The Global Story: Russia and Israel put Witkoff's diplomacy to the test

Summary

Global News Podcast – The Global Story: Russia and Israel Put Witkoff's Diplomacy to the Test

BBC World Service | Aired: September 14, 2025
Hosts: Asma Khalid & Tristan Redman
Guest Expert: Tom Bateman (BBC State Department Correspondent)
Main Focus:
An in-depth look at Steve Witkoff, Donald Trump’s handpicked envoy, and his unconventional approach to high-stakes diplomacy as Russia-Ukraine and Israel-Gaza conflicts escalate, challenging both US foreign policy goals and global security.

---

Episode Overview

The episode examines the shifting world order, spotlighting how Donald Trump’s personal pick for orchestrating peace—Steve Witkoff, a real estate developer with no diplomatic experience—has handled the mounting crises in Ukraine and Gaza. As both conflicts reach dangerous tipping points, the hosts and Tom Bateman consider whether Witkoff’s close relationship with Trump and his unorthodox methods represent an asset or a liability for US foreign policy.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Steve Witkoff’s Origins and Trump Connection

• Background:
  Witkoff built a real estate empire in New York, inspired by and befriending Donald Trump in the 1980s.

  • “Steve Witkoff is a 68 year old who made his fortune, an empire in the New York real estate world… very close friendship [with] Donald Trump goes back many decades.” (Tom Bateman, 04:20)

• The Ham-and-Swiss Deli Story:
  Their friendship traces to a moment when Witkoff bought Trump a sandwich, symbolizing their trust and starting point.

  • “I ordered him a ham and Swiss. That appeared… encapsulated and started this friendship of trust.” (Tom Bateman, 04:58)

• Personal Loyalty:
  Witkoff’s loyalty was cemented when Trump comforted him after his son’s death.

  • “When I lost my boy Andrew to an opioid overdose… Donald Trump showed up.” (Steve Witkoff, 06:24)
  • “I have seen his humanity in the quiet moments away from the spotlight.” (Steve Witkoff, 06:52)

2. Witkoff’s Rise: From Trump Donor to ‘Envoy for Everything’

• Political Loyalty:
  Supported Trump through major setbacks, including the Capitol attack and assassination attempts.

  • “Steve Witkoff stuck by him… [He] is an absolutely critical figure throughout that period.” (Tom Bateman, 08:14)

• Assassination Attempt:
  Witkoff was present during the 2024 golf course shooting.

  • “I have a little love thing for my dear friend… thank God that he was not injured or killed…” (Steve Witkoff, 09:56)

• Appointment as Envoy:
  Witkoff’s diplomatic role began on a whim at a golf lunch.

  • “According to Lindsey Graham, Donald Trump says, ‘yeah, whatever you want, Steve.’” (Tom Bateman, 10:59)

3. Early Diplomatic Successes and Methods

• Brokered Gaza Ceasefire:
  Praised by both outgoing and incoming administrations for helping broker a temporary Israel-Gaza ceasefire during the transition.

  • “They were effusive in their praise… frankly, there’s not a whole lot that you heard from the Biden administration… praising the incoming Trump folks.” (Asma Khalid, 11:16)

• Unorthodox Approaches:
  Broke diplomatic protocol by meeting Netanyahu during Shabbat:

  • “Steve Wyckoff put his foot down and basically said, well, we’re here to see you and force that meeting.” (Tom Bateman, 12:24)

4. Diplomatic Style—Disarming but Inexperienced

• Impressions from the Field:
  Pleasant and business-minded, yet deferring to seasoned diplomats.

  • “He’s clearly very bright and he’s quite disarming… but he didn’t feel like the kind of key player among them.” (Tom Bateman, 13:32)
  • “It was positive, upbeat, constructive. We couldn’t have imagined a better result.” (Steve Witkoff, 13:53)

• Reliance on Personal Networks:
  Relies on presidential trust rather than State Department structures.

5. Controversies and Escalating Criticism

• Expanding Mission, Risky Tactics:
  Witkoff began jetting privately, meeting Putin without secure lines or interpreters—diplomatic red flags.

  • “Flying in his own private plane… no secure government communications… meeting Vladimir Putin without an official State Department interpreter…” (Tom Bateman, 18:04)

• High-Profile Podcast with Tucker Carlson:
  Lavished praise on Putin and mirrored Kremlin talking points—drawing bipartisan alarm.

