you've been waiting for the right moment, this is it. Head to WaldenU.edu and take the first step. Walden University set a course for change. Certified to operate by Chev There are

moments that reveal who we are and who we're meant to become. For those born to lead. Such moments call for a vehicle of equal distinction. Dynamic by design, uncompromising in execution, the Range Rover Sport was engineered for those rare individuals who demand the world and possess the conviction to claim it. When your time to lead arrives, you need a vehicle that rises to meet it. The Range Rover Sport exclusive offers available now. Explore further@range rover.com Ready or not, summer

is coming and Wayfair's Memorial Day clearance is on now. Right now through May 25th, get up to 70% off everything home at Wayfair. Plus score amazing doorbuster deals all sale long and surprise flash deals on Memorial Day. We're talking thousands of products at every style and budget. Now is the time to save big on must haves for your patio, backyard and beyond. These savings won't last, so don't wait. Shop Wayfair's Memorial Day Clearance now through May 25th Wayfair Every style, every home.

[Paige Desorbo]

Hey, it's Paige from Giggly Squad. We need to talk about Abercrombie's new summer drop. Especially the swim. Just seeing the new coastal inspired prints and patterns is making me want to book a last minute trip to the beach. And Abercrombie made packing for vacation even easier with the launch of reversible swimming. Perfect for mixing, matching and customizing your look Prep for summer with Abercrombie in app, online and in stores.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

It's a fall morning like any other, except for one key difference. Bruce's neighbors notice that he hasn't wheeled his bike outside yet to exercise his hip. Neighbor Alan Thomas explains why this is unusual.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Bruce was like clockwork. He would come out with the biking table. You could sit Amtrak by his schedule.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Little does anyone know, Bruce has made other plans. He knows Smitty's schedule. And when his rival ventures home at midday, he puts his sinister plot in motion.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Smitty had came home for a break, went upstairs, had his lunch, and then on his way down, this man had to been waiting for him.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

This was premeditated. He timed when Smitty would come down.

[Bruce Anderson]

Yo, told you to move, man. Now you move. Now you pick.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce confronts him. He slugs him in the face.

[Bruce Anderson]

Get off. Come on. Get off.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Get him. Get up.

[Bruce Anderson]

Smith. Get off. Get poke.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

I think Anderson just snapped. He didn't see anything working in his favor. So listen, let me just do what I gotta do.

[Bruce Anderson]

I told you. I told you.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Huh?

[Bruce Anderson]

Huh? I told you. I said I told you.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

Told you.

[Bruce Anderson]

Get up. Get up. Told you, man.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Neighbor Ronnie Mitchell recounts that as the fight continues, Bruce pulls out a knife and plunges it into Smitty.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

He got stabbed 11 times. I think when you go after someone like that and you just keep on, that's built up rage.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

That was rage, and that was a crime of passion. Barry stabbed him. He probably called them names while he stabbed them.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

And the carnage doesn't end there. After stabbing Smitty 11 times, Bruce pulls out a gun and shoots him directly in the head. Hearing the gunshot, Yvette Rivera rushes out of her apartment and comes barreling downstairs, stairs.

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

What happened?

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Seeing Bruce Anderson looming over her husband, Yvette frantically returns inside and locks the door. But what she doesn't know is that Bruce has Smitty's keys.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Bruce forced his way into Yvette's apartment.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He probably told her, listen, I killed you. Gonna be with me?

[Neighbor / Yvette Rivera]

No, that's not cool.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

She was screaming for help, so he took that as, oh, she's rejecting me again. He couldn't have her, so nobody else can.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

Once the devil is in you, then the devil takes you where he wants to take you.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

Neighbors are calling the police after they hear the gunshots, and Bruce races downstairs to his apartment, barricades himself in, and then just starts spraying bullets at the wall that he shares with Mary's apartment.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Thankfully, Mary hall isn't home. She stopped for a Cigarette on her way home from lunch and missed her bus.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

I was never so grateful for Mary smoking a cigarette since I've known her in my relationship. Because if she'd have smoked that cigarette, we would have ran into that nut at 2:50pm and our lives would have been changed forever.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

I'd have been dead. Nosy as I am, I would have went to the door.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Police descend on the building. Within minutes, they start pushing all the

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

apartment buzzers, just trying to get somebody to open up. And Bruce answers.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

This is an actual recording of Bruce Anderson responding to police over the building's intercom.

[Bruce Anderson]

Come on in and get it over with. What's that? Come on in and get it over with.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

What doing are you?

[Bruce Anderson]

What are you talking about?

