Loading summary
Transcript67 lines
- [00:00]
Grow Therapy Advertiser
Grief doesn't keep a calendar. Anxiety doesn't clock out after five, Depression doesn't care if it's your busy season. But support can still fit into your life. With Grow, you can find a therapist who meets you where you are. They connect you with thousands of independent licensed therapists across the US offering both virtual and in person sessions. You can search by insurance provider, specialty treatment methods and more to find a therapist who works for you. And if it's not the right fit, switching is easy. There are no subscriptions, no long term commitments. You just pay per session. Find therapy on your time, evenings, weekends and Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Whatever challenges you're facing, GrowTherapy is here to help. Sessions average about $21 with insurance and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's GrowthTherapy. Do growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.
- [01:09]
Verizon Advertiser
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on my plan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you. Or two for you and one for someone else. Or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on rootmetric Truth score report dated 1 each 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [01:39]
Grow Therapy Advertiser
Okay, only 10 more presents to wrap. You're almost at the finish line, but. There the last one. Enjoy a Coca Cola for a pause that refreshes.
- [02:13]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
Hello, I'm Dr. Eleanor Jennica and welcome to Gone Medieval From History Hit, the podcast that delves into the greatest millennium in human history. We uncover the greatest mysteries, the gobsmacking details, and the latest groundbreaking. From the Vikings to the Normans, from kings to popes to the Crusades, we delve into the rebellions, plots and murders that tell us who we really were and how we got here. I want you to imagine the dusty road from Tunis to Salerno. Sometime in the 11th century.
- [03:01]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
A weary.
- [03:02]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
Traveler is making his way towards Europe, carrying not silks, not gold, but books. His name is Constantine the African, a merchant turned scholar who has spent years in the libraries of North Africa, immersed in the medical wisdom of the Islamic world. When he arrives at the medical school of Salerno. He has brought with him Arabic manuscripts on pharmacology, surgery and the theory of disease, works by Avicenna and Al Razi. For the first time, European students can begin to learn medicine, not just from Galen or Hippocrates, but through the lens of Islamic science, preserved, expanded and translated by Muslim scholars. It is a turning point. The Mediterranean here is a bridge, not a boundary. One generation later, another restless mind is following the same path. Aldred of Bath, an English scholar with a taste for travel, crosses into Spain and southern Italy to study Arabic. He will later confess, I learn from my Arab teachers and return to England with treasures. Euclid's elements, works on astronomy and instruments for observation. He will introduce not just text, but methods, reasoning, experimentation, calculation that will reshape how Europeans approach science. To Aldred, Arabic learning isn't foreign. It's a revelation, a window into a deeper intellectual tradition and then into the early 13th century. Along comes Leonardo of Pisa, better known as Fibonacci. Unlike Constantine or Aldred, his journey isn't spurred by books, but by business. Growing up in the bustling ports of Algeria, where his father works as a merchant, young Leonardo has been struck by the elegance of the Hindu Arabic numeral system. He has marveled at how easily traders perform calculations with these strange symbols. It's so much more efficient than the cumbersome Roman numerals still used in Europe. When Fibonacci brings this system home, he unleashes a quiet revolution. Merchants learn how to balance accounts, convert currencies, and measure profit with unprecedented precision. Suddenly, European commerce can keep pace with the sophistication of Islamic markets. The very fabric of trade, double entry, bookkeeping, contracts, loans will rest on a foundation that can be traced back to Baghdad, Damascus and Cordob. The examples of Constantine, the African, Adelard of Bath, and Fibonacci are just three among a multitude of stories that challenge the conventional narrative of perpetual conflict between Christians and Muslims in Europe. In her new book, Crucible of Islam and the Forging of Europe from the 8th to the 21st century, my guest today, Dr. Elizabeth Drayson, presents Europe as a vessel of transformation, where Islamic and Christian civilizations forged a hybrid European identity through both conflict and collaboration from the 8th to the 21st centuries. It's the story of ideas in motion, how Islamic knowledge didn't just flow into Europe, but transformed it, laying the groundwork for the Renaissance and beyond. It's a reminder that the progress of civilization has always depended on extreme exchange, curiosity, and the courage of wanderers who dared to learn from the other.
- [07:12]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Elizabeth, welcome to Gone Medieval.
- [07:15]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Hello, Eleanor. Thank you very much. Thank you for welcoming me. It's great to be on the show.
- [07:20]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
We are delighted to have you here because I cannot say enough good things about Crucible of Light and what I think is a really important book, both just historically in general, but especially in the current political climate. And I suppose a great place to start talking about it is to talk about your really incredible ability to write this book that goes against the overly simplistic and, let's be honest, really childish clash of civilizations narratives that a lot of us have grown up with and that we're really familiar with as result. What were some of the things that surprised you when you were doing this research? You know, some of the things that I think you've done a great job of highlighting in the book are that there are Islamic influences behind things that we now just consider to be totally, quintessentially European.
