The Doom Loop Keeping You Broke (feat. Arthur Brooks)

Summary

Podcast Summary: "The Doom Loop Keeping You Broke"

Podcast: George Kamel (Ramsey Network)
Guest: Dr. Arthur Brooks
Date: April 8, 2026

---

Overview

In this episode, George Kamel sits down with Dr. Arthur Brooks, Harvard professor, happiness expert, and bestselling author, to explore the relationship between money, addiction, and happiness. They break down why certain financial behaviors—like debt, gambling, and over-consumption—trap people in what Brooks calls "doom loops," leading to more misery rather than fulfillment. The conversation blends actionable advice, pop culture snark, and deep insights into male identity, societal vices, and the real roots of success and meaning in life.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Ubiquity and Danger of Addictive Behaviors

[02:18-05:12]

• Explosion of Betting and Gambling: Online betting platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket let people gamble on almost anything, which is highly addictive, especially for young men.

  • Arthur Brooks: “Gambling, like many other behaviors, stimulates the dopaminergic pathways in our brains, which means that we want, learn and like and turn into addicts.” [02:41]

• Addictions Target Young Men: Cannabis, pornography, and gambling are most heavily consumed by men aged 18-49, driven not by vice-seeking, but by a search for relief from anxiety and boredom.

• Society's Role: Legalization and ease of access (gambling apps, cannabis dispensaries, pornography) have made it easier for all, but especially young men, to become addicted.

• The "Doom Loop": Addictive behaviors offer temporary relief but create bigger, cyclical problems—escaping boredom or anxiety only leads to more of it.

  “That’s the way addictive things always work. That’s called the doom loop.”
  – Arthur Brooks [05:21]

Money, Stress, and Happiness

[08:40-13:48]

• Money Reduces Stress—To a Point: Research shows that as income rises, stress goes down until a “sweet spot” (~$250k/year average), then starts to rise again.

  • Arthur Brooks: “Your stress goes down as your money goes up until you get to a particular point...then it starts to come back up again.” [09:04]
  • Overconsumption and “trophy” purchases (big houses, many cars) add cognitive and emotional load.

• Minimalism and Sufficiency: Both Brooks and his wife choose to live on a small portion of their income, reducing debt and keeping “stuff” to a minimum.

  • “I determined a long time ago that I feel worse when I have more stuff.” – Arthur Brooks [12:00]

• Behavioral Economics: The mental and emotional benefits of being debt-free often outweigh potential investment gains from arbitraging low-interest debt for higher returns.

  “I am much happier when I have zero debt. ... I suffered through years of a doctorate to learn about how the spread works, and still I don’t have a spread because I want to be happy.”
  – Arthur Brooks [20:48]

The Ranking of Debt – From Most to Least Harmful

[16:17-19:45]

• Consumer Debt: The worst—spending money on things that are consumed and gone (e.g., gifts, vacations on credit cards).
• Car Debt: Also highly negative; huge monthly payments (trucks over $1,000/month) hurt financial and emotional well-being.
• Student Loan Debt: Especially damaging when there’s debt but no degree; the U.S. has "sold a bill of goods" around the value of expensive colleges.
  • “You can get a garbage education at Princeton if you’re a bad student...the most cost-effective way is community college to a flagship school.” – Brooks [18:40]
• Mortgage Debt: The least harmful since it builds equity, but ideally should be paid off before retirement.

Meaning, Values, and Financial Choices

[22:43-26:19]

• Buying "Meaning": People lacking a sense of life’s meaning often try to fill the void through “trophy” or "flex" purchases.

• Male Identity and Fatherhood: Brooks stresses a father’s role in a son’s success is to love/adore the boy’s mother; for mothers, it’s to admire the father, even if imperfect.

  • “Love his mom. Adore his mom. Well, what if I don’t adore her? I don’t care. I don’t care.” – Arthur Brooks [24:46]

• Being Admirable: True admirability comes from character—not material success, debt, or flaunting status.

  “To be admirable is not to have the biggest possible truck and to be in unbelievable amounts of debt and running around behind your wife’s back. That’s not admirable. That's animal impulse, not moral aspiration.”
  – Arthur Brooks [26:03]

Chasing Wealth vs. Chasing Fulfillment

[26:19-29:21]

• Proxy Goals and the Millionaire Mindset: Many young men confuse achieving wealth with achieving character or admiration.

  • “The impulse is to be admirable. The problem is that it’s the wrong goal.” – Brooks [26:19]
  • “You follow the wrong star and it’s sitting over the ocean.” – Brooks [27:48]

• Beware of "Never Enough": Even billionaires chase ever-larger numbers—a fruitless game.

• True Goals: Focus on becoming the person you admire, not just hitting bank account milestones.

