Freakonomics Radio Episode Summary: "Why Does Tipping Still Exist? (Update)"

Release Date: August 6, 2025
Host: Stephen J. Dubner
Podcast: Freakonomics Radio

1. Introduction to the Tipping Debate

Stephen Dubner opens the episode by revisiting a topic initially explored in 2019: the economics and social norms surrounding tipping. This follow-up episode delves deeper into recent developments and ongoing debates, particularly in light of legislative changes like President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill act, which allows workers to deduct up to $25,000 of qualified tips from federal tax returns.

Notable Quote:
Stephen Dubner [00:49]: "Why tipping, as controversial as it may be, isn't likely to go away."

2. Historical Context and Social Norms of Tipping

Economist John List provides a historical overview, tracing tipping practices back to either the Roman era or 17th-century England, eventually taking root in the United States in the 18th century amid significant resistance. Notable figures like Mark Twain condemned tipping as an unjust tax, and by 1915, six U.S. states had abolished it.

Notable Quote:
John List [03:13]: "Some people argue that tipping goes all the way back to the Roman era... but either way, tipping ended up coming to the US roughly in the 18th century."

Uri Ganese, an economist at UC San Diego, highlights the perplexing nature of tipping behaviors, emphasizing their reliance on hard-to-follow social norms.

3. The Economics of Tipping in America

Tipping in the U.S. contributes over $50 billion annually—surpassing entire industries like health and fitness and doubling NASA's annual budget. Despite being labeled as optional, tipping often becomes an implicit expectation, especially in full-service restaurants where employees are paid below minimum wage supplemented primarily by tips.

Notable Quote:
John List [04:45]: "Tipping is one of the most interesting behaviors that we have... It's really a very strange behavior."

4. Uber's Tipping Experiment

John List, former Chief Economist at Uber, spearheaded an ambitious field experiment to introduce tipping within the Uber platform—a company that had not previously incorporated tipping. The experiment aimed to assess whether tipping could be genuinely voluntary and not succumb to social pressure, targeting a tipping rate of 10-20%.

Setup Details:

• Timing: Passengers could tip only after exiting the vehicle and completing a driver rating, ensuring no direct quid pro quo.
• Scope: Over 40 million Uber rides were observed, involving approximately 800,000 drivers.

Notable Quote:
John List [12:29]: "Travis had a pretty strong intuition that was a little bit like Mark Twain. He viewed it more as a tax or an increase in price because he felt that everyone would feel compelled to tip because it will become a social norm."

5. Results of the Tipping Experiment

The experiment revealed that approximately 15-16% of Uber rides resulted in a tip, aligning with Uber's target range. However, this rate is significantly lower than in traditional dining settings, where tipping occurs in nearly every meal.

Tipper Classification:

• Consistent Tippers: 1% of passengers consistently tipped on every ride.
• Non-Tippers: 60% never tipped.
• Occasional Tippers: 39% tipped intermittently.

Notable Quote:
John List [21:06]: "So one of the most surprising results is that when you look at the data pattern, it's actually the rider variables that are roughly three times more important than the driver variables."

6. Factors Influencing Tipping Behavior

John List's analysis identified passenger characteristics as more influential in tipping decisions than driver behavior or trip specifics. Key findings include:

• Passenger Ratings: Riders with five-star ratings tipped twice as often as those with lower ratings.
• Gender Dynamics: Male passengers were 19% more likely to tip than female passengers, a contrast to broader charitable behavior where women tend to be more generous.
• Time and Occasion: Higher tips were observed during early morning hours (possibly due to expense accounts) and weekend evenings associated with dining out and socializing.
• Driver Attributes: Female drivers received approximately 12% more in tips than male drivers. However, driver-specific factors like language settings and vehicle age had minimal impact.

Notable Quotes:
John List [22:36]: "A man is about 19% more likely to tip than a female rider."
John List [26:04]: "Drivers in the old cars are tipped slightly less than drivers in the new cars."

7. The Impact of Tipping on Driver Earnings

Although cumulative tipping accounts for about 4% of Uber fares, this additional income does not increase driver earnings on average. This is because the introduction of tipping attracted more drivers to the platform, increasing labor supply and offsetting potential wage gains.

Notable Quote:
John List [27:45]: "Driver earnings actually do not increase on average because of tipping."

8. Optimizing Tipping Through App Design

List's research also explored how app interface changes could influence tipping behavior. By adjusting default tip amounts, Uber could affect both the frequency and size of tips. Lower preset tips led to more frequent tipping, while higher presets increased the average tip amount.

Notable Quote:
John List [28:26]: "Roughly 16.5% of trips are tipped when you have a low preset, versus about 14.5% when you have a higher preset."