  • “He was calling him a great guy. He was super smart…” (Tom Bateman, 19:51)
  • “There have been referendums where the overwhelming majority of the people have indicated that they want to be under Russian rule.” (Steve Witkoff, 20:38)

6. Miscommunications and the Alaska Summit

• Breakdown Over Ukraine:
  A key summit between Trump and Putin was set up based on Witkoff’s misinterpretation of Russian intentions.

  • “Steve Wyckoff told them… Putin was prepared to withdraw from Zaporizhzhia and Kherson… turns out that was wrong by the next day…” (Tom Bateman, 22:08)
  • “According to the European accounts, clearly there was a change in interpretation in the course of 24 hours by the administration…” (Tom Bateman, 23:35)

• No Lasting Results:
  US media and global observers left confused as to real progress.

  • “You had this hugely visual moment… but… nothing has changed. And in the end, who’s the winner of that? It would seem… Vladimir Putin.” (Tom Bateman, 24:14)

7. Was Breaking with Convention a Mistake?

• Trump’s Trust in Witkoff:
  Trump values Witkoff as a channel “untainted by veteran foreign policy experts…”

  • “Trump believes he is getting the unvarnished position… untainted by… political ambitions.” (Tom Bateman, 26:02)

• Critics’ View:
  Nine months in, no breakthroughs in either conflict despite unconventional methods:

  • “...the evidence is they haven’t been able to get the breakthroughs on those two key areas…” (Tom Bateman, 26:36)

8. Escalating Risks and the Limits of Unorthodoxy

• Recent Escalations:

  • Israel strikes in Qatar derailing Gaza negotiations.
  • Russian drone incursions pushing Poland toward conflict, testing NATO.

• Risk of Worsening Instability:

  • “If you try a peace process in a way that hasn’t been tried before, there is always the risk you can make things potentially worse…” (Tom Bateman, 28:39)
  • “We are inching a bit closer towards that moment. And… that is a big risk for Europe and global security.” (Tom Bateman, 28:58)

• The Looming Question:

  • Will Trump blame Witkoff if diplomacy fails, or will he blame US allies?
  • “Everything we’ve talked about about the reason he appointed Steve Wyckoff to this role, I think means that he won’t do [blame Steve]. He’s much more likely to point the finger at one of the sides involved…” (Tom Bateman, 30:24)

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

“I have seen his humanity in the quiet moments away from the spotlight.”
— Steve Witkoff, discussing Donald Trump (06:52)

“Steve Wyckoff put his foot down and basically said, well, we’re here to see you and force that meeting.”
— Tom Bateman on Gaza ceasefire negotiations (12:24)

“He’s a super smart guy. Okay. You don’t want to give him the credit for it. That’s okay. I give him the credit.”
— Steve Witkoff, about Putin (19:51)

“If you try a peace process in a way that hasn’t been tried before, there is always the risk you can make things potentially worse…”
— Tom Bateman (28:39)

---

Important Timestamps

• Witkoff’s Trump Relationship & Personal Loyalty: 04:20–08:14
• Assassination Attempt Golf Course Story: 08:24–10:22
• Appointment as Middle East Envoy: 10:30–11:16
• Gaza Ceasefire Story: 11:16–12:50
• Diplomatic Impressions in Riyadh: 13:02–13:58
• Rising Diplomatic Controversy: 18:04–19:56
• Tucker Carlson Podcast Fallout: 19:18–20:46
• Ukraine Miscommunication & Alaska Summit: 21:38–24:14
• Was Unorthodoxy a Mistake?: 25:39–26:36
• Polish Airspace Escalation & Risks: 28:07–28:58
• Who Gets Blamed if it All Fails?: 30:19–30:24

---

Conclusion

Takeaway:
Steve Witkoff’s journey from Trump’s real estate confidant to international dealmaker highlights both the gamble and the pitfalls of bypassing diplomatic convention. Trusted by Trump for his loyalty and devoid of bureaucratic baggage, Witkoff’s approach—bold, informal, at times naive—has yielded both fleeting breakthroughs and dangerous misunderstandings. As war threatens to escalate in both Europe and the Middle East, his story becomes a case study in the perils and promise of personal diplomacy amidst unprecedented global volatility.

Final thought:
In a rapidly changing world, the question persists: Is breaking with tradition a path to peace, or does it fuel greater instability? The fate of two major wars—and perhaps the credibility of American diplomacy—hangs in the balance.

