
Original Air Date: May 08, 1960Host: Andrew RhynesShow: GunsmokePhone: (707) 98 OTRDW (6-8739) Stars:• William Conrad (Matt Dillion)• Parley Baer (Chester)• Georgia Ellis (Kitty)• Howard McNear (Doc) Special Guests:• Harry Bartell• Sam Edwards• Lawrenc...
Loading summary
Matt Dillon
Foreign.
Andrew Rines
Welcome to the Old Time Radio Westerns. I'm your host, Andrew Rines, and I'm excited to bring you another episode absolutely free. This is one of over 80 episodes released monthly for your enjoyment. Now, let's get into this episode.
William Conrad
Around Dodge City and in the territory on west, there's just one way to handle the killers and the spoilers, and that's with a U.S. marshal.
Matt Dillon
And the smell of guns. Smell? Smoke.
William Conrad
Gun smoke. Starring William Conrad. The story of the violence that moved west with young America and the story of a man who moved with it.
Matt Dillon
I'm that man. Matt Dillon, United States Marshal. The first man they look for and the last they want to meet. It's a chance, a job. And it makes a man watchful and a little lonely.
Jim Waddell
I ain't hiding. Come around back.
Ruth Waddell
I didn't know if you was to the house.
Jim Waddell
Yeah, well, I ain't now. Why? Were you lost finding Dodge?
Ruth Waddell
Lost? Well, you know why I wasn't lost, Pa. Been there twice since we come here.
Jim Waddell
What kept you? Well, I stopped off in one of them saloons.
Ruth Waddell
You know I ain't never been in one of them places, Pa. You'll go in one.
Jim Waddell
You just keep right on riding through town. Don't never bother to come back home.
Ruth Waddell
I know, Pa. What kept you there was one of them medicine shows, Pa. Fella with a magic AK and a pretty girl.
Jim Waddell
You were supposed to ride right home.
Ruth Waddell
I was thinking on you, Paul, with them pains in your back. This elixir some fellow was talking about. It would have fixed you up real good.
Jim Waddell
You didn't buy none.
Ruth Waddell
Well, you know I didn't have no money for it, Paul.
Jim Waddell
That's a good thing.
Ruth Waddell
Oh, they was selling a lot of it. And folks was drinking it down right there. You could see right away that they was feeling better.
Jim Waddell
Did you get what you went for?
Ruth Waddell
Oh, sure, Pa. I fetched a paper from the lawyer feller and about buying this place. And I fetched the mail, too.
Jim Waddell
Mail? Now, who'd be writing it's from?
Ruth Waddell
Jim. He must have found out we'd moved here.
Jim Waddell
You must want something pretty bad.
Ruth Waddell
Well, he. He's coming through this way. He wants to stop and stay a spell.
Jim Waddell
He ain't welcome.
Ruth Waddell
Jim's your boy, same as.
Jim Waddell
Not anymore, he ain't.
Ruth Waddell
Well, you ain't seen him in three years.
Jim Waddell
That was his doing, not mine. Him and his fancy manners and his fancy women. He didn't belong around his home no more.
Chester Proudfoot
What?
Ruth Waddell
I'd kind of like to see Jim.
Jim Waddell
Again, Pa. You ain't going to do it. Your brother's gone bad, Ruth. Mean, fancy bad. He didn't come when your ma lay dying and he ain't coming here whilst I live. Now, you got that straight?
Ruth Waddell
Yes, Paul.
Jim Waddell
All right, then. Come help me with this stock and try to do something right for once.
Chester Proudfoot
Plenty more coffee, Sheriff. You'd like another cup of it?
Matt Dillon
Oh, this will do nicely, thank you, Chester.
Chester Proudfoot
Wouldn't be no trouble. It's all hot and everything.
Matt Dillon
No, no, thanks. Hello, Blair. I'm sorry to keep you waiting, Matt.
