Heath (2:22)

Well, without further ado, this is episode 574 of Going West. So let's get into it.

Rob Misla (3:05)

Just what Monique had told us stories wise of her. She never called him by name. She would just call him her ex husband and just how much of a monster he was, to be honest, emotionally abusive and threatening. You know, she did everything she could to extricate herself from that situation.

Daphne (3:25)

Since the murders of Monique and Spencer Tepe and the arrest of their alleged killer Michael McKee. An extradition hearing has taken place and police and family members have released more information that gives a closer look into what happened on that fateful early morning when two incredible people were ruthlessly taken. Talks of surveillance footage, a found weapon, abuse and terror have come out with police now classifying this case as a targeted domestic violence attack and a premeditated aggravated double homicide. This is part three of the murders of Monique and Spencer Tepe. If you haven't yet, make sure you listen to parts one and two of the Monique and Spencer Tepe story just to have a better grasp on what happened up to now because we're going to be doing very little recap in this one, so it's not too repetitive. So first we want to pick up right where we left off. One of the last things we reported in part two was that on Monday, January 12, 2026, 39 year old accused murderer Michael McKee had his extradition hearing for the murders of 39 year old Monique Tepe and 37 year old Spencer Tepe that occurred on December 30, 2025 in their wineland Park, Columbus, Ohio home. Now, what we didn't know when we reported this on the day of his arrest January 10th was that this hearing was going to be incredibly short. To be fair, most extradition hearings are, they're very cut and dry. But by the way, when he was arrested in Rockford, Illinois just before noon, he was charged with two counts of murder. But those charges were upgraded shortly afterwards to premeditated aggravated murder as police had evidence to prove this was a planned targeted attack. So when he entered that hearing, those are the new charges that he was up against. And apologies if you follow us on social media because this next small snippet may be familiar if you watched our videos, but the rest of what we have for you today will be totally new and not yet discussed or shared on our socials or TikTok. Now, the hearing lasted only about a minute and a half with Michael wearing a yellow jumpsuit, his hands handcuffed in front of him with a chain around his waist. As Winnebago County Assistant Public Defender Carrie Puyer told the judge, Mr. McKee believes the most expeditious manner in which he may defend himself against the charges pending in Ohio. And to plead not guilty is to waive his right to an extradition hearing and have a governor's warrant for his immediate transport. So let's break down what this actually means, what Michael's public defender is saying here. Is basically, we don't want to waste time. You know, they're choosing the fastest path to get him back to Ohio, which is, of course, where the crime occurred. Since he lives in and was arrested in Illinois after police tracked a vehicle seen on surveillance footage somewhere outside the Tepes home to Illinois to him, to his name. So by waving extradition, he's not fighting the transfer. He's kind of saying, go ahead and send me there. Because the goal is to get in front of an Ohio judge as quickly as possible, enter a not guilty plea, and start defending himself in the case. So now we know his intentions are to plead not guilty. And with what we're going to discuss today, and obviously knowing that a car at the scene was traced to him six and a half hours away, you're probably wondering, why the hell would he plead not guilty? Honestly, almost everyone charged with serious crimes pleads not guilty at first, especially in a case as serious as aggravated double homicide. Because it basically preserves his right to challenge evidence, preserves his right to a trial and whatever his defense strategy will be. Because later, like we've seen many times, Michael may try to even say that he killed them in self defense. Maybe he will admit to the killings, but not to planning to kill them, going to their home and then killing them. This just gives him wiggle room to decide potentially what to lie about. So this not guilty plea is very procedural at this point and not a statement about what evidence exists or doesn't exist against him.

Heath (8:24)

Well, on Wednesday, January 14, Columbus Police held a press conference to discuss the case publicly for the first time since Michael McKee's arrest. Columbus Police Chief Elaine Bryant laid out a timeline of events which we're all very familiar with at this point. Just breaking down what we already know about what happened at the Tepe house on Tuesday, December 30, 2025. Something police have actually admitted to since the release of our first episode on this story is that when they responded to the first 911 call from Spencer's boss, they actually went to the wrong house that day, which is why no one was answering the door. And I think something a lot of us were probably curious about was how they didn't hear any crying kids. When shortly afterwards, other friends and colleagues arrived to hear Monique and Spencer's kids, aged four and one, in distress. But it's because they were again at the wrong home, and they've taken responsibility for this error. And here's a small clip from that presser so that you can hear.

