Loading summary
Transcript69 lines
- [00:02]
Matt Lewis
From long lost Viking ships and kings buried in unexpected places to tales of murder, power, faith, and the lives of ordinary people across medieval Europe and beyond. Join me, Matt Lewis, Dr. Elena Jarninger, and some of the world's leading historians as we bring history's most fascinating stories to life. Only on History Hit with your subscription, you'll unlock hundreds of hours of exclusive documentaries with with a brand new release every week exploring everything from the ancient world to World War II. Just visit historyhit.com subscribe.
- [00:43]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
Insurance isn't One size fits all that's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's Name youe Price Tool for years now. With the Name youe Price Tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they'll show you options that fit your budget. So whether you're picking out your first policy or just looking for something that works better for you and your family, they make it easy to see your options. Visit progressive.com find a rate that works for you with the name your Price tool Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and Coverage match limited by state
- [01:11]
Peloton / SoFi Mortgage Announcer
law Fuel your fire with peloton Instructors show up and experience our instructors breathing energy into your fitness. Need new workout buddies? Peloton Teams helps you find your crew and stay accountable with the support system. Don't just train, connect with others, crush the leaderboard and rediscover your momentum with the Cross Training Series.
- [01:32]
SoFi / OnDeck Announcer
Does it feel like your student loans are a permanent part of your life? It doesn't have to be that way. With SoFi, you can consolidate your student loans and refinance for the shorter term, potentially becoming debt free Sooner. Join over 580,000 members who have already refinanced their student loans with SOFI to take control of their financial future. Getting started is easier than you think. View your rate@sofi.com Next today, SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank NA member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891
- [02:05]
Matt Lewis
hello, I'm Matt Lewis. Welcome to Gone Medieval from History Hit, the podcast that delves into the greatest millennium in human history. We've got the most intriguing mysteries, the gobsmacking details and and latest groundbreaking research. From the Vikings to the printing press, from kings to Popes to the Crusades, we cross centuries and continents to delve into rebellions, plots and murders to find the stories, big and small that tell us how we got here. Find out who we really were with. Gone Medieval On a blustery September morning In the year 832, two armies faced one another on a battlefield somewhere in what is now eastern Scotland. One belonged to the Picts and Scots led by King Angus. The other was an invading force from the Anglo Saxon kingdom of Northumbria. Outnumbered and fearing annihilation, legend has it that Angus prayed for divine intervention. Then, as dawn broke overhead, a white cross appeared against the blue sky. Inspired by this heavenly sign, his warriors charged into battle and won a stunning victory. Whether true or not, the story became one of Scotland's founding myths. The white diagonal cross of Saint Andrew the Saltire remains Scotland's national flag to this day. And while the tale clearly riffs on an overused trope of medieval myth and legend, it also helps paint a helpful picture of the tensions, fishes and factions that ran through Scotland's contested medieval history. In the Middle Ages, there were many Scotlands, lands of Picts and Gaels, Britons and Northumbrians, rival kingdoms and competing identities. And yet, by the dawn of the early modern age, these diverse peoples had been molded into a single realm, one that survived Viking invasions, resisted English conquest and emerged as one of Europe's most distinctive kingdoms. I'm Matt Lewis and this is gone Medieval. Today we're taking on the rather ambitious challenge of plotting the complete history of medieval Scotland in one episode. Joining me is Professor Murray Pittig, author of the new book the Shortest History of Scotland. And together we'll journey from the age of the Picts and the coming of St Columba through the rise of the kings of Alba and the wars of Independence, to trace how a recognizably modern and vibrant Scotland was forged in the crucible of the Middle Ages. Welcome to God. Medieval. Murray, it's great to have you with us today.
- [04:54]
Professor Murray Pittig
Great to be here, Matt. Looking forward to it.
- [04:57]
Matt Lewis
I mean, we've been limbering up, haven't we? We're warmed up because we're just going to have a little thousand year sprint through Scottish history as quickly as we possibly can.
- [05:03]
Professor Murray Pittig
So that's it.
- [05:04]
Matt Lewis
All the pressure is on you. We're going to be ambitious. Let's start ambitious. If we're going to try and cover the, the whole kind of medieval history of Scotland, we need to obviously start at the beginning. So when we think about the fall of Roman Britain, who are the different kind of tribes and peoples that inhabited the land that we, we call Scotland? Who is there?
- [05:25]
Professor Murray Pittig
We have some Roman names. I'm not quite sure how much faith we should put in them, but we have got obviously the Picts. I suspect, though not identified, we got the Scots and we have the other Britonic peoples, such as the Votadini, those figures who are the heroes and the subject of the Gododin, the Welsh language epic, which commemorates their 6th century raid on Catraith Catterick in Yorkshire, which led them to get a bloody nose and a bit more besides. So those are among the central ones. The Picts are still called the Picts, but they're called that because in the 4th century they began to be called Picti, the painted ones, by the Romans who traded with them from the Adrian's Wall area and elsewhere. So they're the bulk of the inhabitants of the landmass that we now call Scotland. But although we used to think that the Scots came in as kind of Irish invaders in the 5th century, it's all a bit 19th century. If you look at very early Irish traditions, you're probably looking at a borderless Irish Scottish world in which there's Gaelic, although basically they were the same language then and for much later is spoken right across an area from the western shores of what is now Scotland to Cork in Ireland.