  “Focus on the person that you want to be and then the proxy goals will come into view and they won’t be so...both elusive and ultimately false.”
  – Arthur Brooks [29:17]

---

Memorable Quotes & Notable Moments

• On The Root of the Problem:
  “Addictive behavior is disproportionately concentrated among young men. And so when you make it more common...the part of the population that's most at risk is always gonna be young men.” – Arthur Brooks [04:08]
• On Financial Minimalism:
  “Owning stuff is costly, man. Owning stuff is costly.” – Brooks [11:16]
• On Happiness and Debt:
  “Arbitrage is not a path to happiness.” – Brooks [21:32]
• On Meaning in Life:
  “When people have a sense of the meaning of their lives, then they use [money] to accentuate the sources of real meaning.” – Brooks [22:47]
• Speed Round Reflections:
  • “People will be the happiest in 2026 if they focus on love instead of money.” [31:07]
  • “The biggest lie about success is success is something that you can ultimately achieve; rather, it’s something you can approach and make progress toward love.” [31:14]
  • “The meaning of life is to love and be loved.” [31:43]

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [02:18] — Explosion of online gambling and addictive vices
• [05:21] — Concept of the "doom loop"
• [08:40] — Money reducing stress (until the “sweet spot”)
• [16:17] — Debt power ranking (worst to least harmful)
• [20:48] — Paying off mortgage vs. investment “arbitrage”
• [22:43] — How (lack of) meaning drives unhealthy purchases
• [24:46] — Role of family and fatherhood in male success
• [26:19] — Chasing wealth vs. chasing character
• [31:07-31:43] — Speed round (Arthur Brooks’s reflections on meaning and happiness)

---

Tone and Style

The episode stays witty, conversational, and lightly irreverent, mixing research-backed advice with pop culture analogies and personal anecdotes. George Kamel’s questions keep the discussion practical, while Dr. Brooks blends academic knowledge with relatable stories and humor.

---

Key Takeaways

• Addictive behaviors trap people in "doom loops"—quick fixes that worsen the underlying problem, especially among young men.
• Wealth brings freedom only up to a point; after that, overconsumption brings more stress.
• Debt hierarchy matters: avoid consumer and car debt; be prudent with student loans; treat mortgages as tools—not ATMs.
• Stable families, healthy relationships, and clear values support well-being and success far more than material trappings.
• True happiness and meaning come from love, character, and pursuing personal growth—not bank balances or stuff.

---

For more, check out Dr. Arthur Brooks’s new book, "The Meaning of Your Life," and previous episodes with George Kamel.

Transcript

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Anything in our society that relieves a problem in an artificial way, generally speaking, makes a bigger problem. The more junk that you buy to show to yourself that you're worth something, the worse off you're actually going to be. The future and the success of young men has to do with the father of the home. You know, people often ask, just tell me one thing that I can do that will give my son a higher likelihood of success. Here it is. Love his mom. Adore his mom. Well, what if I don't adore her? I don't care. I don't care. What does it mean to be admirable? To be admirable is not to have the biggest possible truck and to be in unbelievable amounts of debt and running around behind your wife's back, that's not admirable.

[George]

People will be the happiest in 2026 if they focus on you. Guys are going to love today's episode because I am joined by the one guy who can explain the relationship between money and happiness, and that is Harvard professor Dr. Arthur Brooks. He's a happiness expert, social scientist, bestselling author, and wonderful person. And you guys have loved the conversations I've had with him on this channel. So we brought him back once again. So let's get into the conversation, and as we do, hit the subscribe button so you don't miss more content. Hit the like button on this video because I know you're going to like it. And big shout out to Deleteme for sponsoring the channel. Arthur, thanks for coming back. You look even younger this time.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Really?

[George]

I. I don't know what you've been doing. It's working.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Something's wrong with your glasses.

[George]

It's all the filler.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

You know, I'm actually. I'm getting a little bit of work done. What do you think?

[George]

I can't tell. Whatever it is, it looks very natural.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Thank you. I'm thinking of a quick trip to Turkey to solve the problem up top. Honestly, no, they can do it. Here's the problem, though. If you have enough content on social media and suddenly you show up with hair, then it becomes a source of derision.

[George]

No one's fooled. It's just distracting to see the toupee.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. Then it becomes a. Then it becomes.

[George]

Even if it's glued to your head and it's your real follicles, it's still a tupe. It's a glorified tub. Arthur, I want to talk about this. I don't know if it's a trend, a craze A cancer on society. But the betting world has exploded. So it went from just like gambling and normal betting, you know, the Kentucky Derby, to sports betting. And now there's things like Kalshi and Polymarket. Have you seen these?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Of course.