Chief Elaine Bryant (9:29)

Chief Bryant McKee is the ex husband of Monique Tepe. We can say that we have the suspect's vehicle on neighborhood video surveillance arriving just before the murders and leaving shortly after. Detectives were able to link this vehicle to Makee. The vehicle was located in Rockford, Illinois, and evidence was found that showed McKee in possession of the vehicle before and after the homicides.

Heath (9:57)

After this, Chief Bryant goes on to explain that multiple weapons were taken from Michael McKee's property, which we assume would be his Linkin Park, Chicago apartment, one of which had a preliminary link to the weapon that was used in the murders of Monique and Spencer. So it may have been multiple guns. It could have been one gun or other weapons. But one, the Columbus police are confident, was the gun that was used in those killings.

Daphne (10:25)

Wild. To think that he then may have just had the murder weapon in his home, not throwing it away, getting rid of it during that six and a half hour drive, like that's pretty wild.

Heath (10:36)

Yeah, you kind of would imagine that maybe he would have ditched it somewhere, but apparently he did not do that.

Daphne (10:41)

Would have been in his best interest, but we're glad he didn't.

Heath (10:44)

Well, Columbus Mayor Andrew Ginther also spoke during this conference thanking Chief Bryant as well as the women and men of the Columbus Police Department for working around the clock to solve this case as they are confident that they have the correct person in custody. When asked about a motive, Chief Bryant said that they couldn't comment at this time. When asked where he was taken into custody from, as we had previously suspected, it was maybe his job in Rockford, Illinois, at the OSFC St. Anthony Medical Center. They explained that their partners, ATF, the Department of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, took him into custody very close to his place of employment, either inside of or outside of a chick fil a up the street from his work, perhaps while he was grabbing some lunch. When asked about his whereabouts between the murderers and his arrest, they could not share that with us, but said that they do have evidence proving that he was there at the time of the murders. Other questions that they weren't able to answer yet for the sake of the investigation include how did he get into the house if there were no signs of forced entry? Did he have any interaction with the Tepes children while inside the home? Neighbors said that they saw Michael McKee outside of the home in the days leading up to the murders. Can you confirm this? Are you able to say anything about Monique and Michael's relationship while they were together? And how quickly did Michael McKee become a suspect? And really, the only additional information that they were able to share included that Michael mckee will be headed to Columbus, Ohio, and that will happen soon. But they don't even know when yet, as the planning is still underway. They confirmed that they received numerous tips that helped secure the arrest, Many of which were the same tips from family, People close to the family and the suspect, and also people in Columbus. So a lot of people pointing them to Michael. But interestingly, Columbus police never received any reports of stalking or abuse regarding Michael and Monique. So whatever happened between them, if there were reports made by Monique, they were not made in Columbus.

Daphne (13:00)

I'm glad that she was willing to share that, because I think that does potentially answer some small questions about reports. I kind of was surprised when she answered that, but that's good to know.

Heath (13:11)

And this part is really interesting to us because lastly, chief Bryant confirmed that the person of interest in the surveillance footage released was indeed Michael mckee. You know, the video that we shared and discussed in parts one and two, we. Of the. That man that was wearing the black jacket, Casually walking with his hands in his pockets down that back alley near the garages. Well, guess what? That actually was Michael.

Daphne (13:39)

She had just been saying the same thing over and over again, like, we can't confirm that, we can't say it this time, etc. And it felt like she was about to say that when a reporter asked if they could confirm if Michael is the guy in the surveillance footage of the person of interest, and then chief bryant smiled and said, we do. So. So chief bryant decided, hell with it. I'm giving them this one thing. And I felt like she kind of was hesitant to share that based on her facial expressions, But I kind of didn't think that would be the case.

Heath (14:12)

Yeah, because a lot of us thought, you know, maybe this could just be a random person. I mean, how lucky could we possibly get that the killer is seen walking in that alleyway and it's actually the person that was inside the tepe house? Well, now we know that that's exactly who it was. It was Michael.