- [06:58]
Matt Lewis
Is there very much that separates those groups of people either in terms of culture or religion?
- [07:04]
Professor Murray Pittig
Religions are rather hard, again, to be exact about. In terms of culture too, you can see the basis of. You perhaps can even see it. I'm being maybe a little bit fanciful in the great hill forts like Traplane Law in the southeast of Scotland are the. The things that become central to Scottish experience. Association of family, association of institution or group, as it was then, rather institution and association of place. Who are you related to? How do we know each other? Where do you come from? Those questions. And I think all the peoples of what became Scotland have that to some degree. But of course we know the Picts and Scots best. And the Picts too, probably like the votadini, if indeed the Votadini can really be distinguished from. The Picts are Brythonic speakers, that is Welsh speakers, functionally.
- [08:03]
Matt Lewis
Yeah. And you sort of alluded to my next question, but I was going to ask about how important that connection to Ireland was for the west of Scotland and whether we should see the west of Scotland as almost part of an Irish group at that point.
- [08:18]
Professor Murray Pittig
I think that I probably wouldn't. I mean, yes, except I probably wouldn't use the term Irish. But I think the key element is that it was not until the 12th century that the papacy started to request that scoti was used as a Latin term to describe Scots and not interchangeably to describe Irish and Scots, mostly Irish, but sometimes Scots. They were not fundamentally distinct Groups, but then I wouldn't want to call them Irish either. If you mean they are a Scottish nor Scotch Irish, which is a different American term, but they are fundamentally Gaelic speakers who are ethnoculturally the ancestors of many of today's Scots and Irish people living in a continuum right across Scotland, Western Scotland and Ireland.
- [09:14]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, yeah. And one of the really early beneficiaries that we hear about of that, that continuum that you talk about is St Columba. Can you tell us a little bit about who he is and the work that he does to Christianise Scotland?
- [09:26]
Professor Murray Pittig
Well, St Columba was a member of the Irish nobility, a princely family, and he comes to Scotland, or rather, I suppose what we might. He's active both with the Picts and the Scots, but sets up the monastery at Iona, which is very much in the Scoto Irish or Scoti kind of world in the West. Coming from a situation where he's effectively probably mixed up in a murder in what is now Ireland, but becomes nonetheless an important religious leader. And one of the things he does is he. He carries out very close relationships and relationship building with the kings of Scotia and the kings of Pictland. And as a result from Columba's alliance with the crown, or the crowns at that stage comes the development of a medieval Scottish polity which very closely links the king and the Church and the person of Columba as the symbol of clerical and royal authority. And of course, there, Aidan, his monk, who writes the Life of St Columba was very important too, in spreading the image and story of Columba. And it's of course, in the Life of Saint Columba we get the first reference to the Loch Ness Monster, at least it happens to be in the River Ness. But let's not worry too much about details.
- [10:56]
Matt Lewis
No, no, no, we'll just keep it in slop ness. So should we consider that early connection between the Church and the state, for want of a better phrase, is that important in the development of Scottish nationhood from that point onwards?
- [11:12]
Professor Murray Pittig
It is, I think. I think the Synod of Whitby and the resolution of. Of the date of easter in the 7th century, which is seen fundamentally by. In the 19th century, was seen as some kind of struggle between the ancient Celtic Church and alien Catholic power, but is actually really a debate between a left behind group who hadn't yet caught up with the changing dates way of calculating the date of Easter and modern thought past then, for modern thought within the Western Catholic Church, the sense of the crown and the Church as involved in a project of joint mutual support of modernization. Both then and much later in the reign of Bielcholach III and Queen Margaret becomes Saint Margaret, who also does a great deal to change and develop and improve the Scottish Church, though without despising its past. But it brings it more into the presentation, perhaps more into the European mainstream. Yes, that remains absolutely central to the way in which the church and crown developed together in Scotland, not least in the, you know, David I in the 12th century is called a sersangt for the croon because he imports and develops and pays for so many religious foundations. And in doing that he stretches the Scottish state's ability to pay. And by the time of the Little Ice Age, when climate, the climate was turning down and Scotland is not so productive as it had been at the close of the 13th century, then that was one of the things that triggered the Reformation, because Scotland had huge amount of productive capacity invested in the church and in religious orders.
- [12:56]
Matt Lewis
From around the 8th century, we begin to see the emergence of some much more clearly kind of defined Scottish kingdoms like Alba and Outclut that goes on to become Strathclyde and Benicia. Why do you think we're beginning to see these things solidify and do you think there's any influence there from increasing Viking incursions?
