Podcast Title: Flipping Tables
Host: Monte Mader
Episode: Queer & Christian with Brandan Robertson
Release Date: May 28, 2025

Introduction

In this poignant episode of Flipping Tables, host Monte Mader delves deep into the intersection of faith and LGBTQ identity by engaging in a heartfelt conversation with Brandon Robertson, a renowned gay activist, writer, theologian, and pastor. The discussion centers on the misinterpretation of biblical texts used to condemn LGBTQ individuals and explores the journey towards a more inclusive and progressive Christianity.

The Rise of Anti-LGBTQ Rhetoric in Evangelicalism

Monte begins the episode by highlighting the alarming increase in anti-LGBTQ rhetoric within evangelical circles, emphasizing how these narratives are weaponized for political gain. She outlines the historical context, tracing the origins of Christian nationalism and its strategic use of issues like homosexuality and abortion to unify white evangelicals and influence legislation.

Monte Mader [02:05]:
"Homosexuality, along with abortion, became a central axis of their man-made fake culture war. And this marriage was solidified in the Reagan era."

She discusses the pivotal moments that marked the shift of evangelicals from isolated theological debates to active political engagement, leading to the proliferation of anti-LGBTQ laws and propaganda.

Brandon Robertson’s Personal Journey

Brandan Robertson shares his personal story of growing up in a fundamentalist Baptist environment and grappling with his emerging sexual identity. His journey of deconstruction began in college, where exposure to diverse cultures and rigorous academic study of the Bible led him to question the rigid doctrines he was raised with.

Brandon Robertson [17:22]:
"I recognized that the faith I was a part of was rooted in fear. If asking questions about whether hell exists elicited such fear, then what does that say about the God they believed in?"

He reflects on the cognitive dissonance experienced by many LGBTQ individuals within evangelicalism and the emotional toll of reconciling faith with personal identity.

Deconstructing Biblical Misinterpretations

Monte and Brandon meticulously examine several biblical passages commonly cited to condemn LGBTQ individuals. They argue that these scriptures have been historically misinterpreted and mistranslated to serve anti-LGBTQ agendas.

Genesis 1 and 2: Redefining Marriage

Brandon explains that Genesis 1 and 2 are poetic accounts aimed at establishing the origins of the Jewish people rather than prescribing universal marital norms.

Brandon Robertson [29:53]:
"Genesis 1 and 2 isn't about the creation of the world. It's actually the creation of the Jewish people. It's their origin story."

He emphasizes that the original Hebrew terms do not equate to modern concepts of sexual orientation and that the biblical narrative focuses on relational needs rather than gender-prescribed partnerships.

Sodom and Gomorrah: Contextualizing the Narrative

The dialogue shifts to the story of Sodom and Gomorrah, where Brandon argues that the condemnation was directed at rampant sexual exploitation and abuse rather than consensual same-sex relationships.

Brandon Robertson [36:27]:
"The very fact that Lot offers his daughters suggests that the men of Sodom were not gay. They were simply trying to abuse men from a different culture."

This interpretation challenges the traditional view by placing the story within its historical and cultural context, highlighting xenophobia and power dynamics over sexual orientation.

Leviticus 18 and 20: Addressing Ancient Exploitation

Brandon dismantles the notion that Leviticus condemns homosexuality by presenting evidence that these passages refer to exploitative practices prevalent in ancient Egypt and Canaan.

Brandon Robertson [41:16]:
"The author of Leviticus is condemning the widespread practice of sexual exploitation and abuse, not consensual same-sex relationships."

He underscores the patriarchal and oppressive societal norms of the time, which influenced these biblical laws.

Deuteronomy 22: Gender Distinctions in Clothing

Discussing Deuteronomy 22:5, both hosts argue that the scripture was intended to maintain cultural distinctiveness rather than enforce rigid gender norms applicable today.

Brandon Robertson [46:25]:
"This verse is trying to say to the Jewish people, maintain your cultural distinctiveness, not about making moral law codes about gender for all people."

Reclaiming and Reinterpreting the Bible

Monte and Brandon advocate for a re-examination of biblical texts through a progressive and inclusive lens. They highlight the existence of nuanced and often overlooked narratives within the Bible that resonate with LGBTQ experiences.

Examples of Queer Narratives in the Bible

Brandon shares examples of biblical stories that can be interpreted to reflect queer experiences, such as the relationship between King David and Jonathan, and the loyalty between Ruth and Naomi. He also discusses scholarly perspectives on Jesus embodying a subversive approach to gender norms.

Brandon Robertson [61:58]:
"Reclaiming our Bible means creating space for our stories and our love within these ancient texts."

Encouragement and Hope for LGBTQ Christians

Brandon offers solace and practical advice for LGBTQ individuals struggling with their faith. He encourages listeners to seek out inclusive communities and engage with progressive theological resources.

Brandon Robertson [56:53]:
"There are churches out there that are truly inclusive and affirming. Step into one worship service and experience the difference."

He recommends resources such as queerchurch.org and the SBL Study Bible for those seeking a deeper and more accurate understanding of scripture.

Conclusion: Vision for the Future

In closing, Monte and Brandon express a shared vision of a future where the Bible is a source of liberation and justice rather than oppression. They emphasize the importance of reinterpreting sacred texts to reflect love, inclusion, and the true teachings of Jesus.

Brandon Robertson [68:19]:
"We have the opportunity to take the Bible back and use it as a tool for liberation, progressive social renewal, and justice."

Monte reflects on the healing power of reclaiming faith, reinforcing the message that true Christianity aligns with advocating for and embracing the marginalized.

Notable Quotes

• Monte Mader [02:05]:
  "Homosexuality, along with abortion, became a central axis of their man-made fake culture war."

• Brandon Robertson [17:22]:
  "If asking questions about whether hell exists elicited such fear, then what does that say about the God they believed in?"

• Brandon Robertson [29:53]:
  "Genesis 1 and 2 isn't about the creation of the world. It's actually the creation of the Jewish people."

• Brandon Robertson [36:27]:
  "The very fact that Lot offers his daughters suggests that the men of Sodom were not gay."

• Brandon Robertson [41:16]:
  "The author of Leviticus is condemning the widespread practice of sexual exploitation and abuse, not consensual same-sex relationships."

• Brandon Robertson [46:25]:
  "This verse is trying to say to the Jewish people, maintain your cultural distinctiveness, not about making moral law codes about gender for all people."

• Brandon Robertson [56:53]:
  "There are churches out there that are truly inclusive and affirming. Step into one worship service and experience the difference."

• Brandon Robertson [68:19]:
  "We have the opportunity to take the Bible back and use it as a tool for liberation, progressive social renewal, and justice."

Final Thoughts

This episode of Flipping Tables serves as a crucial resource for anyone grappling with reconciling their faith with their sexual identity. Through Monte’s empathetic hosting and Brandon’s scholarly insights, listeners are offered a path toward healing, understanding, and a redefined spiritual journey that embraces inclusivity and love.

Listen to the full episode on Flipping Tables to gain deeper insights and join the conversation on fostering a more inclusive and compassionate Christian community.