Frugal Friends Podcast: "The Man Responsible For Why You're Broke"

Hosts: Jen Smith & Jill Sirianni
Release Date: February 24, 2026

Episode Overview

In this thought-provoking episode, Jen and Jill dive deep into the origins of modern consumerism, focusing on the life and influence of Edward Bernays—often dubbed "the father of public relations," whose pioneering psychology-based marketing tactics laid the groundwork for how and why we buy. The hosts break down four key ways Bernays’ ideas shaped our spending, relating them to present-day issues of overconsumption, shopping as identity, and the manipulation behind everyday decisions.

The conversation is lively, full of wit and relatable anecdotes, and reinforces the concept that much of our shopping behavior isn’t "all your fault"—but that awareness is essential to reclaiming your financial autonomy.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Who Was Edward Bernays? (06:46–11:23)

• Author of the 1928 book Propaganda.
• Nephew of Sigmund Freud, who blended Freudian psychology with mass communication to create deeply influential marketing tactics.
• Instrumental in crafting the fields of public relations and modern advertising.
• Helped corporations and politicians alike use psychological manipulation to "engineer consent."

Notable Quote:

"He made psychological manipulation look fun, cool, and interesting. Like it was good for people." (07:10, Jill)

Memorable Moment:
Bernays jokingly explains on Letterman that the title "Doctor" was more about perceived credibility due to honorary degrees (08:55).

1. Shopping as Identity: The 'Torches of Freedom' Campaign (11:44–20:34)

Story:

• In 1929, Bernays was hired by cigarette companies to make smoking acceptable for women.
• He orchestrated the “Torches of Freedom” campaign: women smoked in the New York City Easter parade, linking cigarettes to feminism, independence, and equality.
• The campaign reframed smoking as an act of empowerment; buying (and using) products became a way to perform—and purchase—identity.

Current Relevance:

• Products and brands still market identity and aspiration (e.g., Patagonia = outdoor lifestyle, environmentalism).
• Social status, belonging, and virtue are often attached to purchases and brands.

Hosts’ Reflection:

"You cannot buy identity. You cannot buy your way to a cause or to solving a problem... But if you can attach [a product] to the idea of hope in achieving that identity... that's where the marketing is." (15:23, Jen)

Memorable Quote:

"Awareness reduces effectiveness [of influence]." (28:39, Jen quoting Bernays)

2. Shopping for Leisure & Boredom (23:53–29:07)

Evolution:

• Before Bernays, shopping was functional and frugality was valued.
• After Bernays, department stores and brands repackaged shopping as a leisure activity. He turned stores into social centers, especially targeting women.
• Browsing and buying became interactive, community-driven pastimes—the start of “retail therapy.”

Modern Examples:

• Target runs “just for fun,” Amazon scrolling, TikTok/Instagram hauls.
• Overconsumption disguised as entertainment and emotional fulfillment.

Hosts’ Reflection:

"He programmed our minds to think—‘I want to do something with my friends, let's go shopping.’ He took that organic desire for community and attached it to consumption." (26:03, Jen)

3. Shopping as Patriotism & Economic Duty (29:29–34:44)

Overview:

• Bernays promoted mass consumption as critical for democracy and the nation’s prosperity.
• Shopping became synonymous with supporting the economy, jobs, and progress—a “moral duty.”
• Frugality was reframed as unpatriotic or even unhelpful to societal good.
• Guilt became intertwined with not spending, particularly at the expense of "supporting small businesses" or "stimulating the economy."

Recent Example:

“We saw this as recently as 2020–2021: ‘We need you to stimulate the economy.’” (32:57, Jen)

Insightful Discussion:

• The pressure to keep up with economic trends (like AI) and consumption "for the greater good" persists today.

4. Manipulating Health Habits: The Bacon & Eggs Breakfast (34:45–41:11)

Story:

• Bernays was hired by the bacon industry to boost bacon sales.
• Used a "study" (by polling 5,000 doctors via his agency) that advocated for larger, hearty breakfasts—implying (but never proving) that bacon and eggs were ideal.
• Spun this into press coverage: "4,500 physicians urge Americans to eat heavy breakfast."
• Manipulated consumer habits with expert-backed but misleading health narratives.

Modern Connection:

• Similar tactics used in today's supplement and food industries.
• Hosts caution against trusting industry-funded research at face value.

Quote:

"We cannot necessarily trust a study or the results... if we don’t know the full scope of the study and who did it, and who hired them to do it." (40:27, Jill)

Important Quotes & Moments

• “We are governed, our minds are molded, our tastes formed, our ideas suggested, largely by men we have never heard of.” —Edward Bernays, quoted by Jen (42:17)
• “Awareness reduces effectiveness [of influence].” (28:39, Jen quoting Bernays)
• "If you don’t buy your identity, then you’re kind of a social pariah." (18:48, Jen)
• "He took that organic desire for community... and attached it to something quasi-desirable—consume, consume, consume." (26:03, Jen)
• "It takes a longer time for financial information to trickle down to women than it does to men, historically, statistically." (51:36, Jen)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Edward Bernays Background: 06:46–11:23
• Shopping as Identity (‘Torches of Freedom’): 11:44–20:34
• Shopping for Leisure: 23:53–29:07
• Shopping as Patriotism/Duty: 29:29–34:44
• Bacon & Eggs for Breakfast Campaign: 34:45–41:11
• Awareness & Influence Reflection: 41:12–43:55
• Lightning Round (Personal Financial Influences): 47:24–52:21

Memorable Personal Stories

• Jen recounts running the Disneyland Half Marathon and using the Rally app to get supportive voice notes from listeners (03:27–05:09).
• Lightning Round: Both hosts name mentors and friends who shaped their positive financial habits, reflecting on the importance of community for breaking free from manipulative consumerist programming (47:24–52:21).

Final Takeaways

• Many spending and shopping behaviors are engineered by outside influences—awareness is key to regaining autonomy.
• Modern marketing techniques have roots in 20th-century propaganda and manipulation.
• Separating personal identity from purchases is an ongoing, intentional process.
• Be skeptical of industry-backed research and recognize when emotional needs are being exploited to boost consumption.
• Building a supportive, informed community (like Frugal Friends!) can help counter these influences.

Notable Resources Mentioned

• Edward Bernays’ book: Propaganda (1928)
• Frugal Friends’ book: Buy What You Love Without Going Broke
• Podcasts and personalities that positively influenced the hosts: Stacking Benjamins (Joe Saul-Sehy), ChooseFI (Brad Barrett), Paula Pant (Afford Anything)

Closing Thought

“Here’s to forming our own tastes and our own ideas. Become aware—so the effect of influence is less effective.” (43:31–43:55, Jill & Jen)

For more on this topic, or to join the growing Frugal Friends community, subscribe to their podcast, newsletter, or read their book!