wavePod

Get Wave AI

Freedman's Bank & Economic Disparities Today - Fresh Air | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to Fresh Air

Freedman's Bank & Economic Disparities Today

Fresh Air

Thu Nov 07 2024

Summary

Fresh Air Podcast Summary: "Freedman's Bank & Economic Disparities Today"

Host: Tanya Moseley
Guest: Justine Hill Edwards, Historian and Author of Savings and Trust
Podcast: Fresh Air
Episode Title: Freedman's Bank & Economic Disparities Today

Introduction to the Freedmen's Bank

In this episode of Fresh Air, host Tanya Moseley engages in an enlightening conversation with historian Justine Hill Edwards about her latest book, Savings and Trust. The discussion delves into the establishment, rise, and eventual collapse of the Freedmen's Savings and Trust Company, a pivotal institution founded to empower newly emancipated African Americans in the post-Civil War era.

Establishment and Mission of the Freedmen's Bank

The Freedmen's Bank was established in 1865 by white abolitionists, notably John Alvord, a minister from Connecticut. Alvord's interactions with freed African Americans during General Sherman's march underscored the community's desire for financial independence and land ownership. Edwards explains, "They wanted the opportunity to buy land… to create a piece of the American dream for themselves" (02:09).

African Americans' Financial Acumen and Aspirations

Despite systemic disenfranchisement, African Americans possessed a profound understanding of money's value, rooted in their experiences of enslavement. Edwards emphasizes, "The enslaved understood what money meant… they knew the value of their bodies because capital was held in their bodies" (04:04). This financial literacy was a cornerstone for their trust in the Freedmen's Bank as a vehicle for economic uplift.

Marketing Strategies and Paternalistic Approaches

To attract depositors, the bank ran advertisements in black newspapers that combined moral imperatives with financial incentives. Edwards notes, "The idea that you can save a penny or a nickel…and take that money and put it in a freedman's bank account" (08:00). These ads not only promoted saving but also subtly imposed a paternalistic view on African Americans' financial behaviors.

White Supremacy and Economic Violence

Reconstruction was marred by intense white resistance, including violence against African Americans asserting their newfound freedoms. Edwards describes, "African Americans exercising their own independence, especially financially, was a real threat" (09:20). Incidents like the harassment and vandalism of Freedmen's Bank branches exemplified the economic violence inflicted to undermine black economic progress.

Shift from Savings to Commercial Banking and Mismanagement

Initially a low-risk savings institution, the bank's trajectory changed under the influence of trustees like Henry Cook. Edwards explains, "Cook... convinced them to support a bill… to transition from being just a simple savings bank to essentially a commercial bank" (14:16). This shift led to substantial loans directed predominantly at white businessmen, deviating from the bank's original mission.

Collapse of the Freedmen's Bank

By March 1870, the bank held approximately $12 million in deposits. However, mismanagement and risky loans led to financial instability. Frederick Douglass, a prominent African American leader, assumed the presidency in 1874 and swiftly realized the extent of the bank's insolvency. Douglass lamented, "Bad loans and bad management have been the death of it" (28:10), highlighting the betrayal of the bank's patrons.

Congressional Investigations and Lack of Accountability

In 1879, Senator Blanche K. Bruce led investigations revealing the bank's failings. Edwards notes, "None of the administrators who were culpable for the bank's failure were brought on criminal charges" (36:04). The testimonies exposed the deliberate mismanagement by white trustees, but justice remained elusive.

Long-Term Impact and the Racial Wealth Gap

The bank's collapse had profound ramifications, with African American depositors recovering only about 48-49% of their funds by 1900. Edwards asserts, "If something like this were to happen today… nowhere near the full amount" (38:54). She connects this historical injustice to the ongoing racial wealth gap, advocating for reparations and systemic financial reforms to address accumulated disparities.

Conclusion: A Legacy of Economic Betrayal

Savings and Trust by Justine Hill Edwards illuminates the Freedmen's Savings and Trust Company's tragic downfall and its enduring impact on African American economic stability. The podcast underscores the importance of recognizing historical financial exploitation as a foundational element of present-day economic inequalities.

Notable Quotes:

"They wanted the opportunity to buy land… to create a piece of the American dream for themselves." — Justine Hill Edwards (02:09)
"The enslaved understood what money meant… they knew the value of their bodies because capital was held in their bodies." — Justine Hill Edwards (04:04)
"Bad loans and bad management have been the death of it." — Frederick Douglass (28:10)
"If something like this were to happen today… nowhere near the full amount." — Justine Hill Edwards (38:54)

This comprehensive discussion provides listeners with a nuanced understanding of the Freedmen's Bank's historical significance and its lasting effects on economic disparities in America.

Loading summary...

Transcript

Sponsor Announcer (0:00)

Support for this podcast and the following message come from Humana. Employees are the heartbeat of your business. That's why Humana offers group dental, vision, life and disability plans designed to protect them. Exceptional service, broad networks and modern benefits. That's the power of human care.

