Loading summary
Transcript120 lines
- [00:00]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University. Interested in a quality online education? Capella is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more at capella. Edu.
- [00:17]
David Biancolli
This is FRESH air. I'm David Biancooli. John Le Carre wrote spy novels that transcended the genre. Philip Roth called Le Carre's 1986 novel a perfect spy, the best English novel since the war. The author's most beloved character was George Smiley, the physically unassuming but brilliant British spymaster. He was the protagonist of many Le Carre novels, including Tinker Tailor, Soldier Spy and Smiley's People, both of which were adapted into hit TV miniseries starring Alec Guinness as George Smiley. Le Carre, whose real name was David Cornwell, died in 2020. But George Smiley returned last year in the novel called Carla's Choice. It was written by Cornwell's son Nick, who goes by his own pen name, Nick Harkaway. Harkaway spoke with FRESH air's Sam Brigger last year. Here's Sam.
- [01:15]
Sam Brigger
Carla's Choice takes place in 1963 between Le Carre's novels the Spy who Came in from the Cold and Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. Smiley has retired from the circus, the nickname for the British overseas intelligence agency, after an agent and his lover were killed in East Berlin, their lives sacrificed for the success of a mission, a decision Smiley initially agreed to but has come to regret. But Smiley is called back into service by his boss, known as Control, to conduct one simple interview. However, that leads to much more than he bargained for. The story also serves as the origin story of Smiley's nemesis in the kgb, known only as Carla. This is Nick Harkaway's first George Smiley novel, but his eighth overall. They include Tiger Man, Gnomon and Titanium Noir. So, Nick Harkaway, welcome to FRESH air.
- [02:05]
Nick Harkaway
Hello.
- [02:06]
Sam Brigger
Tell me, how did you decide to write a George Smiley novel, and why now?
- [02:10]
Nick Harkaway
I actually decided not to. We had this conversation running inside the family because when we inherited the estate, the literary estate, we inherited an obligation to try to keep the books read, to keep the name alive, but more than anything else, to keep the books in circulation and so on. And in this moment, the way that you do that is by focusing attention on them through adaptations, through new material, through essentially commercial projects. So the conversation we were having was, what can we do to put the books back in everybody's mind? How do we fulfill this obligation? And the obvious thing is you need a new book. So I had a list in my Head or of people who would be amazing at writing a new George Smiley novel. And I had decided I wasn't going to suggest I should do it. I had firm reasons why I wouldn't. And we were having the meeting and my brother Simon said, so before we get started, there's a really, it's quite a compelling logic that it should be you. And I was like, yeah, I know. And he said, no, but I mean, I'm asking you, will you do it? And in that moment, all the reasons why I wouldn't. It's incredibly challenging. It's this extraordinary piece of 20th century literary history. It's this, it's that all these things became the reasons why I would.
- [03:39]
Sam Brigger
It must have been a pretty daunting task though, when you decided to go ahead to actually start writing this book.
- [03:45]
Nick Harkaway
Oh, yeah. And I mean, not past tense either. It's still daunting. It's still. And it'll be daunting after the book comes out. It'll probably be daunting for the rest of my life. Yeah, no, it's huge. But it's also. But again, that's why, you know, that's why it's worth doing. You don't do things that are safe, you do things that are scary. And when I started doing it, yes, it was terrifying, but it also became something that I loved.
- [04:08]
Sam Brigger
What were some of the things in your head that you thought about that sort of overrode the anxiety or fear about writing this that you were really excited to try to do in the novel?
- [04:19]
Nick Harkaway
I mean, so nonspecific things. I wanted a literary apprenticeship with my dad because I watched him write. I learned writing from him by osmosis. But we never really talked about writing very much. And so the idea of sitting down and holding the controls of the machine and operating it the way he did and working with those characters was a way to learn, which I wanted.
- [04:46]
Sam Brigger
Let's talk a little bit about George Smiley. He's physically unremarkable. He's this pudgy middle aged guy who you'd likely forget. What if you saw him in a crowd? And that's in part intentional. One character, when first meeting him, thinks he has more like the personality of a green grocer rather than a spymaster and not how she would imagine what a spy was like. And you write, he has a wit so dry that many people miss it and mistake it for dullness. So why do you think your father originally wrote the character like that?
- [05:23]
Nick Harkaway
I think he wanted. I mean, I think first of all, it was because he wanted to say that the spy world is not the world of James Bond, the one that.
- [05:32]
Sam Brigger
He knew, which was, it was almost an antidote to the James Bond novels originally.
- [05:36]
Nick Harkaway
And, you know, in the uk you had James Bond, you had Bulldog Drummond, you had these very, you know, very much action hero type spy stories. And his experience was not that. It wasn't these sort of incredibly energetic, combat orientated people, you know, sort of flawless heroes. It was ordinary people doing a hard, endless, possibly slightly futile thing and banging up against their own flaws. And he wanted, you know, to show the humanity. Showing the humanity so that you can understand it and feel compassionate about it is a big part of everything he wrote. So I think that's where it is. And Smiley is in many ways the epitome of that. He's just this guy. And yet at the same time, of course, he's this tremendously intelligent reasoner and he's empathic and he understands people before they understand themselves.