[George]

I wanted to just pull up here, just today. Here's what's going on on Kalshi. The things that you can bet money on. Who will Trump nominate as fed chair? There's $178 million in the pool for that. Uh, let's see. When will Bitcoin hit 150,000? Before June 2026 or before May of 2026. $26 million in the pot for this. What has happened? Have we lost our minds?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

No, what has happened is that gambling, like many other behaviors, stimulates the dopaminergic pathways in our brains, which means that we want learn and like and turn into addicts. It's a very, very addictive thing. Gambling is an incredibly addictive thing. And if we make it more common, more ubiquitous, people are gonna do it more. And what happened is that we've liberalized laws such that people can gamble more easily on anything, and it's addictive. And so they do. It's the same thing as the fact that weed is legal in most states. And so you see cannabis dispensaries popping up all over major cities, and major cities smell like just a big cloud of weed. Well, what happened? How come everybody wants weed so much? Well, because people like to get high.

[George]

It's like going to get a cup of coffee.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, well, yeah, it's euphoric. It's something that people actually want, and their brains want it because they don't want to feel normal, and it became more available, and so they do more of it. That's all that is. That's all it is, is like, you know, the polymarket and Kelshi and DraftKings and the ubiquitousness of that across the Internet is just cannabis dispensaries.

[George]

But this one seems to have a chokehold, specifically on younger men. I know 18 men, 18 to 49. Half of them are sports betting.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, but who's also. Who's also visiting the cannabis dispensaries?

[George]

Those guys.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Young men, 18 to 49. That's what's going on. Because young men have brains on fire.

[George]

Are they just looking for a vice?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

They're not looking for a vice. They're looking for relief. They're looking for relief.

[George]

That's how they let off steam now.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, well, addictive behavior is disproportionately concentrated among young men. And so when you make it more common in any part of our society, pornography, which is extremely dangerous and incredibly addictive, who consumes it?

[George]

Young men.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, young men. Young men. 80% of men under 21 years old look at pornography every week is what we see. And that's because it's incredibly addictive and unbelievably ubiquitous and easy to find. And it's also arguably the most profitable part of the Internet. It's all of a piece with all this. And what we've done in our society is we've made it easier and easier and easier for people to get addicted. And the part of the population that's most at risk is always gonna be young men, which is one of the reasons that we're finding such a big crisis among young men. And so, you know, our leaders, which is the most amazing thing, they're like, ah, what do we do about the young men? I don't know. I know, let's have more cannabis dispensaries.

[George]

Easy.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Gambling and pornography. Ah, it got worse. That's weird.

[George]

And we let them get a thousand dollar truck payment.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I mean, all of it, it's all of a piece.

[George]

And then we wonder why everybody's miserable. Is this all part of it? Yeah, of course. Is this them trying to escape the misery or is this the root of the misery?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's both. Because that's the way addictive things always work. That's called the doom loop. With the doom loop.

[George]

Tell me about that.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So with the doom. I'll give an example. In the case of alcohol.

[George]

It sounds cool.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, doom loop is cool. It's like, that's sounds like a Lord

[George]

of the rings type thing.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

That's how I sell books.

[George]

Did you make up the doom loop?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I did, I did. It's like I'm the trademark.

[George]

Don't use it, guys.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's like Doom loop TM COPYRIGHT strike

[George]

on this video now.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So what happens? What most predicts alcohol abuse is sort of two things. Boredom and anxiety. So people who are really bored and people who are really anxious are people who tend to be most attracted to alcohol. And there's a reason for that. I mean, in the case of anxiety, for example, alcohol is incredibly effective at cutting the connection between the amygdala, which is the part of the limbic system that gives you fear and anger, that makes you experience fear and anger. And your prefrontal cortex, where you're able to assess that feeling. So you're super stressed out. But when you drink alcohol, you don't Know it. And that gives you instant relief, which is why if you're a really anxious person, two drinks makes you feel like a new man.

[George]

So it doesn't take it away. It just masks it.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It completely masks it. And very temporarily, because it comes rushing back. You'll get a rebound the next day, anxiety will be higher, which leads to escalation, and then you have more anxiety, so you drink more. And that's the doom loop. That's how people get stuck in that particular loop. This is, by the way, why I

[George]

gotta take the edge off the hangover with another drink the next day.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Or I just. Yeah, even it's not a hangover where I just feel, yeah, I'm really stressed out again. And that's why people drink every night. That's because they're stressed out from the night before, which is actually made worse by the fact that they drank alcohol

[George]

the night before, which becomes habitual.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. And their neurochemistry is upside down, et cetera.

