Gone South: Operation Sideswipe | Part 1
Season 4, Episode 38
Release Date: July 9, 2025
Host: Jed Lipinski

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "Operation Sideswipe | Part 1," Gone South delves deep into a sophisticated criminal conspiracy that has plagued the roadways of Orleans Parish, Louisiana. Host Jed Lipinski unravels the intricate web of staged trucking accidents designed to defraud insurance companies and trucking firms, showcasing how a seemingly minor scam evolved into a multi-million-dollar scheme involving prominent attorneys and organized conspirators.

The Emergence of a Scam

Nick Arnold, a defense attorney specializing in transportation and insurance in New Orleans since 2008, serves as a pivotal voice in this narrative. He recounts the origins of the scam, initially perceived as isolated incidents but soon recognized as part of a larger, orchestrated effort to exploit insurance systems.

Nick Arnold (02:50): "I think they were first called the truck stop cases."

These early scams involved individuals deliberately creating low-speed crashes with tractor trailers, making it appear as though the truck drivers were at fault. This tactic resulted in the scammers filing bogus insurance claims to secure payouts.

Scaling the Conspiracy

As the frequency and complexity of these staged accidents increased, Nick Arnold identified a more alarming variation where entire passenger vehicles were intentionally sideswiped by 18-wheelers on the interstate. This method not only amplified the insurance payouts due to increased injuries but also made the fraud appear more credible due to the scale of the accidents.

Nick Arnold (07:02): "So it doesn't really help to stage an accident against another passenger vehicle. You would want a commercial vehicle with million dollar policy minimum..."

The strategic focus on the Interstate 10 corridor and Orleans Parish was deliberate, targeting a liberal jury pool more inclined to award substantial settlements compared to their conservative counterparts in rural areas.

Uncovering the Web: Operation Sideswipe

By 2018, with the scam's magnitude becoming undeniable, the FBI and the U.S. Attorney's Office initiated a covert investigation named Operation Sideswipe. This federal probe aimed to dismantle the burgeoning network of criminals orchestrating the staged accidents.

Nick Arnold played a crucial role, collaborating with insurance adjusters and other defense attorneys to share insights and patterns that highlighted the scam's organized nature.

Nick Arnold (08:04): "Defense attorneys like Nick Arnold were the canaries in the coal mine. They spotted the scam before anyone else realized how big it was."

Key Players and Indictments

The investigation began with low-level participants, many of whom swiftly cooperated with authorities in exchange for leniency. However, the real breakthrough came with the indictment of personal injury attorney Danny Patrick Keating Jr., marking the first high-profile legal professional entangled in the scam.

Nick Arnold (15:27): "You settled your case for $100,000. You went home with $30,000 after expenses and attorney's fees. We know what you did. We want you to cooperate and tell us who got you involved."

As the case unraveled, it revealed deeper layers involving disbarred attorney Sean Alfortish and the formidable Vanessa Mata, known for her aggressive legal tactics and extensive caseload within a short span post-law school.

The Role of Litigation Finance

A critical component that facilitated the scam was litigation finance, where companies provided upfront funds to plaintiffs in exchange for a share of successful settlements or verdicts. Sean Alfortish's involvement through his litigation finance company not only funded but also actively participated in perpetuating the scam by recruiting and managing participants.

Nick Arnold (20:38): "He was able to find people who had, I say nothing to lose, but to get in a car. I'll make sure you get $601,000 to get in this accident."

Turning Points and Escalation

The indictment of Cornelius Garrison, a prominent "slammer" responsible for orchestrating numerous staged accidents, was a significant turning point. However, shortly after his indictment, Garrison was mysteriously killed, raising suspicions about the lengths to which conspirators would go to protect their interests.

Nick Arnold (28:18): "It was announced on maybe a Thursday that Garrison had been indicted by a federal grand jury and that he was cooperating."

This assassination highlighted the dangerous underbelly of the conspiracy, suggesting that higher-level operatives remained at large and potentially willing to eliminate threats to the operation.

Conclusion and Cliffhanger

As Gone South concludes Part 1 of "Operation Sideswipe," the episode leaves listeners on the edge of their seats. With high-level conspirators still at large and the federal investigation intensifying, the stage is set for further revelations and potential takedowns in the subsequent episodes. The intricate dance between law enforcement and the organized fraudsters underscores the complexities of combating sophisticated white-collar crimes.

Stay tuned for Part 2, where Jed Lipinski continues to uncover the layers of this Southern crime saga, exploring the human motivations and systemic vulnerabilities that allowed Operation Sideswipe to thrive.

Notable Quotes

• Nick Arnold (06:48): "What Nick and other attorneys in the trucking space started hearing about was something different. These weren't one offs. This was organized, methodical, and run like a business with a playbook designed to maximize insurance payouts."

• Nick Arnold (11:24): "Yeah, I thought the insanity of putting yourself in a vehicle that's sometimes lower than the truck itself and throwing yourself into that truck with the hope of $1,000 at a burger King after the accident... that just from a very pure, violent risk standpoint, bothered me."

• Nick Arnold (20:38): "He was able to find people who had, I say nothing to lose, but to get in a car. I'll make sure you get $601,000 to get in this accident."

Production Credits:
Gone South is created, written, and narrated by Jed Lipinski, with executive producers Jenna Weiss Berman, Maddie Sprung Kaiser, Tom Lipinski, Lloyd Lockridge, and Jed himself. The episode was meticulously edited by Chris Basel and Perry Crowell, with additional production support from Ian Mont and Sean Cherry.

Connect with Gone South:
For more stories, bonus content, and updates, follow Gone South on Facebook, TikTok, and Instagram. Subscribe to the newsletter on Substack to stay informed about upcoming episodes and exclusive insights.