Transcript

[Tom Bateman]

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

[Commercial Advertiser 1]

Saks Off 5th is your secret to fashion's most wanted deals at up to 70% off on the hunt for designer steals that'll turn heads and leave a trail of envy. Uncover Gucci, Valentino, Versace, Stuart Weitzman and more. With new arrivals dropping weekly at prices too good to stay confidential, Luxe Layers statement boots and tailored essentials From Saks Off 5th will put your wardrobe on the most wanted list. Head to saksofffifth.com or a Saks Off Fifth store near you for a style lineup you won't want to miss.

[Commercial Advertiser 2]

This message comes from Greenlight Ready to start talking to your kids about financial literacy? Meet Greenlight, the debit card and money app that teaches kids and teens how to earn, save, spend wisely and invest with your guardrails in place with Greenlight, you can send money to kids quickly, set up chores, automate allowance, and keep an eye on what your kids are spending with real time notifications. Join millions of parents and kids building healthy financial habits together on Greenlight. Get started risk [e-mail] iheart.

[Asma Khalid]

Hey there. I'm Asma Khalid.

[Tristan Redman]

And I'm Tristan Redman, and we're here with a new weekly bonus for you from the Global Story podcast.

[Asma Khalid]

The world order is shifting. Old alliances are fraying and new ones are emerging. Some of this turbulence can be traced to decisions made in the United States. But the US Isn't just a cause of the upheaval its politics are also a symptom of it.

[Tristan Redman]

Every day we focus on one story looking at how America and the world shape each other.

[Asma Khalid]

So we hope you enjoy this episode. And to find more of our show, just search for the Global Story wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

[Tristan Redman]

Donald Trump wants to make two big diplomatic deals, Gaza and Ukraine, and this week both of them are on the rocks. On Tuesday, Trump's Middle east plan took a big hit when Israel targeted the Hamas negotiators in Qatar. That's America's closest Middle east ally, firing missiles into its second closest Middle east ally. On Wednesday, Vladimir Putin was testing the boundaries of NATO.

[Asma Khalid]

Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk has confirmed.

[Tristan Redman]

That Russian drones were shot down in Polish airspace overnight.

[Asma Khalid]

Polish and NATO jets were scrambled to shoot down Russian drones that violated its airspace.

[Tristan Redman]

Poland's prime minister says his country is the closest it's been to open conflict since World War II. The incursion by Russian drones into Polish airspace was another big hit for Trump.

[Tom Bateman]

You can, I think, quite convincingly argue Right now that not only has he been played by President Putin, he's also.

[Tristan Redman]

Been played by Prime Minister Netanyahu of Israel. President Trump, his ambitions to be this Nobel Peace Prize winning ender of wars appears to be, you know, hitting another roadblock. And at the center of all of this is the man Donald Trump asked to solve these two wars for him, his best friend, somebody with zero diplomatic experience. Steve Witkoff from the BBC. I'm Tristan Redmond and this is the global story on today's episode, who is stuck? Steve Witkoff, Trump's envoy for everything. And what happens when you put a real estate magnate in charge of diplomacy?

[Asma Khalid]

Maybe I should just turn my volume down. I'll turn my volume down a bit. All right, well, I think we're ready to.

[Tristan Redman]

All right. Yeah, we better get going.

[Asma Khalid]

All right. All right.

[Tristan Redman]

On Monday, Asma and I spoke to the BBC's Tom Bateman. He's our State Department correspondent based in.

[Tom Bateman]

Washington, D.C. so I cover foreign policy from Washington, but that involves quite a lot of trips with the Secretary of State and covering all things foreign policy under the Trump administration.

[Tristan Redman]

So today we are talking about Steve Witkoff. Could you tell us who is Steve Witkoff?

[Tom Bateman]

Well, Steve witkoff is a 68 year old who made his fortune, an empire in the New York real estate world. Steve Witkoff started actually as a real estate lawyer and his acquaintance, and more importantly, very close friendship. Donald Trump goes back many decades, but notably to the 1980s. There are acquaintances on property deals. Steve Wyckoff the lawyer, Donald Trump the property director. And he talks about one night when he was in a New York deli and in walks Donald Trump. And Trump had no cash on him. So Steve Wyckoff says, I ordered him a ham and Swiss. That appeared to be the moment that encapsulated and started this friendship of trust. And Steve Wyckoff then attributed his desire to get into property development to Donald Trump himself. And he said, I'm going to go.