[George]

At dinner, I get a glass of wine.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

And you escalate and you escalate and you escalate because your brain is like, oh, man, I got to put up some sort of a bulwark against this assault, these euphoric substances coming in, and then just to feel normal, et cetera. And so even if you're not an alcoholic per se, you can be functionally dependent on a substance because of this doom loop. And this happens a lot. And that's really bad for you. I mean, it's just like any euphoric substance, by the way, is neurotoxic. Which is not to say that you shouldn't ever have a drink, but you have to have your eyes open is what it comes down to. And anything in our society that relieves a problem in an artificial way, generally speaking, makes a bigger problem. And we do this all the time. And I'll give you a perfect example. I hate being bored. Everybody hates being bored. But you have to be bored. Our brain is built to be bored. Because when you think about nothing, you exercise a set of structures in the brain called the default mode network. That's where you're thinking about the future, where your mind wanders, where you're thinking about the meaning of your life, et cetera, et cetera. But it's boring. So I created, in my ingenuity, I, as in Homo sapiens, created an anti boredom device. Here's my anti boredom device. But what happens when you drive away the boredom is that you get more bored, is what happens from that. Because you get the same sort of doom.

[George]

Is it a doom loop?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's another doom loop.

[George]

Oh, my gosh. They're everywhere, guys.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

And anything that's actually addictive is actually creating a doom loop. And it's gonna get worse with escalating behavior and trouble escaping. And that's what we see. So we're relieving the problem and creating the problem simultaneously.

[George]

When with betting, you got. It's in the app. There's notifications, it's gamified. All your friends are on it. They're text. So this just adds to the doom totally.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

And if you're of the demographic that's most prone to addictive behavior, it's going to afflict you the worst.

[George]

So you talk a lot about how wealth is freedom, Freedom from avoidable unhappiness, freedom to take meaningful risks. At what point do you think wealth stops reducing stress and starts creating new anxieties?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So there's, of course, there's research on this. And what you're talking about is it

[George]

called mo money, mo problems because missed opportunity if they didn't.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Kind of. That's kind of what it's called. That's actually not the name of the paper. I mean, it's like, that would be a great title for an academic journal.

[George]

I would have read it, guys, if you just would name it something snappier.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

And so the way that people actually look at this typically is they'll look at a large sample of people across the income spectrum, and they ask them about their experience of stress and anxiety and negative affect, which is their experience of negative emotions over the course of the day. And then they look at how much money they have and how much money they're bringing in. And what they find is that your stress goes down as your money goes up until you get to a particular point, and then it's curvilinear. And then it starts to come back up again. And it's not that high. When it starts coming back up again, you tend to see that people start to stress out. The bottom point is like $250,000 a year and a lot of people. And again, this is average. $250,000 a year in New York City is different than it is in Franklin, Tennessee. It just is. Which maybe, folks, maybe you should move from New York to Franklin, Tennessee. Anyway, that's it. Yeah.

[George]

No state income tax.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Open for business. Right. Lots of open land. Anyway, so. And so that's on average. And your results may differ, but there's some point that's high but not insane. Where you get the sweet spot, and then it starts to come back up again. And generally speaking, the mo Money, mo problems, what that actually is, is you complicate your life because you have opportunities to consume more. And the more stuff that you consume, the more responsibilities that you take is, the more stuff you have to chase and pay attention to is what it comes down to. Many people who have a good amount of money, they live in a house that's bigger than they should be living in, and stuff is breaking, and, you know, they actually wind up. It's very interesting in these studies on how people live. If you have a really big house, you're probably going to use about the same amount of the house as the size of the apartment that you were in when you were 24. You're probably. You'd be using about 1,000 square feet of it for 90% of your time. And then you'll be like, I got four bedrooms down that hall that nobody's ever in. And you won't actually use it because you don't feel homey. It actually is uncomfortable for you to do that. But those extra four bedrooms and the three cars that you don't drive, that's a trophy. That actually requires cognitive energy, cognitive bandwidth, and that's costly, man. Owning stuff is costly.

[George]

Well, you get the boat. Well, now you need a marina. You got to pay the slip fee. You got to go to the boat. You got to haul the boat.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

There's a lot of people say that the happiest day of boat ownership is the day you sell it.

[George]

Amen.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah.

[George]

The day you buy and the day you sell it.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. Well, I mean, the day you buy it is great. The day you sell it is better.

[George]

Yeah. Are you a boat guy? Would you consider yourself.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

No, I'm not a boat guy.

[George]

Not a man of the water.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I'm not a stuffed guy. Oh, I'm not a stuffed guy.

[George]

I mean, it's like, you must have a thing, though. What is Arthur Brooks's thing that you're like, this is really where I think just. It's stupid. There's no reason for it. I just enjoy it. A consumable good that I got a consumable good. He's a watch man.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I have a nice watch. This is at Heuer Monaco.

[George]

Do you have a watch collection?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

No.