Chester Proudfoot
I've been extending to him the courtesies of your office, Mr. John.
Matt Dillon
You've been what? Give me some coffee. I don't know if that was a courtesy or not.
Chester Proudfoot
How's that?
Matt Dillon
It's all right, Chester. Matter of fact, I'll have some myself.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, sure. Ah.
Matt Dillon
Something on your mind, Blair, besides that cup of coffee? Yeah, Matt, there is. I'm after a man I'd like you to keep a lookout for. I think he may pass through here.
Jack Norman
In his way from Texas.
Matt Dillon
Oh. Name's Waddell. Jim Waddell.
Chester Proudfoot
Here's your coffee, Mr. Jones.
Matt Dillon
Oh, thanks, Sheffner. What's he done? Just about everything. But I want him for murder. You got a circular on him? No, there isn't one out yet. How's he look like? He doesn't look like the kind who gets in trouble. He's a slick one. Never carries a gun, dresses like a dude. Does he act like one? Yeah. He's a soft spoken fella. Fancy mannered, especially with the ladies. He shouldn't be too hard to spot if he comes through a place like Dodge. Maybe not, but I'd be careful with him. No, he likes to do his killing with a knife. And he don't care much whether it's.
Jim Waddell
A man or woman.
Matt Dillon
I'll keep an eye out for him. Blair. If you spot him, will you lock them up till I can come get him? Yeah, I'll let you know if I do.
Kitty
Just look at that.
Matt Dillon
Look at what?
Kitty
The plate full of leftovers they serve you for stew.
Matt Dillon
I don't know, Kitty. Tastes pretty good to me.
Kitty
Everything tastes good to you.
Matt Dillon
Well, food's food, you know.
Kitty
That's the trouble with this town.
Matt Dillon
What? The food?
Kitty
The food and everything in it. Including the people.
Chester Proudfoot
Ah.
Matt Dillon
Somebody been giving you trouble?
Kitty
Oh, no. Isn't anybody in particular? Just everybody.
Matt Dillon
It's taken in a lot of territory, isn't it?
Kitty
Sometimes I think if I see another drunken cowboy, I'll scream.
Matt Dillon
Your saloon makes a lot of money off of Drunken cowboys. Kidding.
Kitty
Yeah, but I don't have to like it.
Matt Dillon
Maybe not. There are a lot of other people in town.
Kitty
Yeah. They're either blown dry by the prairie or trying so hard to scramble for money they never look up.
Matt Dillon
You're in a mood for fair, aren't you?
Kitty
I guess I am. Sometimes I just get sick of it all.
Matt Dillon
Well, I sort of admit that Dodge isn't the prettiest place I've ever seen.
Kitty
Well, the people aren't very pretty, either.
Matt Dillon
Oh, come on, Kitty. Have some more coffee. It'll make you feel better.
Kitty
No, no, thanks. You have some. I think I'll go on.
Matt Dillon
You sure?
Kitty
Yeah, sure.
Matt Dillon
You want me to come along with you?
Kitty
No, thanks. I'll go on alone. See you later.
Matt Dillon
All right, Kitty.
Kitty
Thanks for the d.
Jack Norman
Oh, hello, Miss Kitty.
Kitty
Hello.
Jack Norman
Beg your pardon.
Kitty
You could at least look where you're going.
Jack Norman
Did I hurt you, ma' am?
Kitty
No, no, you didn't hurt me.
Jack Norman
I certainly am relieved to hear that.
Kitty
My purse.
Jack Norman
I'll get it. Here you are, ma' am. And if there's any damage, I'll be glad to buy you a new one.
Kitty
Well, no, it doesn't really hurt you.
Jack Norman
Be sure now. It was right clumsy at me, bumping into a lady like that.
Kitty
Oh, it could happen to anyone. You're new and Dodge, aren't you?
Jack Norman
Why, yes, ma' am. Jack Norman at your service.