[Steve Witkoff]

In the real estate business because I can do this, too. He saw me do it and he said, if Trump can do it, I guess I can do it.

[Tom Bateman]

And he has since said that Trump was basically his inspiration and the person he wanted to emulate.

[Steve Witkoff]

He had this swashbuckling style. I used to see him come in and I used to say, God, I want to be him. I don't want to be the lawyer. I don't want to be the scrivener. I want to be that man.

[Tom Bateman]

And from there grew this huge empire, which is now both him and his sons in ownership called the Wyckoff Group.

[Asma Khalid]

You know, the thing I find so striking about Donald Trump and Steve Wyckoff's friendship is the longevity of it. Donald Trump is not someone who is known necessarily to have a whole bunch of loyal, intimate friends. He has even himself said he doesn't trust a whole lot of people, but he seems to trust Steve Witkoff. Why is that?

[Tom Bateman]

That was something that Susie Walls, who's now his chief of staff, had talked about. The fact that, you know, as she put it, Donald Trump has many acquaintances, but very few friends. But Steve Witkoff is clearly one of them. I mean, there's this story that he has told. When the friendship began between him and Donald Trump.

[Steve Witkoff]

When I lost my boy Andrew to an opioid overdose, the pain was unbearable. But as usual, Donald Trump showed up.

[Tom Bateman]

He's talked about Trump being a great solace to him at that time. It's been a story that he has told to emphasize the closeness of Donald Trump with him and explaining why he's then supported him later down the line.

[Steve Witkoff]

I have seen his humanity in the quiet moments away from the spotlight, and.

[Tom Bateman]

It'S a story he comes back to a lot, and especially in the role of what started as Middle east envoy, but has then spread to the envoy for everything, as some people have put it. You're often dealing in life and death situations, and so he has lent into that.

[Steve Witkoff]

This is the truth about President Trump, the man I have come to know and admire and love.

[Tom Bateman]

You see this relationship deepen in the run up to Trump's 2016 election win. Steve Witkoff was a donor to his campaign to the tune of up to $2 million. And then Steve Wyckoff being given some sort of minor roles in the administration, particularly after the COVID pandemic. But the key moment for me is after that, because it's in January 2021, when you see the assault on the US Capitol and Donald Trump, you know, hemorrhaging support, and Steve Wyckoff stuck by him. And then into 2024, Donald Trump starts his run again in the primaries for the Republican nomination, and Steve Witkoff is by his side the whole way through. And so he is an absolutely critical figure throughout that period.

[Tristan Redman]

Tom, what about the assassination attempt against Donald Trump in 2024? What was Steve Witkoff's link to Trump at that moment?

[Tom Bateman]

Yeah, and I mean, this is what makes this year extraordinary, I think, because you had the assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania, where, of course, Donald Trump had his ear grazed and was. Was wounded, but shortly after that, there was this second assassination attempt on his golf course in Florida. And I mean, I remember the night that story broke. I was here in our Washington bureau. We had to rush down and do a live for the 10 o' clock news and then flew down to Miami and made our way to this golf course. You know, so this story is unfolding of a man who was basically hiding in the bushes on the perimeter of the Trump golf course and had then been spotted by the Secret Service with the barrel of his gun pointing out. And Trump with Wyckoff and the Secret Service on the golf course. And Wyckoff tells this story.

[Tom Bateman (phone interview)]

He.

[Steve Witkoff]

Here he was yesterday on a beautiful day, just trying to get some rest and relaxation like all the rest of us. And there's a man with a. With a machine gun. It was, it was, it was terrible.

[Tom Bateman]

And again, it's this sort of story of literally being by the side of Donald Trump. And he says in his telling of the story, you know, the Secret Service spotted this gunman. They're firing shots at him.

[Steve Witkoff]

You knew immediately it was gunfire. It didn't sound like firecrackers.

[Tom Bateman]

Donald Trump's being bundled back into the golf course.

[Steve Witkoff]

The Secret Service were exceptional. They were on. They were. They had the President secured.

[Tom Bateman]

And Steve Witkoff says, I don't know why, but I continue to stand there and you feel this idea of a sort of protector.

[Steve Witkoff]

You know, I have a little love thing for my dear friend. And I say to myself, thank God that he was not injured or.

[Asma Khalid]

Were.