[George]

That is a beautiful watch.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I have one nice watch, and I wear it every day. Right. And I have. You know, I don't have. I have, like. I have five pairs of glasses, I guess. But the whole point is that I determined a long time ago that I feel worse when I have more stuff. No, I'm also.

[George]

Is there like a mental load, emotional weight in your life particularly?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, totally. For sure. And again, I have to live in the world and, you know, I'm married to a woman. And she's a normal woman, like a normal human woman. And she doesn't mind stuff right now. She was actually raised in poverty by a single mom. And the lights would shut off suddenly because they couldn't have enough money to pay the electric bill in a little tiny apartment in Barcelona. And the whole thing, it was tough. It was very, very tough. She got used to nice things. It's kind of amazing.

[George]

Well, I heard author Morgan Housel, which I'm sure, you know, he talked about this, that if you didn't have money growing up and there was scarcity, then when you do have money, it becomes this abundance where you want to have

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

a bunch of stuff. Yeah. Now she, on the other hand, is very healthy about it in a very normal way. So she's comfortable living sort of within her lifestyle. But never, never, never, never going into debt, never going beyond our means ever. You know. And so for the most of our marriage, we. Especially when there were good times economically, you know, by the time I was a chief executive of a company, for example, we were. The entire time I was a chief executive, we were living on less than half our income. And now we live on a quarter to a third is what it comes down to. And, you know, I mean, a lot of people could criticize us, saying it's like, why are you storing up money? Why are you building new barns? You know, it's like you fool said, you know, Jesus said in the parable, tonight I will take your life will be taken from you. But that's not the point. The whole point is that we don't wanna be heavy and my wife consumes in a normal way. I just tend to be kind of more of an austere guy.

[George]

Yeah, yeah.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Because I just don't like the stuff.

[George]

Our friend Rachel Cruz has this quote that I love. If nobody saw this purchase, would I still want it? So how do you delineate between buying something because you just want it, even if it feels like a flex versus I'm really doing this. Cause it's a trophy in my life I want other people to see.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, there's not that many trophies in my life is what it comes down to. I mean, at this point in my life, I'm very lucky because I fl 200,000 miles a year. So I'm on the road 48 weeks a year. I fly first class. And that costs? It doesn't actually. It's weird. When I was a kid it was super expensive and now it's not that much more expensive because it's not that nice.

[George]

You're not getting like a lay down bed and a five star meal.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I mean, the foot rubs are not as good as they used to be. You know, if you can walk, you

[George]

can hire me, your personal assistant on the road.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Who's this? That's George.

[George]

Yeah, he's my guy. You gotta have to have that.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

My masseuse, so.

[George]

So that's where you spend your money?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Well, I do it on stuff to where I'm actually more effective and I can get better rest and I'm a little bit more comfortable. But I'm not a big hotel guy. I'm a Courtyard Marriott guy.

[George]

Wow.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. Yeah, because I know actually how to do it. I'm a road warrior. I have protocols for everything.

[George]

But your points have racked up.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Oh, they like me.

[George]

You're a Diamond medallion Elite Platinum.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Hello, Professor Brooks. No, I mean, I'm still just.

[George]

They have your picture on the wall. That's so great. Bonus question for you. What's the best way to unlock up to $600 in annual savings on your phone bill? Answer. Switching to Boost Mobile, a sponsor of today's video. Now, you may be wondering, how could changing phone carriers save me that much? Well, Boost Mobile offers their unlimited plan for just 25 bucks a month. Forever. Which means if you're paying more than 25 bucks, you just save money by switching. So head on over to boostmobile.com Ramsey to start saving big today. What is your home address? Let me know in the comments. Oh, what? You don't want to do that? Well, of course you don't, but for some of you, it wouldn't matter anyways. It's already on the Internet budget, all right? You're already letting your personal info float around unchecked on these data broker sites. And that's why I recommend signing up for Deleteme, another sponsor of this video. Deleteme sifts through hundreds of these data broker sites to remove your personal info and make sure your digital footprint stays squeaky clean, saving you plenty of time and stress. Get 20% off an annual plan by going to JoinDeleteMe.com. george, how would you rank the different debts? Because we get calls on the show, and if it's credit card debt, that scares me. If it's Student loan debt. Still scary. And the number can be really high. So do you have like a power ranking?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

We do have a power ranking based on the research. Number one is consumer debt. When you're buying to consume and the consumption actually means the thing is gone, that's the worst. So don't put Christmas presents on your credit card. Don't put your vacation on your credit card. Don't do it. Because that thing is going to be over. Right. That's just the worst. It's really horrible for your happiness. Second is car debt. Car debt is really dumb. If you get. And there are a lot of people who. What's the average car debt in America today? I've heard you talk about this $900 or something.

