Summary of "Murder in Anglo-Saxon England" | Gone Medieval Podcast

Introduction

In the February 11, 2025 episode of Gone Medieval hosted by History Hit, Matt Lewis and Dr. Eleanor Janega delve into the intricate and often violent tapestry of early medieval England. Focusing on Annie Whitehead's book, Murder in Anglo-Saxon England, the discussion uncovers nearly a century of murder cases that illuminate the societal norms, power struggles, and justice systems of the time.

The Turbulent Reign of King Edwin

The episode opens with a deep dive into the assassination attempt on King Edwin of Northumbria. Matt Lewis sets the stage by explaining the fragmented nature of England during the 7th century, where multiple kingdoms, such as the Anglo-Saxons, Jutes, and Frisians, vied for power.

"This is at a time when there's no such thing as England. There are Anglo Saxons, Jutes, Frisians, whoever," Matt Lewis explains (05:18).

Edwin's tumultuous rise to power involved exile, rivalry, and eventual consolidation of his kingdom. An assassination attempt during a feast, orchestrated by the King of Wessex, is narrated in detail. Notably, Bede, a Northumbrian monk and primary source for this period, provides specific names and dramatic elements, such as the servant Leela who sacrifices himself to save Edwin (05:18).

The Violent Landscape of Northumbria

Dr. Janega highlights the recurring theme of kings being killed or deposed in Northumbria during the 8th century, emphasizing the era's instability.

“Kings in exile is a recurring theme... We might term English kingdoms, that there were jostling for control,” Dr. Janega notes (10:24).

Matt Lewis further elaborates on the sheer number of reigns and the often short and violent tenures of these kings. He lists various fates met by Northumbrian kings, including assassination, exile, and deposition, underscoring the relentless power struggles of the time (10:24).

The Role of Sources: Bede and Beyond

The conversation shifts to the reliability and perspective of historical sources. Bede's portrayal of Edwin is both admiring and strategic, reflecting his own religious and political biases.

"We have to assume that's in. So, you know, we have to... Bede is all about the religion and the conversion," Matt Lewis remarks (13:32).

Dr. Janega questions whether Bede's focus on assassination over battlefield confrontations serves to highlight divine intervention or to underscore non-Christian elements within the narrative (11:35). Matt concurs, suggesting that Bede's selective storytelling paints Edwin as a divinely protected and strong leader, which might not fully represent the complex political dynamics of the time (13:02).

Stories of Offa's Queen and Daughter

Moving forward, the podcast explores the murky tales surrounding King Offa of Mercia, particularly focusing on his wife and daughter. Matt Lewis discusses chroniclers' embellished narratives, such as Queen Cunnethrith allegedly poisoning King Athelbert of East Anglia at her behest.

"She's actually supposed to have said... the king of East Anglia is killed and Offa goes into a terrible state," Matt recounts (42:32).

Further, the story of Offa's daughter, Beatrich, who purportedly poisoned her husband and fled to Charlemagne's court, showcases the intertwining of political maneuvering and personal vendettas in these narratives. Dr. Janega and Matt analyze the plausibility of these stories, considering the potential biases and motives of the chroniclers (37:47; 42:58).

Women and Children in Anglo-Saxon Murder Narratives

A significant portion of the episode examines the role and portrayal of women and children in these medieval murder stories. Dr. Janega points out the gender dynamics, noting that women often appear as central figures in these tales, either as conspirators or victims.

"When the children are involved, it's like... they're going so hardcore on the gore," Dr. Janega observes (54:20).

Matt Lewis discusses the contrast between Anglo-Saxon sources, which often name and attribute actions to women, and later Anglo-Norman chroniclers who tend to demonize them further. He highlights examples like Queen Althreth, who was both a powerful figure and accused of heinous crimes, reflecting shifting societal attitudes toward women over time (63:05).

Conclusion: The Complexity of Medieval Murder

The episode concludes by acknowledging the complexities and challenges in interpreting medieval murder narratives. Matt emphasizes the importance of scrutinizing sources and understanding the biases inherent in historical accounts.

"We've got to take these stories with a pinch of salt," Matt advises (52:26), urging listeners to consider the broader political and social contexts that shaped these narratives.

Dr. Janega echoes this sentiment, appreciating the depth and intrigue of these histories while recognizing the distortions introduced by later chroniclers (64:36).

Notable Quotes

• Matt Lewis on the assassination attempt: "Edwin survived and he promised. Then essentially what Bede says is, after this, you know, brush with death, Edwin agreed to convert to Christianity." (05:18)

• Dr. Eleanor Janega on gender dynamics: "When the children are involved, it's like the minute there's a kid they're like, let's go." (54:20)

• Matt Lewis on the portrayal of women: "It's a shame that they're being portrayed so badly in a lot of the cases." (60:23)

Final Thoughts

"Murder in Anglo-Saxon England" offers a compelling exploration of the violent and politically charged environment of early medieval England. Through meticulous analysis of primary sources and a critical examination of historical narratives, Matt Lewis and Dr. Eleanor Janega shed light on the enduring fascination with medieval true crime and its relevance to understanding contemporary societal structures.

For more in-depth discussions and original documentaries on medieval history, consider subscribing to History Hit.

Note: Timestamp references correspond to points in the podcast transcript where specific discussions or quotes occur.