- [08:16]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Well, I suppose the biggest thing you mentioned, the translation of learning and what was translation from Arabic? A huge amount, I mean, the main body, I would say, of Greek mathematical and scientific learning, was translated originally into Arabic by the Arabs. And then when they had a foothold in medieval Spain, majority, I would say, of the important texts of that body of work were translated from Arabic into Latin and later into vernacular Spanish. And that was carried out at various times at translation schools which were mainly based in the city of Toledo. And we have some in the 12th century, we have some in 13th century. What happened was that scholars traveled from northwestern European countries, from the uk, from France, from Italy, from Germany, to translate collaboratively at the school. And they worked very often with an Arab colleague and the Jewish colleague. Jewish scholars often acted as intermediaries between Arabic scholars and the European ones. And so it was in that way, it was a very long, painstaking process, really, that took place over probably a couple of hundred years, that this enormous body of learning that was sort of really lost to Europe, northwestern Europe at the time, was translated and made its way up into northwest Europe and was discussed in the universities there and gradually fed its way into the evolution of scientific knowledge in Europe.
- [09:58]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Yeah, I think that that's such an important one because, you know, in my studies, I was always quite taken with, because one of my side interests is magic. And so I was really particularly interested in the court of Alfonso X and the scriptorias that he controlled and how much was being translated in and out of Arabic and into Latin and all of the really incredible science that is making its way through There, I mean, of course, you know, we, we tend.
- [10:26]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
To call it natural philosophy now, but.
- [10:29]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
The way that there is a very lively interplay between the Islamic world and Christian world I think is often completely overlooked for any number of reasons. But I mean, you've mentioned already the fact that this is a history, this, you know, the convivencia, you know, which I think we don't want to kind of overdo it, you know, this idea that there is always a really peaceful and harmonious relationship between Muslims and Christians on the Iberian Peninsula. But it certainly is there. And we know for a fact, for example, this, this is something that is suppressed under Franco. But we see similar things, for example, in the Central European context because there is rather a lot put into this idea that there is, there is this all constant Ottoman looming, that is the threatening Central European ideals as well. And this is something that is really kind of pushed forward in an imperial context there as well. I mean, these are, you know, the more obvious examples because you have these particular political movements that seek to, to put forward that ideal. But what else can we see across Europe that, that feeds this?
- [11:42]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Well, I think there are two aspects to that. I mean, I think as regards the legacy of medieval history, certainly in Spain after 1492, which was the year when the Christian reconquest was finally achieved and Granada fell to the Christian monarchs, Ferdinand and Isabella. After that there was a great suppression of what was Islamic and Spain forged a completely different country from the one that, that there had been. They suppressed knowledge, they tried to make it solely a Catholic country. And that went on really until the death of Franco, because he espoused this policy of national Catholicism as well, which I sort of talked about how that all changed in the 1980s and I think later the Renaissance scholars turned to the Greek and Latin past and bypass the Islamic element. I think there was just a persistent unwillingness to acknowledge that presence. Although we come across great scholars like Sir Isaac Newton, who had a selection of important Arabic works in his library, his personal library, and referred to them and used them in his own work. And we have examples like Copernicus who. Everyone thinks, I think that Copernicus discovered the heliocentric system for the universe himself, and in fact, he based it very closely upon 12th century Arab astronomers work.
- [13:13]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I mean, this is how we get most of our Aristotle really in the Middle Ages, specifically through the Arabic school, which I always find that very funny because, you know, that there's the myth of this idea that medieval Europe has completely lost all classical knowledge and it needs to sit around and wait for the Renaissance. But at the same time, in part of the reason why that myth is so pervasive is nobody wants to admit that the way that we got it was through the Arabic line of thinking, which I thought. And I find that really interesting, you know, this desire to simply erase an entire mode of philosophy in order to serve a very particularized political agenda.
- [13:51]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Absolutely, Eleanor. Yes. I mean, I think the fall of the Roman and Persian empires was a huge historical turning point, and I think it left a vacuum. I think it left a kind of space for the new to emerge. And the new was obviously poised to do that. And it was revolutionary. You know, I mean, the Prophet Muhammad founded this completely new egalitarian religious movement that rocked the political and religious foundations of the known world, basically. And it had this radical new ethic of the family, and it wanted to return to monotheism. And I think the fact that it spread so lightning fast, which was quite remarkable, was in part due to the great appeal of that for people at that time who were probably left rather stunned by what was happening around them with the collapse of. Of their known societies and systems. And of course, I think as well that in Islam, religion is intertwined with politics and militancy to a fine degree. And I think that helped Muslim armies to establish new states and systems much more quickly.
- [15:08]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Quite so. I mean, it's such an incredibly fascinating story, but I suppose one thing that we need to do is kind of go right back. I've launched us in to the politics of it, but if we can kind of go back to the origins of Islam, how important do you think it was that this is kind of coming up as a major religion at the same time that the Persian Empire is. Is falling apart? Certainly we've seen the Roman Empire crumbling a bit, you know, in the west, we're already into the successor states. In the East, Constantinople is losing its ability to have quite as much say in what's going on. For example, in the. And literal, do you think that plays a part of what we see as this quite meteoric rise?
