What Was Really Going on With Those Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Set Photos

Summary

Gloss Angeles Episode Summary: "What Was Really Going on With Those Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Set Photos"

Release Date: June 24, 2025
Hosts: Kirbie Johnson and Sara Tan

---

Introduction: Unboxing the Labubu Surprise

[00:38] Kirbie:

• Kirbie and Sara kick off the episode with a playful unboxing of a mysterious "labubu" package Sara has procured.
• Sara teases Kirbie to close her eyes, building suspense about the surprise inside.
• Upon unveiling, Kirbie humorously exclaims, “Oh, my God. It's all a boob” ([00:51]) indicating a humorous or perhaps unexpected item.

[02:32] Kirbie:

• The duo delves into their initial reactions, discussing the quirky design reminiscent of "Where the Wild Things Are" and the Cheshire Cat, sparking Kirbie’s playful discomfort and eventual fondness for the item.

Notable Quote:
Sara: “It's like a little monster ready to attack at any time. It still makes me feel queasy.” [02:05]

---

Deep Dive: Kosas Product Masterclass

[04:34] Transition:

• After the unboxing fun, Kirbie and Sara transition to discussing beauty products they’re excited about, highlighting their continuous exploration in makeup and skincare.

[04:43] Kirbie:

• Kirbie shares her experience attending a Kosas masterclass at their headquarters, where they were the first to test a new product launch.
• Reflects on her evolving relationship with Kosas products, particularly the BB Burst, initially finding it cumbersome but later appreciating its blend of coverage and hydration when applied correctly.

[06:25] Sara:

• Sara reminisces about the early days of BB creams and their application challenges, drawing parallels to her current experience with Kosas’s products.

[07:23] Kirbie:

• Discusses the brand founder Sheena’s wellness-oriented approach, emphasizing the spiritual influence on product names like Soulgazer Eyeliners.
• Announces the upcoming Kosas Soulgazer Mascara, detailing its unique silicone brush and non-tubing formula designed for length and volume without clumping.

Notable Quote:
Kirbie: “Once you get past the idea that it's not gonna instantly just, like, rub in, you have to really work it in. You kind of have to mix both the actual coverage with the hydrator that's within it.” [05:24]

[11:23] Kirbie:

• Explains the transition from their previous mascara, Big Clean, to the new Soulgazer Mascara, highlighting improvements in formula and application experience.

[13:27] Sara:

• Shifts focus to lip products, discussing the Violette FR Lip Nectar and ColorPop's Hydra Glossy Lip Stain, comparing their hydrating qualities and staying power.

Notable Quote:
Sara: “These experts need to come out and defend him. I know they're busy though, and they don't.” [24:19]

---

Breaking Down the Buzz: Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Set Photos

[17:55] Transition:

• Kirbie and Sara pivot to discussing the viral photos from Ryan Murphy's upcoming series featuring Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy and JFK Jr., analyzing public reactions and industry insights.

[18:09] Sara:

• Sara introduces the topic by mentioning the leaked stills from a lighting test that sparked widespread critique, particularly targeting Carolyn’s attire and hair styling.

[19:21] Kirby:

• Kirbie expresses initial frustration with the photos, describing Carolyn’s outfit—a silk miniskirt, blazer, and Chuck Taylors—as incongruent with her sophisticated image.

[21:32] Sarah:

• References expert opinions, including Amy Odell’s newsletter insights revealing that Carolyn did indeed wear Converse in her early career, clarifying misconceptions about the leaked images.

[22:44] Sarah:

• Notes Ryan Murphy’s transparency in interviews, where he confirms that the criticized looks were from pre-JFK days and not representative of Carolyn’s iconic style.

[23:34] Kirby:

• Highlights Murphy’s strategic release of photos to deter paparazzi but acknowledges the misstep in sharing unfinished set images, leading to public misinterpretation.

[24:52] Kirby:

• Reflects on regret over prematurely forming opinions without full context, emphasizing the importance of understanding production intricacies before critiquing.

Notable Quote:
Kirbie: “We are not running these productions. We don't work on set. I'm actually embarrassed that I didn't wait to form an opinion before getting more information.” [24:42]

[27:32] Sarah:

• Sara discusses consistency in the portrayal of Carolyn’s hair and attire, debunking initial negative reactions by referencing Lauren Sherman’s confirmation that the looks were accurate for specific scenes.

[29:02] Kirby:

• Kirbie commends Ryan Murphy for his honesty and the meticulous effort in sourcing authentic looks, likening Carolyn’s attention to style to legendary fashion icons like the Olsen twins.

[31:50] Sara:

• Concludes the segment by humorously narrowing down current concerns to "Labubus and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy's hair," highlighting their focus areas amidst broader discussions.

---

Final Thoughts: Embracing the Chaos with Humor

[31:55] Kirby & Sara:

• The hosts wrap up with light-hearted banter about focusing on their quirky unboxing and the in-depth analysis of the Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy photos, maintaining their signature blend of humor and insightful commentary.