- [13:16]
Professor Murray Pittig
The short answer to that is yes. I mean, at least some part of the crystallization of politics in Scotland comes from external pressure. Two kinds of external pressure. First of all, pressure from Northumbria and Benicia is really part of the Northumbrian realm to the south. And also pressure from the Vikings from the end of the 8th, beginning of the 9th century from the north and east. But I think there's also the question as the extent to which Reged, as it's called, and some of the kingdom, some of the Welsh speaking kingdoms in what's now the northwest of England and Alt Strathclyde have a commonality in the sense that we know very little about them really, but they probably have a strong degree of cultural commonality. Colt Klut is permanently. Because they're both Welsh speakers and they don't think they're English and Scots. They think they're the same sorts of people and they probably are. The extent to which political borders are important between them is I think, maybe a bit moot in the early part of this period. Certainly Strathclyde ot never recovers from the Viking siege of 870 on Dumbarton Rock, their hilltop capital. And although they move the head of the kingdom to govern in what is now Glasgow. They never, I think, properly recover from the strength they had before that. It's very interesting because that's the same year870, that a huge army is raised in England by the Danes for the Viking kingdom of York to challenge effectively those first few years of the reign of Alfred the Great. A huge challenges from Vikings in England too. So there's a degree of similarity in the emergence of both England and Scotland as polities, and they actually develop at the same time. So when Constantine II defeats the Vikings at Strathearn in 904, he's the, you know, he's the last king to be called King of the Picts and King of the Scots. We traditionally associate the Scottish kingdom uniting with Kenneth MacAlpin in the 840s, but that's more of a convenience. He was probably king of both, but there had been kings of both before. But really by the time of Constantine ii, but likewise, it was really Edward the Elder and even more clearly Athelstan, he united the English kingdom. And that's really very close in time to the uniting of the Scottish kingdom under Constantine. But the critical reason. There are probably two reasons why a different kingdom developed in the north of the island. The first is quite simply Hadrian's Wall and the persistence of the wall. After all, the Kingdom of Scots always wanted the land, at least to the wall until the 13th century, didn't always have it, but intended to pursue it. And also the second is the defeat of the Northumbrian warband by Bride III and his allies at Dunnichan near Forfar, in AD 685. So that's. I mean, that probably is the first decisive battle of what becomes Scottish history, because it stops Northumbrian incursion into Scotland.
- [16:30]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, yeah. And how significant during this period are the. The kings of Alba?
- [16:35]
Professor Murray Pittig
The first kings really of Alba, as it's. As the term is used, is are Constantine II and his successors, rather than kings of the Scots and Picts. There's a Scottish habit which you can discern early in the medieval period of being more aggressive than you can actually get away with. And Constantine gets himself fundamentally in trouble with Aethelstan, who makes. Athelstan has got designs in being of being Bret Valder, overlord of the whole of the Roman province of Britannia, but he also has designs on places that were outside the ruined province of Britannia in Scotland. And he defeats Constantine. Constantine effectively goes down to Buckingham to give homage to Akelstown as a sub king. He's given the first place among sub kings in the island. But nonetheless it seems to have annoyed him because the first thing he does when he goes back is raise a great allied army with the Danes in the north of England to attack and hopefully overthrow Athelstan. And the battle takes place. The best site we have, we're not certain, is in the Wirral Brunambara. And Constantine is defeated. I have to say he was a trier. I mean, he must have been getting on for 70 when that battle was fought. But he was clearly so determined not to accept Athelstan's overlordship that he went for total overthrow and lost.
- [18:11]
Matt Lewis
Yeah. Which does point to a clearly kind of defined and identifiable sense of Scottishness and independence, at least from England as it's emerging at this point. So in Constantine's mind and those of his followers, there must have been a sense that they were Scottish now.
- [18:27]
Professor Murray Pittig
Well, I think we're not probably. There's still a number of peoples in Scotland. We know there are a number of peoples in Scotland who identify separately. However, it's also how your enemies identify you. So the Anglo Saxons start using the term Scots in the early mid 10th century. So yes, they are identifying the forces opposing them as a unitary force. Sometimes, of course, these things aren't, you know, but they're categorized as such by those fighting them and occasionally by themselves. So that seems to have happened to some extent.
- [19:02]
Matt Lewis
And is it around this time too that we get the emergence of the St Andrew Saltire as the kind of flag of Scotland, allegedly.
- [19:10]
Professor Murray Pittig
So it's of an earlier, an even earlier date, and is supposed to have appeared in Lothian as a sign in the sky and not two jet trails, but two traces of cloud crossed over a blue sky. But we don't actually see it used by the Scotland explicitly or by the Scottish army until much later in the medieval period. So it's possibly there, but we don't know it's there.
- [19:35]
Matt Lewis
It might just have been giving it sort of ancient origins, mythical origins, when they start using it.
- [19:40]
Professor Murray Pittig
Indeed, it's not one which has got claims to be the oldest flag with a Danish flag in Europe. Whether it is or not is another matter.
- [19:47]
Matt Lewis
I'm not going to disagree. How do the kings of Alba then start to. To spread their influence south? Because they'll reach out into areas that are covered by Northumbria, for example. Are they. Are we seeing them take advantage there of. Of again, Viking incursions into England and the Norman invasion in the south of England? Are the Scots in the north seeing that as an opportunity for them to take some land.
