Little Happier: Good Idea or Bad Idea? Do I Regret My Experience, or Not? I Can’t Decide.

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Happier with Gretchen Rubin

Episode: Little Happier: Good Idea or Bad Idea? Do I Regret My Experience, or Not? I Can’t Decide.

Host: Gretchen Rubin
Date: September 29, 2025

---

Episode Overview

In this “Little Happier” episode, Gretchen Rubin reflects on a formative dilemma from her school days: Was choosing to join and stick with a field hockey team—despite disliking it and lacking skill—a good idea or a bad one? Through this personal anecdote, Gretchen reevaluates the merits and drawbacks of persistence in unenjoyed activities versus investing energy in pursuits more aligned with one’s natural inclinations. She invites listeners into her thoughtful, self-questioning process, ultimately suggesting that grappling with such questions is valuable in itself.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Gretchen’s Field Hockey Experience (02:16 – 05:00)

• Background: Gretchen describes herself as a student who always went for “extra credit and signed up for extracurriculars,” despite knowing she wasn’t athletic and didn’t enjoy games.
• Participation on the Team: She played on her small school’s field hockey team—an inclusive one without tryouts, where everyone got to be on the roster.
• Mixed Feelings: While she enjoyed some aspects (friendship, team spirit, travel), she “passionately disliked the actual field hockey of it all.”

A Vivid Memory: The Canceled Practice (03:33)

• Relief over Cancellation: One of Gretchen’s “clearest and happiest memories” in childhood was hearing practice was canceled due to a soaked field from sprinkler mishaps.

  • “I was so happy. I was jubilant. My joy and relief was so intense at the news of this respite that this moment is one of my very clearest and happiest memories of my childhood. Which is kind of sad to admit, but it’s true.” – Gretchen Rubin (03:49)

Unanswered Questions: Regret or Benefit? (04:06 – 05:22)

• Pros: She weighs the upsides:
  • Social connection and physical activity,
  • Learning new things and pushing through difficulty,
  • Building humility and empathy by doing something hard.
• Cons: She considers the costs:
  • “It was a drain on my soul to keep doing something that I was just so, so bad at and disliked so much.”
  • The “opportunity cost”—time spent on field hockey that wasn’t devoted to other interests.
• Perpetual Ambivalence:

  • “Was it good for me to make myself do something that I really didn’t want to do? … Or would I have been better off doing something that came more naturally to me...?” – Gretchen Rubin (04:45)

  • “Probably it was both good and bad. Even though I can’t decide, I think it’s a useful question to keep in mind.” (05:17)

Reflection & Takeaway (05:19)

• Gretchen encourages listeners to reflect on similar forks in their life paths—when is sticking with something challenging “good grit,” and when is it unnecessary suffering?

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On motivation:

  “I thought it was important to be on a team, so I played on my school’s field hockey team. My small school was the kind of school where everyone who tried out got to be on the team. I hated field hockey practice and games.” – Gretchen Rubin (02:38)

• On relief:

  “I was so happy. I was jubilant. My joy and relief was so intense at the news of this respite…” – Gretchen Rubin (03:49)

• On ambivalence and wisdom:

  “Was it good for me to make myself do something that I really didn’t want to do? ... Or would I have been better off doing something that came more naturally to me?” – Gretchen Rubin (04:45)

---

Important Segment Timestamps

• 02:16 — Start of story: Gretchen discusses her extracurricular approach in school
• 02:38 — Field hockey experience and self-assessment of athletic ability
• 03:33 — “Clearest and happiest” memory: practice is canceled
• 04:06 — Pros/cons analysis of sticking with unpleasant activities
• 04:45 — Ambivalent reflection and open questions for the audience
• 05:19 — Conclusion and invitation to ponder

---

Closing Thoughts

Gretchen closes by acknowledging the enduring relevance of the question—whether to persevere in things we dislike or pivot to what feels more authentic. She leaves listeners with an empowering ambiguity, suggesting that the mere act of reflection is beneficial.

“Even though I can’t decide, I think it’s a useful question to keep in mind—what do you think?” – Gretchen Rubin (05:17)

---

This concise, introspective episode is especially resonant for anyone grappling with choices between obligation and personal joy—reminding us that, often, the questions themselves are worth living with.

Transcript

[A]

There's something about a love story that takes your breath away. Not because it's perfect, but because it's impossible. Imagine finding the person you were meant to be with in the very place designed to destroy you. Imagine choosing love when everything around you is hate, everything designed to strip away hope. That's not just romance. That's survival. That's destiny. That's exactly what you'll feel watching Bow Artist at War the film opens September 26th, and you can visit Baomovie.com to see the trailers.