[Tom Bateman]

Killed, in a sense, at the end of that year, he gets his reward as he is named by Mr. Trump Middle east envoy.

[Asma Khalid]

Can you help us understand how he got that job? Because he, he is not a diplomat. He is, as you say, a real estate developer.

[Tom Bateman]

Now, the story, as it is told by Lindsey Graham, Republican Senator, very close to Trump, is that it was on the golf course or at a golf lunch in Florida, and they were talking about what Steve Wyckoff was going to do if Donald Trump won the presidency. And then according to Lindsey Graham, Steve Wyckoff says, oh, I want to be the Middle east envoy. I think that's an area I can really help him because he has these business contacts with Qatar and with the Emiratis and across the Gulf and with the Saudis, and because he has very strong support for Israel historically and he knows the politics there. And according to Lindsey Graham, Donald Trump says, yeah, whatever you want, Steve. And literally that appeared to be the way in which that decision was made.

[Asma Khalid]

The first time, Tom, that I really recall hearing a lot about Steve Witkoff in his new Middle east envoy role. I'm sure you recall this. It was January, during the transition period, the Biden administration was still in office, and they held a briefing call with a bunch of US Reporters in which this senior Biden official very directly and explicitly praised Steve Witkoff for making that Israel Gaza temporary ceasefire deal happen. They were effusive in their praise and thanks for Steve Witkoff, which caught my ear, because frankly, there's not a whole lot that you heard from the Biden administration that they were praising the incoming Trump folks for.

[Tom Bateman]

I mean, I think since then, the account of this has diverged quite a lot. But what you hear from the Trump administration and officials within it is that the deal wouldn't have happened without Donald Trump and Steve Wykoff. And Steve Wykoff was the middleman that really made this happen. And there's this story that is told in the weeks running up to that, when it was felt clearly on the American side that they needed to get Netanyahu to move. Wyckoff turns up on Shabbat on the Friday night in Israel and asks to see Benjamin Netanyahu, the Prime Minister. Now, the protocol of the Israeli Prime Minister's office generally is that he wouldn't do any diplomatic work or see foreign visitors over the Shabbat. But Steve Wyckoff put his foot down and basically said, well, we're here to see you and force that meeting. And that was described as being instrumental in getting towards this ceasefire and hostage release deal.

[Tristan Redman]

Tom. So that was just before the inauguration. But when did you first come up close with Steve Witkoff, when he was fully in his role as this Middle east and Ukraine negotiator?

[Tom Bateman]

Well, the first time I met him properly was in Saudi Arabia. Now I was on the plane with Rubio as part of the press pool. And they met the Russians, so they met the Foreign Minister, Sergei Lavrov, and the Russian delegation in Riyadh. And I saw the two sides facing each other across the table. After that, Wyckoff was with Rubio and Mike Waltz and they basically did a sort of 15 minute interview with a small number of us. So I got a chance to sort of see him up close at that point.

[Tristan Redman]

What did you make of him?

[Tom Bateman]

Well, I mean, I thought he was very charming. You know, he's clearly very bright and he's quite disarming. But I did also feel quite strongly a kind of sense of deference from him to Rubio and Waltz. I mean, he didn't say much during that period of time. And I felt also the way he described it was very much how you might talk about a sort of real estate deal.

[Steve Witkoff]

It was positive, upbeat, constructive. We couldn't have imagined a better result.

[Tom Bateman]

But he didn't feel like the kind of key player among them. Will you be traveling to Russia again, Mr. Wyckoff?

[Steve Witkoff]

I'm not sure we'll make that determination in the next couple of weeks.

[Tom Bateman]

But having said that, you know, clearly he has the greatest amount of trust from the President himself and probably the President's ear, much more than the other two men in the room.

[Tristan Redman]

Coming up, Witkoff takes the lead on the world stage and things get tricky.

[Commercial Advertiser 2]

There's a moment every parent remembers the day their child takes off on two wheels. With Guardian bikes. That moment comes as early as 2 years old and with less stress and frustration. These bikes are built just for kids. Lightweight frames, low center of gravity, easy to use brakes. Everything about Guardian is designed to help kids ride confidently, often in just one day. No training wheels needed. And because Guardian bikes are designed and assembled right here in the usa, you know they're built to last with care in every detail. Their patented SureStop braking system stops both wheels with a single lever helping your child stop safely without tripping forward or losing control. Right now, save hundreds when comparing Guardian to its [e-mail] and get a free lock and pump when you join their newsletter a $50 value. Visit guardianbikes.com today to save and help your child learn an essential life skill safely. Guardian Bikes Built for your kid and for the memories you'll never forget.

