
Scott Wapner and the Investment Committee debate the state of the tech trade after Nvidia gets crushed. The experts detail their latest portfolio moves. The Chart of the Day is UnitedHealth and Steve Weiss calls in with his trade. Josh Brown adds a new name to his “best stocks in the market” list.
Loading summary
Scott Wapner
Growing a business can feel impossible, but with HubSpot's built in AI, you can get more done than ever before, which means anything's possible. Breeze agents help you do things in seconds that used to take hours, providing the customer support of 5 us generating the content of 10 us. And Breeze Copilot keeps you two steps ahead, giving you the right insights at the right time to close more deals than ever. HubSpot Impossible growth made impossibly easy. Get started today@HubSpot.com AI are you still quoting 30 year old movies? Have you said cool beans in the past 90 days? Do you think Discover isn't widely accepted? If this sounds like you, you're stuck in the past. Discover is accepted at 99% of places that take credit cards nationwide. And every time you make a purchase with your card, you automatically earn cash back. Welcome to the now it pays to Discover. Learn more@discover.com CreditCard Based on the February 2024 Nelson Report, I'm Scott Wapner and.
Josh Brown
You'Re listening to CNBC's Halftime Report, the podcast the most profitable hour of the trading day. We record this live weekdays at 12 Eastern. Listen in. All right, Carl, thanks very much. Welcome to the Halftime Report. I'm Scott Wapner. Front and center this hour, the state of the tech trade after Nvidia gets crushed and we're not seeing much of a rebound today. We will discuss with the investment committee. Joining me for the hour, Josh Brown, Jenny Harrington, Jim Leventhal and Bill Baruch. We will show you the markets here obviously being heavily skewed. The Dow is by unh. We'll get to that a little bit later. We're going to get to Powell versus the President a little bit later as well. But a really big story continues to be tech. We're watching it closely. You had the double whammy yesterday, Josh, the export curbs, and then you had the New York Times reporting about a possible deep sea bar of buying tech from the US how about this stat, too? Before you give me your thoughts here, JP Morgan's retail investor tracker. Not institutions, not the fund flows that we cite often from bank of America, but JP Morgan's retail investor tracker, the biggest in video outflow since 2015. You think about that?
Jim Leventhal
Yeah, look, I think this is an area of the market where people got really excited and of course the promise of AI is exciting. But you know, allocations got stretched, valuations got stretched. People were looking at the sector as this incredible secular growth story where it almost didn't matter what was happening in the rest of the economy because it's this technological shift and everyone has to invest and etcetera, etcetera. There's really no such thing as a technology Trend that is 100% completely impervious to the cyclical picture around it. As much as we would love to believe that that's a thing that exists, it really doesn't. And then the other thing is this is not just a cyclical story, it's a political story wrapped around a cyclical story. And the AI chips and semiconductors and the data center spend and the AI spend, it's all like highly politically fraught. So it's not secular to the point where you could just wall it off. And I think when you talk about the flows that you just pointed out, Judge, I think that's just like an acknowledgment on the part of the public at large. Yes, Nvidia is great. Yes, GPUs are strategically important. Yes, it's really cool, all the things that you could do with AI. But this is going to be a roller coaster because you've got now the political angle, you've got the cyclical economy around it, you've got crashing stock prices amongst the companies that are supposed to be the companies that are going to spend the most right now. The median Percentage below the 52 week highs for a technology stock, by the way, is negative 29%. So the S&P negative, I don't know, 14 or 13. The median tech stock is in a 30% bear market. So all of that gets called into question. People look at a stock that they're up 500% in. The easiest decision in the world is, all right, I got to take something off. I got to lessen the pain here. I'll sell a little Nvidia. And that stat that you just quoted is all of those things writ large in one number, distilling all down.
Josh Brown
I've got, you know, ownership obviously on the desk. Bill, what do you do within your own Nvidia position here? We know that Jensen Huang has flown to Beijing for talks. You got price target cuts consistently now on the street, including yet again today. UBS did it today to Nvidia 180 from 185. That looks a little adventurous considering you're at 100 bucks right now. Is it going to get back to 180 anytime soon? What do you think?
Bill Baruch
Well, we're not projecting 180, you know, anytime soon. I do think the back half of the year for Nvidia in the air trade is Going to be much better than what we're seeing right now.
Josh Brown
Why is that?
Bill Baruch
Well, I think a lot of these policies we're going to work through right now, it's uncertainty. I mean, let's talk macro about it. I mean, uncertainty is really driving this market. When those April 2 tariffs were announced that the result was not on the probability spectrum, the market raced to, to the discount the situation. What we saw in the aftermath was the Vix hitting 60. We saw three of the five most highest volume days in the S and P in history. That's capitulation. I mean, those, those are things that we had some cash on the sidelines. We want to be looking to be a buyer. You know, Nvidia 95 to 100 is attractive. Now, do I like seeing the move we've seen the past week where it went up Sunday night, I think it was trading as high as 115 and then it's surrendered all that. The news flow is not good and it hasn't been good. But I think there is a light at the end of the tunnel here where we're flushing out a lot of the negativity and we get the semiconductor news this week that everybody was really anticipating and yesterday it got bludgeoned again. So I am looking forward to the earnings that we're going to see in the coming weeks from some of these hyperscalers. Where is their spend?
Josh Brown
We flushing out the negativity? It feels like we're surrounded by it.
Bill Baruch
Oh, yeah.
Josh Brown
Like we're not ridding ourselves of it in any way as it relates to export curbs, whether it obviously relates to tariffs and the trade war with China. And then you have the residual effects potentially of a slowdown in the economy further than now, which you get a drop in spend from the hyperscalers. So what are we flushing through?
Bill Baruch
Well, I think looking at that, flushing out the negativity of Vix at 60, I mean, could you. Could you believe. I mean, and imagine us going back up there. So what causes a vix get to 60 is flushing out the negativity. You have hedge fund desks that take on exposure, a certain amount of exposure. When The Vix is 15 to 20, they have to, they have to de risk. When it's 20 to 30, imagine how much they have to de risk. When we're talking 50 to 60 Vix or constantly above 40, we are flushing out. There's positions being taken down. If the market can steady a bit, even if we go down and make a new low with lower volume, that is a very Positive thing here.
