Happy Face Podcast – “Introducing: Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer”

Host: iHeartPodcasts
Date: November 26, 2025

Overview

This episode of Happy Face provides a dramatic introduction to the series Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer, setting the stage for an in-depth exploration of a chilling true crime case. The episode revisits the notorious Gilgo Beach murders, highlighting the decade-long investigation, the recent arrest of Rex Heuerman, and the lingering questions about why this case remained unsolved for so long. Through first-person accounts, archival audio, and investigative commentary, listeners are drawn into the urgency and complexity of the search for one of America’s most elusive serial killers.

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. The Discovery at Gilgo Beach

• Opening Soundscape (00:04): The episode begins on location:
  "This is Gilgo Beach. I remember it like it was yesterday." (A, 00:04)
• Media Shockwaves (00:10-00:18): News of the discovery makes headlines:
  "Investigators on Long Island say they found the remains of 10 people thought to be the victims of a serial killer." (C, 00:11)

2. The Hunt and the Arrest

• Intense Pursuit (00:18-00:26):
  "The day they had finally caught the Long Island serial killer, AKA Lisk, one of the most elusive serial killers of the 21st century." (A, 00:18)
• Breakthrough and Suspect Named (00:26-00:35):
  "Shocked today after an arrest in the infamous Gilgo Beach murders. 59 year old Rex Hugh from Long Island is now charged in the murders of three women." (B, 00:26)

3. Investigation Retrospective

• Almost Caught Him (00:35-00:48): The team reflects on their earlier efforts:
  "Ten years earlier, we had gone on our own hunt for Lisk. And even though we didn't find him, I had no idea how close we came. Closer than anyone had been before." (A, 00:35)

4. Chilling Fears and Leads

• Suspicions and Warnings (00:50-01:01):
  "We followed every lead hoping to find Lisk before he found his next victim." (A, 00:50)
  "Craigslist. Same way he finds. The body count is climbing as investigators grapple with a very elusive monster." (B, 01:01)

5. Potential Contact with the Killer

• A Killer Calls (01:25-01:42):
  "Our investigation got so close, we may have even gotten the attention of Lisk himself." (A, 01:25)
  "We're learning that Rex Heuerman may have called a documentary filmmaker. Audio expert Anthony Nelson analyzed the recordings for Inside Edition." (B, 01:30)
  "In my opinion, it sounds exactly like him." (C, 01:39)

6. Uncovering Corruption and Scandal

• Police Connection (01:48-02:00):
  "There's a connection between Suffolk police, prostitutes and Gilgo Beach." (B, 01:48)
  "Former Suffolk County Chief of Police James Burke was put in handcuffs." (C, 01:56)

7. The Vital Clue: The Chevy Avalanche

• Breakthrough Revelation (02:07-02:18):
  "The clue buried in our footage... he was driving a green... what the hell is that thing called? Green Avalanche. Chevy Avalanche truck." (C, 02:07)
• Persistent Oversight Highlighted (02:18-02:30):
  "It was a tip about this Chevy Avalanche that led to the arrest of Rex Uerman. Investigators had a description of a Chevrolet Avalanche in their case files since 2010." (B, 02:18)

8. Lingering Questions and Call for Justice

• Why Did It Take So Long? (02:30-02:40):
  "We're looking back and asking the question, why did this man get away with something so monstrous for so God damn long?" (A, 02:30)

9. Series Teaser and Introduction

• Killer’s Voice (02:40-02:47):
  "I'm Rex Uman, born and raised on Long Island, working in Manhattan since 1987." (C, 02:40)
• Show Introduction (02:47-end):
  "From Tenderfoot TV and iHeart podcasts, I'm Josh Zieman and this is Monster Hunting the Long island serial killer coming November 17th." (A, 02:47)

Notable Quotes and Memorable Moments

• “The day they had finally caught the Long Island serial killer, AKA Lisk, one of the most elusive serial killers of the 21st century.” – A (00:18)
• “Our investigation got so close, we may have even gotten the attention of Lisk himself.” – A (01:25)
• “In my opinion, it sounds exactly like him.” – C, referring to Rex Heuerman's possible call (01:39)
• “There's a connection between Suffolk police, prostitutes and Gilgo Beach.” – B (01:48)
• “We’re looking back and asking the question, why did this man get away with something so monstrous for so God damn long?” – A (02:30)

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:04 – Opening at Gilgo Beach
• 00:11 – Discovery of victims reported
• 00:26 – Rex Heuerman arrest announcement
• 00:50 – Discussion on hunting the killer, fear of another victim
• 01:30 – Rex Heuerman allegedly contacts filmmaker
• 01:48 – Corruption and connections within Suffolk police
• 02:07 – Discovery of the Chevy Avalanche clue
• 02:18–02:30 – Clue overlooked for years leads to arrest
• 02:40 – Rex Heuerman’s own words, teaser for series

Tone and Style

The episode maintains a suspenseful, investigative tone. The dialogue is urgent, concise, and at times, emotionally raw, reflecting the high stakes and frustration experienced by those seeking justice for the victims.

Summary

This episode sets a gripping stage for the Monster: Hunting the Long Island Serial Killer series, deftly weaving together investigative audio, commentary, and tantalizing clues. It emphasizes both the human and institutional failures that allowed the killer to evade capture and invites listeners on a tense journey through a decade of missed opportunities, chilling encounters, and systemic corruption.