- [06:35]
Sam Brigger
I'd like you to just read a little bit from the book. This is as Smiley is going back to the circus for the first time. He's been asked to come back after he's retired and he's been enjoying his life. He's been spending time with his wife. He hasn't really been thinking about espionage. He's experiencing joy in a way that he hasn't in a very long time. But now he has to return to the circus, which is the nickname for the intelligence agency, and he has to go through this transformation in order to become a spy again. And I asked you to shorten the excerpt, but if you could please read it for us, that'd be great.
- [07:15]
Nick Harkaway
For Smiley, the experience of returning to the circus that evening was like a willed drowning. It was as if, as he climbed St Martin's Lane in the direction of his old office, he were making his way down onto the plain of an abyssal sea. For the last months, he had lived in a daylight world, had espoused its meanings and attitudes, and enjoyed the simple pleasures of other men. Now, as he approached the familiar door, he found that he was once again engaging in the exercise of paranoia which had governed his former life. Deliberately, he let the nature and movements of his fellow pedestrians function as a random factor in his own movements, making up ridiculous rules as he went along. The notion of constant danger was a madness that men in his profession must both inhabit and put aside. And the truth was more complex, that the world could change in an instant from clear and kind to desperate and cold. And the Trick to survival lay in knowing that instant before it happened and not when. This was a skill he had once possessed, but could not guarantee until he tested it again. By the time he reached the circus, he was, as he had been for the three preceding decades of his life, afraid.
- [08:30]
Sam Brigger
That's Nick Harkaway reading from his new book, Carla's Choice. So, Nick, tell us about that idea that you came up with, that in order to be a spy, you really must be afraid.
- [08:41]
Nick Harkaway
I think the job of the spy, in many ways, is to think the unthinkable, to ask yourself the questions which in normal life you would dismiss as absurd. I had some brief discussions. I did a consultancy gig here in the UK where people were asking me to look at what are the unseeable threats, what are the invisible ones? And it's very hard. You can't look at the back of your own head in the mirror. But a spy's job is to do that all the time, and to do it, if you're an operative in the field, to do it in the micro as well. To ask yourself whether the waiter is putting something in your drink, to question whether the person you see delivering the mail is actually a postman. And, I mean, we are, to a certain extent speaking of fantasy life, but hyper vigilance, that sense of looking at everything twice and seeing things out of place, the psychological trait that people develop who've been in traumatic situations for prolonged periods of time, I have absolutely no doubt that that is an aspect of being in the field in an espionage.
- [09:50]
Sam Brigger
Context, and this is in his own country. But you have characters that have to go behind the Iron Curtain, and they're their contingencies. They're worried, have I picked the right shoes? Are they scuffed enough? Are they going to look too new? Did I forget to put on the right watch? Did I just whistle a song that's going to betray my origins? You actually have a funny moment where a Soviet spy tells someone that he was trained at a facility that had a dozen different kinds of toilets. Because the one thing that would betray you the quickest would be if you didn't really understand how to use a bathroom that supposedly you'd lived with your entire life. So, first of all, was that something you came up with or had you heard that?
- [10:38]
Nick Harkaway
So I had, a long time ago, a conversation with a guy who identified himself as having been trained at a facility like that, which I thought was, I mean, the most extraordinary idea. But the logic is impeccable, right?
- [10:52]
Sam Brigger
Yeah. It makes sense if you don't know that the cold water is, say, switched in the sink, then that's going to give you up right away.
- [10:59]
Nick Harkaway
Yep. I mean, yes, so it would seem. Certainly someone in a training facility somewhere apparently believes that.
- [11:05]
Sam Brigger
Right. So, Nick, this could be considered a prequel to Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy, if you care to use that word. And one of the things that a prequel can do is kind of explain the background to behavior in the original book. And one of the things I really like about this book is that you. You rehabilitate the character of Anne, George, Smiley's wife, in your father's books. Anne is almost always off stage having very public and multiple affairs, being unfaithful to Smiley. And in fact, in Tinker Taylor, she's sort of a pawn in a huge betrayal of Smiley. And so when you read those books, like, it's hard not to think of Anne as a kind of villain. But you turned that on your head in this book.
- [11:55]
Nick Harkaway
Yeah, I mean, with Anne specifically, I wanted to do that. But in general, when I approached the characters and the story that I, you know, that I knew I was fitting into, one of the things I wanted was to have a situation where they would, on the one hand, kind of be illuminated by the story, but on the other hand, that would just leave you with more questions. And so when you learn things about the characters in Carla's Choice and you're going to see them again later in Tinker Taylor, if you go on and read Tinker Taylor and so on, what I want is for you to feel that you know them, but somehow that just makes them more mysterious. The more you learn about people, the less you know, the more there is to know. And so with Anne and with George, first of all, when I was talking to people about Anne and George's relationship, I asked a bunch of people who love my father's books, and I said, does Ann love George? And everybody said, yes. No one has any doubt that she loves him, and no one has any doubt that he loves her. So why doesn't it work? They have a relationship which by any measure ought to work, and yet it doesn't. It's fundamentally broken by the time you get to Tinker Taylor. And so I wanted to elucidate that. I wanted to, you know, to kind of say why that could be. How can that be? And then obviously, you know, the book ends where it does, and that leaves you with kind of. Yeah, but how come, you know, surely there must be something they can do.