- [15:57]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yeah, Well, I mean, in less than a century, the Islamic empire had stretched from Central Asia to Tangiers in Northwest Africa. And then if we count from the year 622, which was the date of the Hegira, or Muhammad's flight from Mecca to escape from the hostility of the Meccan pagans, it took approximately 88 years for them to reach Europe, which is astonishing, you know, So a Muslim, the very first Muslim raiding party landed in Tarifa. On the coast of southern Spain in 710. And then the following year, the Berber general Tadi Ibn Ziyad landed at Gibraltar and defeated the Visigothic armies of King Roderick in a battle in southern Spain in July of that year. And that's the date we usually take as the date of the Islamic invasion, as it's called. So Tariq just swept through Spain, he swept northwards without any real resistance and he got as far as the Pyrenees, with the only exception being the Christian stronghold of Asturias, in the sort of mountain fastnesses up there in the north. So by 714 what we call the Muslim conquest of Iberia was actually was complete. It was amazing. But I would think I should add as a sort of postscript to that that obviously that it was an incredibly dramatic time for the native inhabitants of Iberia, but they were not entirely unfamiliar with the Berbers and Arabs of northwest Africa because they'd been trading with them for hundreds of years. So what was new in that was the advent of Islam.
- [17:35]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
And speaking of, how long does it take for Islam to reach Europe? Because we see a pretty rapid expansion into the former Byzantine areas. But what does it take in terms of getting into Europe proper?
- [17:50]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yeah, I mean, that's right where the Muslim is actually invited in sometimes. And I think that's a really interesting thought if we think take the founding legend of Spain itself, which was this, you know, the story of Count Julian, who was one of Roderick's Visigothic generals, and he was posted in Ceuta on the North African coast. The legend goes that he had a beautiful daughter who Roderick either violated or had a passionate affair with. And as an act of revenge, Julian invited the Muslim leaders that of course he was in contact with, being an in North Africa himself, to assist him in invading Spain and defeating his enemies. So that's, you know, a sort of primary example, if you like, of inviting in the invader. Of course that is a legend, but I do, I think it's not far off. There are lots of elements of truth in that story. One point as well I thought that I think is interesting in this regard is particularly in relation to what's going on in the world at the moment. That the first instance I know of, of an alliance between peoples of the three faiths, you know, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, comes really early in the history of Islam in Europe. And when the city of Cordoba was captured in 7 11, so in that first year the Muslim leaders left it in the hands of a garrison made up of Jews and Christians and Muslims and They were all in charge of its defense together. And Jewish groups often welcomed in the Muslims as they arrived in towns and cities further north because they knew they were going to live under far less severe conditions than they'd lived under with the Visigoths. So I think that's interesting too.
- [19:35]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Yeah, and I think that's a really important point. There tends to be this idea that there's some kind of stasis. But even in terms of what's going on in the Iberian Peninsula, we've already very recently seen the takeover of the Visigoths. You know, we're already used to new groups coming in and controlling things. So this is just sort of, you know, one of the groups we already know kind of moving in a little bit more. But you make a really great point in the second chapter of your book about when the so called conquest happens, because this isn't always necessarily a matter of bloody conquest. Right. You know, there's times when people say, oh look, it's, it's our neighbors, the Berbers. Come, you know, come on in.
- [20:16]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yes, I mean, that's absolutely right. You know, it's a very complex situation, really. There's nothing clear cut or black and white about it. And I think, you know, an awful lot of the time. Yes. I mean, certainly if people resisted the Muslim armies at the beginning, then they didn't meet a very nice fate. But people seem to soon, very soon have settled down. And of course they intermarried mixed with each other at an early stage. That changed later on in the Middle Ages. But there was a very great degree of interchange and interaction on what I think are quite amicable, tolerant terms really, right from the start.
- [20:56]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Oh, absolutely. And this is something that we see repeatedly, especially in this period that I don't think you can talk about it enough really, is that when you do have Muslims come and take over a particularized society, they want Jewish people and Christian people around because someone has to pay the jizya. You know, someone, someone's got to pay the taxes around here. So it's not as though that this is something that is an all crushing, all consuming cultural defeat. It's more of an opening up for a lot of people and certainly for Jewish people it represents new possibilities for freedom. Really.
