Transcript
A (0:01)
And now on to Part 2 with Dr. Alex Baugh. Doctrine and Covenants 115 to 120. One of the things I was excited to ask you today was. I don't know if these are myths or hearsay or secondhand third hand accounts. People mention Adam's altar. It's hard to imagine there were people there that you can't find a trace of. But Adam's stuff is still there. Also a Nephite altar. But when I researched it I found actually what George W. Robinson wrote was a Nephite ish altar, which changes the meaning dramatically.
B (0:39)
You're spot on. Yeah.
A (0:40)
What can you tell us about those?
B (0:42)
Well, I'm just going to read to you what I wrote.
C (0:46)
What you're going to read is that's from this new book, the Voice of the Lord exploring the Doctrine and Covenants that you edited.
B (0:53)
On this same occasion we get the following report. I'm going to summarize just a little bit. When he identified this Spring Hill, it's so named by the brethren at that point in time as being Adam on Diamond. George W. Robinson, who's keeping Joseph Smith's book, this is his journal, wrote that they discovered the remains of an old Nephiteish altar and tower. This location soon became known by the saints that come here and soon thereafter who settled in the area as Tower Hill. And significantly, however, there was considerable speculation regarding what it was that the company actually came across. In early 1844, Willard Richards, the general Church Recorder, began making a transcription of Joseph Smith's journal, the script rebook for inclusion in Joseph Smith's official history, generally referred to as the manuscript history of the Church. When Richards came across the May 19, 1838 entry made by Robinson about the location of Adam Onda Ammon and the ruins the Prophet's company discovered. On that occasion, Richards incorrectly altered the text to read that the remains located there were part of an old Nephite altar or or tower, replacing the word Nephite ish written by Robinson with Nephite. This error by Richards was later perpetuated by B.H. roberts when he added the manuscript history for publication in what became known as the History of the Church. The mistake by both Richards and Roberts is significant since it has led to the erroneous conclusion by some that the stonework or rubble discovered on Tower Hill was actually a remnant from the Nephite civilization in the Book of Mormon, which would have been about 600 B.C. to 400 A.D. as we know when in fact the term Robinson used was Nephiteish So what did Robinson mean when he reported that the stone ruins were Nephiteish? It's important to note that in the 1830s, many latter day Saints considered the North American Indian tribes or the indigenous people were descendants of earlier Nephite Lamanite civilization in the Book of Mormon. With that understanding, Robinson may have simply been trying to convey the idea that the Prophets company, what they discovered on this occasion were the remains of what appeared to be a sacred ancient, meaning old stone structure of some kind erected by the Native Americans, meaning Nephiteish, not Book of Mormon. It's significant to note that George Robinson's description of what Joseph Smith's company discovered on this occasion aligns with the findings from an archaeological excavation conducted in 1979 and 80 by Ray Matheny, a former professor of anthropology at Brigham Young University. Matheny and his team concluded that what Joseph Smith and his company discovered on this occasion were the remains of a stone structure that was part of an ancient Native American burial ground dating to the early part of the late Woodland period, which is 500 to 1000 AD. I share that with you. Number one, it's not Adamic Altar. Number two, it's not Nephite, it's Native American. That bears out why did people say they saw Adam's altar? Well, when they come up there and they go to this site and they see this remains, those who are there say, well, yeah, this is where Adam offered sacrifices. This was his altar. They're naturally assuming, oh, this is Adam's alder. It's not Adamic and it's not Nephite. It's Nephite ish, meaning ancient Native American. We've got to eliminate some of the speculation on this. But again, to the Latter Day Saints, if they came up there, they'd go, this must be Adam's altar. Eliza R. Snow comes up. He says, I saw Adam's altar. Well, you thought you did, but it's not that. That should not be the meaning of faith by any means. It's just that they did not know and understand that this is where it happened, where Adam did offer sacrifices according to Joseph Smith. But what remains there was not from Adam or Nephite, the Nephite civilization.