Notable Quote:
Kirbie: “Nothing else matters. World War 3. Hard pass.” [31:56]

---

Key Takeaways

1. Product Insights:

   • Kosas Soulgazer Mascara emerges as a standout product with its innovative silicone brush and non-clumping formula.
   • Violette FR Lip Nectar and ColorPop’s Hydra Glossy Lip Stain are highlighted for their hydrating and long-lasting properties.

2. Industry Analysis:

   • The premature release of set photos by Ryan Murphy sparked unnecessary backlash, underscoring the importance of context in media releases.
   • Expert opinions and insider information can significantly alter public perception and clarify misunderstandings.

3. Host Dynamics:

   • Kirbie and Sara demonstrate a dynamic rapport, balancing humor with professional insights, making the content engaging for both regular listeners and newcomers.

---

Overall Conclusion:
In this episode of Gloss Angeles, Kirbie Johnson and Sara Tan skillfully blend their passion for beauty with an insightful critique of a trending media event. Their discussion offers listeners a nuanced perspective on product launches and the intricacies of television production, all while maintaining an entertaining and relatable conversation.

Transcript

[Verizon Representative]

Now at Verizon, we have some big news for your peace of mind. For all our customers, existing and new, we're locking in low prices for three years guaranteed on myplan and myhome. That's future youe peace of mind. And everyone can save on a brand new phone on myplan. When you trade in any phone from one of our top brands, that's new phone peace of mind. Because at Verizon, whether you're already a customer or you're just joining us, we got you. Visit verizon today. Price guarantee applies to then current base monthly rate. Additional terms and conditions apply for all offers.

[Kirby]

G L a M Los Angeles.

[Sarah]

Hi, Kirby.

[Kirby]

Hi, Sarah. Welcome to Los Angeles.

[Sarah]

Okay, I have something for you. Close your eyes. Close your eyes.

[Kirby]

I know what it is. Open your eyes. Oh, my God. It's all a boob.

[Sarah]

A different boo boo. She knows what it is, though.

[Kirby]

Okay.

[Sarah]

Oh, and it's open.

[Kirby]

Oh, it's not the surprise.

[Sarah]

Well, no, because. Well, it could be, actually.

[Kirby]

Oh, one could be. Okay, okay, okay. So apparently Sarah has like, a labubu dealer.

[Sarah]

I do, but he's all tapped out now, so I can't help anyone. I can't help anyone else.

[Kirby]

I feel bad because I really do not care about these.

[Sarah]

No, but you. But this one, you should. Cause it's so cute.

[Kirby]

And she was like, if you got a labubu, what would you want? And I was like, for me, it's the coca Cola one. That's the only one that I would even, like, really gravitate towards. So thank you. Okay. I have to open it.

[Sarah]

You have to open it.

[Kirby]

You have to do an unboxing. You have to do an unboxing. Okay. We know that these are loosely based off of where the wild things are. Monsters.

[Sarah]

They're monsters.

[Kirby]

This gives me the same feeling I feel when I see the Cheshire cat.

[Sarah]

Yeah. Unsettled up to no good.

[Kirby]

It makes me feel ill. Yeah. Like, that's why when I see people with them, I'm like, that's why I need to pray.

[Sarah]

I have this. Well, this one's with me today. I think this one's maybe with the eyes closed. It's like a little.

[Kirby]

I think I'm okay, but it's like, oh, it could be sleeping ready to attack at any time. It still makes me feel queasy.

[Sarah]

Have you seen Chloe? How do you say her name? Chloe Fineman. Feynman.

[Kirby]

Feynman Fenneman. I don't know.

[Sarah]

She did this video. I'll have to send it of her doing an impression of a labubu. And it's exactly what I picture. It's like, I'm mean, but I'm really cute. I'm cute, but I'm really mean. No, that's literally it. Okay, well, now you know which one you're getting.

[Kirby]

Is this. Is it the Coke bottle? Yeah.

[Sarah]

Open it.

[Kirby]

Is this a car refresher? What is that?

[Sarah]

Okay, so you don't have a bag. Cause this one's a special one. But now you know. Wow.

[Kirby]

It has a Santa cap on.

[Sarah]

I don't know why it has a Santa cap on.

[Kirby]

It's a Christmas version. It's a Christmas Boo Boo.

[Sarah]

Wow.

[Kirby]

Wow.

[Sarah]

Are you gonna.

[Kirby]

Now I feel like.

[Sarah]

Like, are you gonna put it on your purse or are you gonna put it in a display in your house?

[Kirby]

Probably. I'll put it in my office. I'm a little. I mean, honestly, I am a little unsettled still looking at it, but now I feel slightly territorial over it.

[Sarah]

Yeah, it's yours now. It's yours.

[Kirby]

This is mine.

[Sarah]

This is your child. This is mine. It's so cute. Look at the Coca Cola bottle.