Josh Brown
Okay, so you're talking about negativity of the overall market, not around in video.
Bill Baruch
Well, I did. I'm, I've got macro real quick on it and I want to say that what we're looking at with Nvidia, I mean there's still high demand for, for deep Seek. And if you didn't expect that China was going to get, you know, some, some export controls, then, I mean, it wasn't factored in to your, to your narrative, then you would be surprised. But I don't think you shouldn't be totally surprised about what we saw on last Sunday. When Lutna came out and put, poured cold water over the Saturday news. We knew something was coming from semiconductors. We didn't know how bad it would be. Down 7% in a day, was down as much as 10%. I think we're flushing out some negativity. It can't find ground right now. There's a lot of uncertainty. But look at the reaction. The market is very reflexive right now. And if we get any sort of positive news here in videos, we back at 115 to 120 over a couple of weeks and then if we get good earnings, I mean that's how we get back to 130. 180 is not what we're concerned about. Let's get back to 120s.
Josh Brown
Well, that, that's why it's been hard. You know, I hear a lot of people say it's really hard to get all beared up now from here because we are a few type keys away from anything. You just don't know.
Jenny Harrington
Right. In both directions. Right? Yeah, we're a few type type keys away from, from good or bad. And I think what the challenge of being a portfolio in the man at, of being a portfolio manager in this moment is, is that we're all looking for the answer and the answer doesn't exist right now. There are no concrete answers. I've explained it to clients like in a normal market environment and we're trying to make decisions and the decision tree has three branches or five branches. And we can kind of say, hey, here are the two statistically most probable branches in this environment, the decision trees. Branches have exploded to, I don't know, 100, you know, and when we say things like what, you know, what's behind this policy? What's behind that policy? What's the end game? I'm going to tell you all, there's not an answer to that right now. Right. There's really Not.
Josh Brown
I know, but everybody knows that, you know, what do you think?
Jenny Harrington
I don't think you're right.
Josh Brown
I think how many times, I mean, we've said uncertainty, like $650,000.
Jenny Harrington
There's a reason in the last week, there's a reason. And people still think that if they read enough and if they dig enough, they're going to find it. At the macro level, you can't. So I think Bill, you know, this is getting semantic on what Bill saying, but Bill saying, we're flushing it out. And my question to you, Bill, would be, okay, at what point is it flushed out? And what makes it complicated too is you never know. But, but you know what it's like, what's that porn thing like? You can't define porn. But you know, when you see it, we've all been around long enough.
Josh Brown
But I think my great, I think my larger point honestly is the idea that why we're focused so heavily on this trade is because there was a defensive tilt to it for a good while in this market. When things got a little bit dicey, these were the stocks that hung in there more than the others. And they were a port in what was a storm over periods of time. Now I think they're more questionable, which is why the market is questionable in its direction right now.
Scott Wapner
Has questioned it. Absolutely, the market has questioned it. I mean, Nvidia is 1/3 off of its high from just several months ago. The S&P 500 is off 15% from the high of just two months ago. So Jenny, when you said, you know, the tweet can go or the news item can go either direction, that's absolutely true. But the market has already taken us in one direction, whether it's the market for Nvidia or the market overall. And just to put a little bit of a finer point on this, we've already gone through the risks. And Josh, you mentioned valuation, but you went by it. I just want to add a little more to that. I mean, Nvidia is Now trading at 22 times times forward earnings. We can have a discussion about whether that's expensive or cheap. I will give you my opinion that it's cheap and I will base that just not just on the growth rate of 40 odd percent going forward in earnings that's estimated. But I'll also put that multiple of 22 times forward earnings up against other companies that I think we know and respect. Think about for instance, a Proctor and Gamble, which has a Forward earnings roughly 23 times. Think about a John Deere has afford earnings roughly 24 times. And my point with this is not to say anything negative about those stocks, but to say that the earnings growth rate projected in Nvidia even after all the bad news on China on Deep Sea is still multiples of the earnings growth rates on.
Bill Baruch
That's the multiple it was when it was a gaming chip company. It started the fourth industrial revolution. I mean this, I mean that's a great time to be looking at buying long term for Nvidia right here.
Jenny Harrington
But the earnings are not as certain today as they were before and even, even reflected in the price. I don't think. No, I don't think so. I definitely, I don't think you can put as much. No, because you're saying it's 22 times. I don't forward earnings.
Josh Brown
Well, the multiple is right, but fine.
Jenny Harrington
But they're going to be.
Josh Brown
Well, I don't know. I think Jenny's point is maybe it's not fully reflected in that. If you have an actual recession. Right. So you have a. Hold on, let me finish. A larger retraction in GDP then you have what potentially Satya Nadella warned about a week or so ago that well, of course we expect to spend all this money but it is somewhat GDP dependent. Like you have to maintain a certain level of economic power to expect that this stock is going to continue to power forward.
Jenny Harrington
I mean even over the weekend, what was it, 12 billion hit to revenues. John saw that coming.
Jim Leventhal
Sorry. I think what the hardest part about this. So you have Fortune 500 companies right now coming out and saying okay, here's our guidance if, if this and here's our guidance if that like this is where we are because it's so binary. The thing about recession and Nvidia may or may not be a great example of this, but just generally speaking, I think this is really important. The thing about recession that's so frustrating for investors, it's not just that economic activity turns down and that companies start to revise their guidance lower and that analysts then get in on the game and they try to beat the companies to the punch. So all of a sudden the sell side is trying to cut numbers faster than the CEO can cut. Like that's, that dynamic sucks. Like we all hate it, we've all been through it. But while that's going on, the other thing that's happening is that the multiples are coming down too. So you get hit twice for the same thing happening. So it's not just earnings falling, it's what we're willing to pay for dollar earnings falling because to Jenny's point, those earnings become less certain the longer that that process plays out. So we're seeing that market wide right now. I would argue that's like one of the things that we're fighting with. Typically in a recession, you get an earnings multiple decline down to like 13, 14 times. We're just not there. And you get earnings fall off about 20%. We're definitely not there. In the midst of this quarter, we still think we're going to do like 7% growth. So if we don't have a recession, these valuations are great. I totally agree with Jim.