- [13:20]
Sam Brigger
One of the things that I find so sad about Tinker tailor, soldier, spy, is that George spends the most amount of his time trying to figure out two people. Like, one is his nemesis, Carla, in the kgb, but the other is Ann, his wife, and they're both mysteries to him. That's not a positive view of marriage, I guess I would say, too.
- [13:45]
Nick Harkaway
No, it's not. Well, and I don't think it's a secret that my dad was abandoned by his mother at the age of five. And his relationships, you know, I mean, by the way, for good and sufficient reason, because his father was a monster, you know, so his relationships were shaped by that, as you would expect. I mean, and he was, you know, he was in a traumatic environment for an extraordinarily chunky part of his young life and eventually kind of ran away from school and ran away from the UK and found himself a place to exist in Bern and so on. But, you know, so, you know, without wishing to be kind of armchair psychologist about it, it's not hard to see why, you know, particularly in his earlier writing, the female characters tend to be absent and off stage or inaccessible, because that's what he knew.
- [14:32]
Sam Brigger
We'll talk about your dad's family life a little bit later, but before we get to that, how did you approach the language of this book? It seems to me that you're emulating your father's style of writing, which I think is quite different from your own instincts as a writer. Like, your father tended to write pretty straightforward, elegant, but simple sentences. And I think when I read your previous books, like, I feel like you tend to be playful in the structure of your sentences. Like, they. They're almost Victorian in their complexity. Sometimes I feel like I'm on a roller coaster and the pleasure is sort of watching the daring of the sentence and there's, like, humor almost embedded in the sentence structure. So how did you go about writing more in your father's style?
- [15:25]
Nick Harkaway
So lots to unpack there. First thing is, my father's style isn't constant across his writing. I mean, of course it's not because it's a huge career, but with the Smiley books particularly, you have the first three Call for the Dead, Murder of Quality and Spy Coming from the Cold. And they are, as you describe, shorter sentences, quite declarative, they're almost noirish, they have quite simple plot lines, and they obey this dictum that he had that he liked to trot out from civil service telegrams and civil service reports. 400 words, no adjectives. They're very clear and stark. And then by the time you get to Tinker Taylor, you've had a couple of books in between. You have a different ethos at work. The language is much more roving, much more illusory. The book is more complex, the structures are more complex and it's more poetic. So that's the first thing is that there's a lot, there's a lot going on. And then his language changes again in the post Cold War novels. There's a whole other thing going on there. So that's number one. Second thing is, yes, my writing in my books does tend to be denser, playful and so on. But part of that with my earlier books is an absolutely determined attempt to put some clear blue water between him and me. And the thing that I realized when I started talking about Carla's Choice because. And I would have been so great to have this thought before I wrote the book. Not because it would have changed anything, but because it would have made me feel much safer. I was born in 1972 and I grew up with my dad reading his work. New pages. He'd write in the early morning and then come to the breakfast table, read them across the table to my mother. Sometimes she'd type them up and then he'd be reading them again in the afternoon from the typescript or he'd be working on the typescript the following morning. And incidentally, I love this, they used to use scissors and a stapler that was cut and paste because we're pre digital word processors. But in the fundamental years where I was developing language at all, an hour, two hours of my day consisted of hearing the George Smiley novels being written. So when I came to write this and I thought, I gotta turn the dial a little bit towards dad. It was 1%, one notch. And suddenly it was there.
- [17:52]
Sam Brigger
Really, it was that easy to come to.
- [17:54]
Nick Harkaway
It was so simple.
- [17:56]
Sam Brigger
So Nick, you grew up really during the height of your father's career. When his books came out, it was an event like everyone read his books. I remember them sitting on my parents bed, bedside table. And your father was one of the most famous, if not the most famous writers of his time. He was a celebrity as a writer, but he was also considered a serious novelist. What was it like to be his son at that time? Like, what was your home like?
- [18:28]
Nick Harkaway
So the first thing I should say is that it's unknowable for me in a way because I don't know what it was like to be anybody else's kid. And for most of my life I have imagined that because my mother made a huge effort to keep our lives somewhat down to earth in various ways and was very successful in that my life was sort of mostly like everybody else's, but not in certain very specific ways. And the more I look at it now from a distance, the more I realize that's nonsense on an epic scale. My life was very odd by any reasonable standard. I mean, so how did it actually how did it work? I mean, we've talked about him reading across the table to my mom and so on. So, you know, and that's you know, that's not something most people experience and certainly it's not something most people experience with kind of genre defining, historical period defining fiction. I remember on the one hand we lived when I was little, we lived on a house on the Cornish cliff. Our nearest neighbor was a mile away. I'm a Gen X kid. I spent my time walking up and down the coastal path with a dog, dog by myself at the age of six, you know, I was a little bit feral. I came back with mud on my face and, you know, and I dreamed Lord of the Rings dreams because I was reading Lord of the Rings well, a year later, you know, and I mean, I just thought I lived in Rivendell. And then every so often the house would fill up with people and those people would be in some way important that I didn't properly understand. And they would be publishers and they would be foreign correspondents and journalists and some of them would be politicians and some of them would have no defined profession. And they were fascinating.