- [20:08]
Professor Murray Pittig
The Scots in 1018 at Caram effectively drive Northumbria out of what is now Scotland and that starts to shift the border to the Tweed. Northumbria up till that point probably had about 30 miles or 35 miles of territory inside what's now Scothon on the east coast. But Scotland was taking advantage of what I think is, you know, this is not how it features in English history, but what was effectively the collapse of the Anglo Saxon kingdom, Ethelred the Unread, is incompetence and brutality. The fact that first of all Sweyn Fortbeard and then his successor Canute turned it into a Danish or quasi Danish polity. So there were a lot of problems. And it wasn't until Edward the Confessor came to Power in 1042 that Scott's ambitions were reined in. After the conquest, there is a real geopolitical moment when Edgar Atheling, the heir presumptive to the throne after the death of Harold II Hastings and visitors to the British Museum this summer can decide whether or not he's being knocked down by a spear or an arrow, since both are possible. In the Bayou Tapestry, Edgar Atheling and his sister Margaret under the Scottish court and Malcolm III marries Margaret. And he also tries to support Northumbria, always a semi detached part, indeed, till rather later than this, in some ways a semi detached part of the English kingdom. But to support Northumbria as a stalking horse, to push William, to push William out, or at least partly out. It's possible. Zadar Atheling had promised Malcolm Yorkshire as well as Northumberland if he were to restore him to the Saxon throne, but doesn't work. William responds, as William and his successors certainly knew how, with the utmost brutality. And Malcolm III falls back into Scotland, but he keeps on. I mean, his children by Margaret all are very robust Anglo Saxon names. And he's obviously looking to the possibility of the children by his first Celto Norse wife as being son and heir there becoming King of Scots and possibly one of his sons by Margaret becoming king in England. So once again, this inordinate, one might say, geopolitical level of ambition for somebody who is much less well off than William in terms of troops, resources, power.
- [22:59]
Matt Lewis
He's dreaming big, though. You've got to love that.
- [23:01]
Professor Murray Pittig
He's dreaming big. And then of course, he gets killed in a squabble at, at Alnwick in 1093. So that is the end of him.
- [23:09]
Matt Lewis
Yeah. How much of a sense do we have about how the Scots kingdom is governed at this point, is there an identifia capital, Is it quite a centralized system or is it delegated into regions?
- [23:21]
Professor Murray Pittig
No, it's. It's very decentralized effectively. There are large scale lords in terms of peace, military leaders in terms of war, which we call more mares. The term is a bit slippery. Some more mares thought of themselves, particularly those from the family of Macbeth, who of course became King of Scots as sub kings or indeed kings, and their persistent problems from that family against what you might call the central power. But the central would have to be an inverted commas. And some became great territorial. Probably came the great territorial magnates like the Earl of Fife who succeeded them. One of the things you see about in Scotland as opposed to England is that lordships and names such as Earl of Fife are linked with lots of lands in Fife, whereas the Duke of Norfolk, say may have tons of lands in Yorkshire and you know, the Earl of Salem, lots of lands in the north as well, that they're not linked clearly linked to geographical leadership. But in Scotland they really do tend to be. And that's a difference which reflects the decentered nature of the polity. If we were to go slightly later in, that was in some ways part of the salvation of Scotland, because to some extent some of the Franco Norman nobility who didn't conquer but were invited in by King David I in the 12th century, although they'd actually been first invited in by Macbeth in the 1050s, but not to settle. But some of them in the 12th century thought to themselves they made kindred who held title in England and certainly in France, that actually the Scots King was significantly less able to tell them what to do. I mean, of course they still did a lot of what they wanted to do in England and France, but the Scots King was really a lot less able at holding them back. And so they thought when the time came of crisis at the end of the 13th century, well, we might support the Scots King because actually we get to do what we like here. So that's all.
- [25:43]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
- [26:03]
SoFi / OnDeck Announcer
Does it feel like your student loans are a permanent part of your life? It doesn't have to be that way. With SoFi, you can consolidate your student loans and refinance with a shorter term, potentially becoming debt free Sooner. Join over 580,000 members who have already refinanced their student loans with SOFI to take control of their financial future. Getting started is easier than you think. View your rate@sofi.com Next Today, SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank NA member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696-891 Funny Thing about about your
- [26:35]
Peloton / SoFi Mortgage Announcer
mortgage, it kind of runs on autopilot. Same payment, same rate month after month. But SoFi can help make it work harder for you. Explore refinancing options like lowering your monthly payment or tapping into your home equity for cash so your mortgage is a better fit for your lifestyle. Take your mortgage off AutoPilot today. Visit sofi.com powermove Mortgages originated by SoFi bank in a member FDIC NMLS 696. Terms and conditions apply.
- [27:02]
SoFi / OnDeck Announcer
Equal Housing Lender Ondeck is built to back small businesses like yours. Whether you're buying equipment, expanding your team or bridging cash flow gaps, Ondeck's loans up to $400,000 help make it happen fast. Rated A by the Better Business Bureau and earning thousands of five star Trustpilot reviews, OnDeck delivers funding you can count on. Apply in minutes@ondeck.com depending on certain loan attributes, your business loan may be issued by Ondeck or Celtic Bank. Ondeck does not lend in North Dakota. All loans and amounts sub to lender approval.
- [27:49]
Matt Lewis
And we we begin to see a period from the kind of the 12th century onwards in which under kind of David I, William the Lion, Alexander ii, there's this switching between kind of allying with the English and fighting against the English. And they tend to have fairly generally quite bad relationships with the Plantagenet kings, but sometimes not quite so bad too. Why do you think Scottish kings are becoming so connected to English kings at this point?