Scott Wapner
Which.
Jim Leventhal
Close your eyes and buy.
Josh Brown
Which is part of my point.
Jim Leventhal
Forget it.
Josh Brown
Which is part of my point. But back to you, Bill, making the argument where all the negativity is getting fleshed out. Not if you get closer or have a recession. It's not. You trying to. Are you making the argument that 5,300 on the S and P is that reflects all of the negativity in the market?
Bill Baruch
I think we'll be higher than 5,306 months in a year from now. But let's. Right or wrong, what's the administration's goal here is. Is really on shoring and on shoring is a tailwind to gdp. Tech is not what you're doing for me right now, it's what you're going to do for me in the future.
Josh Brown
So we're on shoring all of this in six months.
Bill Baruch
We're building. I'm not saying what we're going to do in the future. So it's not going to be priced in at the moment, but we know what the plan is. They're signing contracts for data centers. The White House is bringing a tailwind to this onshoring of AI. They're bringing, you know, the Taiwan Semiconductor into the White House.
Josh Brown
Right. The CHIPS act had already done that.
Scott Wapner
Yeah.
Bill Baruch
But there's a lot of tailwinds behind this. And if and at the end of this, coming out of the next six months, it could end up being, and I believe so, we're going to see right or wrong. It's going to see a tailwind.
Josh Brown
So is that why you're buying Broadcom, which, by the way, JP Morgan today says about the semis that you could have another 10 to 15% downside, potentially, that you have to remain really selective. I see you bought more Broadcom.
Bill Baruch
Yeah, yeah. When. When we bought Broadcom a day or two early, earlier we had added a little more in video. We had about 10% just under 10% cash we raised in the weeks prior to that from a higher level. And if we're not going to strategically get this to work, then really, what are we looking to do? Now this is very tactical. If the market deteriorates, we're going to look to raise this cash, whether it be from Broadcom or another name. But what we're looking to do here is get that to work. Broadcom announced a $10 billion repurchase. They are showing confidence in what they're, what they're doing as a company. They think their stock's undervalued. I think within the infrastructure of, of AI if we're looking at onshoring and we're looking at US Centric growth in the space, I think Broadcom is, is right front and center now. They also hit a big support level. I'd like to see the stock get above 185. But right here, yeah, we are in a little bit of no man's land. I'm not sitting here and denying that there's as uncertainties.
Josh Brown
We're going to listen to President Trump now at the White House.
Scott Wapner
I'm sure, and I'm here to help on that. I cannot look the appeal in the.
Josh Brown
Name of the European Union.
Jenny Harrington
My goal would be inviting President Trump.
Scott Wapner
To pay an official visit to Italy and understand if there's a possibility when it comes and understand if there's a possibility when it comes to organize also such a meeting with Europe. I think the best way is that we simply speak frankly about the needs that every one of us has and.
Jenny Harrington
Find ourselves in the middle.
Jim Leventhal
That's useful for all.
Scott Wapner
I really. Somebody calls me such a Western nationalism. I don't know if it is the right word, but I'm sure that together we are stronger. And I have to find a way. I'm here to find the best way.
Josh Brown
To make us both stronger on the two shores of the of the Atlantic.
Jim Leventhal
We're going to have very little problem.
Scott Wapner
Making a deal with Europe or anybody else because we have something that everybody wants. You know what that means, right? We have something that everybody wants. We're going to have very little problem. So we'll see you in a couple of minutes.
Josh Brown
We'll be ready right there in the Oval Office.
Jim Leventhal
Thank you very much.
Scott Wapner
Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you.
Jenny Harrington
Thank you, Prime Minister.
Josh Brown
All right, I'll take it back. We'll obviously monitor what's happening in that room. The Italian Prime Minister is there. Meloni in a meeting with the president and others from the cabinet and other Staff, as you saw there, there, the president saying very little problem making a deal with Europe. So he's trying to suggest that they'll be able to make some deals regarding the tariffs that are on everywhere really. So we'll follow it. Any more headlines come from that? We obviously will. We'll bring that to you. So we're talking about Broadcom. You also bought more Metta.
Bill Baruch
Yeah, I mean, in the air trade, I think Metta is actually the one that's, that really has the best leg in implementing it in the advertising. When you're looking at the spectrum, all right, you're looking at if we do go into a recessionary like quarter or two, where who's going to be the strongest, who's going to be. Who's going to be that. The, that floats up. And I think Meta and the advertising that companies are spending, spending through their AI tools and through their, their platform is the last one that's going to be cut. So we own Meta and it's a name that we strategically wanted to get more money into at the right time. And we think this is the right time.
Josh Brown
Jenny, you bought Microchip. Why did you do that?
Jenny Harrington
Yeah, so this is an interesting one. So we actually owned Microchip in the portfolio back from 2011 to 2015 and it had a big yield back then. Haven't seen it on the screen since in 10 years. And about a month and a half ago it popped back on because the share price had gotten clocked not just on tariffs, but because they did a terrible job with customer and order management during the pandemic that then continued to reverberate. So fast forward, they brought in the new CEO, shares trade down, they start showing up on my screen with like a 3 1/2% yield, a 4% yield. So we started to do work and, and we really accelerated that work towards the end of March into beginning of April when the shares were down 60% from their high. And here's what we found. We found that the business is still intact. Right? It's a great business. They make really small nothing, little semiconductor chips, things that go into like remote controls and gaming console, the little controller things there and medical devices and small parts. Nothing like Nvidia, nothing like what AMD makes, just small little chips. Three of their five manufacturing plants are here in the U.S. two are overseas, but we know they're still global. So they do have serious tariff risk there. But as we started looking at the company, we saw two things. One, I'm not sure that Microchip Common is going to be able to cover the dividend. But when you look out three years, you see a huge earnings recovery coming. And this goes to me picking on Jim saying, can you really count on earnings? I don't know that you can for the short term. I think as we look out longer term, three and four years, we kind of can guess directionally where earnings totally agree.