Daphne (14:28)

Yeah. Cuz then you wonder, did they know who he was? Like, did they already connect the car to him? By the time that they released that footage, did they know it was probably him? Like, what did they know when they released that? I really want to know.

Heath (14:44)

And I also think it's very important that now not only do we have the fact that the car. His car was in the surrounding area of the tepes house, but now we can actually confirm that he was in that area as well. Like his person. He was there. It wasn't just his car.

Daphne (15:05)

Yeah, they confirmed it. Well, both the mayor and Chief Bryant pointed out that this was a targeted domestic violence attack. That is how they worded it. So based on their knowledge of the whole situation, that's how they categorized it. So let's dive into what the family has since said about mo' Nique's past relationship with Michael. Now, first, I want to say When Michael and Mo' Nique's divorce was finalized in June of 2017, they had already been living apart, of course, since their separation in March of 2016. After they got married, though, together they left Ohio and they moved to Roanoke, Virginia for Michael's residency at the Virginia Virginia Tech Carilion Clinic. But Monique wasn't happy living in Virginia. She wasn't happy in their marriage. So she went back to Ohio after they separated and started working for Nationwide Insurance in Columbus. Now, in 2017 is also when Michael obtained his medical license in Virginia. So he stayed there for a little bit before moving to California, Maryland and then Nevada over the next five years until 2023. That's when he left Nevada. It actually wasn't until 2024 when Michael obtained his medical license in Illinois and moved to Chicago. So he hadn't been at his current place of employment in Rockford very long. But these years, these few years of moving to different states were difficult for Michael, who did not want to move on from Monique. Rob Misla, who is Spencer's brother in law, married to his sister Madeline, just did an interview with correspondent of the Law and Crime Network and Jeanette Levy and revealed some of what the family knows about Monique's ex husband. He explained that he wasn't surprised when Michael McKee was arrested because he, and at least everybody in the Tepe family believed free from the jump, that it was Michael due to what they knew about him. Now, mo' Nique's family has not spoken out publicly, understandably so as they deal with this horrific loss and the media storm and just everything that's going on and finally laying them to rest this past Monday. But we can imagine that they know even more about Monique's previous marriage, of course. But yeah, so Rob confirmed that mo' Nique had indeed spoken about Michael before only referring to him as her ex husband. She never referred to him by his name. She never said good things about him either, only that Michael was a monster. This is coming from her brother in law on her, you know, husband Spencer's side and that he was emotionally abusive throughout their marriage. We aren't yet sure if he was like this before they were married or, you know, after they got married. He showed a completely different side to himself, but he was emotionally and verbally abusive, and he would often threaten her. Rob said that that marriage really changed her and her mindset and that he was kind of always in the back of her mind that. That Michael was out there because he was so unstable. Rob even said that she wasn't shy about talking of her past marriage struggles because she actually seemed very proud about getting out of that relationship and then finding such an amazing and supportive partner in Spencer. You know, this. This marriage with Spencer was completely different from her first marriage. So she was like, I can't believe that I was able to get out of this horrible situation and find somebody who truly loves me and treats me well. Like, she was so happy about that.

Heath (18:53)

Yeah. And the terrible part about this story is the fact that it really did feel like she had moved completely on with her life. You know, Michael is so far removed from her situation, from her kids, her new husband, Spencer. I mean, in her mind, she's probably thinking, I made it, I did it.

Daphne (19:12)

Exactly. That's. That's What Rob insinuated, 100%. So, of course, knowing all of that, when she was killed, according to Rob, the Tepes, her own family, and even friends and co workers of Monique's submitted tips to police to look into Michael McKee. I mean, even Spencer's family knew that she had concerns about Michael even years after their split, because Rob also explained that, like, it wasn't to a point, at least that he knows of, that she was worried about her safety or Spencer's safety or the safety of her kids. But he said, quote, she was always worried about him. So again, because Monique was so vocal about that relationship, she. She wasn't hiding that it happened to her. It was almost like he said it was almost therapeutic for her to kind of talk about it since he was in her past. But he also knew that she. There was a piece of her that was worried that he was out there alive. You know what I mean?