- [20:15]
David Biancolli
We're listening to Sam Brigger's interview from last year with novelist Nick Harkaway about his book Carla's Choice. It's now out in paperback. Harkaway's novel takes place during the Cold War and follows the pursuits of spymaster George Smiley, a character created by Harkaway's father, John Le Carrey. More after a break. I'm David Biancooli, and this is FRESH air.
- [20:38]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from NPR sponsor Capella University. Sometimes it takes a different approach to pursue your goals. Capella is an online university accredited by the Higher Learning Commission. That means you can earn your degree from wherever you are and be confident your education is relevant, recognized and respected. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more about earning a relevant degree@capella.edu. this message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet terms apply. See capital1.combank for details. Capital1NA member FDIC. This message comes from Sports in America with David Green. The world of sports is filled with stories that go beyond the highlights of the game. Join former MORNING EDITION host David Green for Sports in America from WHYY and prx, a weekly show featuring in depth conversations with star athletes, coaches, parents and the millions of fans whose lives are touched by the game. Hear about the personal and transformative moments that make fans want to stand up and cheer each week on Sports in America With David Green. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
- [21:56]
David Biancolli
This is FRESH air. I'm TV critic David Bean Cooley. Let's get back to our interview with novelist Nick Harkaway. That's the pen name of Nick Cornwell, son of David Cornwell, better known by his pen name, John Le Carre. If all those aliases remind you of a good spy thriller, well, then I guess that's appropriate. John le Carre wrote spy novels considered great literary fiction. They often revolved around his most beloved character, British spymaster George Smiley. Le Carre died in 2020, but his son, Nick Harkaway, has written a novel featuring George Smiley called Carla's Choice. It takes place in the time period between two of his father's best known books, the Spy who Came in from the Cold and Tinker Taylor, Soldier Spy. This is Nick Harkaway's eighth novel. His books include the Gone Away World, Titanium Noir and Tiger Man. Sam Brigger spoke with Nick Harkaway last year.
- [22:56]
Sam Brigger
Why did you decide to use a pen name? I mean, I think you probably could have gotten away with being Nick Cornwell since you wouldn't have been associated with your father because, well, perhaps you would have been, but he was more known as a novelist, as John Le Carre.
- [23:10]
Nick Harkaway
Also, there's two reasons why, and the first one you just experienced, which is saying Nick Cornwell is quite difficult.
- [23:17]
Sam Brigger
It's just genuine Nick Harkaway is not.
- [23:21]
Nick Harkaway
Well, but you don't have to do the double C in the middle, right? The second thing is actually, I mean, you're right and you're wrong about whether I would have been associated with my dad. The name of David Cornwall was sufficiently well known, certainly within the industry, that it wouldn't have been a very big fig leaf. But also, when you go into any bookshop in London, look in the C section for Cornwall. You find Patricia Cornwall and Bernard Cornwall. And between them they have, I don't know, a hundred books or something more. And I was like, I'm gonna write one book and they're gonna put it right next to these and no one's ever gonna find it Never mind if they never look for it. Even if they look for it, they're never gonna see me. And I just thought, okay, I'm just gonna. I'm gonna have a pseudonym. And the other thing was, to be honest, I knew from my father's life that having a pseudonym is a really useful shield. If somebody wants to yell at Nick Hawkaway, they can really do it as much as they like. In the end, however much it upsets me, it doesn't get to me, you know? But when somebody comes for you in your real name, that's a different experience.
- [24:25]
Sam Brigger
Why Harkaway? Because it does kind of rhyme with Lucare, doesn't it?
- [24:28]
Nick Harkaway
I know. Isn't that weird? I did not notice that until much too late to change it. I think it's because I just. Again, like, osmotically, I believe that the rhythm of a pseudonym should have. The second part should have three syllables.
- [24:45]
Sam Brigger
Yeah.
- [24:46]
Nick Harkaway
You know the story about my dad choosing his own pseudonym that he was told he should have a good, solid, like, two monosyllables, good English name. And he was so irritated by this advice that he chose to make up a French name instead. So, anyway, yeah, so I. When I decided I wanted a name, I went to Brewer's Dictionary of Phrase and Fable, and I literally let it flop open and stuck pins in the words. And I had a list of 20 absolutely stupid names. Hawkaway was the last one.
- [25:14]
Sam Brigger
Can you give us another one?
- [25:15]
Nick Harkaway
Do you have your cantaloupe?
- [25:17]
Sam Brigger
Cantaloupe.
- [25:18]
Nick Harkaway
Thomas cantaloupe. Which would not have been good.
- [25:22]
Sam Brigger
No. So, Nick, your paternal grandfather Ronnie, known that he was a con man. He did time for fraud at one point. He was an arms dealer. Your father would have periods of life with him where they would be living the high life, and then other times when they had to hide from creditors. And your father seems to have wrestled with this relationship his whole life. Like my favorite chapter of his memoir, the Pigeon Tunnel, is all about his father. And his novel, A Perfect Spy, considered one of his best, is also a way where he's wrestling with his dad. He died when you were very young. Do you know if you ever met him?