Scott Wapner
Just to be clear, you're not picking on me. Okay. The short term's always unknowable.
Jenny Harrington
Right. So we're researching this stock and I'm like, look, the dividend's not going to be covered at the common. But what we found was they. And this was so exciting. I know you all think I'm a nerd on this, but I was so excited. They have a convertible preferred that they issued about three weeks ago. The ticker is mchpp. And the convertible preferred at this price has nearly, not quite, but nearly one for one upside on the common shares. So if we can look out three years and say those earnings should be three to four bucks in three years from now and that would put the stock trading at a 10 times multiple, we think it deserves a premium. The worst case is it should stay flat. In addition, the coupon on the convertible preferred is 7.5%, which means the yield at this price is over 9%. So this is fantastic. I've got a three year convertible preferred. I've got equity like upside. The yield on the convertible preferred preferred, where it stacks up in the corporate structure is much safer. Right. I know I'm going to get that. There's no risk of bankruptcy here. They brought the new, the old CEO back in to manage it. The company's on much sounder footing and it got clocked because of too much noise. So I was thrilled on this.
Josh Brown
Okay, we will watch it getting a nice move in the market. We, we're going to get to the UNH story, I promise you that, because it has just killed the Dow today. Steve Weiss is going to join us in a little bit to tell us what he's doing with the position that he's advocated for repeatedly. We're also going to get to another move that Bill Baruch has and it's related to a really important earnings report that's coming up. But I want to get to the story that a lot of people are talking about today and that's Powell versus the President, the chair of the Federal Reserve versus the President of the United States. As you know, the chair was in Chicago yesterday. He said a number of things and was asked about the idea, idea of a Fed put. To which he said, quote, I'm going to say no with an explanation. And he gave an explanation. But he was blunt about the President's trade war. He said much higher tariffs than they expected, higher than Smoot Hawley, he said will lead to higher inflation and slower growth. He used the word persistent when talking about what inflation is going to do. To which the President weighed in today on Truth Social, to which he said, quote, termination can't come fast enough, that the Fed is too late and wrong, and he's urging Powell to cut rates. Megan Casella within the last hour or so reported from a White House official that that post should not be seen as a threat to firepower. To which we bring in our senior economics correspondent Steve Liesman to weigh in on this battle rap Royal. It's pretty clear to me at this point, based on the comments of Powell himself. Forget the President's stuff on Social this morning for a moment, just Powell alone yesterday, that if he thinks there's an issue with current policy, it's the President's policy, not the Fed's. And I think he was making that point fairly clear yesterday day without being so explicit to call out anybody. He was just telling it like he sees it, making the case that, well, bigger than expected tariffs, maybe more persistent inflation than we first thought, and it's anyone's guess where all this is going.
Scott Wapner
Yeah.
Josh Brown
And we're not the ones who did it.
Scott Wapner
I think that's clear. And I don't think he's shy about saying that, that his problem with figuring out what to do with policy is the tariffs and to some extent, the other things that the President is tinkering with relative to fiscal policy. Deregulation as well as immigration is an issue we don't talk enough about when it comes to the overall economic outlook. So all those things are in play. And they're saying, look, I got to figure out what all this means. I have a job to do. Part of my job is making sure unemployment doesn't go up. Well, it's at or near essentially maximum employment at 4.2% unemployment, my inflation rate is running higher than I want it to. I just had a big bout of inflation and you're raising prices on things. So it's not that sort of. It's not rocket science to say, I got a pause to wait to see what happens. Right.
Josh Brown
And then there was this report earlier that the Treasury Secretary had been telling or is telling White House officials, like, okay, the market is going to have a problem if you actually fire the Fed chair. And the bond market has been the point of pain and concern in this, in this whole thing right at this point. And they don't want the Treasury Secretary being the principal. They doesn't want a larger issue beyond worried about tariff stuff, with having to think about the idea of the president firing or at least attempting to fire the Fed chair.
Scott Wapner
I don't know that there's any actual limit to the number of fights that President Trump wants to have at any one time. It appears to be an infinite number. He has. It's his prerogative, 75 trade negotiations going on. He has fights with all the universities. So I don't know. And he has multiple court cases now. So maybe he wants to have this fight with the Fed. But I think what Bessen is saying, Mr. President, of all the things that are on your plate right now and all the things that markets worry about, you don't need to have a problem with the Fed. In part, Scott, because Powell is not saying I won't cut. I think Powell would like to cut. I think Powell is a little more dovish than some people on his committee.
Josh Brown
Like Waller.
Scott Wapner
Like Waller. Well, Waller is more dovish. I think we can have that debate.
Josh Brown
But I think Waller, I mean, he's more dovish, more dovish.
Scott Wapner
But I think there are people on his committee, like Muslim, maybe Hammock, depends. Some people have talked about the idea of needing to raise rates. He's not talking about that. I think he wants to cut. I just don't think he has essentially the license or the clearing to cut until you figure out what happens with inflation here. So it's a reason. I think the market is a little out ahead of itself and banking on and hoping for a June cut. And there's another debate to have, which is what good would cutting do if you have a supply shock to the economy? Do you really want to goose aggregate demand, which is what rate cuts do, which we found out not all that long ago, makes the inflationary effects of the supply shock worse.
Josh Brown
I know the other side of this.
Scott Wapner
Whole thing, like, did we really not.
Josh Brown
Understand that there is a belief and people on the street are talking about it, Like Wolf, research today about the Fed, the risk of the Fed being behind the curve. You know why they have the phrase behind the curve? Because the Fed's been behind the curve before and people worry that they are going to be again. I mean, it's a legitimate thought.
Scott Wapner
Which curve are they going to be behind? The one of rising inflation or the one of declining growth.
Josh Brown
I don't know.
Scott Wapner
Misreading. Misreading one at the expense of the other, the Wolf report.
Josh Brown
But maybe, maybe it is not understanding fully that inflation is coming down. The greater risk at this point is the labor market.