[Kirby]

Oh, my God. I have cute aggression now. Okay, it is kind of cute.

[Sarah]

Oh, yeah. You can, like, take the hat off if you don't want to. I feel like people customize.

[Kirby]

We kind of look alike.

[Sarah]

That's what Benny says. That's what Benny drama says.

[Kirby]

This is so. I really didn't get the. Like, this maybe is not my truest match, because. Sarah.

[Sarah]

Yeah, I. Yeah, I do. I know.

[Kirby]

Like, acquired it, like, specifically for me.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

But it's kind of just like either having a child naturally or adoption.

[Sarah]

Totally. So this is adoption.

[Kirby]

This is my adopted little boo Boo, and I kind of love it now. The feet are freaking me out.

[Sarah]

You can, like, move it, too, I think. What, like, move the feet?

[Kirby]

No, the arms move.

[Sarah]

Oh, my God. I can't wait till Quinn sees this.

[Kirby]

Quinn? Is she not gonna be happy?

[Sarah]

She might.

[Kirby]

Quinn's my real life labubu.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

This is exactly what Quinn looks like.

[Sarah]

Oh, I like her nose. It's pink or it's red.

[Kirby]

I cannot believe it has a Santa cat. A Mexican coke in a bottle.

[Sarah]

There's nothing better in life.

[Kirby]

Truly. Truly. Thank you for my first.

[Sarah]

You're welcome. You're very.

[Kirby]

Maybe I will put it on my bag because I have a red bag.

[Sarah]

Oh, yeah. Just don't let anyone snatch it.

[Kirby]

I know. Because, like, this might be a special one.

[Sarah]

It is a special one. It is a special one. Yeah.

[Kirby]

Thank You.

[Sarah]

You're welcome. You're very welcome.

[Kirby]

Okay, now that we have given birth.

[Sarah]

To the Labubu out of the way, let's talk about a product or two that we're currently working. Really excited about. Okay, you start.

[Kirby]

Sure. So I went to this Kosas masterclass at Kosas headquarters this past week, and they had teased that we were going to be the first to try a new product that was launching. And it was really cool because I, you know, you and I have known Sheena, the founder, for a very long time. Right. When she launched the brand back when they were in, the lipsticks were in the black crazy block packaging, when she had the highlighter blush duos.

[Sarah]

And I think I still have those lipsticks.

[Kirby]

Yeah, I have them expired. Yeah. Hidden somewhere. Like, in, like, a library. Totally.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

We got to go through our entire makeup routine with her guiding us and explaining, like, how to use each of the products.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

And I thought it was really helpful for me because I really did not, like BB Burst when it launched. I thought it was an interesting concept, but then when I would use it, I just felt like it was constantly piling up in one area, and it was hard for me to actually utilize it because it's like a BB cream with moisturizer, and it's like a very hydrating formula. And I was just like, this is not my favorite. But then she provided us both foundation and the BB burst, and I didn't have the shade I needed in my foundation, so I used the BB burst, and I started going. And I think she could tell. I was like, what the fuck is going on here? And she was like, you really have to work it in with your fingers, and then you can take a brush or sponge and buff it out. And I felt like my complexion looked so beautiful. Once you get past the idea that it's not gonna instantly just, like, rub in, like, you have to really work it in. You kind of have to mix both the actual coverage with the hydrator that's within it.

[Sarah]

Well, we remember, like, when BB creams came out, like, you had to. It was almost like you needed to burst it to, like, really get that color out.

[Kirby]

Well, like the Eborian ones, right? Yeah. Because they had those color correctors in it, but. And this is, like, a similar mechanism, but it's an actual foundation. It's supposed to match your skin tone. So I was very excited to go. We did, like, our whole face, I was able to do. If you go to my Instagram, you can see the makeup I did. I used All Kosas. I only use Kosas, like brushes, tools. My eyeliner that day was so good, and I only used the actual eyeliner, so I used the smudger to clean up. I used the end of the, like, the little sharpener that they have on the end to make it super sharp. And I was very happy with it. So I. I felt like I fell in love with Kosas, like, all over again.

[Sarah]

See, I feel like it's always so helpful to have those classes to, like, one, refresh you on all the products, and two, really learn how to use it as they created it, as they intended you to use it, you know.

[Kirby]

And then you learn more too. Like, Sheena is very wellness oriented. Like, she's very in tune with spirituality. Kosas itself is like a spiritual term that she used to to name the brand. And so she was going through, like, this is why our packaging is this certain color or whatever. We got to the eyeliner. So the eyeliners are called, like, the Soulgazer eyeliners. I love these eyeliners. I use them all the time. They come in black, brown, but then like a red brown, and then like a blue black and then purple. Like brighter shades that you would want to, like, make your eyes pop. And she was like. Because I wanted people to be able to look at your eyes and think how beautiful your eyes are, not just like, oh, your eyeliner looks great. So. So then basically, like the sister to that now is this new mascara that they launched, and it's called Kosa Soulgazer Mascara.

