The Bellevue Killer // 521

Going West: True Crime

Published: Fri Jul 18 2025

In the summer of 1990, a serial killer originally dubbed “The Charmer” began his crusade of committing brutal acts of violence against Seattle-area women, then placing their bodies in crude positions before abandoning them. Locals were terrified of the perverse madman loose on the streets of their city - but, thanks to DNA and a few careless slip ups, a suspect was identified. And quickly, the evidence against him began to stack. These are the gruesome murders of Mary Anne Pohlreich, Carol Beethe, and Randi Levine - committed by the Bellevue Killer.

Summary

Podcast Summary: Going West: True Crime – Episode 521: The Bellevue Killer

Introduction

In Episode 521 of Going West: True Crime, hosts He Daphne and Heath Merryman delve into the chilling case of "The Bellevue Killer," a serial murderer who terrorized the Seattle metropolitan area in the summer of 1990. This detailed examination covers the brutal murders of three women—Marianne Pulick (Mary Ann Polreich), Carol Beith, and Randy Levine—and the subsequent investigation that led to the apprehension of the perpetrator, George Russell.

Case Overview

The episode begins with He Daphne issuing a content warning:

"There is resolution for this sick piece of shit behind it all. So I do want to give a little bit of a disclaimer because some of the positioning of the victims in today's story are not really appropriate for young ears." [02:20]

Heath Merryman echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the disturbing nature of the case:

"It's kind of unique of a story in a very disturbing way." [02:36]

First Victim: Marianne Pulick (Mary Ann Polreich)

The first victim, Mary Ann Polreich, was discovered on June 23, 1990, outside a McDonald’s adjacent to Black Angus Steakhouse in Bellevue, Washington. Her body was grotesquely posed, with signs of both pre- and post-mortem torture:

"Her arms were folded across her chest, and in one hand she held a pine cone. Her legs were outstretched but crossed at the ankles." [04:00]

Despite initial challenges in identifying her, detectives eventually matched dental records to confirm her identity as Mary Ann. The community was shaken by her murder, marking the beginning of the Bellevue Killer's spree.

Investigation Progress

Investigators focused on Mary Ann's last known whereabouts at Papagayo's Cantina, a popular bar among her friends. However, leads were scarce, and the case remained stagnant until a second brutal murder shook the community.

Second Victim: Carol Beith

Less than two months after Mary Ann's murder, Carol Beith, a 35-year-old bartender, was found brutally murdered in her home on August 9, 1990. Her body was similarly grotesquely posed:

"Her bedspread was pulled all the way down to the foot of the bed and she had been left naked except for a pair of red high heels... her legs were spread and bent at the knees." [15:07]

Carol's ex-husband, Paul Beath, became a person of interest but was quickly ruled out due to his genuine grief and cooperation with the investigation. Suspicion then fell on Mike Sewell, Carol's boyfriend, who exhibited concerning behavior during police interviews, further complicating the investigation.

Third Victim: Randy Levine

Three weeks after Carol's murder, Randy Levine, a 24-year-old secretary new to Bellevue, became the third victim. Her body was discovered on August 30, 1990, in her basement apartment, marked by brutal head wounds and posed unnaturally:

"Randy's face was turned toward her left shoulder and her legs were pulled with her knees straight upright." [32:10]

This pattern of posing and brutality hinted at a serial pattern, prompting investigators to consider the possibility of a single perpetrator responsible for all three murders.

Suspect: George Russell

George Walter Field Russell Jr., a 32-year-old resident of Mercer Island, emerged as the prime suspect. His troubled background included:

Early Life Struggles: Born in Florida and later moving to Washington, George faced familial challenges, including a hostile household and behavioral issues. By his teenage years, he was involved in petty crimes and started impersonating police officers, seeking authority and control.
Connection to Victims: George was a regular at Papagayo's and Black Angus Steakhouse, frequented by Mary Ann and Carol. He had known connections with Randy Levine through mutual friends, which positioned him near all three victims' social circles.

Notable Quote from He Daphne on George’s Behavior:

"George is very, very troubled." [39:30]

Investigation Leading to Arrest

The investigation took a pivotal turn when George was apprehended for posing as a police officer. Key evidence linking him to the murders included:

DNA Evidence: DNA from Mary Ann's body matched samples found in George’s possession, including fibers from his truck.

"Police ran the serial numbers of the gun found in the Volvo that George had been driving and found that it was registered to a neighbor of Randy Levine's and that it had been reported stolen." [45:05]

Motive and Behavior: George exhibited violent tendencies and had expressed disdain for his victims, particularly Randy, whom he derisively referred to as someone who "acts like a whore."

Heath Merryman highlights the gravity of George's actions:

"This is such a horrific story." [58:08]

Trial and Conclusion

George Russell was formally charged with three murders. During his trial in September 1991, the defense attempted to discredit the connection between the murders by blaming other individuals. However, the jury found the evidence against him compelling, leading to a guilty verdict on October 18, 1991.

"George was eventually found guilty and handed two life sentences without the possibility of parole, plus 29 years." [58:08]

He Heath concluded the episode with relief:

"Thank God he's exactly where he needs to be. In prison." [58:56]

Conclusion

Episode 521 of Going West: True Crime offers an in-depth exploration of the Bellevue Killer case, highlighting the meticulous investigation process and the eventual justice served. Through detailed narratives and poignant quotes, hosts He Daphne and Heath Merryman bring to light the dark chapters of Bellevue's history, providing listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the events that transpired.

Stay Connected

Listeners are encouraged to follow Going West: True Crime on social media platforms for photos and additional content related to the case. The hosts also announce an upcoming tour, inviting fans to join them in various cities for live discussions and events.

"Don't be a stranger. I like you guys staying with me." [60:03]

For more information or to participate in the community discussions, visit their Instagram at @goingwestpodcast and join their Facebook groups.

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

"Something's happening to us." – Host 2 [00:35]
"There is resolution for this sick piece of shit behind it all." – He Daphne [02:20]
"It's going to be okay." – Host 4 [00:54]
"This is the most shocking detail..." – Host 3 [16:11]
"You are fucked up." – Host 3 [17:26]
"You're a piece of shit." – He Daphne [43:03]

Important Highlights:

Pattern of Posing: All three victims were found in highly unusual and provocative positions, suggesting a ritualistic or symbolic motive.
DNA Breakthrough: One of the key factors that led to George Russell's arrest was the advancement in DNA profiling, despite it being relatively new in 1990.
Behavioral Red Flags: George’s erratic behavior, including impersonating police officers and his hostile interactions with law enforcement, were significant indicators of his guilt.
Community Impact: The murders left the Bellevue community in fear and highlighted the challenges law enforcement faces in tracking serial offenders.

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the key points, discussions, insights, and conclusions drawn in Episode 521 of Going West: True Crime. It provides an engaging and informative overview for those unfamiliar with the podcast while maintaining the depth and detail essential to true crime storytelling.