9. Danny Meyer's No-Tipping Initiative

Renowned restaurateur Danny Meyer transitioned his restaurants to a "hospitality included" model, eliminating tipping and incorporating higher menu prices to ensure fair wages for all staff. Meyer's approach aimed to:

• Equalize Pay: Reduce the wage gap between front-of-house (servers) and back-of-house (kitchen) employees.
• Enhance Professionalism: Foster a work environment based on professionalism rather than tip-dependent performance.
• Improve Employee Retention: Address high turnover rates and attract culinary talent deterred by the previous tipping system.

Notable Quotes:
Danny Meyer [31:49]: "We never wanted to hire people who would only be nice to you in expectation of a higher reward."
Danny Meyer [32:18]: "Why in the world can we not make this work when we're serving you a hundred dollar dinner at Gramercy Tavern?"

10. Challenges Faced in Eliminating Tipping

Meyer's initiative faced several hurdles:

• Increased Menu Prices: Implementing a 21% price hike to compensate for eliminating tips.
• Employee Turnover: A 30-40% turnover rate among legacy staff due to changes in compensation structures.
• Customer Perception: Balancing higher prices with customer expectations for service without tipping.

Despite higher revenues and improved pay equity (e.g., kitchen wages increased by 37%, reducing the wage gap from 2.4 to 1.9 times), Meyer expressed uncertainty about inspiring a widespread industry shift.

Notable Quotes:
Danny Meyer [36:36]: "We've converted about one every four to six months. We just have one more to go."
Danny Meyer [41:07]: "Yeah, well, we did not succeed at inspiring an entire industry to change its tune."

11. Michael Lin's Perspective on Tipping and Service Quality

Michael Lin, a social psychologist at Cornell, challenges the perceived link between service quality and tipping. His research indicates that only about 4% of the variance in tips correlates with service ratings, contrary to the belief held by many servers that tips are strongly influenced by service quality.

Research Insights:

• Server Beliefs: Approximately half of servers believe tips are moderately to strongly affected by their service, despite data suggesting otherwise.
• Customer Expectations: Tipping systems may enhance customer satisfaction by raising expectations for better service, even if actual service quality does not improve.

Notable Quotes:
Michael Lin [44:19]: "Look, when I started doing research on tipping, I thought tips would be strongly related to service quality. But what I found was that about 4% of the variance in tips left by different groups can be explained by their ratings of service quality."
Michael Lin [46:18]: "Tipping increases customer satisfaction. Customers expect service to be better under a tipping system, and that can bias their perceptions."

12. The Future of Tipping

Both Meyer and Lin acknowledge the complexities of abolishing tipping. While Meyer's model shows promise in higher-wage environments and upscale restaurants, broader societal and economic factors, such as minimum wage increases, may eventually pressure more establishments to adopt similar models. However, Michael Lin remains skeptical about completely eliminating tipping, emphasizing its role in consumer satisfaction and the challenges in altering entrenched social norms.

Notable Quotes:
Danny Meyer [42:31]: "But I also understand that movements happen in a big way when the economics work for everybody. And I don't think we're quite there yet."
Michael Lin [47:32]: "I'm less likely to want to just ban tipping now because the data I have suggests that customers are happier with tipping."

13. Reflections on Human Behavior and Generosity

John List concludes by highlighting the disparities in generous behavior among individuals. His experiment revealed that a small percentage of passengers consistently tip, while the majority either never tip or do so sporadically. This suggests inherent variability in generosity and challenges the notion of tipping as a reliable incentive for service quality.

Notable Quotes:
John List [48:32]: "I think a first point that the data really highlight is that very few people will be continuously generous and consistently generous."
John List [49:46]: "I think that this is an important time to send wealth or income to another person who's doing a job such as this. But I also feel good about doing it. I have a warm glow, and it makes me feel good inside that I'm not stiffing the person."

14. Conclusion

The episode underscores the intricate and often contradictory nature of tipping in modern economies. While attempts to reform or eliminate tipping reveal potential benefits in wage equity and employee satisfaction, deep-seated social norms and consumer expectations continue to sustain the practice. As economic models and societal values evolve, the future of tipping remains a pivotal question in the landscape of service industries.

Produced by:
Matt Hickey, Dalvin Abuaji, Jasmine Klinger
Freakonomics Radio Network Staff: Alina Coleman, Gusta Chapman, Eleanor Osborne, Ellen Frankman, Elsa Hernandez, Gabriel Roth, Greg Rippon, Jeremy Johnston, Morgan Levy, Sarah Lilly, Teo Jacobs, Zach Lipinski.

Find More:
Podcast Archive: freakonomics.com
Credits and Contact: @freakonomics.com