[Sarah]

Cute.

[Kirby]

It's very cute. I love the component that it comes in. Initially, when she was telling us about it, I was like, I'm gonna hate it because it is a silicone brush, not bristles. And I was like, I just never gravitate towards a silicone. I don't think it grabs my lashes and makes them look as, like, long and voluminous as I want. But. But I was like, whatever. So I started using it. It's not a tubing formula. I know that's a question that's, like, really popular now. Is it tubing because it will keep from transferring and all of that stuff? She said that basically there's a mechanism in this particular formula that is similar to waterproof, but it's not waterproof. So it's easy to remove, but it's not supposed to transfer. However, it also is not waterproof. So if you have a problem with your lashes not curling, this may not. You might have to use, like, foreplay from Too faced as a Primer first before you curl your lashes. But I'm wearing it right now. In the images that we took at the event from Max Brauner, like, people were like, are you wearing falsies? This is crazy.

[Sarah]

Lashes look so long.

[Kirby]

I'm really impressed with this. I think it's because the way that this particular brush looks to me, it kind of looks like bristles in a way, the way that it's structured.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

The best part about it, in my opinion, is that you can keep applying and it won't clump. So, like, I'll just, like, go in and, like, bump every, like, couple of hours if I want to, like, add a little bit more. Va, va, voom. And I've been very impressed. Now, they. I asked Gina. Yeah, they did have a mascara.

[Sarah]

Yeah. Okay. Because I was like, I thought they had one.

[Kirby]

So they launched a mascara in 2020 called the Big Clean.

[Sarah]

Yes. Okay.

[Kirby]

And I think that this is my interpretation of it. At the beginning of a class, she was like, you know, we were one of the first makeup brands to really, like, fall into this clean category. But, like, clean is not something that we promote.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

And so I was like, interesting.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Yes. They do have clean marketing on. Like, if you're reading a box, like, clean. Whatever.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Clean at Sephora, and it's clean at Sephora. But I think they're trying to walk back the clean narrative in a way and focus more on it being makeup for skincare freaks, which has always been like, a tagline of theirs, instead of it being, like, this clean, darling. So I don't think that a product called the Big Clean really falls in line with that. I also don't think that product was as beloved as other Kosas products. I used it and I liked it, but I never gravitated towards it again.

[Sarah]

Did you help her with it or, like, did you consult? No. Was that not that mascara? I think I did. I feel like you did.

[Kirby]

Wow.

[Sarah]

I'm like, I feel like you consulted on it.

[Kirby]

Yes. I thought it was. I liked it, but I wasn't like, this is gonna be a go to for me. It had a curved wand, and I think it actually was a bristle brush. And I think that's why I liked it and made my lashes look nice. But it wasn't, like, my favorites, like, Mac Gigablack Lash or now, you know, Maybelline Falsies or whatever. And so I asked her, I'm like, is this in addition to the Big Clean? She said, no, we have sunsetted that product. This is our Sole mascara. So.

[Sarah]

Wow.

[Kirby]

We were the first to try it. It comes out July 31st. It's going to be the biggest launch for them. And I think that if you deal with irritation with mascara, this could be a really good option. It'll still give you that length and that fullness that you're looking for. But because you can reapply it, you don't have to worry about, like it irritating your eyes in a way. Like, I feel like the formula, there's no other way to describe it. It's a soft formula.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

So I haven't ever experienced, like, I've been wearing it for the past five days. I think it doesn't have fallout. Like, it doesn't have flakes. Like, it doesn't fall. Like, I love some new mascaras that have launched, but I've been seeing flakes on my face later. But it's like a soft formula. So it's like if you are reapplying it, you don't have to worry about it.

[Sarah]

It's like pretty lightweight.

[Kirby]

Yeah.

[Sarah]

How is it removal wise?

[Kirby]

So easy. Like, it just comes right off. It's not tubing though, so it's not like it's sliding off your lashes. I always use an eye makeup remover.

[Sarah]

Though, so like, that's mostly where it comes off.

[Kirby]

Yeah. I'm not like looking for my mascara to like wash off my face when I wash my face.

[Sarah]

How much is it?

[Kirby]

That's a good question, I believe. Don't quote me. It's gotta be like 28.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

Maybe less. Maybe more.

[Sarah]

Less than 30, probably.

[Kirby]

It's probably less than 30.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Again, we are like the first people to have this. And I was looking. It's gonna be obviously at Sephora. It's probably in line with like a benefit mascara too. Faced mascara.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

I am really loving it so far and have been. I've been like in a really good mascara kick. Like, I've been finding so many mascaras that I like, totally obsessed with, like Maybelline Falsies, Lash Lift, Love.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

The new Mario mascara bomb.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Also really love Mobs mascara that they just launched. That one's like, I feel like it has a thicker brush. So if you really like, if you struggle with a thicker brush. Not for you. And then this one, I just feel like we've been getting banger after banger.