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Come on, kill him. Get it over with.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Avoid.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

We need to get a shoe here. Bruce's plan then takes an explosive turn.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

He used an accelerant to set that polar apartment on fire.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He wants it to be like some fatal attraction. He didn't want to go to jail.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He buzzes them in, and they see Smitty on the ground in a pool of blood and smoke billowing from under this door that's right off the hallway. And there's smoke, like, filling through the building.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

Police remove Smitty from the scene while Bruce locks himself in the bathroom of his burning apartment. Reporter Rebecca Rosenberg explains what happens next.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

FDNY shows up with ESU units. There's like 100 emergency personnel on the scene trying to figure out what to do here. It's a really dangerous situation. You have this building that's on fire, and the firefighters can't even go in yet because there's an active shooter situation. The police make their way upstairs, and they find Yvette is on the ground with a gunshot wound in the head and in the neck. This quiet neighborhood where very little ever happens is now the scene of a double homicide and this enormous police presence.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

It was surreal. Capital S. And I said to myself, this actually looks like a movie set, but a movie set can't be this good. By the time we got to hunt 30 second umpteen fire trucks, I counted at least three ambulances. And ESU was there. And we went into the block and they had it taped off. And ESU was there with their bulletproof shields. And I even saw a police officer with an oxygen tank and mask. I said, damn.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

When first responders finally make their way to Bruce's apartment, their face faced with another gruesome discovery.

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

He's in the bathtub with a gunshot wound to his head.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

We actually watch him being rolled out down the street to an ambulance. They tried to save him, but that bullet was in his head. He was too far gone. And a reporter came and said to us, three are confirmed dead. And Mary started crying and lost it.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

The murders of Hampton Smith and Yvette Rivera leave their family and friends devastated.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

New he knows the little things that he did that, you know, you just take for granted that you don't have, that's gone now. You don't have that.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

I never would have thought that anything like this would have been happening on where I live, especially to people that I cared about.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

The havoc that one sick mind can do. One sick mind can destroy so many lives. How do you kill two people over noise? And how do you kill a woman because she's not attracted to you? She don't want you. You don't kill another person because they don't want you.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He's a troubled person and apparently nobody really dug into his past to find out what he was really about.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Bruce thought that the world was against him. Yvette didn't want him. Smitty never backed down from him.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

He was angry, just couldn't take any more of either one of them. He took it out on him first and then he went after her.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

He eliminated his infatuation and his competition. He took two good people from a community that loved him.

[Neighbor / Rebecca Rosenberg]

They were so loved because they gave love. Smitty, he see you struggling down the road, he'd ask you, can I help you?

[Neighbor / Alan Thomas]

It was especially difficult for Yvette and Smitty's friends that they had to continue to live in the building where this terrible tragedy happened.

[Neighbor / Ronnie Mitchell]

The block came together. People donated money for his funeral.

[Neighbor / Dolores Nettles]

Maybe last week I asked Mr. Ronnie, you know, how you doing? And he was telling me, I miss my friend. I said, yeah, I miss him too. We picking up the pieces little by little.

[Narrator / Rebecca Rosenberg]

This podcast is produced by Cream Productions in association with Fremantle Media and id. You can check out Fear Thy Neighbor on Max Discovery plus and id.

[Neighbor / Mary Hall]

Par le tu francais hablas espanol? Parl italiano?

[Commercial Narrator]

If you've used Babel, you will. Babbel's conversation based technique teaches you useful words and phrases to get you speaking quickly about the things you actually talk about in the real world. With lessons handcrafted by over 200 language experts and voiced by real native speakers, Babbel is like having a private tutor in your pocket. Start speaking with Babbel today. Get up to 55% off your Babbel subscription right now at babbel.com acasta spelled B A B-B-E-L.com acast rules and restrictions may apply.

[Paige Desorbo]

Hey, this is Paige Desorbo from Giggly Squad and this episode is presented by Depop. Okay, be honest. How many things in your closet are just sitting there waiting for their next main character moment? Instead of staring at them, list them. You can list an item in just a few taps on Depop. Snap a photo and their AI powered listing fills in the details sales and you're done. It's not giving stressful and it's giving efficient and make money easily. With no selling fees on Depop, no seller fees means what you earn is yours. Your personal taste has value. Someone is literally looking for what you're not wearing. Download the Depop app and list your first item today.

[Liv Perez]

Hi, I'm Liv Perez from the let's Get Dressed podcast and this episode is presented to you by Depop. If you've been meaning to clean out your closet, but it feels feels so overwhelming, my best piece of advice for you as a fashion expert is to start with one thing. Depop. Depop makes it so simple to give your pieces a new home. Just snap a photo and their AI powered listings fill in all the details for you. And here's the best part. Make money easily. With no selling fees on Depop. No seller fees means that you earn exactly what is yours. Another perk. There is someone out there who's going to love that piece the way that you did and and who doesn't love making room for something new too. Download the Depop app and list your first item today.