A Masked Man. A Silent Trail. The Hunt for the Bogeyman.

Summary

Podcast Summary: Firebug

Episode: A Masked Man. A Silent Trail. The Hunt for the Bogeyman
Date: November 12, 2025
Host: truth.media

---

Episode Overview

This gripping episode delves into the story of Nicole Ernest Pate, who, as a young woman, survived a terrifying home invasion and sexual assault in the early 1990s. The episode unravels her account of that night, the trauma that followed, and the years-long mystery of the masked predator who eluded police for decades—earning him the moniker “the Boogeyman.” The episode also sets the stage for the related series "Hunting the Boogeyman," highlighting the strength and perseverance of survivors and the relentless pursuit of justice.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Nicole’s Story: The Night That Changed Everything

• Setting the Scene (03:12–05:56)
  • Nicole, 19 and newly single, buys her first home in Rohnert Park, CA.
  • After breaking up with her boyfriend and living alone, she places a newspaper ad for a roommate.
  • Receives a suspicious call from a man identifying himself with the generic name “Bob Smith,” whose flat, monotone voice sticks in Nicole's memory.
    • Quote: “I got this specific inquiry that stuck in my brain because it just sounded like an odd name. My name is Bob Smith. Really? Your name's Bob Smith? Interesting. And I just remembered his voice.” – Nicole (04:37)
• The Lead-Up to the Attack (05:26–06:10)
  • Nicole, exhausted after work, stays home one Saturday night, plans to meet “Bob Smith” Sunday morning.
  • She prepares to relax, wearing a light robe, watching TV.
• The Attack (07:05–08:02)
  • Nicole wakes to a masked man with a gun to her head, claiming, “Don’t move, I’m just here to rob you.”
  • Realizing this is not a simple robbery, sheer terror sets in as he walks her upstairs.
    • Quote: “I will never forget the feeling of being walked up the stairs. I will never forget that as long as I live. Because that’s when it hit me. Oh shit. I’m in real trouble.” – Nicole (07:56)
  • The masked man sexually assaults Nicole for hours.

2. Aftermath & Lasting Trauma

• Living With the Unknown (08:16–08:30)
  • Nicole reflects on the profound impact, stating she has thought about the crime daily since.
    • Quote: “I thought about this crime every day of my life and still do. And I always will.” – Nicole (08:16)
  • The identity of her assailant remained a mystery, heightening her fear and anxiety.
    • Quote: “Did not know his name, did not know what he looked like. Is he somebody I know? Is he in my own community?” – Nicole (08:30)
• Isolation and Secrecy (08:30–09:00)
  • Nicole confides she never told most people, withholding the truth from even her husband.
  • She fantasized about the day the attacker would be caught, longing for closure.
    • Quote: “I would fantasize about how good it would feel to not have to wonder who he was for the rest of my life and be scared for the rest of my life.” – Nicole (08:56)

3. The Boogeyman and the Broader Hunt

• Pattern Recognition and Forensic Breakthroughs (00:12–03:02)
  • Nicole’s perseverance helps detectives recognize her attack was part of a larger pattern.
  • Introduction of cold case detective Paul Holz and prosecutor Keith Hill, who describe the attacker as “the boogeyman, the manifestation of a nightmare.”
• Long Road to Justice (02:38–03:12)
  • The attacker evaded capture for nearly 30 years, until advances in forensic science and persistent detectives cracked open the case.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Vulnerability and Fear:
  “We all have our bedtime routine...But another part of the routine is safety. You're about to shut down your senses. It’s the most vulnerable part of your life and you do it every day. So you lock your doors at night...There’s a word for the thing we’re protecting ourselves from in the middle of the night. The boogeyman. The boogeyman that we want to believe doesn’t exist. And then you’re confronted with the reality that they do.” – Host (00:37)

• On the Masked Assailant:
  “For most of my life after this happened, I didn’t have a face at all or a name, just a voice and a presence.” – Nicole (02:38)