[Sarah]

Technology of mascaras have really come a.

[Kirby]

Long way and so many mascaras are launching, like, I think it's like a mascara year for sure.

[Sarah]

Yeah. That's exciting.

[Kirby]

So, okay, what product have you been into?

[Sarah]

Okay, okay. Kirby and I have been really obsessed with the Violette FR Lip Nectar. It's been amazing. Right.

[Kirby]

It's such a beautiful product.

[Sarah]

Beautiful product.

[Kirby]

And Kulfi makes a similar version. Do they? Yeah. Kulfi launched first.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

And they have one that has been viral on TikTok that when I would go to Sephora, I could not find a shade to match it.

[Sarah]

Oh, yeah. Okay. Okay. So I haven't tried that one. So it's like a. It's a hydrating lip stain is how they describe it. It's $29. It really is like a stain. It goes on like a gloss, stains your lips and then you. It. You know, I feel like it lasts a long time and then. But then you're like reapplying it for that kind of gloss. So I've been wearing that a lot. However, colourpop recently launched a very, very similar product. This is the Hydra glossy lip stain. They sent me a bunch of shades. You probably have seen this too, because they partnered with PopSocket to do a very a la road. I don't have it with me, but. Because I just use my road phone case. But they have a popsocket that you put in the back and then you stick your colourpop lip gloss in and it's super cute. So I don't have that yet. I mean, I have it, but I don't have it on my phone. But I was like, I need to try these because the colors I think.

[Kirby]

Do they have a larger range?

[Sarah]

They have a larger range.

[Kirby]

Okay.

[Sarah]

So the Violette, I think they only have like three shades.

[Kirby]

I wanna say four.

[Sarah]

Four shades. Okay.

[Kirby]

And then I think Kulfi only has six.

[Sarah]

Okay. So the Hydra pop gloss has seven shades.

[Kirby]

Okay.

[Sarah]

They have seven shades, but the range is really good. So there's like a light nude to a pink mid tone pink, bright pink. There's a red browny plum and a deep berry. I've been wearing 90s babe, which is like this like brownie plum shade and blueberry marg, which is sort of like this like rosy pink purple.

[Kirby]

Oh, my God. Okay. You know what's so funny? We need to have a conversation about color. I would not describe either of those that way.

[Sarah]

Okay. This is like a what, a mauve?

[Kirby]

I would say mauve. That's more of like a pinky mauve with maybe like a rose. Like you're describing the other one as rose. I'm like, that's like a rose pinky mauve to me.

[Sarah]

Okay. Okay.

[Kirby]

And Then that one is more of.

[Sarah]

A berry, like, no, no, you're right. This is more berry. I said brownie pump because that's how they. They described it. But I do think this is definitely like, a mauve, like you said. And you're right. This is like a berry. I'm not very good at color description.

[Kirby]

No, I just think it's interesting because people have different perspectives on what certain colors are. Oh. You know what I mean?

[Sarah]

Yeah, no, totally.

[Kirby]

Like, some people think something is green, and I'm like, that's.

[Sarah]

Oh, yeah. No, I do have this conversation with Zoe and Kate all the time. Well, Kate doesn't really know his colors very well, but it's always like, that's blue. And I was like, no, girl, that's green. That's green.

[Kirby]

That's green. I'm constantly telling people something's green, and they're like, no, it's blue. And I'm like, am I? No. And then I'm like, I think I'm losing it.

[Sarah]

Am I? Do I need to get my eyes checked?

[Kirby]

Yeah, yeah.

[Sarah]

It's very strange. Okay, so I'm. The one that I'm wearing right now is the Brownie Plum Mauve 90s, babe. And I've been getting a lot of questions about it.

[Kirby]

It's very pretty.

[Sarah]

Oh, my God. I'm obsessed with it. It goes on like a gloss, like the lip nectar and probably, like, the kulfi. I do feel like the stain lasts longer.

[Kirby]

Oh, really? Okay.

[Sarah]

And I feel like it's a little bit. So my thing with any lip stain, it's not gonna be as hydrating as they promised. Like, there's just no way, because it's staining your lips and it dries down. Right. But this one, I feel like it really doesn't dry down my lips that much. And the stain lasts a really long time. So I've been obsessed. And it's only, I think, $9.

[Kirby]

Okay. That's incredible. Yeah. I feel like we're gonna see a lot more of this technology.

[Sarah]

I know. Is this where we're moving? So we were like, lip butters, lip oils, and now we're like, stains.

[Kirby]

Yes.

[Sarah]

Hydrating stains.

[Kirby]

I mean, obviously Sachu with their liner stain, Wonder Skin with their lip stain. And then people are, well, we want the best of both worlds.

[Sarah]

Totally. Of course. Of course. So I think you can get colourpop at Target now.

[Kirby]

Can you? Yeah, definitely at Ulta.

[Sarah]

Definitely at Ulta. You can get it at Target and then I think, obviously on their website. But I would pick these up the next time you are shopping at Target.