- [28:16]
Professor Murray Pittig
Well, I think first of all Scotland provides under David I Scotland provides again advantageously because England's got a civil war between Stephen and Matilda, a major political and military threat to England. The Scots crown backs Matilda because she's the Holy she is the Holy Roman Empress and she is also the granddaughter of Male Column iii. So she is Scotland's, if you think by that biggest geopolitical counter and in doing so, David I, the English crown still wants to claim so the English church wants to claim suzerainty over the Scottish Church. David I argues that there should be a I mean there are arguments for the Scots having majority of their own church as they come to do, but David actually thinks about settling up the headship of the primacy of the church at York, because he has every intention of capturing York and he doesn't. He's not far off it. He exerts very significant power across the north of England, more than any other Scottish king does. And that sets up a reaction because Stephen, who dies in 1154, succeeded by Henry II, Henry II is, even at this distance, a hell of a tough bastard. David has just died, David's son and heir has just died. And we're left with the teenage male column iv, who goes to see, you know, Henry to ensure that his claims can be upheld. And Henry tells him to sod off, basically, and, and that he's got to sign up for giving them all away. And basically he backs down because he's a teenager and Henry's a thug. And also, Henry is quite prepared to deploy not only English power, but now the lands of his queen, which involve very significant possessions in the west of France. So he's a very powerful king. But then when William the Lion comes to contest with Henry, and indeed he dedicates the arbroath Abbey to St Thomas of Becket, particularly just to thumb his nose at Henry, because Henry's had Thomas of Becket killed, he loses critically, effectively becomes a dependent of the English king and Henry is allowed to intrude some English occupation, in theory anyway, to some extent in practice, into southern Scotland and also hold William effectively under his thumb. It's very dynamic at this stage because Richard I, who really wants to go and kill Saracens in the Holy Land, basically allows William to buy back all his rights with a substantial cash payment which the Scottish state raises for their king. And William continues then to extend his power in Scotland, but once again runs into trouble because he's seen as too close to foreign interests and it needs John to help him put down a revolt in 2011. 12. So it's all over the place then. The biggest, I think the thing that probably comes to a non Scottish audience and to some Scottish audiences comes as the most surprising answer to the question, how far has Scottish army ever advanced into England? Occurs in 1215. 16, when Alexander II, taking advantage of John's weakness at this point, brings Scotland's army to Dover, with the aim of which he does of offering homage to King Louis of France for a whole range of lands he's taken over in the north of England. And it must be said, the barons in Yorkshire submit and the north generally submit to Alexander ii. And it's only because the King Louis is Eventually defeated by the now, John dies fortuitously and Henry III comes to power. Only because the French king is defeated does Alexander II lose a very advantageous position. But he does lose it eventually he has to put up with the quick claim of York in 1237, which means fundamentally that Scotland gives up its claim to the northern counties of England down to the wall and in some cases beyond. And it establishes what is perhaps Andorra has a case, but I'm not quite sure how good a case it is. What is arguably the earliest land border in Scotland because apart from Berwick and a few square kilometers around the Solway for debatable land, rather Solway froth, the border set at the quick claim of York between England and Scotland almost 800 years ago is the border we have today.
- [33:14]
Matt Lewis
I'm always fascinated during this period, during the anarchy with David and as you mentioned there with Alexander, you know, getting submission from the barons of the the north of England, the English in the north at least don't seem too concerned about being ruled by Scotland. You know, when David is in charge of the north of Scotland, everyone seems actually fairly comfortable.
- [33:31]
Professor Murray Pittig
It absolutely. I don't think it's a big deal for the baronial classes at this stage. I think it's probably and indeed possibly for ordinary people it's harder to know. I think it's probably the extent of wars in the round the Scottish wars of Independence and the extent of attacks on the north of England by the Scottish crown in that period which are critical though it must be said that they were slaving raids on the north of England to carry off principally women, but not just women for enslavement in Scotland which can't exactly have been popular.
- [34:07]
Matt Lewis
How significant a problem for Scotland was the death of Alexander III without a clear male heir because they've had a good long strong run of kings by
- [34:16]
Professor Murray Pittig
this point it was enormously significant, absolutely enormously moderate who was the heir. And of course once again like male column iv, it was Scotland's misfortune to have a highly aggressive and very well armed and organized Plantagenet king in the shape of Edward I on the throne south of the border. Margaret dies on the voyage to Scotland and effectively an interregnum succeeds and Edward is called in to adjudicate because there isn't a clear successor to the crown. And he makes certain claims he won't adjudicate unless people say that he's the supreme authority. And although sometimes in later controversy this is made a lot of I think for most people it wasn't necessarily a big deal to say, Edward, you're the supreme authority here. They weren't saying, yeah, you owners lock, stock and barrel. It was a formal submission so that he could make the decision. But of course it was to have terrifically bad consequences because he chose King John rather than the very elderly Robert V to Bruce Robert, the competitor who was probably. Which shows the medieval. He was probably 77 at the time that John Balliol became king. His competitor was 77. So medieval people didn't always peg out at 45. But John Balliol, of course, drawing on the significantly Franco Norman and French sympathizing nobility, concluded the old alliance with France in 1296. And that was quite clearly seen by Edward I as a stab in the back. It's not as if this hadn't been coming. Scots were active on the French side in crusades in the 13th century. There's a very clear tendency under Alexander II and Alexander III to move closer to France. In Alexander III's time, people start to complain about English barons, all those clearly majority of their interest in England, whole land in Scotland. So the old alliance is coming before it's, you know, signed, sealed and delivered. But for Edward I is absolutely intolerable. He invades Scotland and of course, Balliol, being the strategic genius he wasn't, effectively meets him at Dunbar in East Lothian. Effectively basically very disadvantageous ground. Just when Edward's supply chains are fully intact, he's just crossed the border. Let's stop him at once. Basically, the further north you try to stop him, the more chance you've got. And John Bale is beaten and effectively runs up the east coast and is overtaken and has to surrender his badges and clothes of royal office and so becomes what was called tomb to bard empty coat. You got nothing left.