- [21:34]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Oh, my goodness, yes, yes. I mean, we have fabricated holy writings, we have hostile histories, and even in sung poetry. So what come to mind are three instances of that. And the first one I know of was a book by a Syrian priest which has the rather weird title of the Apocalypse of Pseudo Methodius and of course, this priest was pretending to be a church father of the 4th century, hence the name Methodius. So he wrote this book in the late 600-00 a.d. and in it he paints a picture of Islam as a punishment for Christian sexual depravity, which was also actually what historians made of what happened to King Roderick. You know, they saw the Muslim invasion as a punishment for the sexual depravity of the Visigoths. So this Syrian priest really got his teeth stuck into this. And, you know, he criticized homosexuality, cross dressing and even swinging he mentioned. So, you know, it was really quite an extraordinary sort of start to these fabricated narratives. And then, of course, there was the venerable Bede, the great English historian of the seventh and eighth centuries. Well, Bede's interesting because he had quite a change of heart about what he thought about Islam and Arabia. And to start with, I don't think he thought anything about Islam. As a matter of fact, he called the people, called them Saracen, which comes from the Greek word sarekinoi, which means people of the tent. So he saw them as wanderers, as nomads, and he described Arabia as a pleasant place in his writing. And he wrote about how the Muslim caliphs had allied with Christians against the Jews. However, by about 730, which is when Bede was writing his great ecclesiastical history of the English people, there was quite a severe threat from those Saracen invaders because they'd reached Gaul, which is now, of course, part of France. And so the threat of that was looming. So Bede constructed this really rather extraordinary narrative which he based on the book of Genesis. And he set out this idea that Ishmael, who was the son of Abraham and is an important prophet in Islam, was illegitimate because he was the son. But he was illegitimate. He was the son of Abraham and his servant Hagar. But therefore, Ishmael was an outcast and a wandering warrior, and he founded and prefigured, you know, the advancing Saracen armies. And this was all set in opposition to Abraham's legitimate son with his wife Sarah, who was Isaac, who's equated with the foundations of Christianity. But I don't think Bede still didn't refer to their religion as such in his writing. You know, he just seemed to, as you said, really, I think, to view them as just another group of non Christian invaders. And then, if I may, I'd love just to mention an example of this in the 11th century in sung poetry. And this example is about the great French epic poem, the Chanson de Roland, the Song of Roland. Of course, Roland was a count, a Frankish count at the court of Charlemagne and very famous, described as bravest of the brave. So an elite soldier. And what had happened was that Charlemagne had decided he was going to try and attack the Muslims in Spain. He launched a campaign against them and they didn't really get very far. So Charlemagne decided they would. They would hightail it out of the north of Spain and go back, destroying one or two cities on the way. And they had to go through the Pyrenees to do that. And they went through a pass, which is called Roncesvo Pass or Roncesvalles in Spanish. And as they did so, Roland was in charge of the baggage train at the back. And it was attacked by a group of Basque guerrillas, not Muslim guerrillas, but Basques, who were taking revenge for Charlemagne sacking Pamplona. And shockingly, Roland and his. His men were all killed to a man by these Basque guerrillas. So it was a terrible, ignominious defeat for Charlemagne. And it wasn't really written about much in the annals at all and chronicles until quite a bit later. But in the 11th century, a poet wrote this Song of Roland, the epic poem, and he completely reinterpreted it, which I think is a rather nice way of putting it, in a way, and he casts Roland as a great hero who fought against the Muslims. And it lionizes Charlemagne, you know, as a champion of Christianity over Islam. And it created what the wonderful historian David Levering Lewis called one of the great constitutive myths of Christendom. And I think it's quite extraordinary, I think, to me, to see the power of that work of literature and the influence it's exerted on future generations and their view of the conflict between those two faiths.
- [26:54]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Now, you've already mentioned the legend of Tariq, which is incredibly important, but at the same time that Muslims are really making their mark in Europe, we see similar kind of fabricated narratives that are coming from Christian writers. Is that correct?
- [27:12]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yes, yes. I mean, it's remarkable. And so it's been. It pulled the wool over people's eyes, for it pulled the wool over my eyes as a student too. I didn't know that at all until I further into the subject.
- [27:40]
Verizon Advertiser
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on my plan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed, even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you, or two for you and one for someone else or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on RootMetric Truth Score Report dated one each 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [28:09]
Grow Therapy Advertiser
Grief doesn't keep a calendar. Anxiety doesn't clock out after five. Depression doesn't care if it's your busy season. But support can still fit into your life. With grow, you can find a therapist who meets you where you are. They connect you with thousands of independent licensed therapists across the US Offering both virtual and in person sessions. You can search by insurance provider, specialty treatment methods and more to find a therapist who works for you. And if it's not the right fit, switching is easy. There are no subscriptions, no long term commitments. You just pay per session. Find therapy on your time, evenings, weekends and Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Whatever challenges you're facing, Growth GrowTherapy is here to help. Sessions average about $21 with insurance and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growtherapy.com acast today to get started. That's growththerapy.com acast growtherapy.com acast availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.
- [29:20]
Lowe's Advertiser
Bring home a winter wonderland shop Lowe's limited time doorbuster deals during Black Friday to save big on holiday staples. Show your cheer with select two quart poinsettias for $6 and shine and shimmer with 100. Count holiday living incandescent string lights now four for $10. Then get a fresh cut Christmas tree now 25% off your holiday list. Lives at Lowe's. We help you save offers value through 121 poinsettias and fresh cut trees in store only. Selection varies by location, while supplies last excludes Alaska and Hawaii.
- [30:04]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I think that this is such an important point because I think that there is this tendency to write off literature or mythologies as somehow, oh, I don't know, just fluff. You know, there's just stories that we tell that don't necessarily mean anything, but. But changing the Basques into an army of Muslims is a pretty big deal. And the Chanson de Roland this is something that gets brought up over and over again. I see people now look to it as though it is a formative text that is telling a real story despite the fact that it is literature. This is why, you know, historians have to keep doing the work right? Because it's so easy to just kind of go along with the story that you're told, and that's why we do the digging in the first place. But, I mean, I don't want to spend the entire conversation just talking about these silly myths, because one of the things you do really well in the book is you highlight the incredible and very European successes of the Muslims who are living here as well. And in particular, you talk about one of my very favorite places in the world, Cordoba, which in the 8th to 11th centuries experiences this incredible Umayyad golden age. Can you talk a little bit about the importance of Abd al Rahman in.