[Kirby]

Wow. I'm going to request these because that's.

[Sarah]

Sammy Elphis needs to send you.

[Kirby]

Yes. A bunch for sure. All right, we have. There's not a lot of news.

[Sarah]

Not a lot of news.

[Kirby]

But there is, like, one headline that's perfect. Been persistent. We can't get enough of it.

[Sarah]

Can't get enough of it.

[Kirby]

We can't get enough of hate watching it. And I have my thoughts on this, but, Sarah, what's going on?

[Sarah]

Okay, so we have been seeing photos of the upcoming Ryan Murphy series featuring JFK Jr. And Carolyn Bessette Kennedy. They released some stills from what, like a light lighting test. I don't know what it was. What was it?

[Kirby]

It was a camera test. A camera test, which is something that you do to make sure the lighting looks good. It's also something that you send almost as not proof of concept, because it's already been greenlit. But to the studio to say, this is what things are looking like.

[Sarah]

I don't know why they decided to share it with the public, because I feel like anyone who saw those photos would have been like, no, we're not ready yet. We're not ready yet.

[Kirby]

So, yes. Okay, so keep going. Keep going. Because there's more.

[Sarah]

So the first initial critiques were of their clothing. I think that was the first thing I saw immediately. They were like, what in the Zara Temu is she wearing? Because she is an icon. She is a fashion icon. 90s minimalist fashion icon. Like, she is just the epitome of chic, right?

[Kirby]

Capricorn.

[Sarah]

And she's a fucking Capricorn publicist. I'm like, come on. Everything she wears, it just like, she can make anything look really, really expensive and really, really beautiful and effortless. So effortless. And she's, like, not wearing a lot of makeup, Barely any makeup. You know, her hair's thrown in, like, a messy bun. You know, it's a kitten heel. It's like just the slip dresses, whatever it is. But you're like, oh, my God, I need what she has, whatever this energy is. Then it moved on to the hair, which that, to me, was, like, glaring. I was like, oh, my God. So, Kirby, what was going on with the hair?

[Kirby]

Okay, her hair was way too light. It was like Elsa from Frozen Platinum. It was platinum. This was also, though, during the lighting test.

[Sarah]

Lighting test.

[Kirby]

Okay. Then we get images of production actually happening. She's, like, running through the streets of New York. You see, like, a guy with a camera rig, like, following her, she's holding, like, a little. And she's wearing this silk miniskirt with a blazer and Chuck Taylor's.

[Sarah]

Yes.

[Kirby]

This is when I joined the angry mob. Because when Ryan Murphy released those stills of the lighting test, I was like, these never. Pun intended. Should never have seen the light of day, literally. He was clearly so excited and wanted to share in that excitement. But we never should have seen those.

[Sarah]

No.

[Kirby]

I'm sure wardrobe was so upset. And probably hair and makeup as well, because the likelihood of them using those. Those clothing. That clothing, those wigs is not. It's like what they had around and on set. And like, I talked to. When this was all happening, people were really upset about the lighting test. I was asking my friends that work in hair and makeup on films, like, is this final? And they're like, I just don't know why he released these, because they never would. This would never have, like, gone to set.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Then I was. But then we see the Chuck Taylors and I'm like, what the fuck? She was this.

[Sarah]

Literally probably have never owned a pair of Chuck Taylors.

[Kirby]

Well, we all. You're gonna eat your words in a second. Because thankfully we have really great fashion journalists that, like, get to the bottom of these things.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

So the first thing I saw was from Amy o' Dell. She has an incredible newsletter, Back Row. Please go pay and subscribe because she does amazing work. And she said that in her early days, according to the book Once Upon a Time, the Captivating Life of Carolyn Bessette Kennedy by Elizabeth Beller, Carolyn did in fact wear Converse.

[Sarah]

Okay. Because she had to run around New York, busy publicist.

[Kirby]

And then I got a DM from someone who is, let's just say, very familiar with what's going on with production of this show and said that that particular scene was before she was a Kennedy. So it was pre meeting JFK Jr so she was younger and she was not the immaculately dressed power publicist that we remember.

[Sarah]

Okay, okay, okay.

[Kirby]

This is further confirmed because then Lauren Sherman of Puck's Line Sheet, another amazing newsletter. Please go subscribe. Talk to Ryan Murphy himself.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

Okay. And love or him or hate him. This is why I like Ryan Murphy, because he does not do bullshit.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

So he's like, let's get on a phone call. And I love reading the transcripts of her interview with him because they didn't make it polished. So, like, what he's saying to her and what she's saying back, it's like their actual conversation.

[Sarah]

It's literal combo. Yeah.

[Kirby]

And he confirmed that nothing in those test shots, including the wig, would be used when filming. Those were photos that he had to show the studio. And that by releasing them, he was thinking that maybe the paparazzi would back off of the actors while they're filming in the city.

[Sarah]

Oh, God, I'm sure it was even worse.