[B]

If you were moved by Schindler's List or even the bittersweet hope in Jojo Rabbit, you'll understand why Bao is different. This isn't just about what was lost, it's about what was found. Artist at War tells the remarkable true story of Joseph Bao, a brilliant artist and master forger who risked everything to help others survive. Artist at War opens September 26th. Visit baomovie.com to watch the trailer and learn more or sign up your organization for a group screening. Again, that's Baumovie.com when our dogs thrive, we thrive too. Prioritizing their health means more joyful moments together, whether it's with walks, play, or just having them close by. I have a new puppy, Taffy, and along with our dog Barnaby, they make us so happy. Now with us. Humans taking small, consistent daily actions to keep us healthy are so important to our happiness. And that's important for our dogs too. That's why we love Get Joy's Freeze Dried Raw Dog Food Get Joy's Freeze Dried Raw Dog food is made with real whole food ingredients like 100% USDA sourced beef or chicken, pumpkin for digestion, salmon oil for their skin and coat. Plus it includes bellybiotic blend with pre, pro and postbiotics for gut health and.

[A]

It'S great for a busy lifestyle. Just scoop and serve, no thawing or prep needed. Plus it's pantry friendly, no freezer space required. Save 30% on your first order plus receive a free scoop and free bag of treats, $33 in value. Visit getjoyfood.com Happier.

[B]

Lemonade Gretchen I'm Gretchen Rubin and this is a little Happier There's a question I have about an aspect of my childhood that I reflect on often. I don't think it has an answer, but I think it's a valuable question for me to ponder because it raises an issue that remains quite relevant to my life even to this day. When I was in grade school and high school, I was one of those kids who always did the extra credit and signed up for extracurriculars. For that reason, even though I have absolutely no athletic skill, I have zero eye hand coordination. I am not athletic and I do not like games. Nevertheless, I thought it was important to be on a team, so I played on my school's field hockey team. My small school was the kind of school where everyone who tried out got to be on the team. I hated field hockey practice and games. I liked aspects of being on a team well enough, like spending time with other kids and traveling to other schools, but I passionately disliked the actual field hockey of it all. There's one moment that I recall often. I'll never forget it. I was in my 10th grade chemistry class and a student stuck her head in the door to announce the sprinklers accidentally got left on overnight and the field hockey field is soaked. Practice is canceled because if people play on it, they'll rip up the grass. I was so happy. I was jubilant. My joy and relief was so intense at the news of this respite that this moment is one of my very clearest and happiest memories of my childhood. Which is kind of sad to admit, but it's true. So here is my question. Given the situation, was it a good idea for me to be on the field hockey team? I go round and round in my thinking. On the one hand, it's great to be on a team. It's great to have a reason to connect with other kids. It's great to be outside and get exercise. It's great to push yourself to learn, even when a skill doesn't come easily. Maybe it's good to have to do something you're bad at to develop humility and empathy. On the other hand, I really disliked playing. It was a drain on my soul to keep doing something that I was just so, so bad at and disliked so much. And there's also the opportunity cost. That is, I spent very considerable time and energy on field hockey that I might have spent on something else. I will never know what that something else might have been. Was it good for me to make myself do something that I really didn't want to do? To persist against my inclinations and aptitudes? Or would I have been better off doing something that came more naturally to me, pursuing some activity that I would have enjoyed and could have done well? I don't know. I can't make up my mind. Probably it was both good and bad. Even though I can't decide, I think it's a useful question to keep in mind what do you think? I'm Gretchen Rubin, and I hope this makes your week a little happier from the Onward project. If you've been keeping up with the podcast, you know that last month Elizabeth and I went on our first ever reading retreat, which was amazing. It was so fun. Just eating, reading and sleeping all day every day. No sightseeing, no scheduling, no stress. And it got us thinking that you could really turn anything into a themed retreat. You could go biking, you could go hiking, you could do a board game retreat with friends, or a binge watching retreat. Whatever you're into, it's all about blocking out time and dedicating yourself to something you love.

[A]

And while you're away, why not host your home on Airbnb? It's an easy, flexible way to take in some extra cash and make the most of your space. And who knows, that cozy reading nook that you enjoy in your house day to day could be the site of someone else's first annual reading retreat. Your home might be worth more than you think. Find out how [e-mail] host.