Felonious Florida: The Altidor Massacre - Episode 5: "The Wall"

Release Date: May 6, 2025

Introduction

In the fifth episode of Season 5, titled "The Wall," Felonious Florida delves deeper into the chilling unsolved quadruple homicide that took place in Miramar, Florida, in 1997. The brutal murder of three generations of the Altidor family left investigators grappling with limited evidence and a prime suspect whose alibi has remained unbroken for nearly three decades.

The Crime Scene and the Mysterious Message

The episode opens with a vivid description of a critical piece of evidence from the crime scene:

David Shutes [00:57]: "Deep in the back of an ordinary, windowless building across the street from an elementary school lies an eerie relic of a horrific crime, a silent witness to the 1997 Altidor massacre."

At the heart of this relic is a section of drywall from the Altidor home, displaying a haunting message: "I want my hundred thousand drug money. They stole my drugs." This message, scrawled in black marker, has remained a focal point of the investigation, suggesting a possible motive rooted in drug-related disputes. However, the absence of typical signs of a drug-fueled attack, such as a ransacked home, has puzzled investigators.

George Altidore: The Prime Suspect

The narrative centers around George Altidore, identified as the husband, father, and son-in-law of the victims. Under intense scrutiny by Miramar police detectives, George ceased communication and sought refuge at his sister's home, effectively placing himself out of reach.

Insights from George's Ex-Wife: Jos Yannick Fidi

A crucial breakthrough in understanding George's character comes from his ex-wife, Jos Yannick Fidi, whose testimony sheds light on his controlling and manipulative nature:

Jos Yannick Fidi [07:25]: "A very good person. Okay. Was he demanding when we were dating? No."

However, post-marriage, her perception drastically changed:

Jos Yannick Fidi [08:32]: "He was very demanding. He was very jealous."

Fidi describes a marriage suffocated by George's obsessive need for control, including:

• Control Over Social Interactions:

  Jos Yannick Fidi [09:21]: "He was very jealous. Now, prior to your marriage, did you ever notice that trait in George? Yeah, but not that extreme."

• Sexual Manipulation:

  Jos Yannick Fidi [10:10]: "Everything was totally controlled by sex."

• Surveillance and Intimidation:

  Jos Yannick Fidi [11:32]: "He used to tape all the conversations that come in the house by telephone."

These revelations paint a picture of a man whose desperate need for control extended into every facet of his personal life, potentially providing motives aligned with the crime.

The Enigmatic Wall: Forensic Challenges

Detectives focused on the wall message sought to link it directly to George through handwriting analysis. Multiple markers from the scene, including one from George's pickup truck, were tested for ink consistency:

Detective Ron Peluzzo [14:12]: "The ink in this is the same as that on the wall."

However, this discovery led to a dead end as the marker’s ink matched millions of others, rendering it ineffective for pinpointing the suspect.

Further forensic attempts involved a forensic tool marking analysis, akin to ballistic tests, to find unique patterns in the marker's tip. Yet, the comparison yielded inconclusive results:

JT Harris [15:45]: "The comparison was inconclusive."

Handwriting Analysis: A Roadblock

The investigation faced significant hurdles in conclusively linking George to the wall message through handwriting analysis. Initial tests by an expert suggested a possible match but lacked official credentials, leading to skepticism within the investigative team.

J.J. Harris [20:59]: "Then we took pictures of it, and then we folded it up and saved it. And we did it over and over."

Even after multiple analyses and escalating efforts to involve higher authorities, the handwriting comparisons remained inconclusive:

J.J. Harris [25:25]: "It took six months for them to get back to me, okay? It came back inconclusive again."

Expert testimonies highlighted the challenges in matching handwriting from high-stress, hastily written messages:

Elin Bryan [26:19]: "There are characteristics in there that are habitual. Depending on the pen or the marker, the way the letters were formed, there may have been some minor similarities in the writing, but not enough for them to conclude that there was a match."

George's Alibi: The Mysterious Phone Call

A pivotal element in George's defense is a phone call log indicating a call from the Altidor's landline to Marie Altidore's godfather's residence on the morning of the murders:

J.J. Harris [33:13]: "I pick up the phone and I say, Jesus love you. And then the person gave me like a response. And then I Say hello."

This call, lasting two minutes, placed George away from the crime scene at the time of the murders, supporting his alibi. However, inconsistencies arose:

J.J. Harris [34:55]: "My aunt does not recognize Mami's voice, and they didn't have that kind of relationship for her to be able to distinguish who was on the phone."

Further investigative efforts involved a time-motion study to verify George's claim of being en route to work:

J.J. Harris [37:23]: "I needed to determine, you know, how long does it take them to get from point A to point B?"

The study corroborated George's assertion that he could not have committed the murders post-call and arrived at work by his stated time. However, the absence of surveillance footage and time cards left the alibi unchallenged.

Investigative Frustrations and Ongoing Challenges

Despite meticulous investigative work, the case remains unresolved. The combination of inconclusive forensic evidence and a solid alibi for the prime suspect has left detectives grappling with limited leads. The episode concludes with a sense of frustration among the investigative team as they reach a stalemate, emphasizing the perplexing nature of the Altidor massacre.

Conclusion and Tease for Next Episode

As detectives stand on the brink of a cold case, the episode hints at forthcoming revelations that could potentially unearth new evidence or shift perspectives in unexpected ways.

J.J. Harris [38:30]: "That killed that case. The phone call right there. How do you get around that phone call?"

Stay tuned for the next episode, where Felonious Florida promises to unravel more layers of this enduring mystery.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• J.J. Harris [05:14]: "The house wasn't ransacked. So it's almost like a plot of a movie where that's completely fake. That doesn't make any sense."

• J.J. Harris [10:23]: "She goes, 'If I wanted anything, I had to have sex with him.' She goes, 'Everything was totally controlled by sex.'"

• J.J. Harris [18:43]: "He had a .38 snub nose, which is five shots. We had five shots an hour. Homicide. And he told her that I will kill you and no one will ever know and I will get away with this."

• J.J. Harris [25:12]: "We had two people, two different agencies looking at it. A third agency, you know, you couldn't get it done."

• Elin Bryan [26:19]: "No one can write the same way twice. It's physiologically impossible because you have neurons and axons in your brain firing at all different billions of different times a second."

Final Thoughts

"The Wall" serves as a critical exploration into the complexities of the Altidor massacre investigation, highlighting the interplay between personal testimonies, forensic science, and the elusive nature of conclusive evidence. As the case remains unsolved, it underscores the persistent challenges law enforcement faces in bringing closure to victims' families.

Felonious Florida continues to unravel the dark mysteries of Florida's most perplexing crimes, offering listeners an in-depth look into cases that have long awaited resolution.