[Kirby]

Totally backfired. He also confirmed that they are filming in chronological order and that that sneaker discourse that we were all so pissed about, myself included, was in vain because there are personal photographs that they are referencing for that particular look.

[Sarah]

And that's what you have to think, too. When all of us are yelling at.

[Kirby]

Ryan Murphy, he's like, this is not my first rodeo. What are you talking about?

[Sarah]

Right. And they have this whole team of people.

[Kirby]

Exactly. Well, exactly. Not only that, but they have an advisory board of 10 people that he said he didn't feel comfortable saying their names quite yet because he didn't want to use them for clout before he got permission to. But they are people that, like, friends. Friends study her. Like, have archival pieces of hers. And that in the fall, before the series comes out next February, they're planning on doing these mini short films on how they landed on particular looks of hers and what they did to source them. And if they couldn't actually source them, how they're replicating them and who they're working with. And that they're going to actually invite some of the dedicated fashion blogs. Cause Carolyn Bessette Kennedy has a worldwide fan base to this day, dissecting every look of hers.

[Sarah]

Totally.

[Kirby]

It's kind of like the Olsen twins, except they're still alive. And those fashion blogs will be invited to get a preview of that, which I thought was really cool. You should subscribe for Pucks in Her Circle. I finally did it to read this whole Ryan Murphy interview.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

And it's really illuminating. And I think it just proves that we all collectively need to touch grass.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

Like, we are not running these productions.

[Sarah]

Totally.

[Kirby]

We don't work on set. I'm actually. I'm embarrassed that I didn't wait to form an opinion before getting more information.

[Sarah]

Which we all should do, by the way.

[Kirby]

And also, I'm embarrassed for the people that didn't like that spoke publicly in the press.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Because I'm like, but wait, you could have been a part of this.

[Sarah]

But what about the hair? Okay, so the hair that we're seeing currently with her wearing, like, the Converse, this was pre.

[Kirby]

This is pre jfk.

[Sarah]

Okay? So, yeah. So truly, it could have been that could have been.

[Kirby]

More and more images have come out of her going on dates with jfk.

[Sarah]

And her hair was a lot lighter.

[Kirby]

Her hair.

[Sarah]

She did not have that toffee.

[Kirby]

No, no, no, no, no. Like, still images from set of actress Sarah Pigeon going on a date with the guy that plays jfk. And her hair color is different.

[Sarah]

Oh, her hair color is different already. Okay, good, good. Got it, got it, got it. So the hair colorist who used to do Carolyn Bessette Kennedy's hair when he was saying his name is Brad Johns. Margot and Buba. She interviewed him for Vogue.

[Kirby]

Yep.

[Sarah]

When he was saying they got it all wrong, he is referring to the camera lighting test photos.

[Kirby]

Correct.

[Sarah]

Okay.

[Kirby]

Which. That wig was never going to be used.

[Sarah]

Yes.

[Kirby]

You can even see when she. They post a video of it when she turns to the side.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

You can see that her hair is not even laid down properly.

[Sarah]

Properly.

[Kirby]

She has a huge hump in the back of her head.

[Sarah]

Okay. It was just for the photo.

[Kirby]

Like, no. Nobody working on a Ryan Murphy production would have let her, in my opinion. Wouldn't have let her on set with a bump like that.

[Sarah]

For a wig. Yeah, for sure.

[Kirby]

It's a really good wig from the front, though. Like, I was like, is that her natural hair?

[Sarah]

Totally.

[Kirby]

But, yeah, it's not the right color, but it changes. And I think the Ryan Murphy, he's kind of being bitchy in a lot of these interviews, but I don't blame him because people are speaking on things when they don't have the full. They've never worked on a set like this. They have no idea all the effort. He said, they're spending so much money. They're like, the money's being spent. He, like, went down all of the. Like, literally a line sheet, like, with Lauren Sherman, of all the items that they have procured that are, like, exactly what she wore in these, like, famous images of John F. Kennedy Jr. And.

[Sarah]

It'S also, like, we don't know. I mean, now we do, but we don't know when what moment in time that scene is. You know what I mean? Like, the fact that it is in chronological order makes sense now, but, like, all these people are just. Yeah, we don't know anything. We don't know anything. And I would be bitchy, too, because I would be like, let me do my fucking work.

[Kirby]

Well, Lauren Sherman was like. She said something to Ryan of the effect of, like, it was giving, like, 2023 Zara or something, and he's like, I assure you, like, this is literally we are sourcing this from.

[Sarah]

This is archival. Yeah.

[Kirby]

And also this is like, from a personal image we procured. It's not a public one that people have seen. Yeah.

[Sarah]

And you're also. That's a compliment to Zara then, right?

[Kirby]

And like, everyone is saying, like, never would have done that. And he's like, I am literally telling you that we have an image of her in these Chuck Taylors. That's why we are doing it in the first place. And she also mentioned something about a water bottle, which I didn't see this image. I don't know if it was just like, not promoted as much as like the one of her walking with the small coffee cup, but she mentioned something about a water bottle that felt really modern and that wouldn't have existed back then. And he was like, it was literally a run through so the camera guy could, like, get his footing.