Heath (20:15)

Yeah. And I think that speaks a lot towards Michael's character. The fact that it just didn't feel like he had moved on. She never felt like he fully did. Just, you know, the fact that she said she was worried about him, it just feels like it didn't fully come to an end in her mind. Like, he was still right there in the back of her mind, like, oh, could he do something? He's a bit crazy.

Daphne (20:39)

Exactly. So I think that says a lot about what their relationship is like. We're gonna go into that a little bit more soon as well, because we do have some more insight. But I will add that Rob hadn't heard of Michael being, like, a recent concern. Obviously, it's possible Michael had tried to get in touch with her before the murders, but not that Rob had heard of. And of course, since Rob is Spencer's sister's husband, they were all very close. They were good friends, as is the situation with many couples and their siblings and their siblings partners. So Rob just said as far as he knew, it's not. There wasn't some crazy event that happened beforehand where. Oh, yeah, well, a couple weeks before this, he came to their door, like, there. Rob hadn't heard of anything that happened recently.

Heath (21:26)

Sure, yeah, it was. It was in the back of the mind, but it wasn't like, it didn't seem like it was an upfront threat, like something was about to happen. You know what I mean?

Daphne (21:35)

Right. More of, like, a passing concern. Unless something else comes out where she only shared with her mom this one thing, you know, but. Or her sister or whatever. But as far as we know, he was just a general concern, which is enough, of course. Now, before continuing to dive into this interview and all the updates, let's take a quick break.

Narrator/Announcer (22:17)

For the first time ever, a truly beautiful medical breakthrough promises physical perfection. One shot makes you hot, but with terrifying consequences. In the new original series, FX Is the Beauty. The glamorous world of supermodels turns deadly as mysterious deaths draw in FBI agents and a shadowy billionaire who will stop at nothing to protect his empire from executive producer Ryan Murphy. FX is the Beauty premieres January 21st on FX, Hulu and Hulu on Disney for bundle subscribers.

Daphne (22:47)

This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. A new year is a new opportunity to feel lighter, and you don't have to become a new person to do it. Keith and I could not be happier with making the decision to sign up for therapy with BetterHelp.

Heath (23:01)

I've personally been thinking about going to therapy for years, and I always just felt like I couldn't make that push. That's until I found BetterHelp. And they matched me with somebody that I feel like really understands my struggles and these different goals that I set for myself.

Daphne (23:17)

And it's so convenient because BetterHelp is online, so you can choose to text, talk on the phone. You can do video chat. Also, BetterHelp handles the initial therapist matching work for you. All Heath and I had to do was take a short questionnaire. You share your needs and your preferences and thanks to Better Help's industry leading match fulfillment rate usually get your match right the first time, but if it's not the right fit, switching to a different therapist is so easy. That actually happened to Heath.

Heath (23:45)

Yeah, I did switch therapists and I found the perfect one for me.

Daphne (23:48)

You can't step into a lighter version of yourself without leaving behind what's been weighing you down. Therapy can help you clear space, so sign up and get 10% off@betterhelp.com goingwest.

Heath (24:00)

That'S betterhelp.com goingwest how about starting the.

Daphne (24:06)

Year with a wardrobe refresh? Quince has you covered with luxe essentials that feel effortless and look polished. They're perfect for layering, mixing and building a wardrobe that actually lasts. Their versatile styles make it easy to reach for them day after day.

Heath (24:24)

From soft Mongolian cashmere sweaters to that feel like designer pieces without the markup to 100% silk tops and skirts for easy dressing up to perfectly cut denim for everyday wear, their wardrobe essentials are crafted to last season after season.

Daphne (24:41)

I seriously am obsessed with quints. I just got the most beautiful maxi slip dress and this faux fur jacket that I love that will be perfect for some fabulous little dinner this winter. But they have the most amazing sweaters. They have shoes, jewelry, men, women's clothes, everything you could want and it's all so high quality but for such a great price like there is no store like Quince.

Heath (25:05)

Refresh your wardrobe with Quince. Don't wait. Go to quince.com/goingwest for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns.

Daphne (25:15)

Now available in Canada too. That's quince.com/goingwest to get free shipping and 365 day returns.

Heath (25:24)

Quince.com/goingwest.

Daphne (25:29)

After the holiday chaos, cooking is the last thing you want to overthink. Home Chef is here to help you reset with simple recipes, fresh ingredients and meals that feel balanced and achievable.