Scott Wapner
Okay, from what do you take that full understanding?
Josh Brown
You think it's coming down?
Scott Wapner
Well, because we've been through this before and there is some model with which to understand the future here.
Josh Brown
I know that the Fed chair's own words up to the, up to yesterday were transitory. Again, regarding tariff inflation. They've used the word trans. He thought or thinks now that these tariff inflation issues are temporary.
Scott Wapner
He used the word.
Jenny Harrington
But he's been wrong in the past.
Scott Wapner
I don't, I don't think that's what he's saying now.
Josh Brown
No, no, no. I'm saying like, what was it two weeks ago? He used the word transitory.
Scott Wapner
He said it could be transitory, but you have to, Two weeks ago he said it's the Fed's obligation to ensure that one time price hikes from tariffs do not become secondary or embedded or more widespread tariffs.
Josh Brown
That was their, that had been their, that's. But that was their base case at the time.
Scott Wapner
Phrase, that's, that is, that is the operative phrase for how the Fed is running policy right now, making sure, given that unemployment is well contained, growth is good, jobless claims are low, you do not have an obvious worry right now on the unemployment side of the mandate. You take care of the inflation side of the mandate, which is the one that is obviously clearly right.
Josh Brown
The point is that they may have a faster evolving problem on the, on the labor side of the mandate.
Scott Wapner
May.
Josh Brown
And they may be behind the curve.
Scott Wapner
They may, but we just heard that the tariffs are a tailwind for growth. Can I think they're ahead? Can I jump in as a market participant? Because I'll tell you, what the markets want is no surprise. All right, I'm looking at the Fed, at the Fed futures curve right now, all right? We're projecting the first cut in June. I'm not saying either one of you is right or wrong. I'm saying as a market participant. Participant. The worst thing in the world is to now move a rate cut up from there because the market's going to freak. The market's going to say something is really amiss when the Fed's got it.
Josh Brown
Josh wants to get in. Josh.
Jim Leventhal
Yeah, I think, like, I think I'm going to take both sides here. I'm going to say, I'm going to say Powell is going to be doing more cuts in the second half of this year than he thinks he is. And he's already he's spent his entire tenure telling us that the Fed is data dependent. So it's not his fault that he has no idea what he's about to do. And just a week.
Josh Brown
Hang on one second. Forgive me, but I'm going to go back to the White House because Megan Casella has more from there on what the president's saying in the room that we showed you a little while ago with breaking news. Meghan?
Jenny Harrington
Hey, Scott. Absolutely. So that was a surprise press appearance in that lunch. Didn't previously think that we were going to be able to see that. But the president was asked a few questions there, mostly on trade. The headlines to bring you. He was projecting confidence. He said that we will have a deal with China on trade, although we hadn't answered an earlier question about whether he had been in touch with President Xi. So as far as we know, those two leaders still aren't speaking. Looks a little dicey between the two countries right now. But the president projecting confidence, saying we will have a deal with China. EU trade talks have also not been going especially well. We heard earlier this week that the EU thinks this has to be a two way street and that the US hasn't been offering enough. But the president and the Italian prime Minister Meloni, who's here for a visit, both projecting confidence on that deal as well. The president saying he is very confident he will be able to make a deal with the eu. Now, I will say, Scott, both those, the China and the EU deal seen as sort of the ones that aren't going as well, even as negotiations are progressing with countries like Vietnam, Canada, Mexico, you name it. The EU and China are both the two that have been talking more about retaliation and pushing back. So interesting now that the president is projecting this confidence. I'll also say, though, that I've been waved off the idea by White House officials this morning that we're likely to see any sort of trade deal with the EU announced today, that the Italian prime minister, I've been told, is not exactly the right person to talk to when you think about EU trade and broader trade talks for the bloc. But she is a very close ally of the president. They're seen as two both right, far right candidates, you could say, and have some kindred spirits there, if you will. So something of a liaison with the broader eu, but that this meeting had been scheduled before the reciprocal tariffs were announced. So it's not expected to be a focus of the meeting today, Scott.
Josh Brown
All right, Megan, thank you for the update. Come back with anything else you learn from inside the White House. Megan Casella joining us there.
Scott Wapner
All right, I'm going to follow up if, if they make a deal with China and, or with the EU the Fed will be clear to cut boom. That's the kind of thing, thing that would provide the kind of certainty that Powell needs to say, okay, here are the tariffs, here's the inflation. I'm sorry, I don't want to cut off Josh.
Josh Brown
No, but don't we believe I'm going to go back to Josh in a second. Don't we believe we're eventually going to have a deal? What do you think we're going to have a deal? You don't think we're going to ever have a deal? I mean, it's the, it's a, it's a question, I think more so at this point of what have you damaged along the way to get to the deal? What impact have you done to the economy in the process of getting to that deal?
Jenny Harrington
And however long maybe I'm being overly.
Josh Brown
Optimistic and thinking we're going to have a deal, but I mean, I feel like we're going to have some kind of deal at some point.
Jenny Harrington
But that's the thing, right? What's the point that we get to a deal? The longer it goes on, the more damage is done. So. Well, that's, that's the hard part, though.
Josh Brown
That's what we actually share. Powell is going to be left to right.
Jenny Harrington
You can't get to that, Josh.
Jim Leventhal
The market is, the market is no longer worried about whether or not we're going to have a deal. Of course we're going to have a deal. Donald Trump's waiting on the economy last week just hit its lowest level ever. Not his waiting period, not his rating on immigration, not his rating on how he talks. His waiting on the economy hit the lowest level ever. Of course there's a deal. Everybody knows there's a deal. If we didn't think there was a deal, the S and P would be at 15 times earnings would be at 3,800 right now. So what we're really talking about is, is the damage done anyway, does it no longer matter? Because this all started at record high earnings record. It's hard to, it's hard to picture us getting those two things back to where they were just in February. And I'm going to tell you right now, he doesn't have to get rid of Powell. He doesn't is unnecessary. His Kevin Wash is the Fed chair in waiting. Everybody knows this. He was almost the fed chair in 2017. Just so people understand, Kevin Wash was on the Fed from 2006 to 2011. He's married to Jane Lauder. Jane Lauder is Ron Lauder's daughter of Estee Lauder. That's Donald Trump's best friend. What he wants in this role is a loyalist who will do exactly what he thinks needs to be done. And I actually think Trump is right. This economy is not a 4 1/2% fed funds rate economy. It just isn't. And I think this business with the 10 year last last week and capital flight and blah, blah, blah, I think it's a huge head fake. I think rates need to be lower, think financial conditions are too tight. And I worry, Scott, like you do, that the damage is already done. It's now four weeks of incredible uncertainty. It almost might not matter. They'll make a deal. The Nasdaq will rally 6%. Then what? Now you're still facing a cyclical, potentially a cyclical recession.
