Podcast Summary: Harold’s Old Time Radio
Cancer Crusade Program - 1955 - Tallulah Bankhead Baseball Cracker Barrel
Date: March 20, 2026
Host: Harold's Old Time Radio
Special Guests: Tallulah Bankhead, Phil Rizzuto, Al Schacht, Lou Ephrat
Purpose: A lively roundtable about baseball’s most thrilling moments, reflecting on “the most exciting baseball play I’ve ever seen,” and supporting the American Cancer Society’s 1955 crusade.
Episode Overview
This episode gathers the legendary actress Tallulah Bankhead, New York Yankees’ shortstop Phil Rizzuto, “clown prince of baseball” Al Schacht, and New York Times sports writer Lou Ephrat. They share their most memorable baseball moments, personal anecdotes, and reflections on the emotional resonance of America’s pastime, all tied to a larger message in support of cancer research and the American Cancer Society’s ongoing work.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Introduction & Theme ([00:37]–[01:17])
- Mort Lawrence sets the stage, noting:
“We were going to call this baseball Cracker Barrel session, Tallulah and her friends. But the arguments have gotten so violent, I doubt whether they're her friends anymore.”
- The show’s premise: to discuss the most exciting baseball play each guest has witnessed.
2. Legendary Baseball Moments
Lou Ephrat & Joe DiMaggio’s Comeback ([01:29]–[02:58])
- Lou Ephrat recalls Joe DiMaggio’s dramatic 1949 return at Fenway Park after injury:
“He went on to hit four homers and another single... but to me, the most exciting play... was that first single. I knew that Joe DiMaggio had come back.”
- Tallulah Bankhead quips about her bias:
“You don't mind if I can't be impossible, do you, don? ...Call me Tallulah.”
Tallulah Bankhead & The “Shot Heard ‘Round the World” ([02:58]–[06:01])
- Tallulah describes missing Bobby Thomson’s fateful 1951 home run (Giants vs. Dodgers) because she “couldn’t stand the nervous strain” and left the TV room:
“Well, Thompson hit third pitch on the line into the left field stands. ...I left my television room. I was so nervous, I couldn't stand it. I missed that home run, but I had the radios going in all the other rooms and I rushed up the stairs.” ([04:48])
- Adds a humorous anecdote:
Fans at Madison Square Garden cheered for the Lone Ranger, only to discover the real uproar was fans reacting to Thomson’s home run on their radios.
Al Schacht’s Clubhouse Classic ([07:37]–[09:24])
- Al Schacht recounts a double play in 1933 as his all-time favorite:
“Lou Gehrig, ...was on second base. ...Sewell tags Gehrig. Gehrig knocks him about three feet from home plate. And Sewell recovers... turns around and touches Walker for a double play... that play put us ahead in the pennant. ...That was the greatest play I ever saw.”
Phil Rizzuto’s Tense Pop Fly ([09:43]–[11:00])
- Phil Rizzuto reflects on a ramped-up World Series moment (1952) featuring Billy Martin’s catch:
“Jackie Robinson up. He hit an ordinary little pop fly... Billy Martin, at the last minute, came running like a streak of lightning... Billy caught the ball about an inch from the ground... it saved us the ball game.”
- Dismisses personal bravado, credits Martin’s heroics.
Willie Mays & Signature Catches ([11:04]–[12:24])
- Tallulah Bankhead and others reminisce about Willie Mays. Tallulah regrets missing Mays’ legendary one-handed catch, while Lou Ephrat recalls seeing Mays make an extraordinary bare-handed catch in Pittsburgh.
- Tallulah reflects on being unable to attend many games due to her acting schedule.
3. Emotional Reflections & Banter
- Tallulah Bankhead: Frequently self-deprecating and emotional, she underscores baseball’s sway over her, even humorously apologizing for bad recall of stats:
“I've had a little research on this because I'm so bad at names and dates and statistics — I can't even pronounce the word.”
- Lou Ephrat and Al Schacht share humorous jabs:
- Lou: “That was the year you led the league in early showers.” ([09:25])
- Al: “The year I led the league in early showers, in 1910.”
- Lou: “1910. I was born in 1910...” ([09:33])
- Phil Rizzuto pokes fun at Eddie Stanky’s reputation:
“He couldn't hit, run, field or throw, and he's been in the big leagues for over 10 years...” ([12:02])
4. The Serious Side — Supporting the Cancer Crusade
Phil Rizzuto’s Personal Appeal ([06:42])
- Shares that losing friends and teammates (Babe Ruth, Steve Sundra) has driven his support:
“The reason I want to see cancer conquered is because of the people I knew who died of it... That means every one of us has to help support the life saving work the American Cancer Society does...”
- Urges listeners to send donations:
“Mail your contribution today to cancer care of your local post office.” ([07:23])
Tallulah Bankhead’s Closing Plea ([13:04])
- Draws a parallel between baseball miracles, acting through tragedy, and the daunting challenge of curing cancer:
“Today, everyone is asking our research scientists what just a few years ago seemed to be an almost impossible job. We’re asking them to conquer cancer. And it looks as though they’ll do it. ...Delay will mean additional lives lost. So please give generously...” ([13:04])
Notable Quotes
- Lou Ephrat: “But to me, the most exciting play in baseball that I've seen in, oh, 30 years was that first single. I knew that Joe DiMaggio had come back.” ([02:58])
- Tallulah Bankhead: “I missed that home run, but I had the radios going in all the other rooms and I rushed up the stairs.” ([04:48])
- Al Schacht: “We almost got Lazzeri for a triple play. ...That was the greatest play I ever saw.” ([09:24])
- Phil Rizzuto: “Billy caught the ball about an inch from the ground ... actually it saved us the ball game...” ([11:00])
- Tallulah Bankhead: “We all get asked to do the impossible sometimes. ...Today, everyone is asking our research scientists ... to conquer cancer. And it looks as though they'll do it.” ([13:04])
Important Timestamps
- [01:29] Lou Ephrat on Joe DiMaggio’s 1949 comeback
- [02:58] Tallulah Bankhead recounts the Bobby Thomson’s home run (“Shot Heard ‘Round the World”)
- [04:48] Tallulah’s anecdote about missing the home run and the Lone Ranger crowd reaction
- [06:42] Phil Rizzuto’s heartfelt appeal for cancer research support
- [07:37] Al Schacht’s story of the double play with Lou Gehrig in 1933
- [09:43] Phil Rizzuto’s World Series “pop fly” memory with Billy Martin
- [11:19] Stories about Willie Mays’ defensive brilliance
- [13:04] Tallulah Bankhead’s concluding monologue on hope and the fight against cancer
Memorable Moments
- The mix of brash New York banter with sentimental nostalgia, exemplified in Tallulah Bankhead’s blend of humor and heart.
- The shared feeling of missing out on legendary sports moments — relatable for fans everywhere.
- Phil Rizzuto and Tallulah’s heartfelt, passionate public appeals for the American Cancer Society.
- Unique intersection of American sports history and social action, unified in a single lively broadcast.
Tone & Language
The episode retains a spirited, rapid-fire style characteristic of a lively roundtable: a mix of wisecracks, poignant memories, and affectionate sparring, all delivered with the vintage flair of radio’s golden age. The gravity of the fight against cancer is woven throughout, lending emotional resonance beneath the laughs and storytelling.
For listeners:
Even if you missed the golden age of radio, this episode captures its magic — part baseball fever, part star-studded nostalgia, part public service, and all heart.