- [26:09]
Nick Harkaway
I was in a room with him as a baby, and he immediately looked at me and said, there you are. You see my eyes? At which point my mother apparently kind of stepped between us and said, no, he does not. You know, Ronnie was a con man, and he did do prison time. He didn't do enough, you know? And my dad, although he talked about Ronnie and he didn't struggle with Ronnie. He was haunted by Ronnie. He was sort of onwardly terrorized by Ronnie. Ronnie was walking trauma with a shiny smile. And, you know, and the weird thing he had that thing that some really terrible people have where even the people he worst misused were pleased to see him when he turned up again, people he conned, people whose life savings he ruined would go to court to defend him would, you know, because he was charming and he made everybody feel good. But, you know, I have the privilege of having grown up with the funny Ronnie stories and not with Ronnie, but in my kind of adulthood as I look at my dad's life and my dad. And incidentally, you know, when we say they were hiding from the bailiffs and they were hiding from the law and so on, Ronnie was hiding from the law and his, his minor children were dragged along for the ride.
- [27:47]
Sam Brigger
And your dad was at times recruited to work for him?
- [27:52]
Nick Harkaway
Yeah. No, not just recruited. I mean, I think the reason that Ronnie wanted his children to counterfeit the manners of the aristocracy and the elite class in the UK at the time was because that was how you got a better class of mark.
- [28:06]
Sam Brigger
Oh, really? So that was just a further future crimes.
- [28:10]
Nick Harkaway
I'm sure he told himself or told them that he just wanted them to be better than him, but I have absolutely no doubt that he wanted them to be his doorways, his signers, his, you know, his access.
- [28:25]
David Biancolli
We're listening to the interview FRESH AIR's Sam Brigger recorded with Nick Harkaway last year. Harkaway's novel Carla's Choice is now out in paperback. It's a new story about George Smiley, the British spymaster made famous in the books written by Harkaway's father, John Leca. More after a break. This is FRESH AIR support for this.
- [28:47]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
Podcast and the following message come from Lisa Leesa mattresses are meticulously designed and assembled in the USA for exceptional quality. The entire lineup offers premium materials and full body support for restorative sleep. Leesa has been recognized as best hybrid mattress by New York Times wirecutter Leesa includes free shipping, easy returns and a 120 night sleep trial. Right now you can receive 25% off mattresses. Visit leesa.com and use promo code NPR for an extra $50 off. This message comes from the NPR Wine Club, a place to explore the exciting world of wine, including wines inspired by popular NPR shows like All Things Considered. Cabernet. Whether buying a few bottles or joining the club, all purchases help support NPR programming and fund quality reporting. Developed to connect people to their communities they live in. More@NPRWineClub.org podcast must be 21 or older to purchase this message comes from Grammarly. From emails to reports and project proposals, it's hard to meet the demands of today's competing priorities without some help. Grammarly is the essential AI communication assistant that boosts your productivity at work so you can get more of what you need done faster. Just a few clicks can tailor your tone and writing so you come across exactly as you intend to get time back to focus on your high impact work. Download Grammarly for free@Grammarly.com podcast that's Grammarly.com podcast.
- [30:21]
David Biancolli
This is FRESH AIR. Let's get back to our interview with novelist Nick Harkaway. His novel Carla's Choice is now out in paperback. It's set in the world of his father John Le Carre's spy books, centered around the beloved British spy George Smiley. Harkaway spoke with Sam Brigger last year.
- [30:40]
Sam Brigger
When we left off, we were talking about his father's childhood as the son of a con man. Let's listen to a clip where Le Carre is talking about his father from the 2023 documentary the Pigeon Tunnel by Errol Morris. The other voice you'll hear is Errol Morris.
- [30:59]
Nick Harkaway
My father was a confident trickster. Life was a stage where pretence was everything. Being off stage was boring and risk was attractive. But above all, what was attractive was the imprint of personality, of truth. We didn't speak of conviction. We didn't speak.
- [31:28]
Sam Brigger
So you felt like a dupe?
- [31:31]
Nick Harkaway
No, I joined. I joined. You polish your act, learn to tell funny stories, show off. You discover early that there is no center to a human being. I wasn't a dupe. I was invited to dupe other people.
- [31:53]
Sam Brigger
So that's John Le Carre from the documentary based on his memoir the Pigeon Tunnel. And Nick, you know, in the memoir, your father goes on to explain that learning how to be a liar, that watching his father's cons, he thinks that that set him up for his two main careers, being a spy and being a writer, because he says at one point, I'm a liar, born to lying, bred to it, trained to it by an industry that lies for a living, practiced in it as a novelist. I was wondering what you thought of that idea.
- [32:28]
Nick Harkaway
I think it's undeniable. And I think, incidentally, I would throw in the contemporary British public school system, which taught emotional deceit at a very high level. You know, he was shipped off to boarding school at 5. And I was talking to Someone who said, you, you know, in that situation you have to choose whether you love your family or you love the school. And it's just less painful to love the school, you know, and those institutions turned out, our colonial governors, our military commanders, you know, it was a machine for the creation of the British Empire. And that was what Ronnie wanted to participate in. And it's what he wanted his sons to become.
- [33:14]
Sam Brigger
And so do you see that that sort of extends to you that like your ability as a writer is due in part to like this lineage that goes back to your grandfather.