Kitty
Well, I don't know where you came from, Mr. Norman, but you sure don't act like the men around this town. They'd bump into you without even noticing.
Jack Norman
I find it hard to believe anyone wouldn't notice you, ma' am.
Kitty
No, sir, Mr. Norman, you don't act like anybody I know.
Chester Proudfoot
Two beers, Sam.
Jack Norman
Two beers.
Chester Proudfoot
It's my turn to buy, Mr. John.
Matt Dillon
All right, Chester, get your money up.
Chester Proudfoot
I got it right here.
Matt Dillon
You know, you're a real sport, Chester.
Chester Proudfoot
Oh, n. It ain't nothing.
Jack Norman
Here you are.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, I declare, Ms. Dylan, on a hot day, a glass of beer tastes almost as good as a cup of my coffee.
Matt Dillon
Yeah.
Chester Proudfoot
That was a sort of a joke, Mr. Dylan. That was. That's a nice fellow, ain't he, that Kitty's having a drink with?
Matt Dillon
It seems all right.
Chester Proudfoot
George like to have her sat down at his table.
Matt Dillon
Kitty sells a lot of drinks that way.
Chester Proudfoot
Look, she's coming over here.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. She'll lose money on us, Chester.
Jack Norman
I reckon she will.
Chester Proudfoot
I ain't got no more to spend. Well, hello, Miss Kitty.
Kitty
Hello, Chester, Matt.
Matt Dillon
Hi, Kitty.
Kitty
You boys want to sit down?
Matt Dillon
No, thanks, Kitty. I got to be getting back and Chester's out of money.
Kitty
Well, it sounds like I'm wasting my time.
Chester Proudfoot
Is your friend, that Mr. Norman, gonna be in town for long?
Kitty
Oh, I don't know. Chester. He's having pretty good luck at that poker game over there. He may not be in any hurry.
Chester Proudfoot
See, they just dealt him in again.
Kitty
Yeah. Hope he has good luck.
Matt Dillon
He's in with a tough bunch.
Kitty
Oh, he can handle himself.
Matt Dillon
Hey.
Ruth Waddell
Hey, look, they're fighting.
William Conrad
Come on.
Matt Dillon
That's enough.
Kitty
Watch that.
Matt Dillon
Hold on. All right. Yeah, just stand easy, Mort.
Jim Waddell
I ain't the one to grab hold of Marshall. He's the one that pulled the knife, Norman.
Matt Dillon
Yes, sir, he sure did. All right. What about that Norman?
Jack Norman
Man has to protect his interest, Marshall. It was a crooked deal.
Jim Waddell
Ain't nothing dirtier than a knife fighter.
Matt Dillon
I'll take your knife.
Jack Norman
It won't be necessary, Marshall. I won't hurt him.
Matt Dillon
I said I'll take the knife.
Jack Norman
I don't think.
Matt Dillon
Now that's better. Now, do you always carry a knife, Norman?
Jack Norman
I don't like guns. Marshal Dillon.
Matt Dillon
I see you been in Texas lately?
Jack Norman
Yes, I have. I'm on my way from there now.
Matt Dillon
Where are you headed?
Jack Norman
Why, I haven't made up my mind. Just sort of going from town to town, taking it as it comes.
Matt Dillon
With your knife handy, huh?
Jack Norman
Well, now, Marshal, a man has to protect himself.
Matt Dillon
Have you ever killed anybody with that knife?
Jack Norman
It was necessary once, Marshal. Like I said, a man needs protection.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Oh, so does the law.
Jack Norman
How's that?
Matt Dillon
I'm gonna lock you up for a.
Jack Norman
Couple of days for getting into a fight. I didn't hurt anybody.
Matt Dillon
Move. Yeah. She being a little hasty maybe, But I'm gonna hold him until I hear from Blair.
Kitty
I don't think Jack's a killer.
Matt Dillon
I don't know whether he is or not yet. I'm still gonna lock him up.