[George]

The average payment is now 750 on a new car. And in the five hundreds. For a used car.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

For a used car. Okay. And for the average. I think I heard this. On the average payment for people who buy a truck.

[George]

Oh, it's over. Many are over $1,000.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

That's crazy.

[George]

Yeah.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Because I mean, that's crazy. Look, I'm not saying for money. I mean, that's bad enough. Cause I don't know anybody's financial situation personally. That's crazy. For happiness. That's bad for your happiness. And so those two. No. Right. Student debt. Most people have much more than they need. And the biggest problem is when you have student debt and no degree. And so there's a huge number of people running around the United States today that owe 25 or $30,000 or more and they have a year and a half of college. That's a problem. Because nobody's like, oh, yeah, no, that's Great. You got 18 months of college. You got three semesters. Yeah.

[George]

Which means you probably didn't get the career that would have paid you more.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's not an investment. Yeah. All it is is, you know, it's an investment that's a wash that flushed for you. And that's a big problem. So most people take out more than they need. And one of the reasons for this is that we've been sold a complete bill of goods in the United States today, which is that if college costs more, it's better. Now, I say this with appropriate humility. I'm a professor at Harvard University, which is not known for being cheap. Right.

[George]

Yeah.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's a great investment, to be sure, because it's a famous place. There's lots of places that cost just as much as Harvard that are 0% better than your local state university. And so the most cost effective way that you can go to college, by the way, starting at the community College, getting your AA for $3,500 a year or something like that, and then going on to the flagship school, having done the first two years at the community college, you'll get a great education, you'll get as good an education as you want. That's really the key. What's the best predictor of the quality of education is the motivation of the student. That's what it comes down to. If you're a non motivated student, what

[George]

are they wanting to take out?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, you can get a garbage education at Princeton. If you're a bad student, you're basically just trying to get through. But if you're a great student, you'll get a much better education at the University of Tennessee than at Princeton University, depending on the quality of the student. It's not the university that actually matters that much. And you'll come out with zero debt if you do it right, which is so smart. And then the kind of debt that leads to the least amount of unhappiness is mortgage debt. And again, part of the reason for that is because for most people owning a home is an investment and paying rent accrues no equity. So the debt per se is actually leading to some amount of equity.

[George]

You get the progress that we talked about with saving and investing.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Correct. But that actually goes down as you get older. And by the time you're my age, if you cannot have a mortgage, you shouldn't have a mortgage. I mean, if you're 60 years old and you keep. I mean, my parents, like a lot of people their generation, they use their house as an ATM machine. And so, you know, they probably owed $8,000 on their house and then mysteriously, 20 years later, they owed $250,000 on the house. What happened? And the answer is they were financing consumption like so many people of their generation.

[George]

Cash out, refinancing, take out a HELOC.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, completely.

[George]

Get another 30 year.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. Do it again and again and again and again and again. And by the time my parents pass, if they still had 25 years on their mortgage. And I get it, because that was a generational phenomenon, but we've learned our lesson and people shouldn't be doing that. So when you're 30 years old and you're buying a house, make sure there's a house that you can afford within the parameters that people learn about on your show and not taking out too much so that your house poor. And then make sure that you Actually pay it off such that by the time you're. When you're your age, great. When you're my age, not great to have a mortgage.

[George]

We talk about this a lot on this channel. I encourage people to pay off their mortgage early, regardless of the interest rate, and we get a lot of flack for this. I paid my house off early. It was a low rate. And people went, you're an idiot. You could have invested that money. You could have made a spread in the market. So coming from a much smarter person, what would you say to the person who wants to argue and go, well, if I have a 3% mortgage and I can make 8% in the market, it would be stupid to pay down my mortgage early?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I completely understand that. I'm trained as an economist. My background is as an economist. I can do all the numbers, just like anybody else can do all the numbers. But what I really care about is happiness and what it does to your psyche, what it actually does to your behavior, what it does to your peace. And the truth is that some people can, if they're very prudent and they're very serious about what they're actually doing, they can bear a prudent amount of risk such that they can actually manage that spread. But for me, personally, I am much happier when I have zero debt. I just am. You know, look, I mean, it's like I suffered through years of a doctorate to learn about how the spread works, and still I don't have a spread because I want to be happy and I want to be at peace. And so I have no doubt.

[George]

So can you confirm that arbitrage is not a path to happiness?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Arbitrage is not a path to happiness. Arbitrage works for some people as a strategy on the way toward, you know, making some part of their personal wealth. I don't want it. I don't want it because for me, it's not worth the trade off.

