Summary of "The Dartmouth Murders // 470" Episode of Going West: True Crime

Going West: True Crime, hosted by Daphne Woolsoncroft and Heath Merryman of Dark West Productions, delves deep into the harrowing case of the Dartmouth Murders in episode 470, released on January 21, 2025. This episode meticulously explores the tragic and senseless killings of Dr. Susanna and Hoff Zantopp, esteemed Dartmouth College professors, unraveling the investigation that led to their untimely deaths.

1. Introduction

The episode opens with Daphne and Heath expressing gratitude to listeners and acknowledging case recommendations from Christine, Robin, and Alice. They set the tone by emphasizing the brutality and senselessness of the Dartmouth Murders, preparing the audience for a detailed exploration of this tragic event.

Daphne [00:21]: "Today's case takes place in New England and it was recommended by Christine, Robin and Alice."

T [01:15]: "Almost couldn't be more senseless."

2. Background on the Victims

Dr. Susanna Korzukevitz and Hoff Zantopp, both German-born, were prominent figures at Dartmouth College. Susanna, born on August 12, 1940, was lauded for her intelligence, multifaceted talents, and dedication to academia and human rights activism. Hoff, born on January 24, 1938, was a passionate geologist and outdoor enthusiast who overcame significant challenges, including a severe ankle injury and atrial fibrillation.

Their shared academic journey led them from Stanford University to various international postings before settling at Dartmouth in 1976. Both were deeply integrated into the community, fostering a warm and welcoming home environment.

Alan Fair [09:16]: "A rare creature, an intellectual with warmth and humanity."

Daphne [09:35]: "They were extremely, just lovely, memorable people."

3. The Murders

On the evening of January 27, 2001, friends Roxanna Verona arrived at the Zantopp residence for dinner but found the house eerily quiet. Upon entering the study, she discovered the brutally murdered bodies of Hoff and Susanna Zantopp, both covered in blood. The absence of theft indicated the murders were likely not motivated by robbery.

Daphne [00:18]: "We're going to be talking about two victims today who are married."

T [01:57]: "An investigation into their brutal homicides began with police initially believing it was a crime of passion."

4. Initial Investigation and Theories

Initially, law enforcement suspected a crime of passion due to the nature of the killings and the lack of apparent enemies. The crime scene revealed signs of a struggle, including toppled chairs and books, a bloody footprint, and two distinctive knife sheaths from SOG brand specialty knives.

Daphne [25:01]: "James Parker could not have been involved, despite the potential motive and the strange wound on his head."

T [05:21]: "Hoff and Susanna then relocated back to their home continent of Europe."

5. Media Interference and Rumors

A Boston Globe article fueled rumors of Hoff’s alleged infidelity, tarnishing his reputation without substantiated evidence. This misinformation led to public outcry and frustration among the Zantop family and law enforcement, resulting in a retraction and apology from the newspaper.

Daphne [20:58]: "A friend of Susanna and Hoff said with disdain, 'There is not a shred of truth to that claim.'"

T [22:08]: "And I just know that whoever put that out, that motherfucker got fired."

6. Breakthrough in the Investigation

The key evidence—two SOG knife sheaths and a large boot print—guided investigators to James Parker and Robert Tolik, two teenage boys from Chelsea, Vermont. Initially cooperative, the boys offered their fingerprints and boots to assist, but a match was later found linking Robert to the crime scene.

T [24:53]: "Because they were so helpful. And Robert had completely offered that boot up on his own, and now suddenly it's a match."

Daphne [25:56]: "It is not just about finding a match, but also about confirming the culprits."

7. Manhunt and Capture

Following inconclusive leads and the disappearance of the boys, a nationwide manhunt ensued. The turning point came when an Alabama truck driver, posing as a fellow driver on the CB radio, orchestrated a trap that led to James and Robert's apprehension in Spiceland, Indiana.

Daphne [33:03]: "When Bill casually questioned the boys, 16 year old James Parker told him that they were from Encino, California..."

T [33:12]: "He just is listening to the radio. He knows about the crimes that happened back in New Hampshire."

8. Trial and Sentencing

James Parker, at 16, and Robert Tolik, at 17, faced intense legal scrutiny. James confessed to the murders in exchange for a lighter sentence, implicating Robert. During their sentencing on April 5, 2002, the victims' daughters, Veronica and Mariana, shared poignant statements condemning the heinous acts and honoring their parents' legacy.

Veronika [47:42]: "My father's name was Hoff, which in German means to help. My father lived up to his name."

T [37:25]: "They had lofty aspirations of stealing boats and living a life of luxury in exile on the beach."

James received a sentence of 25 years to life with the possibility of parole, while Robert was mandated a life sentence without parole.

9. Aftermath and Parole Hearings

Years later, James sought a sentence reduction, which was initially opposed by the Zantop sisters but eventually granted in June 2024. Veronica and Mariana expressed a nuanced stance, emphasizing their forgiveness yet maintaining their grief and the complexity of teenage culpability.

Veronica [47:42]: "It's not about revenge for every collective year he's in jail. It's not going to make me feel any better about what happened."

James Parker [48:52]: "I've gone over it and over it and just finding an explanation for that. I just, I just don't know how I could do that."

Robert continues to appeal his sentence, citing the 2012 Supreme Court ruling against mandatory life sentences for juveniles, highlighting the ongoing legal debates surrounding juvenile justice.

10. Reflections and Community Impact

The Dartmouth community remains scarred by the murders, reflecting on the loss of two beloved educators and the profound impact on their students and neighbors. The Zantop family's resilience and Veronica's professional achievements underscore a journey of healing amid tragedy.

Daphne [52:06]: "It's always frustrating when kids kill, you know, or teenagers kill, because obviously, if they had been adults, they would not be up for parole."

Veronika [47:42]: "We felt strongly that it wasn't our job to comment on whether or not he should be released."

11. Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Daphne [08:54]: "Incredible woman."
• T [09:35]: "They were extremely, just lovely, memorable people."
• T [37:25]: "They dreamed of going to Australia and decided that they needed about $10,000 to do so."
• Daphne [39:41]: "If you look at pictures of them, they're very unassuming. They look like sweet teenage boys."
• T [47:42]: "It's not about revenge for every collective year he's in jail."

Conclusion

The Dartmouth Murders episode of Going West: True Crime is a poignant exploration of greed, misguided ambition, and the devastating ripple effects of senseless violence. Through meticulous detailing and emotional narratives, Daphne and Heath honor the memory of Dr. Susanna and Hoff Zantopp while dissecting the tragic choices that led to their untimely deaths. This episode serves as a somber reminder of the fragility of life and the profound impacts of criminal actions on a tight-knit community.

Thank you for tuning into this episode of Going West: True Crime. For more insights and discussions, follow us on Instagram at @goingwestpodcast and join our Facebook discussion group. Share your thoughts and engage with our community as we continue to uncover the untold stories of true crime.