Jack Norman
You've got no right to do this, Marshall.
Matt Dillon
You can argue about that in jail.
Jack Norman
Making a big mistake.
Matt Dillon
Mistake? If I am, I'm sure I'll hear about it.
Jack Norman
I'm sure you will too.
Matt Dillon
All right, come on, Chester, let's get him out of here.
Chester Proudfoot
Oh, here you are. Was there a telegram for you, Mr. Dillon?
Matt Dillon
Uh huh.
Chester Proudfoot
Does Sheriff Blair think he's the right fellow?
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Everything matches up but his name.
Chester Proudfoot
Fella could change that easy, no.
Matt Dillon
Yeah.
Chester Proudfoot
I know one thing. I'll be glad to be rid of him one way or the other.
Matt Dillon
He seems quiet enough when I'm around. Chester. Is he causing you trouble?
Chester Proudfoot
Oh, it ain't what he does, it ain't even what he says. It's more the way he says it.
Matt Dillon
He's a smooth talker, all right.
Chester Proudfoot
More like a smart Alec, in my way of thinking.
Matt Dillon
Hello, Kitty.
Chester Proudfoot
Thanks, Kitty.
Kitty
Did you find out anything about Jack Norman?
Matt Dillon
Yeah, we.
Chester Proudfoot
Mr. Dylan disc got a telegraph about him. Sheriff claims he's the right one, all right.
Kitty
Well, it's about time he came and made certain, isn't it?
Matt Dillon
Well, he can't start for a day or two. He's got something to attend to in Wichita.
Kitty
So Norman sits in jail while she, Sheriff Blair takes his time.
Matt Dillon
Well, Kitty, there isn't anything I can do about it.
Kitty
Maybe not. You had to arrest him in the first place.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Come on, Chester. Poor Kitty takes over my office.
Kitty
Sometimes I think I could do a better job of it.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, man, she's kind of all fizzed up, ain't she? I. I mean about that fella Norman being put in jail.
Matt Dillon
Chester, don't try to figure out women.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, there's nothing wrong with your appetite. I can say that.
Jack Norman
Ask the marshal to step back here, will you?
Chester Proudfoot
Well, now, Mr. Dillon is a busy man tending to his job, and I'm.
Jack Norman
Part of his job. Go on, tell him I want to see him.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, Mr. Dillon. Yeah, Chester, he wants to see you. I'll take the tray back.
Matt Dillon
You got something to say to me?
Jack Norman
Yes, Marshall, I do. I think it's about time we were honest with each other.
Matt Dillon
All right.
Jack Norman
I just want you to know I understand how you marshals have to operate.
Matt Dillon
That's so.
Jack Norman
You hear about a crime, then you have to arrest somebody, anybody, to make a show of doing your job.
Matt Dillon
That's the way you figure it, huh?
Jack Norman
That's the way it is. Well, I can see how you have to do these things, but don't you think it's about time to let me go now?
Matt Dillon
No, I don't.
Jack Norman
You haven't got a shred of evidence against me.
Chester Proudfoot
Matt.
Matt Dillon
Oh, Matt. Back here, Doc.
Jim Waddell
Oh.
Kitty
Matt.
Jack Norman
The Reed boy just rode into town for me. Says there's been a terrible ruckus out at the Waddell place.
Matt Dillon
Waddell?
Jack Norman
They're those new folks out west of town. The old man's been hurt bad. Stabbed, I understand. I thought maybe you'd want to ride out, wouldn't they?
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Yeah, Doc, I do. Come.
Jim Waddell
Oh, good. You.
Jack Norman
You got the water. Pour some into that pan, will you, Matt?
Matt Dillon
Yeah, sure. Do you.
Ruth Waddell
Now?
Matt Dillon
Here you are.
Jack Norman
Thank you. Now, just hold his head up a little.
Jim Waddell
Easy.