- [33:28]
Nick Harkaway
Yeah, because stories were the currency around our table when I was growing up. If I came home from school, I had a story, dad would have something to share. We'd swap stories as a way of getting to know each other. If I came back from when I was at university, when I came home, what's the best story you've got? Come on, let's have it. What's been fun, what's been interesting, what's been strange and vice versa. And we traded stories as emotional currency as a way of re establishing contact and closeness. And so in that situation, you learn to tell stories. And I've done it completely unconsciously with my own children. In fact. We play a game where everybody in the room comes up with an object or a thing or even just an idea, and you all say them out loud at the same time. And then people take turns knitting them together into a narrative that makes sense. It's a great car game for children. You can do it, unlike I Spy, you can do it indefinitely because it's attractive to children, it's attractive to adults.
- [34:25]
Sam Brigger
Would you practice those stories as a kid? Because if you knew you were going to have to tell a story, would you perform them in your mind to get them right?
- [34:32]
Nick Harkaway
No, no. You learn to do them first time. You learn effectively basic improv. And that also, by the way, is still part of the curriculum of the schools that I went to. You know, that just that kind of baseline ability to start from a question to which you don't know the answer and knit a response that's plausible. And when we had Boris Johnson as our Prime Minister, I was watching him do all the things I learned how to do. Just make up a plausible answer to a question you have no idea about.
- [35:07]
Sam Brigger
So you went to boarding school as well?
- [35:08]
Nick Harkaway
I did not go to boarding school. I went to a minor or mid grade UK London public school, but not a boarding school.
- [35:17]
Sam Brigger
But were you taught to lie there as well?
- [35:20]
Nick Harkaway
Oh yes, directly, Very, extremely, extremely elegantly. And openly. We had a moment where one of our teachers said, look, in five minutes, we're going to talk about the influence of Ludwig brand on T.S. eliot. And we all looked at each other in absolute horror. And he goes, no, there is no Ludwig Brand. But there will come a moment in your life, whether it's professional or whether it's academic or whatever, when you have to answer a question you don't know the answer to. And I will tell you right now, the best thing to do is say, I'm so sorry, I have absolutely no idea. But there are contexts where you cannot do that and you are not leaving this building unable to counterfeit an answer.
- [35:57]
Sam Brigger
Wow, that's remarkable.
- [35:59]
Nick Harkaway
Actually, incidentally, a really superb skill. Because also, the other thing it teaches you is how to spot when someone else is doing it.
- [36:06]
Sam Brigger
Well, because of their language, or are you looking for tells, or what are you doing?
- [36:10]
Nick Harkaway
Well, the first. So, I mean, the first thing that we were taught was you say, well, I think the really interesting thing about Brand is maybe not his direct influence on Eliot, but the discussion with Pound. And then you can talk about Pound and Elliot for as long as you want.
- [36:28]
Sam Brigger
You've gotten rid of the thing you don't know exactly.
- [36:31]
Nick Harkaway
But then you look back at your interlocutor and they say, of course they do, because they want to be polite and they want to be part of this interesting conversation. They say, well, yes, and of course, you know, Brand was also involved with, you know, with some of the other intellectuals in that circle, and interestingly, with a lot of visual artists, you know, and you bring up then whatever, you know, whatever visual artist you want to. And little by little, in the course of the conversation, you can get more information from them about Brand. And so by the end of the conversation, you can actually know enough to say something obvious, but nonetheless, which they will agree with because they've just told you, but overtly about Brand and Elliot, and then they think you're very clever.
- [37:08]
Sam Brigger
Well, now I'm just questioning this whole interview.
- [37:11]
Nick Harkaway
I haven't had the opportunity to do it.
- [37:15]
Sam Brigger
You know, getting back to your father's family. His mother ran away from the family, abandoning him at 5. Do you think that it was hard for your father to figure out how to be a parent himself because he had no good role models? I mean, it seems like he was a very loving dad, but, like, he had to sort of figure it out from scratch?
- [37:37]
Nick Harkaway
I think that's true. I mean, I think he had bizarrely good role models who were not his parents. He had teachers, he had aunts, he had his Irish grandmother. He had these kind of people who stepped into those roles. Half of them were kind of con artists and chauffeurs and dancing girls, but they, you know, but they did the job because it was there and they were decent people. Decent people, but crooks some of the time, you know, but not, you know, it's possible to be a crook and not be Ronnie Cornwall. But, yeah, he had to make it up. But then I think, I mean, I'm a parent now, and you always have.
- [38:14]
Sam Brigger
To make it up, you know, you said that your father was haunted by his father and he tried to figure out what to make of his father through his writing. And I was wondering that if, in some ways, if your father haunts you not as an unwanted spirit, but because you chose to become a writer, because he's such. He has such a presence as a novelist. Like when, when you're writing, do you sort of see him looking at your work over your shoulder?
- [38:45]
Nick Harkaway
I hoped in the kind of inevitable, kind of corny movie sequence way that when I wrote this book, I would sort of look up from my desk and see him sitting in the chair by the window, kind of, you know, maybe with a kind of Obi Wan Kenobi vibe. Like, remember the semicolon?
- [39:02]
Sam Brigger
He's a force ghost.