Tanya Moseley (0:19)

This is FRESH AIR. I'm Tanya Moseley. In July of 1874, waves of black Americans rushed to their local bank branches to find out if the news they were hearing was true. The Friedman Savings and Trust Company, a bank for newly emancipated black Americans, was abruptly shutting down, and patrons at bank branches throughout the country were met with locked doors and cashiers who had to break the news. Most of their savings were gone. The rise and fall of the Freedmen Savings and Trust Company is the subject of a new book by my guest historian Justine Hill Edwards. And the years after the Civil War, tens of thousands of formerly enslaved people deposited millions into the Freedmen's bank with high hopes that as free people, they too could create a piece of the American dream for themselves. Abolitionist Frederick Douglass even encouraged black Americans to trust the banking system, but even his leadership as the president before its collapse could not save it. Hill Edwards book documents how the bank's white trustees drove the bank to the ground by lending out millions in loans to white finance financiers and businessmen. Justine Hill Edwards is a historian and associate professor of history at the University of Virginia. Her research explores the intersection of African American history, the history of slavery and the history of American capitalism. Her book is called Savings and Trust. Justine Hill Edwards, welcome to FRESH air.

Justine Hill Edwards (1:49)

Thank you so much for having me. Tonya.

Tanya Moseley (1:51)

The Freedmen's Bank. Let's get into how it was established. So white abolitionists established it in 1865. Take us back to that time period. Who were these abolitionists and why was a bank for newly freed black people a priority?

Justine Hill Edwards (2:09)

So the Freedmen's bank was established by, well, it was really the brainchild of a white abolitionist minister named John Alvord. He was from Connecticut and he lived in New Jersey during the Civil war. And in 1864, he was traveling with the Union army in the south, especially in the summer and fall of that year following Union General William Sherman on his famed march to the sea from Atlanta to Savannah. And he took the opportunity to talk to recently freed African Americans. And what he found, what he gleaned from his conversations with them is that they wanted a few things during this new and ripe period of freedom. They wanted their families, because a lot of them had been torn away from their families during slavery. But they also wanted the opportunity to live independently. And importantly, they wanted the opportunity to buy land. And so he figured that he could really contribute to their experience. He could help them in this, again, new period of freedom by establishing a bank for them. And so he gathers in new york in January of 1865 with a group of about 50 white prominent abolitionists, Philanthropists, bankers, and politicians. And they came up with the idea for the freedmen savings and trust company.

D (42:51)

If you, too, have been intensely concentrating on the presidential election, you may be ready for a shift of focus. Vanishing Treasures, an extraordinary book by Katherine Rundle, originally published under the title the Golden Mole in the uk, lifts readers out of the here and now and invites us to train our eyes on wider horizons. Rundle is a publishing phenom. Her 2013 middle grade children's book Rooftoppers drew inspiration from her own adventures as an undergraduate at Oxford, where she climbed brick walls and scale drain pipes to take in the views of that city of dreaming spires from on high. More recently, Rundell has written an acclaimed biography of the metaphysical poet John Douglas sun, as well as a best selling fantasy novel called Impossible Creatures. In short, Rundle is something of a Renaissance woman who writes with the elegance and erudition that distinguish that era. This book is a bestiary, a collection of creatures both odd and mundane, all of whom are more astonishing than you might expect, all of whom, as Rundel tells us, are endangered or contain a subspec that is endangered because there is almost no creature on the planet now for which that is not the case. Rundle begins her book with an epigraph from an author whose reputation is itself approaching extinction, the British essayist and mystery writer G.K. chesterton. The world will never starve for want of wonders, Chesterton says, but only for want of wonder. What follows are 23 very short essays on creatures ranging from the wombat to the spider, the raccoon to the tuna. For anyone whose capacity for wonder could use a jumpstart, Rundle's essays are essential reading. Listen, for instance, to these sentences from the opening paragraph of her essay on the swift, a common creature so named because it's the fastest bird in flight. The swift, Rundle says, is sky suited like no other bird, weighing less than a hen's egg, with wings like a scythe and a tail like a fork. It eats and sleeps on the wing. Swifts mate in brief mid sky collisions, the only birds to do so and to wash. They hunt down clouds and fly through gentle rain slowly, wings outstretched. As you can hear, Rundle's essays are no mere Wikipedia entries about the natural world. Rather, they're deeply felt, lyrical, often witty, and occasionally grisly evocations of the living marvels she's surveying. Her essay on the hermit crab, for instance, begins with a joke. It was perhaps a hermit crab that ate Amelia Earhart, Rundle goes on to explain. It seems that the uninhabited island in the western Pacific where Earhart's plane may have gone down, and where 13 but only 13 human bones were discovered that matched Earhart's size is to this day also home to a colony of coconut hermit crabs, the world's largest hand crab. The oldest crabs, Rundle adds, live to more than a hundred and grow to be up to 40 inches across, too large to fit in a bathtub, exactly the right size for a nightmare. The interconnectedness, both savage and beautiful, of the animal and human world is the message thrumming through these essays, Earhart's possible fate notwithstanding. It's, of course non human creatures who suffer most from their contact with us. The greatest lie that humans ever told, Rundle says, is that the earth is ours and at our disposal. We must cease from telling that lie because the world is so rare and so wildly fine. Vanishing Treasures makes readers see, really see some of the miraculous creatures we still share this fragile world with. Like any wise environmentalist, Rundle also leavens terror with possibility. I leave you, then, with Rundle's tribute to the Greenland shark, the planet's oldest vertebrae, an animal who can live over 500 years, Rundle says, I find the very idea of them hopeful. They will see us pass through whichever spinning chaos we may currently be living through, and they will live through the currently unimagined things that will come after that the transformations, revelations, the possible liberation that is their beauty. And it's breathtaking. They go on. These slow, odorous, half blind creatures are perhaps the closest thing to eternal this planet has to offer.