Heath (25:41)

Home Chef is rated number one by users of other meal kits for quality, convenience, value, taste and recipe ease. It's the easiest way to get back into a routine without resorting to takeout.

Daphne (25:55)

Something I love about Home Chef is that they are so diverse. I'm a vegetarian. They always have vegetarian options. They have calorie conscious options, family friendly meals. They work with everybody and all their food is so good. Like right now they have filet mignon, steak frites with mushrooms and herby steak sauce, Asiago stuffed chicken with bacon Brussels sprouts, vegetarian tortellini and Marsala tomato sauce and so much more.

Heath (26:23)

For a limited time, Home Chef is offering our listeners 50% off and free shipping for your first box, plus free dessert for life.

Daphne (26:30)

Go to homechef.com goingwest that's homechef.com goingwest.

Heath (26:36)

For 50% off your first box and free dessert for life.

Daphne (26:39)

Homechef.com goingwest must be an active subscriber to receive free dessert. Enough dilly dallying. The new year is here. Stop putting it off and start that business that you've been wanting to start in 2026. This is your year. The year that you transform into an entrepreneur, founder, boss. And one powerful move will put your future firmly in your hands. Starting that business with Shopify.

Heath (27:10)

Shopify gives you everything that you need to sell online and in person. Millions of entrepreneurs have already made this leap from household names to first time business owners just getting started.

Daphne (27:22)

And as you grow, Shopify grows with you. Handle more orders, expand to new markets and do it all from the same dashboard. I am so grateful that I started my coffee company a couple years back. It was such a passion project and so fun to try and I couldn't have done it without Shopify. It was the best place for me to launch and I would seriously recommend it to anybody in 2026.

Heath (27:46)

Stop waiting and start selling with Shopify. Sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com goingwest go to shopify.com goingwest that's shopify.com.

Daphne (27:59)

Goingwest Hear the sound of your first sale this new year with Shopify by your side.

Mayra Amit (28:06)

Emoji moment from Mark who writes, I just want to thank you for making GLP1s affordable. What would have been over $1,000 a month is just $99 a month with mochi. Money shouldn't be a barrier to healthy weight. Three months in and I have smaller jeans and a bigger wallet.

Daphne (28:23)

You're the best.

Mayra Amit (28:24)

Thanks, Mark. I'm Mayra Amit, founder of Mochi Health. To find your mochi moment, visit joinmochi.com.

Daphne (28:32)

Mochi members have access to licensed physicians.

Mochi Health Advertiser (28:34)

And nutritionists and are compensated for their stories.

Daphne (28:37)

Results may vary.

Heath (28:52)

So also in that interview, Angenette asks, they were married for seven months and the paperwork's not filed for a year. Was this him trying to get back with her? And then he says, yeah, that would be my suspicion for her to, you can see in the court documents, just give up the house and not fight for it. It's Very obvious that she had to get away from him. And it seems as though he was not. He didn't understand why.

Daphne (29:19)

I think that's big insight that she was just like, take it, take it. I'm out of here.

Heath (29:24)

Yeah, because we know that they had that house in Roanoke, Virginia, for a very short period of time.

Daphne (29:29)

Yeah, it was a few hundred thousand dollars.

Heath (29:31)

Yeah. And then she just said, you know what? This is too much. I can't be with this guy. I got to get the hell out of here. And she goes back to Ohio, but he stays there. So, yeah, in order to give up that house, you really, really got to be done, you know?

Daphne (29:44)

And even after, like, of course, her moving out, she's like, I got to get away from you. But then even in the divorce, when they're going over their shared assets, the house that they purchased is one of them.

Heath (29:55)

And she says, fuck it. I don't want it.

Daphne (29:57)

Which, as we're saying, feels like it says a lot that she was just like, I don't want any more trouble. I got to get out. And I want to add, the last thing that Rob said in this interview was that this is just kind of like a spooky thing. Between 3:30 and 4:00am on the morning of December 30, 2025, which is the alleged timeframe when Monique and Spencer were murder, murdered, Rob was editing a video. He was, like, up really late working, because that's what he does for work. He does videos. And he heard his wife, Madeline, Spencer's sister, wake up and kind of move around upstairs and then go to the kitchen and get water from the fridge. And when Rob asked her why she got up, because, you know, she had been sleeping, she explained that she had a horrible pain in her stomach, like she had to throw up. But then she went back to sleep, and hours later learned that at about that very time that she experienced that weird nausea and that intense stomach pain, her brother was murdered. And Rob was just saying that he thinks, you know, maybe on some spiritual level, that she had this connection to her brother Spencer, as he was dying.