- [37:20]
Matt Lewis
And I mean, does the old alliance point to a Scottish desire to really get out from this idea of English overlordship, that they're looking for allies somewhere else that can bolster their ability to remain independent from England.
- [37:33]
Professor Murray Pittig
So I think in the. In the early stages it is more the still very Franco Norman nobility seeing actually Scotland as an adv. As a more advantageous base for themselves than England, or at least one worth cultivating and one that's prepared to reach out to France, which of course gives Scotland extra power. But the Scottish kings, until the wars of independence, really, the Scottish kings do and sometimes afterwards habitually overestimate their actual capacity to compete with England. So I'm not sure they realized how potentially weak they were. And it's worth noting that when it comes to, say, the papal tax returns in 1296, the Diocese of St. Andrews is not far away from the Diocese of Canterbury. In terms of value, Scotland's richest diocese in the central and south of the country are quite close to English competitors, so they probably weren't as economically disparate as they later became.
- [38:52]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
You're listening to this podcast, so I know you've got a curious mind. Here's a helpful fact you might not know yet. Drivers who switch and save with Progressive save over $900 on average. Pop over to progressive.com, answer some questions and you'll get a quick quote with discounts that are easy to come by. In fact, 99% of their auto customers earn at least one discount. Visit progressive.com and see if you can enjoy a little cash back. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates national average 12 month savings by $946 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2024 and May 2025. Potential savings will vary mortgage refinancing might
- [39:30]
Peloton / SoFi Mortgage Announcer
sound complicated SoFi makes it easier with refinancing options designed to fit your goals. You can explore lowering your mortgage rate, accessing cash from your home's equity with your cash out refi, or shortening your loan term. Whatever your next move, SOFI can help you find the right fit. Ready to Explore refi? Visit sofi.com PowerMove Mortgages originated by SoFi bank in a member FDIC in a MLS 696891 Terms and Conditions apply. Equal housing lender.
- [40:12]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, I love how this is becoming. The, the almost continual story though, of Scotland sort of overreaching over inflating its own ability to achieve things that it can never quite achieve. I mean, this period of the wars of Independence is, it's packed with huge names. William Wallace, Robert the Bruce. Battles at Stirling Bridge and at Bannockburn. Do we see a really solidifying sense of Scottish nationhood? Is it changing during this period? Is it becoming something different than it has been up until this point?
- [40:42]
Professor Murray Pittig
My own view is it's probably there in the 12th and 13th centuries. Undoubtedly it gets a big boost from the War of Independence. I mean, that's, you know, what common sacrifices, which were the way in which both Abraham Lincoln and later Ernest Reynolds referred to nation building are very important. And there was an awful lot of common sacrifice in Scotland in the 50 years from 1296. So yeah, that was, it was important. But also what was important was a formulation of, one has to say, some of the most advanced political Ideas available certainly in Europe and possibly globally at the time and which were put forward initially by Scotland's leading overseas academic voice, Duns Scotus, the Blessed John of Duns as professor of Paris in 1300 and were used as arguments or some of the arguments by Baldred Bissett who was a Scottish not yet that stage was to become a Scottish archdeacon and was professor of civil law Bologna who who brought Scotland's case to the Papal Courier in 1301. SCOTUS argued that human communities had the right to choose their own leaders and that those leaders are dutied to protect them. And once they were chosen, they weren't, as Hobbes would later argue, chosen for all time. Tough luck. If he's a nutcase, he's your nutcase. But they could be chosen at intervals and replaced. So that kind of thinking and also from somebody who was as an individual thinker, the primary thinker about freedom in the medieval period. I mean because Scotus is the philosopher individual freedom, what constitutes our freedom of will theologically and personally as well as talking about the freedom of nations. Absolutely, it's right. Influences the Declaration of our Broth which is a document that crystallizes much of this. And the references to Scottish freedom which you can find in the great poem later 14th century poem about Bruce's campaign, Archdeacon John Barber's the Bruce our freedom is a noble thing. Freedom make man have liking Freedom all solace to man gives he lives at ease that freely lives. And the great opposition which Barber makes in the poem between freedom as the principle of the individual and national as against tyranny and thraldom, enslavement to another, to another king, another country.
- [43:18]
Matt Lewis
And having we've constantly talked about the Scots sort of having ideas bigger than they were capable of perhaps delivering. This is a moment where we see them defeat what is at least on paper a more powerful English kingdom. Why do you think they're they're able to do this? Is it simply the incompetence of Edward II in England or is there something else going on that's that's tipping the scales in Scotland's favor?