Jack Norman
Easy now. We'll fix it.
Matt Dillon
Who did this, Waddell? Can you tell me who did it?
William Conrad
Right.
Jim Waddell
I should have known and never thought that.
Matt Dillon
Me, his own pa. Will you tell me about it?
Jim Waddell
Jim, my boy, he wanted to hide.
Matt Dillon
Here in the house and you wouldn't let him.
Jim Waddell
We ain't got much, Marshall, but we abide by the law. I told him to go.
Matt Dillon
Then what happened?
Jim Waddell
He was trying to get in the door and I wouldn't let him. He cut me. Knifed his own paw.
Matt Dillon
Where did he go, Mr. Wenneau?
Jim Waddell
He made Ruth go with him. Poor slow Rufe. Jim. Jim will kill him, Marshall.
Matt Dillon
Can you tell me where he went? Just try and tell me that.
Jim Waddell
I'm not sure. Loaded horses with supplies. He could have doubled back toward Texas.
Matt Dillon
All right. We'll find it.
Jim Waddell
No, don't. Don't want no harm to come to roof. He ain't bright. He's a good boy. And Jim will kill him.
Matt Dillon
Maybe I can stop that. Mr. Wato.
Chester Proudfoot
I swear, I don't understand why this Jim took his brother along with him. You'd think he'd have finished him off long this fall.
Matt Dillon
He figures to use him some way, Chester.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, maybe. But you'd think that anyhow.
Matt Dillon
Never mind, Chester. Just keep your eye on that shack up ahead.
Chester Proudfoot
Figure they might be up there?
Matt Dillon
They might be anywhere.
Chester Proudfoot
Going in there?
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Leave the horses behind these rocks and bring your rifle. I will head for the side. Get down.
Chester Proudfoot
Guess we found.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Just stay low.
Jim Waddell
Don't come any closer.
Matt Dillon
I'm a U.S. marshal, Waddo. There are two of us there.
Jim Waddell
I'm honored, Marshal.
Matt Dillon
You have a better chance if you give yourself up.
Jim Waddell
Can't quite see that, Marshal.
Matt Dillon
We can wait you out, Waddo.
Jim Waddell
No. No, I don't think so.
Chester Proudfoot
Look, he's opening the door.
Jim Waddell
There are two of us, too. Ruth, stand that door.
Chester Proudfoot
Ms. Dunkey. Standing there without no gun nor nothing.
Matt Dillon
Now, that's the other one. Waddell, your brother's an innocent man. No use letting him get hurt.
Jim Waddell
I hoped you'd feel that way, Marshall. Rufe won't get hurt as long as.
Matt Dillon
You let me move freely.
Jim Waddell
You understand?
Matt Dillon
It won't work. Weto be your fault if it doesn't.
Jim Waddell
I'm moving out of here now.
Matt Dillon
Roof in front of me.
Jim Waddell
I'm coming for your horses. You make any move, I'll have to shoot.
Chester Proudfoot
Ruth, you'll do it too. Mr. Dillon.
Matt Dillon
Yeah. Don't shoot, sister.
Jim Waddell
Glad to see you have good judgment, Marshal. You just walk steady, Ruth. My dad. Michael. You stupid kid. Jim.
Chester Proudfoot
Shot him.
Matt Dillon
Cover me, Chester.
Jim Waddell
Don't come any closer.
Ruth Waddell
Marshall.
Chester Proudfoot
Mr. Dillon. Well, I didn't mean to kill him. I just.
Matt Dillon
All right, Chester, you did fine. Catch a canteen.
Chester Proudfoot
Yes, sir.
Matt Dillon
Roof.
Ruth Waddell
Jim.
Matt Dillon
Your brother's dead. Ruth, we didn't have much choice.
Ruth Waddell
I know that, Marshall. Pa. How's Pa?
Matt Dillon
He has a chance.
Kitty
We.