Josh Brown
Steve, I got to take a break, but I'll give you, I'll give you the last word on all this.
Scott Wapner
I hope you guys are right that there is a deal. It's a good deal for the US Economy. I think that the idea that on shoring is a tailwind for GDP is very suspect to me. It requires you to believe that American companies have made the least efficient, least profitable choice with where to source their, their, their product.
Josh Brown
But don't you think on shoring of chips alone is, is good on short.
Scott Wapner
Chips makes a lot of sense and that's primarily talking about, not talking about.
Josh Brown
T shirts and sneakers.
Scott Wapner
But, but if you look at what's been tested, tariffs right now, all the inputs have somehow have a, have a tariff on them. Things that it makes no sense for us to buy that will create, make the economy much less efficient and make companies much less profitable. That has to be said 100 times.
Josh Brown
Okay, thank you for being here at the stock exchange 101 times. Up next, our chart of the day. It is UnitedHealth for obvious reasons. Today Steve Weiss owns it. He standing by to tell you what he's doing with it today. We do have more moves from the committee. We're back right after this break.
Scott Wapner
Don't just ride the index. Seek to outperform it with FELC, the.
Josh Brown
Fidelity Enhanced Large Cap Core ETF.
Scott Wapner
Unlike passive ETFs, FELC is run by a team of experts to adapt to market conditions and pursue upside potential wherever it's hiding. And while you get the potential outperformance.
Josh Brown
Of an actively managed fund, you can still buy and sell it on your terms just like any other ETF.
Scott Wapner
Discover FELC the Fidelity Enhanced Large Cap Core ETF part of Fidelity's suite of active ETFs.
Josh Brown
Learn more at fidelity.com felc before investing.
Scott Wapner
In any exchange traded fund, you should.
Josh Brown
Consider its investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses. Contact Fidelity for prospectus, an offering circular.
Scott Wapner
Or if available, a summary prospectus containing this information. Read it carefully. While active ETFs offer the potential to.
Josh Brown
Outperform an index, these products may more significantly trail an index as compared with passive ETFs. Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC Member NYSE SIPC.
Scott Wapner
Growing a business can feel impossible. But with HubSpot's built in AI, you can get more done than ever before, which means anything's possible. Breeze agents help you do things in seconds that used to take hours, providing the customer support of 5 us generating the content of 10 use and Breeze Copilot keeps you two steps ahead, giving you the right insights at the right time to close more deals than ever. HubSpot Impossible Growth made Impossibly easy get started today@HubSpot.com AI are you still quoting 30 year old movies? Have you said cool beans in the past 90 days? Do you think Discover isn't widely accepted? If this sounds like by you, you're stuck in the past. Discover is accepted at 99 of places that take credit cards nationwide and every time you make a purchase with your card, you automatically earn cash back. Welcome to the now it pays to Discover. Learn more@discover.com credit card based on the February 2024 Nelson Report.
Josh Brown
All right, we're back. We want to talk UnitedHealth. It's obviously the chart of the day and it is accounting for the basically the entire Dow loss. The Dow loss would be even bigger if not for the other Dow stocks in there, some of which are green, which is why you have what you do a loss of, as you see on your screen, 23%. Steve Weiss owns the stock. Steve Weiss has defended this name. He's bought more at times recently, and he joins us now to tell us what he's doing today. Did you, did you sell? What did you do?
Scott Wapner
No, I actually bought some more this morning. Bought it a couple of points higher, probably more than a couple of points higher. But here's how I look at it, Scott. It's been a good position. I'm down slightly right now. Above, above Cost ever so slightly after having enough of a gain from defensive, from moving defensive stocks. And as I go through the quarter and I was able to speak to to top management today and go through the quarter and their expectations etc. And look it's been a very tough environment to navigate. The narrative last year was that this is a year of peak usage because we saw the backup Covid etc. And so forth and it turns out it wasn't the peak that we're seeing the peak now. Maybe it extends and that's occasioned by a few things. Some it's good news actually occasioned it. They've raised premiums out of necessity on some of the large plans for you know, from $50 a month for a member to 200amonth and as a result they've seen an increase in in usage employees saying hey if I'm paying for them to use it then when you take a look at the transition to value based care that's bringing people in for wellness exams, particularly seniors so you see an uptick front costs on that and that will actually lead to better MLR going forward. So the bottom line is if there's any company that's been able to navigate these issues, it's been UnitedHealth. And then the final part, and this is very important is that Biden really took a hatchet to what the typical rate increases were. So for this year it's only about 2%, just over 2% but for next year and this would drove the stock last week it's over 5% versus expectations of 4%. So knowing management, knowing the company for many many years they built in some cushion for the remainder of this year and I think it's 17 times earnings is an excellent valuation for the company. Down 12% in guidance stock is down 22%. The math doesn't add up to me for one that is just a critical company to to the country and you know, just stands alone in a class by itself.
Josh Brown
All right, thanks for the update. We'll see you back here on the desk. Steve Weiss up next, another move from Bill Baruch. We'll tell you what it is next.