[George]

Case closed, guys.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Well, case closed for Arthur Brooks, you know, but, you know, and it's funny because, you know, I have a son. One of my sons lives in my house, so he doesn't have a mortgage. Another son with his wife and kids. So it's like, people don't have to feel bad for that. They should celebrate. And one of my sons lives up the street in Leesburg, Virginia, and he has a mortgage. But, you know, he has the circumstances to do it. He's a veteran, 25. He's 20. He's 25 years old. And, you know, he came out of the Marine corps with the GI bill and, you know, getting 0% or 0 down payment because that's what veterans get in Virginia and all this. It's unbelievable. And so it really, really works for him. As it turns out now he's in College at 25, and he's saving money because it actually worked out for him. But the circumstances aren't like that for everybody.

[George]

Man. Well, this is comforting. Let's talk about something happier. Your new book, the meaning of your life. How does money play into the meaning of your life?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So people behave very differently when they understand the meaning of their life than when they don't. So we've. In the past, in the last episode that we did together, we talked about what people do with money. When people have a sense of meaninglessness in their life, they try to buy a sense of meaning, typically by buying things that show them something about themselves. And that's when they buy stuff, and that's when they peacock, and that's when they try to do something that has a flex to it. And that's when buying junk is what it comes down to. When people have a sense of the meaning of their lives, then they use it to accentuate the sources of real meaning. And the sources of real meaning are relationships and a relationship with God and your relationship with your community and all that. And you tend to use money in a much healthier way. When you have a sense of the meaning of your life, you can actually get into a meaning doom loop with money as well. The more junk that you buy to show to yourself that you're worth something, to try to find meaning, the worse off you're actually gonna be.

[George]

I have a theory that most of it for guys stems from their dad not hugging them as a child or saying, I'm proud of you. Is that theory correct?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Well, there's a lot that comes in from the relationship that we have with our dads.

[George]

I say the higher the truck, the less your dad hugged you. That's kind of my. That seems just a generic, you know.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I don't know any papers on that, George. I don't know if I've actually seen it.

[George]

Guys, this is what we should be doing research on.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I know we needed studies on the size of the tires on your dad's truck and all that. That might be correlational and not causal.

[George]

Well, let's not get all scientific.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Let's not get all, like, fancy, fancy schmancy about. That's, like, intellectual.

[George]

So, yeah, if you don't have your values ironclad, if you are chasing the wrong identity. That's where this whole thing.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

There's a whole thing. And any of these mildly pathological behaviors in sons, for example, there's a bunch of stuff that dads can do to make it better. Number one, it's like, don't bail. Right. I mean, a huge predictor of pathological behavior with respect to addiction and self destructive behavior and mental illness. And just the future and the success of young men has to do with

[George]

the father of the home they just opted out.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah. People often ask, just tell me one thing that I can do that will give my son a higher likelihood of success. Here it is. Love his mom. That's what it is. Adore his mom. Well, what if I don't adore her? I don't care. I don't care. Now if I could tell mom one thing that's best for the kids. Admire his dad. That's what it. Admire. What if he's not admirable? Admire him. Find something to admire. Now. It's a lot easier for guys if they're admirable. And so dads.

[George]

Yeah, you don't have to fake it.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So job number one is adore her. Job number two is be admirable.

[George]

And women be adorable.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, I mean, I'm not in the business of giving women all this much advice. I give guys a lot more advice than I give women. I say this with appropriate humility because I'm a guy. Right. But what does it mean to be admirable? And to be admirable is to be impeccable, morally true to your word, standing up for your values, being strong in what's right, providing, being compassionate, being honest, being faithful, being loyal. That's what it means to be admirable. To be admirable is not to have the biggest possible truck and to be in unbelievable amounts of debt and running around behind your wife's back. That's not admirable. That's animal impulse, not moral aspiration is what it comes down to.

[George]

Well, I found a lot of young guys, they literally call the show and say, hey, I just want to make as much money as possible. I want to become a millionaire. I'm 18. How do I have a million by 25? What is the danger of making wealth your purpose instead of treating it as a tool?

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

So the problem with that is that the impulse is actually good, but the execution is flawed. So the impulse is to be admirable. That's the impulse. The problem is that it's the wrong goal for becoming truly admirable. So it's basically like this. You know, the three wise men were looking for the stable in Bethlehem. They weren't actually looking for the star. The star was sitting over the stable in Bethlehem. They had a lot of faith that that was the right proxy goal. Life is full of proxy goals. And the young guys who are calling in, it's like my proxy goal to be a truly admirable guy that I feel is worth something is to have a million dollars by the time I'm 25. That's what they're actually saying. I mean, 25 or $5 million or a million dollars in a bank account is just a bunch of ones and zeros in there that could be wiped out by one electromagnetic pulse. I mean, it's incredibly precarious, and it doesn't actually mean anything inherently. What it is is a proxy for the thing that they really want, which is the person that they want to be. It's really important they think about the person that they want to be and not be, focusing only on what they think is the representation of that. That's what it comes down to. Because guess what? You follow the wrong star and it's sitting over the ocean. And I got the data on that. They get to a million dollars by the time they're 25. And it's not enough. It's not enough because the star is still there. And they keep going for the star, and the star is never over anything.