- [31:24]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
This and his emergence?
- [31:26]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
I'd love to do that. Abd al Rahman I is one of my great heroes. He was hugely important. He was hugely important because he was Europe's first true emir, and he was a major medieval ruler. And yet, you know, he's not part of traditional histories or educational courses. I mean, if you ask someone who knows a bit about medieval history, they'll probably know about Richard iii, They'll probably know about King John. No one. Very few people will have heard of abdelrahman I. And he was nothing short of astonishing. I mean, his life story is startling to start with. I mean, he was a Umayyad prince, a prince of that dynasty. And he came from Syria and his family was massacred, with obviously the exception of himself and his brother, by a rival tribe, the Abbasids, who did found a really important dynasty with its court in Baghdad, finally. But Abdelrahman managed to escape with his brother. His brother, unfortunately, didn't make it. He was massacred in front of Abdelrahman's eyes. Abdelrahman and the servant managed to flee across Africa, and they went into exile, got to the North African coast and crossed into Spain. And Abd al Rahman got lots of support when he arrived. And he very quickly conquered Cordoba and set up what was the first emirate in Europe. And he was only 24 at the time. And it was an extraordinary state because it had an ethos of tolerance. It was environmentally green. All the agriculture was rethought, the lands were terraced in a different way. Water was conserved. It was a remarkable place, and it brought huge prosperity to the people who lived there. And Abd al Rahman was seen as a great man by other Muslim leaders, in particular his enemy, Al Mansur, who was another, a minor emir. And he spoke, described him as the falcon of the Quraysh. Abtarrahman was a great man.
- [33:40]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
One of the things that I think, as historians, we really have to thank him for is that in Cordobi he puts a lot of work into very specifically cultivating a culture of literacy and libraries. I mean, we know that he's got something like. I think it's 70 libraries that are extant in Cordoba at the time.
- [34:01]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
That probably sounds about right for that era. Of course, later on, Cordoba became the biggest book market in Western Europe in the 10th century. Maybe I'll say a bit more about that in due course. But, yes, the creation of libraries was remarkable. There was this extraordinary desire to pull together knowledge, to collaborate with other Arabic countries, with Baghdad, and, yes, create a generally intellectual climate, I think, of progressive nature there. Also, he created all these extraordinary botanical and herb gardens, which were really, really important at the time. It was like a green revolution, in actual fact. So those herbals and new plants that were grown there all formed part of what became the European herbal later and was a main source of. For doctors to cure people. And the biggest thing I think Abdelrahman founded perhaps was the first incarnation of the Great Mosque.
- [35:04]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Of course, cannot get away without talking about the Great Mosque because, you know, it's just one of those wonders of the world, you know.
- [35:12]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Absolutely. I mean, it's a major symbol of Islamic power in Europe. And so it had lots and lots of different stages in its. In its development and it was added to and so on. But Abdelrahman began it at the end of his reign and he saw it, his first version finished anyway. So, yeah, so, I mean, really, he created a kind of cultural utopia of tolerance and abundance and prosperity.
- [35:37]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I think that it is really interesting to talk about the Great Mosque as well, because I think that this is one of these quintessentially really medieval buildings, because you see it containing a lot of nods to the cultures around it. And they recycle Roman and Visigothic materials, which is, you know, such a medieval thing to do. You know, you go. You go around, find the. The good pieces that can be used and reuse them. I think one of the things that is really important about the Great Mosque as well is, you know, it is this really enigmatic building. It's something that still attracts us now, and it's got all these wonderful medieval elements that bring it together. You know, bits of Roman and Visigothic materials. It's really a great symbol of Cordoba and how it has this melding of cultures. But also I think that there's this kind of tendency to. To think that it was somehow an affront to Christianity. And I think that's possibly due to its conversion into a cathedral in later years. But one of the things that I used to teach when, when I would be teaching Charles V, you know, great Holy Roman Emperor, very early modern, is he sees the conversion of the Great Mosque into Cordoba and he has this great quote about it in the 16th century. He says, you've taken something that was unique in the world and you've turned it into something mundane. And I think that is incredibly important because when, if we fall into the trap of saying that there's always been this incredibly fracturous relationship between Muslims and Christians and, and certainly Charles V is a huge part of this story, you know, with the Habsburgs fighting the Ottomans constantly, that flattens the fact that people are still able to see things like the mosquito as important, even when they're in the very midst of, of these real battles.