[Commercial Advertiser 1]

Welcome to the W where legends are made and history is written. Under the brightest lights, the WNBA delivers nonstop action and world class talent every single game. And now it all comes down to Will the New York Liberty defend their crown or will another team take the chip? This is where champions rise and legacies are defined. Watch the WNBA post season starting Sunday, September 14th on ABC and ESPN. Now I'd like to introduce you to Meaningful Beauty, the famed skincare brand created by iconic suit supermodel Cindy Crawford. It's her secret to absolutely gorgeous skin. Meaningful Beauty makes powerful and effective skin care simple and it's loved by millions of women. It's formulated for all ages and all skin tones and types and it's designed to work as a complete skin care system, leaving your skin feeling soft, smooth and nourished. I recommend starting with Cindy's full regimen which contains all five of her best selling products including the Amazing Youth Activating Melon Serum. This next generation serum has the power of melon leaf stem cell technology. It's melon leaf stem cells encapsulated for freshness and released onto the skin to support a visible reduction in the appearance of wrinkles. With thousands of glowing five star reviews, why not give it a try? Subscribe today and you can get the amazing Meaningful Beauty system for just $49.95. That includes our introductory five piece system, free gifts, free shipping and a 60 day money back guarantee. All of that [e-mail] this message is sponsored by Greenlight. With school out, summer is the perfect time to teach our kids real world money skills they'll use forever. Greenlight is a debit card and the number one family finance and safety app used by millions of families, helping kids learn how to save, invest and spend wisely. Parents can send their kids money and track their spending and saving while kids build money, confidence and skills in fun ways. Start your risk free Greenlight trial [e-mail] iheart that's greenlight.com iheart.

[Asma Khalid]

So it sounds like in the first couple of months of this Trump administration, Steve Witkoff looks like this somewhat low key, unconventional diplomat. But as the months and months have gone on, he has become this far more influential figure on the diplomatic scene who is rather controversial in some circles.

[Tom Bateman]

Yeah, I mean, I think the point to remember here is that Donald Trump's major foreign policy goal was to end the wars. So you know, Russia, Ukraine and Gaza. What you see over this period of time is then several trips by Steve Wyckoff to Moscow. I think he's now made five or six to meet Vladimir Putin. But what starts to emerge is this incredibly unorthodox style. Him flying in his own private plane, which doesn't have secure government communications, him meeting Vladimir Putin without an official State Department interpreter, you start to see the Gaza ceasefire deal fall apart. The demand by the President to try and get somewhere on Russia, Ukraine going absolutely nowhere. So on all those key objectives that have been set, no progress, and increasing criticism about the way some of this diplomacy is being done.

[Asma Khalid]

So even though Steve Witkoff's original job title and job function was supposed to be Middle east envoy, by March of this year, it's clear that his portfolio has expanded. He is no longer just covering the Middle east. And he did this rather lengthy interview with the podcaster Tucker Carlson, I mean.

[Tom Bateman]

This is one of the features of the Trump administration. There is an openness. And to have the envoy on these key areas do a 90 minute interview in a podcast. I mean, I can't recall anything like that in the middle of such sensitive diplomacy. But it caused in both areas a huge amount of disquiet. But largely to do with his descriptions of his discussions with Vladimir Putin, because, first of all, he lavished praise on Putin. You know, he was calling him a great guy. He was super smart.

[Steve Witkoff]

He's a super smart guy. Okay. You don't want to give him the credit for it. That's okay. I give him the credit.

[Tom Bateman]

They must hate you for sex stuff. Very gracious in how he had dealt with him. But then I think even more significantly than that, when he described the Russia, Ukraine war was basically repeating, what are Kremlin talking points in terms of territory? First of all, he couldn't name them. The four regions in play in the.

[Steve Witkoff]

East, Donbas, Crimea, you know, the name Lugansk, and there's two others.

[Tom Bateman]

He on several occasions implied that Russia had the right to capture that land. And the argument of the Kremlin has always been that these are basically areas of Russia, you know, Russian speaking, and that they held referenda there where people voted to remain part of Russia.

[Steve Witkoff]

There have been referendums where the overwhelming majority of the people have indicated that they want to be under Russian rule. Yes, I think.