Heath (31:07)

We have seen this in different cases as well. There was. There was one case that we talked about where a mother had a similar experience. Her daughter was being killed, and this mother woke up in the middle of the night and just knew that something was terribly, terribly wrong.

Daphne (31:22)

Yes, I was thinking about that case, too.

Heath (31:24)

I don't remember exactly what the case was, but I do.

Daphne (31:27)

It was a while ago.

Heath (31:27)

I do remember that detail, though.

Daphne (31:29)

You do see that sometimes. And I think I've shared this before, but it really got to me when I heard Rob explain this, because my mom experienced something very similar. As many of you know, her sister Carol disappeared in 1984, and we very much believe that she was murdered. And the day she is believed to have been killed in Florida, my mom, who had just recently moved to California, was in a store buying wallpaper, and she just suddenly let out this horrific scream and had this terrible feeling and had to leave this store. And then a couple days later, she finds out that her sister went missing and was presumably killed that day. That. That happened to my mom. So it's really amazing that Rob has shared what he has. He's. He's really been the spokesperson for this whole case, of course, again, being the husband of Spencer's sister. So he's very close to the situation, but also maybe a little bit more emotionally available to speak with reporters.

Heath (32:28)

Yeah. Because I think a lot of the other family are probably at this point, very, very torn up and just don't really want to be in the media right now.

Daphne (32:36)

And he has said that. That, of course, everybody is so shocked and confused because, like we said, it was Michael was always a concern for Monique, but not enough for anybody in the family to even wonder, oh, I hope that he never. This never affects Spencer. You know, like, yeah, I hope he.

Heath (32:56)

Never ends up doing something. Yeah.

Daphne (32:59)

So they're just so shocked. But he said that they're all being very strong and just coming together for Spencer and Monique's two children.

Heath (33:08)

Yeah. And he also told ABC6, quote, Myself and many others were all aware of the negative impact that he had on her. She was willing to do anything to get out of there. And then a friend of Monique's publicly reported that Monique was, quote, terrified of Michael and that she left him after he had tried to strangle her. But she didn't report the incident because, you know, she didn't think that she would be believed at that point, as Michael was this charming surgeon in the eyes of many people. So it's really interesting here just knowing that not only was there some psychological abuse, there was some emotional abuse, but now we're kind of finding out that he had possibly tried to strangle her.

Daphne (33:51)

And it's so devastating that she didn't want to report it because she didn't think that she would be believed. And she probably hoped that. That getting away from him and divorcing him would stop the abuse. She, I'm sure, could not have possibly imagined that nine years down the road, when she's happily married to another man for five years and has two children with another man. That this guy was going to kill her. But as soon as they heard the news again, those close to her knew exactly who had done this. And actually her friend Gina, the day before this episode releases, did an interview with WBNS 10 TV in Columbus and gave a little more insight. So here's that clip.

Gina (Friend of Monique) (34:36)

If you knew Monique, you knew this was what happened to her. She never called. She never. I didn't even know his name. She never said Michael. She said my ex. She said it was. He was bad. She said abusive. I don't think I ever got the impression that she was afraid of him. I got the impression that she hated him and that she knew. She knew things were bad there. And I don't think it ever fully left her mind. I don't think anyone thought that this was gonna happen. I also don't think that she ever thought he would leave her alone for the rest of her life.

Angie Hicks (35:07)

Do you have any idea why now, after all of these years, that he's accused of doing this heinous act?

Gina (Friend of Monique) (35:14)

I think it's just because everything that you like, everything you see, you see the wedding video, everything that people see is who they really were. And they were so perfect and they were so wonderful. And I think he couldn't live with it. I think he could not fathom her happiness. And she was so happy.