- [37:34]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yeah, it was slightly ironic really, because Charles V gave the permission for the cathedral to be built in the center of the mosque. He hadn't seen it at that stage, had he? And that was begun in 1523. And I think it had really arisen because there was a great deal of lobbying on the part of the Christian authorities in Cordoba to bring it into the program of conversion of Muslim buildings, of Islamic buildings after 1492, when, you know, there was this program of making or Christianizing everything, and that included the environment, the skyline, everything, you know, buildings particularly. But I think probably what Charles saw when he actually, you know, had it in front of him, as it were, was he realized that it was usurps and appropriates what was there which was, you know, unique, as he put it. And of course it asserts Christian authority, doesn't it? So on that level, I think it's, you know, it's seen as a very, a very contentious building altogether. The cathedral inside the mosque, you might say, well, isn't it a sign that, you know, the coming together of the two religions? But no, because one is imposed slap bang in the center of the mosque, part of which had to be demolished to do that, you know, and really it was a bit of cultural brutality, I think, to do that in actual fact. But of course, you know, I mean, as you know, I'm sure there's still a great deal of contention surrounding the Great Mosque nowadays because Muslims still aren't allowed to worship in a building, which was where that was the original purpose of it. Yeah, it's been a very contentious building since it was then.
- [39:41]
Verizon Advertiser
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on my plan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you. Or two for you and one for someone else. Or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon, all on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on RootMetric Truth Score Report dated 1H 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [40:11]
Grow Therapy Advertiser
Grief doesn't keep a calendar. Anxiety doesn't clock out after five. Depression doesn't care if it's your busy season. But support can still fit into your life. With grow, you can find a therap who meets you where you are. They connect you with thousands of independent licensed therapists across the US offering both virtual and in person sessions. You can search by insurance provider, specialty treatment methods and more to find a therapist who works for you. And if it's not the right fit, switching is easy. There are no subscriptions, no long term commitments. You just pay per session. Find therapy on your time, evenings, weekends, and Cancel up to 24 hours in advance at no cost. Whatever challenges you're facing, GrowTherapy is here to help. Sessions average about $21 with insurance and some pay as little as $0 depending on their plan. Visit growththerapy.com acast today to get started. That's growththerapy.com acast growtherapy.com acasta Availability and coverage vary by state and insurance plan.
- [41:35]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I think it's got the conversion of it into a cathedral has tremendous historical importance, but I'm telling you it is a crime against to architecture and taste. It is. It's truly hideous what they did in what is otherwise one of the most sublime buildings in the world. So it's.
- [41:51]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
But yeah, I agree with you.
- [41:54]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Okay, but. Well, let's not dwell on but let's talk a little bit more about the Islamic contribution to scholarship and science at the time, which is especially in the sixth chapter of your book. You talk about this a lot. What kinds of things here might the average person find support surprising about the Islamic contribution to mathematics, for example?
- [42:16]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Okay, well I think in a more general way what was very surprising about the Islamic contribution to scholarship and science was the collaboration and the deep reverence for scholarship that took place amid severe conflict that was going on in other parts of the world and around them. And you had these collaborations between Cordoba and the Byzantine Empire and Baghdad. And in addition to that, I think what was surprising was the degree of Cultural importance of the work carried out in Cordoba. You mentioned mathematics. Well, we take the example of the scholar Al Khwarizmi, who was head of the famous House of Wisdom, which was this wonderful library in scholarly sort of center in Baghdad. And he was a mathematical genius. And the Cordoban polymath Ibn Affirnas, him of the first flight and the feathered wings, traveled to Baghdad to bring back copies of Al Khwarizmi's great mathematical works. And in doing so, he introduced to Cordoba and ultimately to Western Europe what we call out Arabic numerals. And as I mentioned a while back, algorithms, which of course is a Latinized version of Al Khwarizmi's name. And those discoveries, I mean, they underpin the whole mathematical knowledge, I think, of the entire Western world. That's an astonishing thing to take on board. But I mean, there is a similar process with the medical works too. Medicine. The great Al Zahrawi, who was called Abulcasis in Latin, was born in Cordoba and he was court physician to the caliph. And he wrote a book called the Method of Medicine, which contained pioneering discoveries we still use today, particularly in the field of surgery. But he pioneered the use of forceps, the surgical syringe, early inhaled anesthetics. And he was the main source of medical knowledge in Europe for centuries. And so that was an important medical texts that got translated and relayed to northwestern Europe.
- [44:29]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
How long did it take these sorts of information to filter through to the generalized European population? Is this something that has tremendous uptake right away, or does it take a while to get people on board?
- [44:43]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Well, I mean, it took. I mean, you can imagine it took a long time. It was a long, slow process of translation and assimilation, I would say, over several centuries, really. And it was done in Spain and in Sicily too. And there, you know, Christian, Muslim and Jewish scholars all collaborated on translations that passed that vital scientific knowledge to the West. And one of my examples and springs to mind is Gerbert of Aurillac, who studied Arab science at a monastery near Barcelona. And the bishop of that monastery called Atto, had traveled to Cordoba and he'd met the caliph and he told jot about all the wonders of Arab culture and science, including he told him about the new mathematical system of numbers, the Hindu, what they called the Hindu Arabic numerals. So Jherbert was the first Christian scholar to take Arabic knowledge outside Spain. In fact, he invented an abacus or a preliminary counting machine, counting system which used Arabic numerals rather than the Roman ones they'd used before. And the amazing thing about Jerbet was that he became Sylvester II and head of the Christian church. So here we have an illustrious scientist who admired and embraced Muslim knowledge. And yet he was at the peak of the Christian head of the Christian church. So it was a great symbol, I think, of a harmonious conjunction of Muslims and Christians in that regard. Another translator, an important translator, was Gerard of Cremona, who lived in the 12th century. And he was really a giant. So he traveled from Italy to Toledo and he translated over 70 of the most brilliant works of Arab science during his lifetime. And what made it even more remarkable was that he didn't know Arabic. So when he got to Toledo, he had to teach himself. So that gives you an idea, Eleanor, if you like, of the sort of laboriousness of the process and how long it must have taken. And then he was helped by an Arab friend he had who translated some of the Arabic works into vernacular Spanish, and then he put it into Latin. And so it was in this way that the great medical works by Galen, Hippocrates and Ptolemy's Almagest, the greatest astronomical work, were translated. And that's how that Greek and Arab learning reached Northwestern schools and monasteries.