[Tom Bateman]

Well, of course, as far as the Ukrainians are concerned, that was a referendum held at gunpoint under military occupation. So it's not free or fair. And so that was derided after the fact. And I think there were a lot, you know, across both sides of the aisle and voicing extreme concern that he had been sucked in by Russian disinformation and was repeating these Kremlin talking points.

[Asma Khalid]

You know, one thing that I found interesting in that interview was also Witkoff's insistence on. On talking to all the parties involved and the idea that if you don't sit down and talk to somebody, even if you're in a fight, you're sort of in a blind negotiation. And ultimately, that kind of thinking leads us to what we saw last month with this summit in Alaska between Russian President Vladimir Putin and President Trump. It was unprecedented. So how did Wyckoff make that summit happen?

[Tom Bateman]

What has happened, I think, during several meetings is you have had Donald Trump get to a point where he believed that the only thing that would create a breakthrough was a summit between him and Putin. And Wykoff became the middleman in that. And it's interesting that during the summer, Trump was getting much more vocal in his anger and frustration with Putin. And then suddenly you have this meeting on August 6th, when Wyckoff travels to Moscow again and they have a lengthy discussion and Wyckoff comes out of that briefing, the president saying that, in effect, he believes there's a breakthrough. Trump called it great progress. The day after this, on August 7th, there was a phone call involving Wyckoff and the European leaders where Wyckoff told them, according to the European accounts, that Putin was prepared to withdraw from Zaporizhzhia and Kherson in the east in return for taking fuller control of two other regions in the Donbas. The problem was that Steve Wykoff, according to the accounts, didn't have any notes of the meeting with Putin. Now, Steve Wykoff was suggesting the Russians had conceded to quite a significant territorial concession to withdraw from parts that they currently occupied. But it turns out that was wrong by the next day, again, according to the European accounts, on a call where Rubio is now also on the call, Steve Wyckoff's position had shifted in terms of his interpretation of what had been said by the Russians in that meeting and had moved to a position where clearly the Russians were not prepared to do any kind of significant withdrawals. But it was on the basis of that meeting with the Russians that the Alaska summit was then set up.

[Asma Khalid]

So I want to be clear. I understand what you're saying. You're saying that that meeting between Putin and Trump ultimately took place because of a misunderstanding that Wyckoff had with the Russians.

[Tom Bateman]

Yeah, I mean, that appears to be exactly what happened. Having said that, two things to remember. Trump had wanted the Putin summit, and it's hard to know the degree to which perhaps the Russians had sold a position that they later backtracked on. But according to the European accounts, clearly there was a change in interpretation in the course of 24 hours by the administration about what Wyckoff said Putin had said to him.

[Asma Khalid]

If we look at Steve Wyckoff through the Alaska summit, Tom, how do you view it? Do you view Wyckoff as a success because he actually got the sides talking? Do you see it as a failure because there's been no actual outcome yet, there's no resolution to the war in Ukraine?

[Tom Bateman]

Well, I think the outcome of that really characterized both Steve Wyckoff and what we've seen of him this year and the wider diplomacy of the Trump administration because you had this hugely visual moment with the President of the United States welcoming Vladimir Putin, the architect of the Ukraine war, onto US Territory, with a red carpet and a round of applause. The key question then is, well, how did the Diplomacy, progress. And I think this is why it characterizes things, because we were left confused. You had within two days, Steve Wyckoff appearing on the US Network saying that the Russians had conceded to what he called a game changer, that they were prepared to allow for a NATO style security guarantee that would protect Ukraine in the event of a ceasefire and an end to the war that would guarantee no further Russian invasion. If that was correct, that is absolutely fundamental. And in the same period of time over the next week or so, the Russians said, no, we didn't agree to that. And then you're left thinking, well, where are things at? In the end? It's become clear that nothing like what Steve Wyckoff has suggested had been agreed, had actually been agreed. The outcome of that is that nothing has changed. And in the end, who's the winner of that? It would seem to me that the winner of that situation is always going to be Vladimir Putin.

[Tristan Redman]

Tom, Asma and I have been having a fairly robust discussion about whether or.

[Tom Bateman]

Not.

[Tristan Redman]

It is right to break diplomatic unorthodoxies and whether it was time to do so or whether it's actually counterproductive. Do you think that Steve Witkoff is actually advancing US Interests at this point or are they regretting?