• On Bravery and Survival:
  “The heart of this story is a courageous woman named Nicole. She not only survived this nightmare, she went after the boogeyman.” – Host (02:57)

---

Timeline of Major Segments

• 00:00–03:12: Setting up Nicole’s story, introducing the threat of the “boogeyman” and the long-unsolved case.
• 03:12–05:26: Nicole’s background, moving into her first home, breakup, and search for a roommate.
• 05:26–06:10: The suspicious call from “Bob Smith”; Nicole’s decision to stay home.
• 06:10–08:02: The attack—Nicole is awoken by a masked man; the assault.
• 08:02–09:00: Nicole’s reflection on the trauma and its lifelong impact; desire for justice.

---

Tone and Language

The episode employs an intimate, respectful, and unsettling tone. Nicole’s recounting is detailed but restrained, the host’s narration is compassionate yet matter-of-fact, and quotes from law enforcement underline the seriousness and horror of these events.

---

Closing Note

This episode offers not only a chilling account of a survivor’s ordeal but also emphasizes the enduring strength it takes to navigate life with unresolved trauma. It highlights the vital role of law enforcement, forensic breakthroughs, and survivor advocacy in bringing serial predators to justice.

Listeners seeking the full story are encouraged to follow the related series “Hunting the Boogeyman.”

Transcript

[A]

Nicole Ernest Pate was 21 years old when a predator assaulted her in her own home.

[B]

He is kind of the boogeyman.

[A]

In the night, she went straight to the cops.

[B]

She said this sounds like some sort of movie plot.

[A]

But no one believed her. Until one day, Cold case detective Paul Holz helped figure out the serial predator's pattern. This is a serious offender. He'd been hiding in plain sight from Sony Music Entertainment and perfect Cadence. This is Hunting the Boogeyman. Hunting the Boogeyman is available now wherever you get your podcasts. Subscribers to the binge can get all episodes ad free today. Here's a sneak peek of the show. Hi, listeners, this is Peter. I just want to let you know that this series includes stories about sexual assault and violence. Please use discretion when listening. We all have our bedtime routine. There's the hygiene part. Maybe you lay out your clothes for the next day, set your alarm, turn out the lights, put down your phone. But another part of the routine is safety. You're about to shut down your senses. It's the most vulnerable part of your life, and you do it every day. So you lock your doors at night. Maybe you have an alarm system. There's a word for the thing we're protecting ourselves from in the middle of the night. The boogeyman. The boogeyman that we want to believe doesn't exist. And then you're confronted with the reality that they do. That's Sacramento prosecutor Keith Hill, who had seen his fair share of boogeymen, but none like this one. This boogeyman is truly the manifestation of a nightmare. The boogeyman. In this story, no one could find him for almost 30 years. To catch him required a groundbreaking forensic discovery and a badass detective who cracked one of the biggest murder cases in history. But the heart of this story is a courageous woman named Nicole. She not only survived this nightmare, she went after the bogeyman. And years later, she realized that what happened to her was only the beginning of this terrifying pattern. The man who attacked her went on to attack many others. And no one could find him.

[B]

For most of my life after this happened, I didn't have a face at all or a name, Just a voice and a presence.

[A]

The first thing you need to know about Nicole is that she's a pretty fearless person. For most of her life, she wanted to find this guy and unmask him. But that's not where this story ends.

[B]

I wanted to understand what happened to him and what made him be this monster.

[A]

Like to give you a brief overview of the series. What we know is this started in 1991 in Rohnert Park. Rohnert Park, a small town north of San Francisco. It's where Nicole Ernest Pate bought her first home when she was just 19 years old.

[B]

It was a really cute place. I fell in love with it when I saw.

[A]

Was a two story townhome and she lived there with her boyfriend who was six years older. It was a rocky relationship though. So When Nicole turned 21, she dumped him. When her ex moved out, he took pretty much everything with him. All Nicole had left were her bed, a couch, some chairs and a landline telephone that sat on her bedroom floor. She also had a mortgage to pay all by herself. But for the first time in her life, she was single. She went out, had fun and started casually dating her friend Mark.