- [47:19]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I'm going to drag us, I think, kicking and screaming out of Spain because I wanted to talk a little bit about Sicily, which I'm also slightly obsessed with. And we really see another one of these multicultural societies to emerge there. What's special about the Sicilian context? And is this really something that we can say is brought about as a result of Roger II of Sicily? Or am I being overly simplistic if I say that?
- [47:46]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
No, I don't think you are. Sicily was a Muslim island for 250 years. It started off being a Byzantine Christian island, and then it was invaded by Sunni Muslims from tunisia in the 9th century. And, you know, it had lots of parallels with Al Andalus in Spain. It was cross cultural. It had a thriving intellectual community. It was a place where Arab and Byzantine and Latin cultures met. But then in the late 10th century, the Normans, who controlled southern Italy, took it over. And there they created, what they managed to do was to bring together lots of different cultural groups on the island and create a tolerant, flourishing community of diverse religions. And Roger, I think Roger II of Sicily probably is the great epitome of that in his Persona. I mean, his father, Roger, who was also Roger, Roger I, who was Count of Sicily, had begun life as a Norman warlord who lived as a bandit in the hills and robbed people. But when he got the opportunity to really make something of Sicily. He did. He laid the groundwork for what was going to become an exceptional society. And then Roger, his son, really brought together Christian, Muslim and Jewish elements in his culture. And what was interesting is it was an inverse, the inverse of what happened in Al Andalus, because this time, you know, it was a Latin, Christian, Norman ruler who was fully embracing the Muslim other as well as the Greek and Byzantine heritage. And so, you know, Roger, he dressed in Muslim clothes and he had coins minted with Arabic inscriptions on them. And I think he even had a Muslim chef, I believe, recall that correctly. You know, in his Persona, he was a symbol of this extraordinary hybridity, I think. And, yeah, I mean, I think also he had this amazing map of the world created. He commissioned it, and it was created. It was called the Book of Roger, and it was created by Muslim scholar Muhammad Ali Dilisi. And it was the greatest single work of geography of the Middle Ages. And so it was the most accurate map of the world for over 300 years. And I think that map and the scope of it epitomized Roger's immense cultural ambitions. And it was, yeah, it was engraved on a cutting edge, flattened hemisphere, apparently, which weighed a huge amount, something about £400. But it was the most remarkable thing for his time and a symbol of, I suppose, his cosmopolitanism, in a way, and what he achieved. And what I really love about Norman Sicily, Eleanor, is that, to me, it shows that kind of hybrid society can thrive, people can exist peacefully altogether, and it can work. And I think that's very heartening thought in present times. Yeah.
- [50:56]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Oh, absolutely. And I think that there's one of the things that your book does a really great job of pointing out, is that oftentimes when we look at these hybrid societies, if we're looking at Norman Sicily, if we're looking at the varying Spanish kingdoms, we see these places where we have this heavy diversity as being actually at the forefront of driving progress, of driving forward intellectual pursuits. And I. I really do think the key here, as you've managed to highlight so well, is a willingness to take on other viewpoints and to truly consider things from the outside. You know, it's a rigidity and a desire to only do exactly one thing that. That prevents you from considering, I think, the. The new ideas that could perhaps drive progress.
- [51:52]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yeah, absolutely. I agree. Yeah, I agree.
- [51:56]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
And I think just kind of to wrap us up, one thing that. Because I hadn't really considered this before, I read about it in your book. You know, everyone kind of knows well, everyone, I say everyone, medieval historians, we all like this story of Saint Francis of Assisi going to the Sultan Al Kamil during the Crusades. And there's this really simplistic idea of looking at the Crusades that people specifically from the European side have. It's like, oh, the, the Crusades, look, these ongoing conflicts, because Christians and Muslims were always at each other's throats. And you know, if you go ask Muslim scholars, they're like, what? No, you know, like you never see any trace of this idea that Christianity is, is offering some kind of ongoing threat to, to Islam. That is just not how they perceive it to be at all. But there's this hilarious story of here comes, here comes St. Francis of Assisi on the Fifth Crusade and he's going to, he's going to attempt to convert the Sultan Al Kamil. And I find this really interesting because the Sultan sort of more or less says, no, thank you, and kind of sending Francis on the way, which I think is a really important story, because if we really did see this existential hatred between Muslims and Christians, I just don't think it would have happened this way or played out at all.