[Sarah]

Well, like, calm down, everyone. Like, I thought that the photo of her in the silk skirt with the Chuck Taylors, I thought there was a photo of her wearing a similar outfit with heels. So that's why I think people were like, oh, my God, you got it all wrong. Why is she wearing Chuck Taylor's?

[Kirby]

So she, like an actual photo of her, you mean?

[Sarah]

Thought so. But maybe I am just confusing. That's what I thought.

[Kirby]

Well, I believe in Lauren Sherman's article, he says that she's wearing the Chuck Taylors, she gets into her job, and she changes into Manolo.

[Sarah]

So then that's probably it. Yeah, Yeah.

[Kirby]

I mean, I'm team Ryan Murphy on this one. I. I feel embarrassed that I was like, in a comment section being like, she's a Capricorn. She deserves better than this. Like, I don't know anything about Carolyn Bessette Kennedy in terms of, like. Like, I'm not reading these books. Right. Like, and then literally there is a book that's like, she often wore Chuck Taylor's. And I'm like, okay, this is why we can't speak on things that we don't know about.

[Sarah]

Truly, these experts need to come out and defend him. I know they're busy though, and they don't.

[Kirby]

I mean, they did. Like, Amy Odell at least did. But again, like, they need to be.

[Sarah]

Fighting in the comment section.

[Kirby]

No, literally, I would if I were Ryan Murphy. Like, I called in to ride for the Hitchhike episode. And I go, I don't know if this is probably never gonna be played, but I'm like, we need to start bullying people back. Like, I'm not talking about children. I'm talking about, like, if you are a grown adult in a comment section saying the most heinous things I've ever read about a human being, I'm allowed. If you're gonna say, this person looks like they were drawn by Picasso, I have a right to respond and say you look like you're inbred.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

No, true. Point blank, period.

[Sarah]

They're gonna play that for sure. That's definitely gonna be included in their episode. But I also feel I. I love when people post. For example, Amanda McCants gets the most insane messages from just gross men who feel like they can say whatever the fuck they want to her. And my favorite thing is her just exposing these gross men on Instagram stories.

[Kirby]

The men's photos and what they say. Yeah.

[Sarah]

And she doesn't block out their handle or anything. I'm just like, who are you that you can say this about her boobs?

[Kirby]

No. Men are deeply unwell.

[Sarah]

And I'm like, always men.

[Kirby]

No, it's the most and also like the most. Like nasty looking old women too.

[Sarah]

Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[Kirby]

Like, and I do not like judging people on looks, but I'm like, you're literally doing that. So I'm gonna give you a little taste of humble pie.

[Sarah]

Yeah.

[Kirby]

Because what, in what universe are you allowed to be saying this about another woman? Like, this is crazy. This is crazy.

[Sarah]

And again, if you were in person, would you say that to your face?

[Kirby]

No, no.

[Sarah]

No one would ever do that in person anyways.

[Kirby]

I do think Ryan bucked it up himself though. Like, he never should have posted those. Camera. Love you dearly, Ryan Murphy. Call me. I have some ideas for American Horror Story. We're going to get that back into scary times. But he never should have posted those. I get it. When you're excited. It's giving kids saying they got into a college or something that can actually get into it.

[Sarah]

There's a little BTS to satiate you, but instead everyone just took it and freaked the fuck out.

[Kirby]

It should have been the Barbie paparazzi images. Remember when we were seeing Margot and Ryan and Venice Beach? Let it be that don't like post these lighting tests where the studio can still be like, is the hair right?

[Sarah]

Are the clothes right? Whatever. But apparently everything is fine.

[Kirby]

Long time, long standing week long national nightmare is over. And they got the Kelly 40 or whatever, the birthday, whatever burger birthday she actually needed. That's full and open.

[Sarah]

Great. That's the only thing we are worried about in this climate today. In this world.

[Kirby]

Nothing else.

[Sarah]

Nothing else matters.

[Kirby]

No World War 3. Hard pass. Hard pass.

[Sarah]

We're just gonna focus on the Labubus and Carolyn Bissette Kennedy's hair.

[Kirby]

I'll find you.

[Sarah]

I mean, I am also cute.

[Kirby]

I mean, but I'm also cute. I am a little scared of.

[Verizon Representative]

Now at Verizon, we have some big news for your peace of mind. For all our customers, existing and new, we're locking in low prices for three years guaranteed on MyPlan and MyHome. That's future you peace of mind and everyone can save on a brand new phone on MyPlan. When you trade in any phone from one of our top brands, that's new phone peace of mind because of Verizon. Whether you're already a customer or you're just joining us, we got you. Visit Verizon today. Price guarantee applies to then current base monthly rate. Additional terms and conditions apply for all offers.