[B]

The guy was, you know, kind of a bad boy. I mean, not bad boy, bad boy. And he kind of, you know, he was the first guy I'd ever dated who had tattoos. And my parents were mortified, mortified that I was going out with a guy with tattoos. I'm like, oh really? Are you mortified? Oh, this is fun.

[A]

But she didn't want to invite Mark to move in with her. She decided to put an ad in the local newspaper for a roommate. She got some calls right away, but.

[B]

I got this specific inquiry that stuck in my brain because it just sounded like an odd name. My name is Bob Smith. Really? Your name's Bob Smith? Interesting. And I just remembered his voice. His voice was quite flat and just monotone. And told him about the room, the rent, where it's located, yada yada. He told me that he was in the construction trade and I believe he said he had kids. Might have said he was married, but he has to commute for work and so he just needed a room.

[A]

The guy asked when he could come over and see the place. Nicole said, well, she had to work on Friday and Saturday.

[B]

Well what about Sunday morning? And I said, well not too early because I'm sure I'll be out late on Saturday night. He said okay, it was a plan.

[A]

On Friday, Nicole went out with some friends. She got home late, got up early on Saturday. Back then she was a hairdresser and spent all day on her feet.

[B]

Then I came home from work exhausted and I took a bath and she called her friends and I said, I'm not going out, I'm staying here.

[A]

She pretty much cancelled all her plans and said she wasn't going to set a foot outside until she had to Go back to work on Tuesday. The only thing left on her schedule that weekend was, was Bob Smith.

[B]

I'm gonna go watch tv. It was hot so I put on this. It was a little green robe that'll become important later. I didn't have anything on underneath so like I'm not just gonna go lay down on the couch. It's probably 8:30 as I'm starting to get really sleepy.

[A]

Nicole fell asleep on the couch in her living room. Across from her was a sliding glass door that led to her enclosed patio. The other townhomes had their patios in the back. But for some reason Nicole's place was turned around. Her patio faced the parking lot so she used her sliding glass door to come and go. The only problem was she couldn't lock it when she was gone. But she figured ah, she didn't have much to steal anyway and she always locked it when she was home. Her friend Mark had even installed a motion sensor security light above it. When Nicole fell asleep on the couch that Saturday night, the TV was on her patio gate was closed. Her sliding glass door was locked and her motion sensor light had a fresh bulb. But at some point after sunset, something woke her up.

[B]

The TV was no longer on and there was an arm around my neck. He had his hand over my mouth, he had a glove on. I caught glimpse of a mask, ski mask. And I realized that he had a gun at my head. Is this a prank? And then he very quietly said, don't move, I'm just here to rob you. He attempted to kind of lift me and I knew my robe would come open so I sort of shook my head and he put me down. But he still had the gun on me the whole time. And then he walked me upstairs with my hands behind my back. I will never forget the feeling of being walked up the stairs. I will never forget that as long as I live. Because that's when it hit me. Oh shit. I'm in real trouble.

[A]

What happened next is most people's worst nightmare. The masked man who invaded her home sexually assaulted her for hours. Nicole's life would never be the same.

[B]

I thought about this crime every day of my life and still do. And I always will.

[A]

Estimates vary, but about 80% of the time victims of rape know the person who attacked them. Nicole had no idea who the man.

[B]

Was, did not know his name, did not know what he looked like. Is he somebody I know? Is he in my own community? It's a really, really weird, scary, strange way to walk around in life. And what I would sit and fantasize about was how I would be informed that he was caught every day. Never told people, never discussed it, never told my husband. I would fantasize about how good it would feel to not have to wonder who he was for the rest of my life and be scared for the rest of my life.

[A]

Interested in hearing the rest of the story? Just search for Hunting the Boogeyman wherever you get your podcasts to listen. Now subscribe to the binge to get access to all episodes ad free today.