Ruth Waddell
You tell him.
Matt Dillon
Tell him what?
Ruth Waddell
You tell him I. I stopped him.
Matt Dillon
Sure. Oh, sure.
Ruth Waddell
I had done much for Paul was right, but you tell him. You tell him I stopped Jim. Nope. That was right, Marshall, wasn't it?
Matt Dillon
That was right.
Ruth Waddell
Ruth, will you tell Paul?
Matt Dillon
Yeah, I'll tell him. All right, Norman, you can go.
Jack Norman
About time.
Matt Dillon
I. I'm sorry. I was wrong about you. I know.
Jack Norman
I know you're sorry, but I've been sitting in this cell for a week. Wasted a lot of my time.
Matt Dillon
Well, don't let me waste any more of it, then.
Jack Norman
Gotta figure a small town lawman doesn't know any better.
Matt Dillon
All right, go on, get out of here.
Jack Norman
It's my pleasure. My pleasure, Marshall.
Chester Proudfoot
Doggone him, Mr. Dung. He didn't have no right to talk to you like that.
Matt Dillon
I don't know, Chester. I can't blame him too much.
Chester Proudfoot
Yeah, but you.
Matt Dillon
He was right about one thing. I locked up the wrong man.
Chester Proudfoot
Well, maybe you did. But you got the right man too, didn't you?
Matt Dillon
Yeah, with his brother's help, I got him.
Chester Proudfoot
People's a bunch of smart Alex. They ain't got no notion of what it takes to be a lawman. Tracking and trailing and risking life and land for folks that don't appreciate it. And half the time don't even deserve it. They make me sick. That's what they do.
Jim Waddell
Doggone them.
Chester Proudfoot
Mr. Dillon. Ms. Dylan, I'd be proud to buy you beer.
Matt Dillon
Thank you, Chester. I'd like that. I like that a lot.
Jim Waddell
Satisfaction produced and directed in Hollywood by.
William Conrad
Norman McDonald, stars William Conrad as Matt Dillon, U.S. marshal. The story was specially written for Gunsmoke by Marion Clark with editorial supervision by John Meston. Featured in the cast were Harry Bartel, Sam Edwards, Lawrence Dobkin, Vic Perrin and Jack Moyles. Harley Bear is Chester, Howard McNear is Doc and Georgia Ellis is Kitty. This is George Walsh inviting you to join us again next week when CBS Radio presents another story of the Western frontier. When Matt Dillon, Chester Proudfoot, Doc and Kitty, together with all the other hard living citizens of Dodge, will be with you once more. It's America growing west in the 1870s.
Jim Waddell
It's gun smoke.
Matt Dillon
Foreign.
Andrew Rines
This has been a presentation of otrwesterns.com and we hope you enjoyed. Please take some time to like and rate this episode within your favorite podcast application. Follow us on Facebook by going to otrwesterns.com Facebook and subscribe to our YouTube channel by going to otrwesterns.Com.
Matt Dillon
Become one.
Andrew Rines
Of our ranch hands and unlock some exclusive content. We want to thank our most recent ranch hands, Steve Technogod and Craig who joined us recently. You too can join by going to otrwesterns.com donate send us an email podcast trwesterns.com and you can call and leave us a voicemail. 707-986-8739 this episode is copyrighted under the Attribution Non Commercial Share Like Copyright. For more information go to otrwesterns.com copyright have a great day and thanks for listening.
Jim Waddell
Sam.
In the "Wrong Man" episode of Gunsmoke, set in the rugged terrains of Dodge City, Kansas, U.S. Marshal Matt Dillon faces the challenges of law enforcement in the American West. Hosted by Andrew Rines and featuring the iconic voice of William Conrad as Matt Dillon, this episode delves into themes of justice, mistaken identity, and the complexities of human relationships during the settlement era.