- [53:21]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
No, and I mean, I think it's an extraordinary example of how, you know, two completely disparate people from different faiths can meet together and get on in a tolerant way. I mean, this was in the Fifth Crusade and the aim of that was to conquer Egypt and Jerusalem. And I think at the time the Christians were at the Egyptian fort of Damietta. That was where their camp was in 1219. And then St. Francis decided he'd travel to Egypt and hope he could make this miraculous conversion. You know, he was incredibly brave, I think, and I suppose he wanted to try and sue for peace and stop people being killed. But anyway, as you said, he crossed over from the Christian camp and went to see the Sultan Al Kamil in his tent. And yeah, I think he was greeted with polite amusement. His offer of peace was rejected. But I mean, it is an example of a surprising and peaceful encounter between a Muslim ruler and a Catholic monk at the height right in the middle, literally, of a violent confrontation between the faiths. And I think there's another example of that with the relationship between Saladin and Richard III in the Crusade. You know, I mean, they, they had great respect for each other. So I think also I absolutely agree with you that it was really on the Christian side that people saw the Crusades as a kind of never ending conflict between the two faiths. And the Muslims didn't have that view at all of it.
- [54:57]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
I think it is an interesting one because we see St. Francis in a way almost kickstart of fad for Franciscans attempting over and over again to intervene with really high level Muslim rulers. You know, because in the 15th century they're forever kind of wandering into the different khanates and attempting to, to. And it's very funny because everyone is sort of bemused that they're, they're in Kazakhstan and sandals in winter and, and saying, oh, you know, we already have Christians, you know, and this sort of thing. But it's, it's very sweet. I quite like Franciscans. I have a real soft spot for them. So.
- [55:31]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Absolutely.
- [55:33]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Well, I suppose the good way to sort of wrap up and we've been hinting at this the entire time is talking a little bit about why it's important to have these discussions, why it's important to point out that we have lots of Arabic words that have entered European languages as a result of this period. You know, how Islamic architecture has influenced our own building practices. You know, how this is as much a part of the European story as anything else. Because I do think that, you know, the 20th century did a real number on the way that we tend to think about the past. And it's attempted to put forward these myths in order to, I don't know, I mean, very specifically in order to get the wars that we want to get done done. And I think that your book has gone such a long way to questioning this idea of like an ongoing clash of civilizations. So do you have anything else you'd like to sort of say about that before we sign off?
- [56:36]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
Yes, absolutely. What I would like to think is that this will make people think in different ways about the relationship between the two cultures, you know, and maybe to encourage better kinds of political and cultural and social interaction between Muslim groups and non Muslim groups and Christian groups. Because I think, what I think really is one of the important messages I wanted to convey in the book is that I think we need to rethink the nature of European identity. You know, it isn't separate, it isn't. It isn't. Here's Europe and here are the Islamic empires. They are on a continuum and they are part of each other and they are so deeply interwoven at all levels that we need to think of it in a different way historically entirely. And I think, yes, that's really what I would like to say, to finish.
- [57:33]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Off with, I think thank you so, so much for coming on to talk to us about this. I think that the book is an absolute triumph. And you know, if anyone has history buffs on their list for Christmas, look no further than this particular book because it's an absolute tour de force and really fun.
- [57:50]
Grow Therapy Advertiser
Fun.
- [57:50]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
That's the other thing about it.
- [57:52]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
A lot of information.
- [57:52]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Really, really fun. So Elizabeth, thank you ever, ever so much for coming on to chat with me today.
- [57:58]
Dr. Elizabeth Drayson
It's been an absolute pleasure, Elle and I thank you very much indeed for inviting me.
- [58:03]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
My thanks to Dr. Elizabeth Drayson and to you for listening to Gone Medieval from History hit. Remember, you can enjoy unlimited access to award winning original TV documentaries including my new favorite film Joan of Arc, as well as ad free podcasts by signing up at historyhit.com forward/subscription. You can follow Gone Medieval on Spotify.
- [58:26]
Podcast Host - Eleanor
Where you can leave us comments and suggestions or wherever you get your podcasts.
- [58:30]
Dr. Eleanor Jennica
And tell all your friends and family that you Gone Medieval. Until next time.
- [58:54]
Verizon Advertiser
This holiday, Verizon is helping you bundle up incredible gifts and savings. You'll get the latest phone with a new line on my plan and a brand new smartwatch and tablet. No trade in needed even on our lowest price plan. That's two gifts for your family and one for you. Or two for you and one for someone else. Or three gifts for you and only you. Either way, you save big on three amazing gifts at Verizon. All on the best 5G network. Visit Verizon today. Rankings based on Root Metric Truth score report dated 1H 2025. Your results may vary. Service plan required for watch and tablet. Additional terms apply.
- [59:24]
Lowe's Advertiser
Looking for a last minute gift for your people? You know your people. That weird bunch of friends and family that you love dearly. Well, here's an easy idea. Oregon Lottery Holiday Scratchets. Because your people, they're the ones that, amidst all the holiday crowds and endless notifications, help you find the fun. Which calls for a little gift that brings big cheer. Oregon Lottery Holiday Scratchets. You know where to find them. Grab some today. Must be 18 or older to play lottery games are based on chance and should be played for entertainment only.