[George]

I see this with the fire movement, the financial independence. Retire early. They go, well, once I have 3 million, I am out. And they go, well, I don't know, I should probably go to 5 million.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

I know, I know. And then, by the way, I know people who are. 100 million is not enough. Yeah, I know people who are a unit, which is what billionaires call a billion dollars.

[George]

That's how poor I am. I don't even know that.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Are you close to a unit?

[George]

No, I'm not close enough to know what a unit is.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Yeah, there you go. A unit. So they need two units. And they know how much the guy down the street, how many units he's got. That's a big problem. And that's because it's an ever elusive goal. And the reason is because what you really want is the person that you want to be. And the number in the bank account isn't the person that you want to be. It's a disembodied bad proxy for that. So what I recommend young people do is that they think, who's the person that I Want to be? At 25. What are the characteristics of my life, which is not the numbers in my bank account. One element might be numbers in my bank account, but there's nine other things. I want to be married to somebody that I'm truly in love with, who respects and loves and admires me. I want to have a kid. I want to have a job where I feel like, you know, when I talk about it, people are like, cool, that's great. That's what I want to have. I want to be a good man. I want. I want to be a faithful man. I want to be a Christian man. Perhaps that's the guy I want to be. And focus on that. Focus on the person that you want to be, and then the proxy goals will come into view and they won't be so. Both elusive and ultimately false.

[George]

That might be the best advice we've had on this channel. So thank you for that. I want to end with a speed round.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Speed round.

[George]

Fill in the blank. I'm going to say the sentence. You fill in the blank with as few words as possible.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

That's hard for a Harvard professor to do. Can I have 350 words for each?

[George]

So test your PhD here.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

All right. Well, that's it. Test my PhD. We'll be here all day.

[George]

This is the opposite of your dissertation.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

There we go. Thank you. Obviously, you've read my dissertation.

[George]

I didn't. I mean, I assumed you had one. I'm not quite a dissertation reader.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

You know, it's like. Actually, I turned in a version that was so bad at the very beginning, and it was both short and bad. And my dissertation advisor read the first draft and he said, this is a very intellectual thing, but you'll get it at the very beginning. Even in the first phrase. He said, you, dissertation draft is a refutation of the old saying that brevity is the soul of wit. It's brief but not witty.

[George]

It was a persuasive argument against that. Oh, my gosh, man.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It was bad.

[George]

That's rough.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It was bad. Anyway, we'll see. I'll hold it in small. Yeah, that's good. What'd you just do?

[George]

That's all elbows, baby.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

You just cracked both elbows.

[George]

If you worked out less, you might get there. Think about it.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Loosen up these joints. Wow.

[George]

One thing that would surprise people about Arthur Brooks's last bank statement is a

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

lot on organic and healthy food.

[George]

He's as boring as he seems.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

It's pretty bad. That's like cottage cheese.

[George]

I'm not gonna see a McDonald's transaction in there.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

You're not gonna see that. I don't remember. I mean, I got nothing.

[George]

You would know that's fraud on your account if you saw this.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Lock it down.

[George]

Call your bank.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Lock down the.

[George]

Jeff, the bank calls you. They're like, arthur, this can't be you. You're go nail this one.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

All right.

[George]

People will be the happiest in 2026 if they

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

focus on love instead of money.

[George]

The biggest lie about success is success

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

is something that you can ultimately achieve. Rather, it's something that you can approach and make progress toward love.

[George]

That the future belongs to people who

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

love more.

[George]

If you had to start from zero again, the first thing you'd do is

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

spend less time thinking about myself.

[George]

And lastly, the meaning of life is

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

to love and be loved.

[George]

Mic drop. Arthur, such a pleasure talking with you.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Thank you, Jerry.

[George]

Thanks for being on the show.

[Dr. Arthur Brooks]

Of course. Always.

[George]

Big thanks to Arthur for joining us on the channel once again. I always love when he's here, and my brain always hurts a little bit after he's gone. That's kind of what he does. Be sure to check out his new book, the Meaning of youf Life. It's available wherever books are sold. Or you can go to themeaningofyourlife.com or click the link in the description to check it out. And if you love this conversation, you're going to love another conversation I recently had with him. It's coming up next, so click here or use the link in the description. We dive into the real reason people do dumb things with their money. And it's a real page turner. Guys, thanks for watching. We'll see you next time.