- [43:42]
Professor Murray Pittig
No, that Robert the Bruce is one of the leading military geniuses of the medieval period and he has some very, very strong supporters such as Randolph, Earl of Murray and Sir James Douglas from the explained Truly I think the first victory he wins after his initial series of defeats. Robert doesn't lose another battle throughout his battle ridden career for more than 20 years. He just doesn't lose. He beats his Scottish opponents, he beats His English opponents. He beats Edward I at Bannockburn. He beats Edward II's army at Border Byland in Yorkshire in 1322 with huge loss of life. He beats Edward III's army in Weardale. And that's the difference. He almost, through his brother Edward takes over the whole of Ireland. He's got ambitions to create a countervailing, scooty type Scottish Irish polity which will put enormous pressure on given the relative sizes. We don't have the Industrial Revolution as a population here on the English polity. So yes, Robert the Bruce is extremely ambitious and he, he comes very close. He does succeed personally in getting it all right, but nobody else could quite manage what he'd done.
- [45:10]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, yeah. So we ought to be looking at his brilliance rather than anything else, I think so.
- [45:16]
Professor Murray Pittig
I mean people still prefer Wallace because he's not. Wallace was not an ordinary bloke. Wallace was a tough by anybody's calculations. But to most people, Scott Wallace and Scotland, Wallace is seen as an ordinary bloke. People prefer the ordinary bloke who is an underdog who lost. You know, that's what, that's of course a Scottish and perhaps a British feature of preferring the underdog. But you know, Bruce is not an underdog. Bruce was a winner. And Scotland exists today because of King Robert I. Yeah.
- [45:45]
Matt Lewis
And as we move on from the success in the war of Independence through the kind of 14th and 15th century, do we see as a result of this, do we see a newly confident Scotland? Do we see kind of cultural and economic growth and vibrance partly as a result of the victories in the wars of Independence?
- [46:04]
Professor Murray Pittig
Culturally, I think probably Scotland struggles to be as well off as it was under Alexander iii actually because the wars of independence take a hu toll economically. Robert has a policy of basically destroying all castles that might be occupied. So although castles aren't modern scale economic luci, they certainly were a medieval scale. It's quite important the kind of market provided by a well occupied castle. The climate is perhaps a little bit later starting to turn against Scotland in terms of what it can achieve. But there are a lot of achievements and one of the things is that you'd see, and this was evident even before King Robert is the early formation of quite sophisticated institutions. First of all, the widespread creation of butter grammar schools in the 12th and 13th century. Universities from St Andrews in 1411 and you know, by the even to the 18th century, Scotland had the largest number of places for university per capita in Europe. And organizations like the Faculty of Advocates, the effect of the legal Profession with rights to plead in 1532 and later on society of writers to the signet and others. So I know we're going slightly towards the end of the medieval period now, but there is a continuum of. Of the creation of quite significant institutions geared towards educational and professional development. And there's also a lot of Scots who go abroad and they repatriate some wealth. It's difficult to say how much into Scotland in this period. So one of the things is, as Scotland becomes finds it more difficult to sustain export markets and at scale because its tastes are getting more and more expensive and its exports are, with the exception of some luxuries like salmon, fairly routine. That actually what Scott start to do is to go and set up business in the receiving ports in Rotterdam, in the Baltic, in Norway, to try not only control the trade which they're involved in, but also to control the export trade insofar as they can from those destinations. So the sense of Scottish engagement with Europe and European institutions and Scottish export of many of its elites, to actually spend time in European cities or to settle there is a medieval initiative and it makes a significant difference to the way in which Scotland develops as a kingdom. And as we move later on in the medieval period, the status of the people that the kings of Scots marry in general keeps on rising and eventually, of course, to the stage where the daughter of the King of Scots is a fit match for the future King of France.
- [49:10]
Matt Lewis
Yeah. And the. The old alliance continues to be incredibly important through this period too. We quite often see Scots forces fighting with the French in the Hundred Years War in France. Do we see Scotland. You've talked a little bit there about the ways in which they are sort of focusing on the continent rather than the British Isles. Maybe in terms of trade, do we see them having a much more continental outlook than perhaps England does?