Scott Wapner
Growing a business can feel impossible but with HubSpot's built in AI you can get more done than ever before which means anything's possible. Breeze agents help you do things in seconds that used to take hours. Providing the customer support of 5 us generating the content of 10 use. And Breeze Copilot keeps you two steps ahead giving you the right insights at the right time to close more deals than ever. HubSpot Impossible growth made impossibly easy. Get started today@HubSpot.com AI are you still quoting 30 year old movies? Have you said cool beans in the past 90 days? Do you think Discover is isn't widely accepted? If this sounds like you, you're stuck in the past. Discover is accepted at 99 of places that take credit cards nationwide and every time you make a purchase with your card, you automatically earn cash back. Welcome to the now it pays to Discover. Learn more@discover.com credit card Based on the February 2024 Nelson Report.
Jenny Harrington
We'Re back on Halftime. I'm Silvana Hanau with your CNBC news update. The Department of Homeland Security is threatening to revoke Harvard University's ability to enroll foreign students unless the Ivy League hands over detailed records on its foreign student visa holders illegal and violent activities. A spokesperson tells the Harvard Crimson that the school's aware of the letter but won't surrender its independence or relinquish its constitutional rights. At least 300 National Weather Service employees employees are expected to take the latest federal buyout offer by today's deadline. According to the Washington Post. The agency's top official told employees this week it could lead the agency understaffed to properly monitor extreme weather events. And it comes as a massive storm is set to hit the central US From Texas to Nebraska, bringing fire risks and damaging hail today through the weekend. And yes, ESPN's legendary college game day analyst Lee Corso announced today he is retiring in August. ESPN said Corso's final broadcast will be on August 30th. It ends a nearly 40 year career with a show where he was known for his signature line when disagreeing with a panelist. Not so fast, my friend.
Josh Brown
Halftime.
Jenny Harrington
We'll be right back.
Josh Brown
One of the best names in the Nasdaq not having to do with the mega caps is Netflix. It reports today. And Bill Baruch, you bought it. This a new position?
Bill Baruch
Yes, it's a new position for us.
Josh Brown
Obviously done well in the wake of a lot of this trade war talk. Just because people say, well, it's, it may not be recession resistant but that it's maybe recession resilient.
Bill Baruch
Yeah, it's done well. I'll pick up where you were from that point there, the Nasdaq relative to the QS, it's back at that gangbusters 2018 level. Price is telling you something here. I think it's going to break out above there, which tells me the Nasdaq will continue to outperform the qs. It is resilient. I mean, I think just anecdotally if, you know, if we are in a recession, I think the last thing that people are looking to to cut is their Netflix subscription. However, I think there are some fears here around this earnings report where we're going to start to see some slowing subscriber growth. And I think they may have front run the story a little bit, talking about doubling their, their revenue by 2030 and increasing the operating income. Revenue expectations are, are at 12% year over year. That's down from 16% year over year. But again, I'm leaning on the fact here the price is telling us something. And we added it opened with a 2% position.
Josh Brown
All right, Josh, you own the stock and you bought it recently too.
Jim Leventhal
Yeah, Bill, Bill and I are on the same page. I basically said that whole thing, but I did it yesterday. Netflix is going to report something like 11% revenue growth. So 10.4 billion in earnings, excuse me, in revenue, $5.74 in earnings. And if they do, that would be 7% year over year growth, which is not like crazy earnings growth anyone's expecting. So I think what's really happening here with the story is people are waking up to this idea that this is one of the most defensive consumer facing businesses, not just tech or not just communications. But you think about what consumers are going to do if and when we have an actual slowdown. One of the things they're probably not going to do is walk away from their Netflix sub. This is TD Cowan. They said this last week, given macro volatility, we expect Netflix as arguably the most defensive stock in our coverage universe. The monthly price of Netflix Premium costs the same amount as a single IMAX ticket in major markets for two hours, or one fifth of the average price of a single Live Nation ticket for a two hour concert. So the bang for your buck entertainment wise that you get with a premium Netflix subscription is head and shoulders better than what you're getting from anything else you could spend money on. And people don't let go of these smaller luxuries. They keep going to Starbucks. We've seen that through multiple recessions. And they don't drop Netflix. So I think, I don't know if that means the next 50 points are up or down. I think the stock will outperform most if we have an outright recession.
Josh Brown
Okay, we'll take a break, we'll come back. We're talking gold because a new name related to it has just popped up on Josh's Best stocks in the market list. We Reveal it next. All right, I mentioned gold has been hitting record highs. There it is. And a new name, Josh on your list. What is it?
Jim Leventhal
Newmont Mining just popped onto the list this week. I haven't spoken about this name in a long time. I was told to be brief so I'll just tell you this. Gold surged 24 year to date is now at 3300 per ounce. This price level is basically double Newmont's average. All in sustaining cost of pulling the stuff out of the mine. So it costs him 1600 to pull out and they can sell it for about 3, 300. That is the most favorable situation. Inflation. Newmont's been in it in a while. I'm not in this trade personally but if you missed the gold rally, this is the largest gold miner in the world, the largest publicly traded gold name here in the United States. And might be the way that you can play that catch up trade as their earnings outlook improves with a much higher gold price than their cost of.
Josh Brown
Production to your light dims as you go longer and longer after they told you briefly. But I mean if that was brief for you, that's good because the information was perfect. Thank you. We'll do finals next. All right, closing bell, 3:00 Eastern. Liz Ann Saunders, Cheryl Young, Rick Heitzman, Alex Cantrowicz, Jason Snipe and Phil Lebeau has the Mercedes CEO. So that should be an interesting interview too. I hope to see you at 3:00. Josh Brown, the light is once again shining on you. What's your final trait?
Jim Leventhal
One of my names was made a top pick at Redburn Atlantic and that is toast they say bullish on resilient restaurant spending in recessions, favorable environment to add more locations, ability to expand margins to protect earnings and an attractive valuation. I remain long here as an investor, not a trader.
Josh Brown
Okay, thank you very much for that. Bill Baruch.
Bill Baruch
Berkshire wanted to highlight a non tech name. We bought in a slew of moves.
Josh Brown
Berkshire Hathaway.
Bill Baruch
Berkshire, yeah. Hathaway. Sorry and sorry. What I'll say is May 2 comes that earnings report. We may have one man that could bring some calm over this market. Looking forward to hearing it.