The episode begins with Matt Dillon receiving a report about a man named Jim Waddell, suspected of murder. Matt approaches Sheriff Blair to gather more information. As Dillon discusses the apprehension guidelines, he describes Jim Waddell as a "slick one" who "doesn't carry a gun" but instead "does his killing with a knife" ([05:12] Matt Dillon). Despite not having an active warrant, Matt decides to keep an eye out for Waddell, demonstrating his proactive approach to maintaining law and order in Dodge City.
At the sheriff's office, Matt encounters Kitty, Chester Proudfoot, and Doc. Kitty expresses her frustration with the town's rough elements, saying, "The food and everything in it. Including the people" ([06:30] Kitty), highlighting the social challenges faced by residents. Chester Proudfoot, the friendly bartender, provides a glimpse into the community's dynamics, emphasizing the strain lawmen endure: "They make me sick. That's what they do" ([23:29] Chester Proudfoot).
Matt's investigation leads him to Jack Norman, a newcomer to Dodge City who doesn't fit the typical profile of a troublemaker. Despite lacking a criminal record, Matt arrests Norman based on circumstantial evidence and Sheriff Blair's circular. Norman's calm demeanor and refusal to carry a gun make him an unlikely suspect, leading Matt to reflect, "He shouldn't be too hard to spot if he comes through a place like Dodge" ([05:38] Matt Dillon). This pivotal moment showcases the challenges of identifying the right suspect based solely on behavior and reputation.
As the plot unfolds, it's revealed that Jim Waddell, Norman's brother, is the actual perpetrator behind the stabbing incident. Jim admits, "He wanted to hide" and "He cut me. Knifed his own paw" ([17:30] Jim Waddell), indicating a personal conflict that escalated tragically. Ruth Waddell, Jim's wife, pleads with Matt, saying, "I stopped him. You tell him" ([21:46] Ruth Waddell), adding emotional depth to the narrative and highlighting the collateral impact of Jim's actions on his family.
The tension culminates in a dramatic showdown between Matt Dillon and Jim Waddell. As Matt confronts Jim, he states, "I have to arrest somebody, anybody, to make a show of doing your job" ([15:19] Matt Dillon), emphasizing the burden of responsibility on lawmen. Jim attempts to negotiate, revealing his disdain for guns and preference for knives: "I don't like guns" ([11:32] Jack Norman). The standoff escalates when Jim threatens to kill Matt's horse unless surrendered, leading to a fatal shootout where Jim is killed. Chester Proudfoot reluctantly takes the fatal shot, expressing regret: "I didn't mean to kill him. I just..." ([21:14] Chester Proudfoot).
In the aftermath, Matt acknowledges his mistake in arresting the wrong man but also recognizes that bringing the true culprit to justice was achieved. He apologizes to Jack Norman, saying, "I'm sorry. I was wrong about you" ([22:43] Matt Dillon), demonstrating his integrity and commitment to justice. Chester Proudfoot reflects on the complexities faced by lawmen, stating, "They make me sick. That's what they do" ([23:25] Chester Proudfoot), underscoring the emotional toll of Matt's profession.
Matt Dillon: "He shouldn’t be too hard to spot if he comes through a place like Dodge." ([05:38])
Kitty: "The food and everything in it. Including the people." ([06:30])
Jim Waddell: "I don’t like guns. Marshal Dillon." ([11:32])
Ruth Waddell: "I stopped him. You tell him." ([21:46])
Chester Proudfoot: "They make me sick. That's what they do." ([23:25])
"Wrong Man" is a compelling episode that highlights the precarious nature of justice in the Old West. Through Matt Dillon's journey, listeners explore the moral dilemmas faced by lawmen, the impact of personal relationships on justice, and the often-blurred lines between right and wrong. The episode effectively balances action with emotional depth, making it a standout story in the Gunsmoke series.
This summary is based on the transcript provided and captures the essence of the "Wrong Man" episode of Gunsmoke, aired on May 8, 1960.