- [39:03]
Nick Harkaway
Exactly. And of course I didn't, and I'm not sure I even really hoped it. I just, you know, it just would have felt kind of movie appropriate. But what I got instead was the companionship of occupying the space that he occupied. The. The business of standing and holding the levers of the smiley machine and. And moving them around. And there is a kind of unity that I get from that, which is incredibly emotionally powerful. And some days it's actually kind of too emotionally powerful. You know, you have to kind of tamp it down. But I'm not haunted by him. I even in the most benign sense, I grieve occasionally. I mean, you know, that doesn't go away, it just gets manageable, you know. But I. When he died, I had this extraordinary moment because it was the deep days of COVID lockdowns in the uk and he was in a hospital we couldn't go into. He was allowed in because he was ultimately an end of life care. They would let one person in every day and there were only two people allowed to be on that list so they could alternate. And two of my three brothers then were in town, and one of them, Tim, who alas, is also now dead, had a more shaky relationship with him at the time. And I had to have this extraordinary sort of moment where one of us could go and, and see him and one of us couldn't. And I was like, well, okay, it's obviously you, because I really didn't have anything that I needed to say or that I needed him to say to me. We had no unfinished business. And I felt that Tim did. And he went in and they held hands. I don't know whether they even spoke really, but it mattered to Tim. It was important. And I hoped that the next day they would bend the rules for me because there was, you know, anything was possible in that moment, if you asked nicely enough because it was obvious what was happening. And then he died at sort of 9 o' clock that night. And obviously on the one hand, I wish I could have kind of said hi and bye one more time, however awful that would have been. But I also don't regret the decision for one second because there was nothing.
- [41:26]
Sam Brigger
Outstanding between us and your brother. Tim passed away a few years after that, didn't he?
- [41:35]
Nick Harkaway
Yeah, he died by ridiculous medical accident, I mean, not in a hospital situation. He had a pulmonary embolism, I think, and died on holiday. So you know that. Yeah, it was a rough few years.
- [41:56]
David Biancolli
Nick Harkaway speaking with Sam Brigger last year. Harkaway's novel Carla's Choice is a new story about George Smiley, the British spymaster made famous in the books written by Harkaway's father, John Le Carre. More after a break. This is FRESH air.
- [42:13]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
This message comes from NPR sponsor HBO Max presenting the Emmy Award winning Max original series hacks for your consideration, starring Jean Smart and Hannah Einbinder. The new season picks up with Deborah Vance's late night show finally in production and Ava Daniels stepping in as head writer. To Deborah's dismay. Don't miss the series Slate says has never been better, now streaming on HBO Max. This message comes from NPR sponsor Adobe introducing the all new Adobe Acrobat studio. Now with AI powered PDF spaces. Need to turn 100 pages of market research into 5 insights with the click templates for a sales proposal that'll close that deal or an AI specialist to tailor the tone of your market report. You can do all that with the all new Adobe Acrobat Studio. Learn more@adobe.com do that with Acrobat. This message is from Synchrony bank who can help you get your do Nothing savings to work hard with their high yield savings account. Put your lazy savings to work@synchrony.com NPR member FDIC.
- [43:20]
David Biancolli
This is FRESH AIR. Let's get back to our interview with novelist Nick Harkaway. His novel Carla's Choice is now out in paperback. It's set in the world of his father John le Carre's spy books centered around the beloved British spy George Smiley. Harkaway spoke with Sam Brigger last year.
- [43:39]
Sam Brigger
There was a collection of your father's letters came out a few years ago. It's called A Private Spy. And there's one letter to you in this book. And I was wondering if you would wouldn't mind if I read it.
- [43:53]
Nick Harkaway
Yeah. It's terrifying. I can't remember which one it is.
- [43:55]
Sam Brigger
Okay. Well, I don't think it doesn't read terrifying, but this was on the occasion of your 21st birthday. I don't know if in Britain turning 21 is a big a deal as it is in the United States, but.
- [44:11]
Nick Harkaway
It doesn't have any legal consequences anymore. But it's still symbolically a rite of.
- [44:16]
Sam Brigger
Passage in some ways. Okay. So here it goes. My dearest Nick, I have had this little candlestick in my workroom for the last 25 years, from the last years of my first marriage and all through my second till today. It acquired a corny but real symbolism for me. And in bad times, I would shove a candle into it and light it as some kind of affirmation of belief in myself, my talent, my survival. For this reason, I wish you to have it now with my love as an antidote to occasional despair. I hope it will remind you that you are a good man when you need reminding and your own man and no one else's, and that you have one life only and no candle ever got longer, and that you have a great spirit and a lot to do with all my love, David. So that's a lovely letter. Do you still have that candlestick?
- [45:07]
Nick Harkaway
I do. Of course I do. Yeah. No, absolutely. And I have it. And normally actually at the moment it's in a cupboard because I need to give it a proper clean. But normally it's sits on a little campaign table that he had, which he occasionally used for writing, although it's not very practical, which he gave me a couple of years before he died. So I have the two of them together.
- [45:30]
Sam Brigger
You know, it's a lovely letter and it's a very thoughtful gift. Were you able to appreciate it at the time you were 21, or were you like, oh, thanks a lot of candlestick?
