Podcast Summary: "Rogue's Gallery 1945-06-23 Mc Donald Murder Case"
Harold's Old Time Radio presents an enthralling episode of "Rogue's Gallery," featuring the charismatic Dick Powell as Private Investigator Richard Rogue. Released on March 12, 2025, this episode delves into a classic murder mystery set in the bustling streets of 1945 New York City, capturing the essence of the Golden Age of Radio.
Introduction to Richard Rogue and Betty Callahan
The episode opens with Private Investigator Richard Rogue introducing himself and his peculiar habit of consulting his alter ego, Ugor (spelled backward). "I hold audible consultations with my alter ego once in a while when I'm confused and in need of advice" (02:30), Rogue explains, setting the stage for his introspective and tenacious character. Alongside him is Betty Callahan, a sharp and strikingly beautiful newspaperwoman, whose keen insights prove invaluable throughout the investigation.
The Mysterious Death of Charles McDonald
During a seemingly pleasant lunch, Rogue and Betty discuss personal matters, including Rogue's desire to visit the races. Their conversation is abruptly interrupted when a distraught woman, Mrs. McDonald, enters seeking Rogue's help regarding her husband, Charles McDonald. Shortly after Charles joins Rogue’s office, he collapses and dies, marking the beginning of the central mystery. Rogue describes the scene poignantly: "I found my mysterious visitor falling forward out of his chair in death" (15:45).
Investigation Begins: Clues and Confrontations
Rogue examines Charles McDonald's body, noting two bullet wounds and an address: 1392 Squirrel Hill. Collaborating with Lieutenant Urban of the Homicide Squad, played by Lt. Urban (25:10), Rogue starts piecing together the circumstances surrounding the murder. Their discussions reveal that Charles was the assistant manager of a Park Avenue jewelry store, adding layers to the investigation.
A pivotal moment occurs when Rogue visits the Park Crest Hotel to locate Mrs. McDonald, leading to a tense encounter with a man named Moore. Moore reveals his interest in the legendary "Star of Savoy" diamond, intensifying the narrative: "It's a large diamond, Mr. Rogue. One of the largest in the world" (42:15). This confrontation not only raises the stakes but also introduces the primary antagonist.
A Clash with Moore and the Alter Ego Ugor
As Rogue delves deeper, he is ambushed and forced into a surreal encounter with his alter ego Ugor: "I feel awful. Who did it? Some big guy I never saw before" (35:50). This internal dialogue highlights Rogue's struggle between his rational self and subconscious fears. Despite Ugor’s warnings, Rogue remains resolute in solving the case, demonstrating his unwavering dedication.
Unraveling the Truth: Alice Ryan and the Diamond Heist
Rogue's investigation leads him to Alice Ryan, identified through fingerprint analysis as the last person to handle the diamond. "They belong to a girl named Alice Ryan" (58:30) confirms her involvement. His confrontation with Moore culminates in a dramatic showdown where Rogue faces imminent danger. Betty’s timely intervention saves Rogue, showcasing her bravery and the strength of their partnership.
Resolution and Rewards
The climax sees Rogue outsmarting Moore, leading to Moore's demise and the recovery of the Star of Savoy. "I got a $5,000 reward for breaking the case. $5,000 for just getting batted around a little isn't bad, is it, huh?" (1:10:25) Rogue shares the reward with Betty, recognizing her crucial role in the investigation. The episode concludes with Rogue reflecting on the case and his relationship with Betty, reinforcing themes of trust and collaboration.
Notable Quotes
- Richard Rogue: "I hold audible consultations with my alter ego once in a while when I'm confused and in need of advice." (02:30)
- Moore: "It's a large diamond, Mr. Rogue. One of the largest in the world." (42:15)
- Sergeant James: "They belong to a girl named Alice Ryan." (58:30)
- Richard Rogue: "I got a $5,000 reward for breaking the case. $5,000 for just getting batted around a little isn't bad, is it, huh?" (1:10:25)
Conclusion
"Rogue's Gallery 1945-06-23 Mc Donald Murder Case" offers listeners a captivating journey through a meticulously crafted murder investigation. With its rich dialogue, compelling characters, and intricate plot twists, the episode embodies the charm and suspense of classic radio dramas. Richard Rogue’s unwavering determination, coupled with Betty Callahan’s sharp intellect, delivers a satisfying resolution that leaves audiences eagerly anticipating the next adventure in Rogue's Gallery.
Produced by B. Engelbach, with music composed and conducted by Leith Stevens, and directed by B. Engelbach. Stay tuned for next Sunday’s episode, where Richard Rogue will navigate a new mystery involving a triangle, a rendezvous, and a failed plan in "Lady with a Gun."