- [49:36]
Professor Murray Pittig
I think England's got. I think England's huge contribution to the international world trade and the Low Countries is a continental outlook. I think probably Scotland's slight more diverse. I mean, it's not. The Scots don't want to trade with England, though some of them aren't very keen on the idea, no doubt. And you do get lots of comments about nationality is not really a modern thing. You do get lots of comments about people from. From England and Scotland in both sides of the border. In the medieval period, there are only 50 Scots in London as late as 1567. And, you know, the. The council of aberdeen in the 15th century, we're very fortunate with Aberdeen. We've got Borough Councilman. It's dating back to 1398 in the 15th century, twice issues orders to the population of the city to stop attacking the English who've come into the city because they're just making a pilgrimage to a saint. They're not actually doing anything that's inappropriate at all. But actually it's about controlling the popular anger and resentment rather than actually being an elite construct. But basically the real issue for trade is that sea is much quicker. And on the west coast, Scotland also continues to remain close to what is now Ireland because sea is much quicker. That's a sea driven society. So that's a big reason for Scotland having a different identity. Medieval period too. But there are very significant donations of Scottish troops and administrators to France in the Hundred Years War. And this also helps to crystallize nationality. The disaster of the defeat of the Duke of Clarence at Bauger in 1418 at the hands of the Earl of Buchan, supported by French troops with 10,000 Scots on the field is a crystallizing moment for Scottish reputation. History in France, when Joan of Arc comes to liberate Orleans and what's the turning point of the war in 1430? You know, it's allegedly the march of what is now known as the March of the Soldiers of Robert Bruce. The traditional tune hey Tutti Tati is played at the final storm where she's accompanied by the Scots Guard. And indeed in the first attempts to relieve Orleans, there's a monument in the city today to Patrick Ogilvie who commanded those attempts. And also Joan of Arc was received by a Scots, a bishop from Fife, who was the Bishop of Orleans when she entered the city in 1429. And to this day, the March of the Soldier of the Robert Bruce is one of the most significant French military marches and is paid in state funerals in France by on the pipes. So absolutely there is a real, and probably still under researched and underdeveloped crystallization there where significant numbers of the Scottish elites are engaged in France and to some extent, a more limited extent, vice versa.
- [52:36]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, yeah. I mean we've, you've, I say we've done an incredible job. You've done an incredible job, Murray, of getting us through almost a thousand years of Scottish history in, in under an hour. So just to, to conclude, just to sum up, when we get to the end of the medieval period, what kind of situation would you say Scotland is in internally? Is, is it now a confident, strong kingdom that is free from kind of threats of being overtaken by England? Has it stepped firmly out of England's shadow now?
- [53:06]
Professor Murray Pittig
Well, I think that was always its aim. And from the granting of the imperial crown, the closed crown in 1329, which was the ambition of medieval Scots kings. Certainly the Stuarts did very well in presenting Scotland as a powerful and independent European kingdom with increasing status. But once again, they showed enormous levels of overconfidence, both in the historic defeat of James IV at Flodden in 1513, and even in terms of the development of James's navy, because the Prince Michael, one of the largest ships of its day in Europe, was in fact the ship that was answered by Henry VIII with the Henri Grass a Dieu some years later. So they were in an arms race, but really this was an arms race they couldn't win. And that was once again what we might call a sign of Scottish over ambition, which you can see in the gift of the Duke of Burgundy of Mons, still extant of Mons Meg in Edinburgh Castle. To James ii, one of the largest bombards of its day. Huge piece of artillery. Banging Mons Meg's belle feu was the statement made as late as 18th century Scotland for having sex inside Mons Meg, which you could just about do, especially if you were small and not particularly active. But it's got a huge caliber of gun and it represented the kind of ambition of the late Stuart kings to. To compete. Once again, they couldn't do it.
- [54:49]
Matt Lewis
I find myself liking this over ambition, though. I've enjoyed all of the stories of them believing they can do these things, even if it turns out that most of the time they can't.
- [54:57]
Professor Murray Pittig
I think that the interesting thing is, and I don't want to take it outside the period, is that actually that it's in the 18th and 19th centuries that they find that they can. And in a way, Scotland is probably in the contemporary era as less ambitious than it's ever been.
- [55:16]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, well, there's a challenge, there's a
- [55:17]
Professor Murray Pittig
rallying cry or an observation. Something's really changed because you can see in the braggadocio and invention and the sheer will to dominate an 18th and 19th century Scots the platform by the British Empire, they can do this, which they've never been able to do before and they've always wanted to.
- [55:35]
Matt Lewis
Yeah, well, this has been absolutely fascinating. Marisa, thank you so much for taking us. You thank Through a fascinating millennium of Scottish history in under an hour, you've delivered as promised and I found it all absolutely fascinating. So thank you very, very much for joining us.
- [55:48]
Professor Murray Pittig
It's been a pleasure. Matt, thanks for letting me ramble on.
- [55:52]
Matt Lewis
Not at all. Thank you. Murray's book the Shortest History of Scotland is out now. If you'd like to discover even more about this nation's history, you can find episodes in our back catalogue on the Viking siege of Dumbarton and the declaration of our growth that Murray mentioned as we were talking. There are new installments of God Medieval every Tuesday and Friday, so please come back to join Eleanor and I for more from the greatest millennium in human history. Don't forget to also subscribe or follow us on Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts and tell all of your friends and family that you've gone medieval. You can also sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries with a new release every week@historyhit.com subscribe anyway, I better let you go. I've been Matt Lewis and we've just gone medieval with History Hit.
- [57:03]
Progressive Insurance Announcer
This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Do you ever think about switching insurance companies to see if you could save some cash? Progressive makes it easy to see if you could save when you bundle your home and auto policies. Try it@progressive.com Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states.
- [57:22]
Peloton / SoFi Mortgage Announcer
Mortgage refinancing might sound complicated. Sofi makes it easier with refinancing options designed to fit your goals. You can explore lowering your mortgage rate, accessing cash from your home's equity with your cash out refi or shortening your loan term. Whatever your next move, SoFi can help you find the right fit. Ready to Explore refi? Visit sofi.com powermove Mortgages originated by SoFi bank in a member FDIC NMLS 696891 Terms and conditions apply. Equal housing lender.