- [45:41]
Nick Harkaway
Oh, no, you know, I knew what I was being given. I mean, it's no, we you know, it's very. It's. It's very un British. But we did big gestures. We did. We did kind of emotional conversations. He. He would almost have you believe that we were all too buttoned up to do that. But. Except if you. If you read the books, you realize that, of course, you know, they are depictions of actually the Brits coming unbuttoned in all kinds of, you know, extraordinary ways. And. And he was very much that person. He was actually the most cosmopolitan soul. He was somebody who reached out looking for, as it were, Goethe's Germany or Red Vienna or, you know, the moments when anything is possible and people mix and great ideas are discovered or great poems are written, whatever. He went as a child and kind of constantly as an adult, he went looking for those places. And so, very appropriately, he's the least British Brit, despite being sort of iconically. And of course, he ended up Irish.
- [46:51]
Sam Brigger
Anyway, I saved the most important question for last, so I hope you're prepared for this.
- [46:58]
Nick Harkaway
I am.
- [46:58]
Sam Brigger
I am for a while. You had a job writing copy for a lingerie catalog.
- [47:07]
Nick Harkaway
Yes, briefly.
- [47:09]
Sam Brigger
So I just. Just was wondering what. What that was like, and I, you know, I. I assume that a lot of lingerie is purchased by men and not by women, you know, as gifts that perhaps women will appreciate, perhaps not. So I was wondering, like, when you're writing copy, were you writing from the perspective of a man or a woman or what. What were you doing?
- [47:29]
Nick Harkaway
First of all, I think. I think we need to loosen our sense of who wears the lingerie in the situation.
- [47:35]
Sam Brigger
Fair enough. Okay.
- [47:36]
Nick Harkaway
It's open season. Okay. Second of all. So this was a friend of mine, ran a boutique in North London, and she had this kind of wildly glamorous, goofy selection which was beloved of all kinds of people. And she said to me, will you. You know, we're doing the catalogue. Will you. Will you do text for the catalogue? And I said, sure. What do you want? And she had created this extraordinary character, Ms. Lala, who was the kind of muse of the boutique, and she wanted it all written in the voice of Ms. Lalla. And so it was less about describing the number of clips and buttons and how frightfully erotic the whole thing is, and more about expressing a kind of massive joy in the ridiculousness and the beauty and the preposterousness of the whole thing and doing a kind of Eartha Kitt as Catwoman kind of, you know, and it was huge fun. And it terrifies me that that biography is still out there in the world for you to find.
- [48:46]
Sam Brigger
Can you channel a little Ms. Lala for us?
- [48:50]
Nick Harkaway
I, you know, I honestly can't. I could. Let me see.
- [48:54]
Sam Brigger
Sounds like the J. Peterman catalog from Seinfeld.
- [48:57]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
Yeah.
- [48:57]
Nick Harkaway
Well, no, it was so. It was kind of. Oh, my darlings, you need to understand the sheer iridescent beauty of this piece. It's just it makes me feel so divine. And of course, except that it was quite fruity and I'm not sure what we're allowed to say, but you know very much. No, exactly. No. It was about the joy of being liberated into a world of passion. That was the brief. Well, we should all for the briefs.
- [49:26]
Sam Brigger
We should all hope for that. Well, Nick Harkaway, it's been a real pleasure to have you on the show and speak with you and I love the new book. Congratulations. Thank you for being here.
- [49:37]
Nick Harkaway
Thank you so much. It's a pleasure.
- [49:40]
David Biancolli
Nick Harkaway's novel Carla's Choice is now out in paperback. He spoke with FRESH air's Sam Brigger last year on Monday's show. Filmmaker Craig Brewer, the director behind Hustle and Flow, Footloose and Dolemite is. My name is back with a new film about a Milwaukee couple who turned their love of performing into a Neil diamond tribute band. It's called Song Sung Blue. Hope you can join us. FRESH air's executive producer is Danny Miller. Our technical director and engineer is Audrey Bentham with additional engineering support and by Joyce Lieberman, Julian Herzfeld and Deanna Martinez. Our interviews and reviews are produced and edited by Phyllis Myers, Ann Marie Baldonado, Lauren Krenzel, Teresa Madden, Monique Nazareth, Thea Chaloner, Susan Yakundi and Anna Bauman. Our digital media producer is Molly Seavey. Nesper Hope Wilson is our consulting visual producer for Terry Gross and Tanya Mosley. I'm David Biancooli.
- [50:45]
Sam Brigger
This is Ira Glass.
- [50:46]
Nick Harkaway
On this American Life, we tell stories.
- [50:48]
David Biancolli
About when things change, like for this guy David, whose entire life took a sharp, unexpected and very unpleasant turn. And it did take me a while.
- [50:56]
Nick Harkaway
To realize it's basically because the monkey pressed the button.
- [51:00]
David Biancolli
That's right, because the monkey pressed the button.
- [51:04]
Nick Harkaway
Surprising stories every week wherever you get your podcasts.
- [51:09]
NPR Sponsor Announcer
Still looking for the perfect holiday gift? The NPR shop is back with the logo tee you love the tiny desk hoodie you've been dreaming of. And new gear for everyone on your holiday gift list. Give the gift that supports independent journalism this holiday season. Shop now@shopnpr.org Evergreen trees are Pacific Northwest icons in journalism. An evergreen story isn't tied to one news cycle. It goes deep and helps you understand the world. The Evergreen is also a podcast from OPB about the Northwest. I'm Jen Chavez. Listen to the Evergreen podcast from OPB every Monday, part of the NPR Network.