Josh Brown
Thank you very much.
Scott Wapner
Farmer Jim, Citigroup reported earnings earlier this week. Really good report. Now we know that the future is uncertain but this is a company trading at nine times earnings estimates. 3.6% dividend yield buying back shares equal to one and a half percent of its market cap in each of the first and second quarters.
Jenny Harrington
Okay, Jenny Stanley, Black and Decker. If you do believe a trade deal is reached that supports rational supply chains. It's really oversold with a 5.7% yield.
Josh Brown
If not for United Health, the Dow would be green. I mean, I think everybody knows that by now. Everything else is green but the Dow. And even the Dow is off its worst levels. I'll see at 3. You've been listening to CNBC's Halftime Report, the podcast. You can always catch us live weekdays at 2012 Eastern only on CNBC.
Scott Wapner
All opinions expressed by the Halftime Report participants are solely their opinions and do not reflect the opinions of CNBC, NBCUniversal, their parent company or affiliates, and may have been previously disseminated by them on television, radio, Internet or another medium. You should not treat any opinion expressed on this podcast as a specific inducement to make a particular investment or follow a particular strategy, but only as an expression of an opinion. Such opinions are based upon information the Halftime Report participants consider reliable, but neither CNBC nor its affiliates and or subsidiaries warrant its completeness or accuracy, and it should not be relied upon as such. To view the full Halftime Report disclaimer, please visit cnbc.com halftime reportdisclaimer Growing a business can feel impossible. But with HubSpot's built in AI, you can get more done than ever before, which means anything's possible. Breeze Agents help you do things in seconds that used to take hours, providing the customer support of five U's generating the content of 10 U's. And Breeze Copilot keeps you two steps ahead, giving you the right insights at the right time to close more deals than ever. HubSpot Impossible growth made impossibly easy get started today at HubSpot.com AI.
Podcast Summary: Halftime Report – "Is the Tech Trade Broken?" (April 17, 2025)
Host: Scott Wapner
Guests: Josh Brown, Jenny Harrington, Jim Leventhal, Bill Baruch
Release Date: April 17, 2025
In the April 17, 2025 episode of CNBC’s Halftime Report, host Scott Wapner delves into the current turmoil facing the technology sector. The discussion centers around the significant downturn in tech stocks, particularly Nvidia, and explores whether the tech trade is fundamentally broken. Joining Scott are seasoned investors Josh Brown, Jenny Harrington, Jim Leventhal, and Bill Baruch, who provide in-depth analysis and insights into the prevailing market conditions.
Scott opens the discussion by highlighting the severe decline in Nvidia's stock and the lack of a corresponding rebound in the market. He emphasizes the broader market skewness and touches upon other indices like the Dow and S&P 500, setting the stage for a comprehensive analysis of the tech sector's woes.
Jim Leventhal (02:20): “There’s really no such thing as a technology trend that is 100% completely impervious to the cyclical picture around it.”
A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to Nvidia’s dramatic stock decline. The panel discusses the unrealistic price target cuts by analysts and the potential for recovery in the latter half of the year.
Bill Baruch (05:01): “I think there is a light at the end of the tunnel here where we’re flushing out a lot of the negativity.”
The episode delves into the tension between Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and President Trump’s economic policies. Powell's stance on inflation and tariffs is contrasted with the President’s calls for rate cuts.
Scott Wapner (24:49): “Your GDP is dependent on a certain level of economic power to expect that this stock is going to continue to power forward.”
The panelists share their investment strategies amidst the volatile tech landscape, focusing on selective stock purchases and defensive investments.
Broadcom: Bill Baruch discusses increasing holdings in Broadcom due to its strategic positioning in the AI infrastructure.
Bill Baruch (15:30): “Broadcom announced a $10 billion repurchase. They are showing confidence in what they’re doing as a company.”
Meta and Microchip: Jenny Harrington elaborates on investments in Meta for its resilient advertising platform and Microchip for its promising long-term earnings recovery.
Jenny Harrington (19:11): “We are looking at a huge earnings recovery coming over three years from now.”
UnitedHealth emerges as a critical player affecting the Dow Jones Industrial Average, with its stock movements accounting for substantial market shifts.
Defensive Positioning: Steve Weiss highlights UnitedHealth's ability to navigate rising premiums and increased usage, positioning it as a stable investment in turbulent times.
Steve Weiss (38:39): “If there’s any company that’s been able to navigate these issues, it’s been UnitedHealth.”
Netflix is portrayed as one of the most defensive stocks, expected to maintain subscriber growth even in a potential recession.
Consumer Behavior: Analysts argue that consumers are less likely to cut back on Netflix subscriptions compared to other discretionary spending.
Jim Leventhal (46:42): “Netflix is arguably the most defensive stock in our coverage universe.”
Growth Prospects: Despite potential slowing in subscriber growth, Netflix’s strategic initiatives position it for sustained performance.
The discussion shifts to the gold mining sector, with Newmont Mining highlighted as a top pick due to the soaring gold prices.
Cost Efficiency: Newmont benefits from a favorable cost structure, making gold mining highly profitable amidst rising prices.
Jim Leventhal (47:02): “Gold surged 24 year-to-date. This is the most favorable situation.”
Investment Potential: Newmont’s robust earnings outlook in an inflationary environment makes it an attractive option.
As the episode wraps up, the panel reiterates the importance of strategic investments and cautious optimism amidst the current market uncertainties. The ongoing trade negotiations, Federal Reserve policies, and sector-specific dynamics continue to shape the investment landscape.
Jim Leventhal (48:26): “I remain long here as an investor, not a trader.”
Bill Baruch (48:48): “Berkshire wanted to highlight a non-tech name. We bought in a slew of moves.”
Scott Wapner signs off by emphasizing the need for informed decision-making and staying attuned to market developments.
The April 17 episode of Halftime Report offers a thorough examination of the fraught tech sector, spotlighting Nvidia’s struggle and broader economic challenges. Through expert analysis, the panel navigates the complexities of current market dynamics, providing listeners with actionable insights and strategic investment recommendations amidst uncertainty.