[Tom Bateman]

I think when he reports back to Donald Trump, Trump believes he is getting the unvarnished position that's sort of untainted by, you know, veteran foreign policy experts or the deep state or however you want to see it, people with their own agendas and political ambitions. And as far as Donald Trump is concerned, Steve Witkoff has none of those. So I think from the perspective of the White House, this is an envoy in the purest form that will deliver the message of the president and bring back exactly what was being told. So that may be an advantage in the way that the diplomacy is done. But I think what the critics of the administration will point out is that so far the evidence is they haven't been able to get the breakthroughs on those two key areas on Russia and Ukraine and on Gaza. And here we are now getting on for nine months of the administration. What the objective was from the president has yet to be fulfilled.

[Asma Khalid]

But Tom, can't you also argue that nothing changed under the last couple of years of the Biden administration either on this conflict? His critics are judging him for failing to solve two of the world's major, major wars and crises at this moment, both of which were unsolvable under the previous American president as well.

[Tom Bateman]

Yeah, of course, you to go back to the Biden situation. I mean, their policy was basically to support Ukraine as far as was going to be possible politically within the United States. And that political will was draining. So it was not politically viable to maintain that situation. So things would have had to have changed anyway. The interesting thing, I think, about Steve Wyckoff and the Trump position is that there are very clear objectives that have been sold to the American public in a very sort of clear and vivid way, which is an end to the war. The issue has always been that it lacks a clear strategy. And in a sense, Steve Witkoff, I think, has become the personification of that.

[Asma Khalid]

Okay.

[Tristan Redman]

When we first spoke to Tom, that was back on Monday. But a lot has happened very fast this week. That was before Israel attacked Hamas leaders in Qatar and before Poland shot down Russian drones. And both those events have changed the picture for the US So on Wednesday, we caught up with Tom again on the phone. I mean, the great. The old saying is that war is diplomacy by other means. Given that we have these developments, what does it say to you about the state of American diplomacy right now?

[Tom Bateman (phone interview)]

Well, it feels to me that in the two wars that Donald Trump said he would stop, you now have a real sense of escalation. Now, you know, who's to say this wouldn't have happened anyway? But I think that it sort of goes back to a point about what the strategy is for Donald Trump and Steve Wyckoff and the administration here, because they have tried to. To get involved in these things in a fairly unorthodox way, wanting to end them. But the warning there was always, if you try a peace process in a way that hasn't been tried before, there is always the risk you can make things potentially worse because you might empower one of the sides. You may also give a sense that deterrence has disappeared for another of the sides, for example. So clearly, this is a really dangerous moment, I think, because if Poland is at threat as a NATO member, and Article 5 of NATO says an attack on one is an attack on all. And the Americans, as the most powerful leading member of NATO, would by default be there to defend that country. But of course, under Donald Trump, and I think one of the things Vladimir Putin has tried to test is whether or not the Americans would really do that. And so it feels in some ways as though we are inching a bit closer towards that moment. And of course, that is a big risk for Europe and global security. The question is always if this process that Donald Trump has tried to pursue to end the Russia, Ukraine war doesn't work or he loses interest in it in the end, who does he blame for that? And that becomes the critical question.

[Tristan Redman]

Well, could he end up blaming Steve Wyckoff?

[Tom Bateman (phone interview)]

I mean, there is always the potential for Donald Trump to sort of take it out internally, I suppose, on his own officials. But I think everything we've talked about about the reason he appointed Steve Wyckoff to this role, I think means that he won't do that. And he's much more likely to point the finger at one of the sides involved. I think if he blames the Ukrainians and there's no longer American weapons support, then the Europeans are left and the Ukrainians in an extremely vulnerable position. Having said that, the Europeans have tried to give every bit of energy they've got to try and ensure that that doesn't happen.

[Tristan Redman]

Tom, thank you so much.

[Tom Bateman (phone interview)]

Thanks, Tristan.

[Tristan Redman]

That was Tom Bateman, the BBC State Department correspondent. And that's it for the global story today. See you tomorrow. Cheerio.

[Steve Witkoff]

This is the story of the 1. As a maintenance supervisor at a manufacturing facility, he knows keeping the line up and running is a top priority. That's why he chooses Granger. Because when a drive belt gets damaged, Grainger makes it easy to find the exact specs for the replacement product he needs. And next day delivery helps ensure he'll have everything in place and running like clockwork work. Call 1-800-granger. Click granger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.