Heath (35:35)

Yeah. And so that. That really does give us quite a bit of insight into their situation. But I believe that more will eventually come out during the trial. Now, in Monique's wedding vows to Spencer, she said, quote, from day one, I knew you were something special. I had quite a journey to get to you. Countless bad bumble dates, wrong relationships, and waterfalls of tears. But it was worth every cringing second because it led me to you. And I'm sure a lot of you guys have wondered if Michael dated anybody or possibly remarried. And according to friends who he had one serious girlfriend before mo' Nique and did not date seriously after their divorce, nor did he remarry.

Daphne (36:22)

I saw a woman posting on Facebook in a group about this case, and she said in, like, a few years ago, she went on a couple dates with Michael and that she stopped seeing him because he gave, like, a creepy vibe. I don't know if that's true, but I wanted to mention that. But I do think it's interesting and possibly shows us more into his mindset regarding fascination with Monique if he could not find anybody after they divorced.

Heath (36:53)

Yeah, I think that the connection there that they had or that Michael had to Monique. It was just one of those things where he really. He couldn't move on. He couldn't find somebody else. Maybe he tried, but it didn't really work. I think there was a certain level of probably envy here as well, knowing that she did move on. She did remarry.

Daphne (37:16)

And found an amazing man.

Heath (37:18)

Exactly. And had kids. And it's like he wasn't doing so hot at that point. And there's something that we're gonna talk about as far as his work goes, that relates back to Nevada, when he was living in Nevada. So, yeah, it's really interesting, the levels here that you can really see. See the jealousy and the envy that comes out. If, of course, he's responsible, which we all kind of believe he is, because I want to say allegedly.

Daphne (37:42)

Well, even police. Police are like, we are confident that we have the right guy.

Heath (37:46)

Sure.

Daphne (37:46)

But you're absolutely right. Especially knowing from Rob Misla that he did not want that divorce to end. Of course he agreed to it ending, but he did not want to split from Monique, probably because Monique is an amazing person and he is not.

Heath (38:04)

Well, a little bit more on Michael's personality and his past. According to friends, Michael was adopted and wasn't told until he started college. And he apparently had a very hard time accepting this. And his personality really shifted a lot after he found this out.

Daphne (38:20)

So much so that they said his personality took a 180.

Heath (38:24)

Yeah, this. This friend explained that Michael allegedly estranged himself from. From his adoptive parents and cut contact with them in 2017, which, as we know, is the year that he and Monique officially divorced. And apparently after he did so, his parents reached out to old friends of his, trying to connect with him again through them, but Michael refused to reconnect. So if that is true, and they really never rekindled that relationship, Michael lost potentially the love of his life and his parents at this at the same time. So this could give some sort of insight into his mental, well being leading up to the killings. Like, maybe he just really was feeling detached from a lot of people at that point. Well, let's talk about that Nevada situation and what went wrong there.

Daphne (39:15)

Yeah, this could be involved, too. This is kind of a potential like this sky is falling in every way and has been for a long time.

Heath (39:23)

And everything's kind of crumbling all at once.

Daphne (39:26)

Yeah. So I'm just going to do something horrible. We talked briefly about Michael's malpractice lawsuit in Nevada, and I think we did that in our Second episode. It would have been our update episode. Well, we have some better insight on that because Michael, along with others, were named in a lawsuit that alleged that he was part of a surgical procedure where an 8 inch piece of plastic tubing. That's pretty big, 8 inches. Was left inside a patient in July of 2023.

Heath (39:58)

So apparently they just weren't paying attention and left a fucking piece of plastic in someone.

Daphne (40:02)

Apparently it, like, disconnected during the surgery and nobody noticed. And then it just, like, went freely into his body, which is so scary. So basically, Michael was supervising the surgery performed by a different doctor. But the motion for this suit was filed only days before his arrest on January 6, 2026, with the lawsuit acknowledging that the incident was accidental, but caused the patient to undergo a separate surgery to remove the tube after they suffered pain, bleeding, etc. From this mistake. But it was Michael who apparently failed to train a physician's assistant, who then caused this injury. Or, well, you know, the injury that was caused by the tube disconnecting and not being removed.

Heath (40:51)

Yeah.

