Ghost of a Chance: BONUS Episode - The Speech
Released on February 17, 2025 by The Minnesota Star Tribune
Introduction & Context
In this bonus episode of Ghost of a Chance, reporter Eric Roper delves deeper into the historical narrative surrounding Harry and Clementine Robinson, the original owners of a 113-year-old Minneapolis house. Host Melissa Townsend sets the stage by addressing listener feedback and clarifying the podcast's intriguing title, "Ghost of a Chance."
The Title: Ghost of a Chance
Melissa Townsend explains the origin of the podcast's title, dispelling misconceptions that it refers to the ghostly presence of Harry and Clementine Robinson. Instead, the title is derived from a poignant phrase in a 1925 speech by W. Gertrude Brown, a close friend of the Robinsons.
"The phrase 'ghost of a chance' comes at a very pointed moment in the speech. You can kind of hear her saying it. Like, has it ever occurred to you they don't have a ghost of a chance?"
— Eric Roper (05:16)
W. Gertrude Brown and the Phillis Wheatley Settlement House
W. Gertrude Brown served as the head resident of the Phillis Wheatley Settlement House from 1924 to 1937. The settlement house was a cornerstone of Minneapolis' black community, offering a wide range of services from classes and recreation for children to employment assistance and housing support for adults. Melissa Townsend highlights Brown's pivotal role in advocating for civil rights and improving the lives of African Americans in Minneapolis.
"Gertrude Brown was the first head resident of the Phillis Wheatley Settlement House. Phyllis Wheatley was a very integral part of the city's black community."
— Eric Roper (02:07)
Historical Context: Social Movements and Black Women
Historian Uhuru Rue Williams provides insight into the broader social movements that empowered black women like W. Gertrude Brown during the early 20th century. The club movement, in particular, offered black women a platform to exert agency, voice, and power, often in conjunction with settlement houses focused on protecting women and girls and combating racial injustice.
"That's what she wrote about in that speech she gave in 1925. When Eric eventually sat down to read it, he was kind of blown away."
— Melissa Townsend (04:17)
Analysis of Brown's Speech
Eric Roper and Melissa Townsend explore the profound impact of W. Gertrude Brown's 1925 speech to a conference of social workers. The speech meticulously outlines the systemic challenges faced by the African American community in Minneapolis, touching upon critical issues such as health disparities, inadequate housing, employment discrimination, and insufficient law enforcement and recreational facilities.
Regina Marie Williams' Reading of the Speech
Actor Regina Marie Williams brings W. Gertrude Brown's speech to life, capturing the urgency and frustration embedded in Brown's advocacy. The speech is a candid exposition of the multifaceted oppression faced by African Americans, emphasizing how systemic barriers prevent them from achieving their full potential.
Highlights from the speech include:
-
Health Disparities
Brown highlights alarming infant mortality rates among African Americans compared to their white counterparts, attributing these disparities to economic hardships and inadequate healthcare access.
"The infant mortality rate among the white infants was 73, and among the colored infants was 110."
— W. Gertrude Brown (06:19) -
Substandard Housing
She describes the dire living conditions forced upon African Americans due to economic constraints, leading to overcrowded and unsanitary housing.
"Cold, damp, overcrowded homes in unsanitary locations. Cheap homes which the Negro was forced to take because of his pay envelope."
— W. Gertrude Brown (15:45) -
Employment Discrimination
Brown passionately argues that systemic employment barriers leave African Americans with limited job opportunities, trapping them in low-paying and unstable positions.
"Has it ever occurred to you that he hasn't a ghost of a chance? Have you ever stopped to think that every real money making avenue is closed to him?"
— W. Gertrude Brown (18:30) -
Lack of Law Enforcement and Recreational Facilities
She calls attention to the absence of adequate law enforcement in predominantly black neighborhoods and the lack of recreational programs, which contribute to social issues and limited opportunities for youth.
"Recreation, a leisure time program, is absolutely necessary for the happiness of any community. The lack of opportunity for wholesome recreation has forced the Negro adult to the public, unsupervised dance hall to the undesirable, clubs and street corners."
— W. Gertrude Brown (22:10)
Conclusion & Reflection
Following the speech, Melissa Townsend and Eric Roper reflect on the enduring relevance of Brown's words. They emphasize the importance of understanding historical injustices to address contemporary racial issues in Minneapolis, especially in the context of the city's role in a global racial reckoning.
Melissa Townsend concludes by providing context about W. Gertrude Brown's legacy and the creation team behind the podcast, encouraging listeners to engage further through the podcast's website and community initiatives.
Notable Quotes:
-
"Has it ever occurred to you they don't have a ghost of a chance?"
— W. Gertrude Brown (05:16) -
"The Negro is not understood and few are willing to take a little time and learn about him."
— W. Gertrude Brown (24:50) -
"Open up opportunities for better health, housing, employment, law enforcement and recreation and you will find a new Negro and a better Negro who will pay you large dividends in good citizenship."
— W. Gertrude Brown (24:40)
Key Takeaways:
- W. Gertrude Brown's 1925 speech provides a critical historical perspective on the systemic challenges faced by African Americans in early 20th-century Minneapolis.
- The speech underscores the interconnectedness of health, housing, employment, and social services in shaping community well-being.
- Understanding historical injustices is essential for addressing ongoing racial disparities and fostering community resilience.
For more insights and to explore the rich history of Harry and Clementine Robinson, visit Ghost of a Chance on the Minnesota Star Tribune website.