Daphne (40:51)

You know, before they closed him up. Well, interestingly, lawyers had tried to serve Michael nine times for months before he was finally served on January 6th. Because he fled Nevada shortly after this surgery happened, moving to Illinois and eventually buying his $400,000 condo in June of 2025. Now, the reason they couldn't contact him is because he had given a false address that didn't even exist, exist, and a fax machine number instead of a phone number to his previous employer. So when this patient filed the lawsuit, the attorney on his behalf went to try to find Michael to serve him. And this attorney is contacting the hospital, and they're like, here's the information we have. And the attorney looks up the address, and it. It's not real. It's doesn't exist anywhere. And the phone number is not connected to a phone line. So he's like, are you running?

Heath (41:53)

Yeah. It kind of feels like at that point when the murders took place, he was already on the run from something else.

Daphne (42:00)

A lawsuit a lot of people online have pointed out. Well, his photo is on the website where he works at OSF in Rockford, Illinois. And they could have just looked up his name and gotten his phone number. So I don't know if the attorney tried this and was just ignored, but either way, Michael was not reachable. This lawyer, Las Vegas lawyer Dan Laird, claimed in the lawsuit, quote, colleagues have no idea where Dr. Michael McKee is now. He just disappeared. So this was months before the murders happened. When that was written so that's just really interesting that people were actively looking for him while he was committing murder. But whether he knew what happened and was running like I said, or just wanted a change of scenery, we don't know. Like we mentioned, Michael McKee is set to return to Franklin county, where the murders of Monique and Spencer Tepe occurred just last month. But the date for that has not been released. They're still working on it, actually. At the end of his extradition hearing, the judge had set another hearing for Ohio for January 19th, which is this coming Monday. But that's actually a holiday. And according to reports online, it doesn't seem like that is still going to happen. And right now they are working. The police in Columbus are working with an extradition company, like an outside company who does this type of thing to bring him to Ohio so that there can be another hearing. He can plead not guilty, as he's apparently going to, and a trial date can be set. So we will keep close tabs on this one for when that trial is. But for now, the Michael McKee revelations continue to disturb us. Thank you so much, everybody for listening to this episode of Going West.

Heath (44:07)

Yes, thank you guys so much for listening to this episode. Like Daphne said in the beginning, this is probably gonna be the last part until that trial happens. And yeah, we're gonna find out a lot. There's probably gonna be a lot of bombshells and a lot of backstory that we don't know yet.

Daphne (44:23)

Yeah. Thank you guys for being on this journey with us. We feel like it's important and interesting sometimes to dive into multi part stories since we do come out with, you know, two different episodes a week usually. But now on Monday or on Tuesday, not Monday, we will be back with a new case for you guys. So thank you for being on this journey with us.

Heath (44:43)

And obviously it's very tough to cover these happening now cases because I understand that the family is grieving at this point. They're going through a lot through this devastation. So our hearts really go out to them. And again, we will put that gofundme in the description of this episode. So if you guys do want to donate to Spencer and Monique's children's fund, that would be amazing. Alongside us.

Daphne (45:08)

Yes, absolutely. So thank you guys so much. We'll see you on Tuesday.

Heath (45:13)

And that's it. You guys are saying, all right, guys, so for everybody out there in the.

Daphne (45:18)

World, don't be a stranger.

Gina (Friend of Monique) (45:46)

Sam.

Angie Hicks (46:34)

Hi, I'm Angie Hicks, co founder of Angie. When you use Angie for your home projects, you know all your jobs with will be done well. Roof repair done well Kitchen sink install done well Deck upgrades done well Electrical Upgrade done well. Angie's been connecting homeowners with skilled pros for nearly 30 years, so we know the difference between done and done well. Hire high quality pros@angie.com start your year.

Mochi Health Advertiser (47:05)

With healthy Restful sleep from Ashley Our New Year's mattress sale makes it easy with Ashley Sleep mattresses Starting at only 249/ take advantage of 60 month special financing on in store purchases made with your Ashley Advantage Synchrony credit card. That's a Tempur Pedic Adapt Queen Mattress starting at $37 a month. Upgrade to a mattress that supports your best nights and energizes your day. Visit your local Ashley store or visit Ashley.com to shop. More New Year's Mattress deals subject to credit approval. Minimum monthly payments required. See Store for details.