Heavyweight – Episode #65: Meredith
Host: Jonathan Goldstein
Date: December 11, 2025

Overview

This episode of Heavyweight explores the tangle of blame, accountability, and apologies within a family after an accidental (and intense) marijuana edible overdose. Host Jonathan Goldstein journeys into Meredith's story—a comically harrowing misadventure after eating her son's weed gummies, and a subsequent struggle for an apology that spirals into family history, a second accidental drugging, and deeper questions about modeling forgiveness and contrition. The episode blends Jonathan’s signature humor, psychological curiosity, and heart, rounding out with perspectives from family, experts, and friends.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Meredith's Gummy Mishap

[04:32]–[12:39]

• Meredith, a mom with a notorious sweet tooth, accidentally eats about 100mg of THC-laced gummies stashed in her son Aiden's room, believing them to be regular peach rings.
• The ordeal triggers a severe, anxiety-filled, 23-hour high. Meredith descends into a semi-conscious state, plagued by wild hallucinations and physical debilitation.
• She discovers the gummies weren’t ordinary: the color (purple and blue), packaging (Ziploc bag), and location (her son’s room) were all clues she overlooked.
• In the aftermath, Meredith's anger isn’t just about her accidental trip—the real rub is Aiden’s lack of apology and insistence that it was all her fault.

Memorable Quote:
“And in the moment of time it took me to think that thought, my knees buckled. I drop on all fours, because whatever was coming for me hit me like a freight train.”
— Meredith [08:48]

2. Unpacking Blame and Family Dynamics

[12:39]–[18:18]

• The incident leaves unresolved tension: Aiden sees Meredith as responsible for helping herself to his things, while Meredith feels unseen and let down.
• Attempts to adjudicate blame, including negotiations on a canoe (from 50/50 down to 99/1), only highlight the family’s inability to meaningfully apologize or share accountability.
• The story expands to more mishaps, illustrating a tendency in the family toward misunderstandings and unintended harm (e.g., Meredith accidentally liberating a neighbor’s dog).

Quote:
“For three years, Meredith and Aiden have been at a stalemate in terms of who should be held accountable. It keeps popping up, and nothing gets settled.”
— Jonathan Goldstein [17:41]

3. The Airplane Incident: A Second Accidental Drugging

[19:13]–[22:09]

• Daughter Quinn reminds Meredith about another episode: Meredith, on a trip home from Europe, gives Aiden a sleeping pill only for him to collapse at the airport, prompting a medical emergency and missed flight.
• This parallel event reveals that neither Aiden nor Meredith are particularly adept at concern or apology in the heat of a crisis.
• Both sides exhibit a pattern: minimizing the other's distress, prioritizing logistics over empathy (Meredith pushes to board the plane; Aiden rushes to work during Meredith’s THC breakdown).

Quote:
“Basically what I remember was kind of just like half consciousness. She had just like kind of grabbed me by the shoulders and she was like, we need to get it together, you need to get on this flight.”
— Aiden [20:35]

4. He Said, She Said: Reassessing the Gummy Incident

[22:32]–[23:28]

• Aiden disputes Meredith’s memory, insisting the gummies were well-hidden and challenging other details, even denying he ever worked at P.F. Chang’s (it was Panda Express, months prior).
• Both sides harden in their positions, modeling stubbornness rather than vulnerability for others in the family.

5. The Blame Adjustment Panel: Dr. Jackie and Steve

[27:33]–[32:18]

• Jonathan consults his friend, Dr. Jackie Cohen, who strongly sides with Aiden:

  “I'm totally with the son on this one… it was on her to be like, fishing around his room and consuming candy.” [29:07]

• Contrastingly, Steve Marsh, a self-described “doctor of the streets,” empathizes with Meredith, calling 100mg an “heroic” and traumatic dose. He faults Aiden for not locking away the gummies.
• Both experts agree that apologies are needed on both sides, but differ on where the responsibility lies.

6. Finally, The Apology Showdown

[36:38]–[42:11]

• Jonathan and Steve visit Meredith and Aiden together, aiming to mediate the elusive apology.
• The exchange circles through familiar defenses but eventually, Meredith apologizes for not showing empathy when Aiden collapsed at the airport.
• Steve coaches Aiden through a clumsy but heartfelt apology for the gummies:

  “Okay, I'm sorry that my actions cause you harm, and... that my irresponsibility was inflicted upon you.”
  — Aiden [41:31]

• The conversation broadens to the family’s pattern of rarely modeling apologies—perhaps tracing back to how Meredith’s own parents never apologized to her.

7. Family Patterns and Hope for Change

[42:11]–[45:13]

• Meredith reflects on growing up feeling sidelined, never receiving apologies, and wonders how the pattern has echoed into her own parenting.
• The episode closes with the suggestion that generational change is possible, but not easy, and that trying to do better is itself an act of care.

Quote:
“Like family heirlooms or the gene for colorblindness, the value of apologizing is handed down. But if you didn't come from a family where there was space for all that, it's hard to create that space. When you become a parent yourself, how can you give the thing you never received?”
— Jonathan Goldstein [44:36]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On the Apology Stalemate:

  “I’m looking for a shrapnel, okay, of accountability, but she hasn’t even gotten that.”
  — Jonathan [17:32]

• On Parenting and Work Ethic:

  “He was so committed to his work at P F Chang's that his mom took the back burner.”
  — Meredith (joking) [12:26]

• On the Family Model for Apologies:

  “I ask her about it later on, and she tells me that she was. She was thinking about her most recent relationship. It had just ended. And she says the situation could have used an apology. She wants her son to learn from her experience.”
  — Jonathan [42:11]

• Episode Reflection:

  “We can't change yesterday and we can't know who we will be tomorrow... Today is the right day to love, believe, do, and mostly live.”
  — Jonathan [45:19]

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Opening & Introductions: [00:06–04:32]
• The Weed Gummy Incident: [04:32–12:39]
• Struggle Over Apologies & Family Stories: [12:39–18:18]
• The Airplane Pill Incident: [19:13–22:09]
• Aiden's Counterpoints & Family Stubbornness: [22:32–23:28]
• Expert Opinions (Dr. Jackie & Steve): [27:33–32:18]
• Meeting for Apologies (Mediation): [36:38–42:11]
• Family Reflections & Generational Wisdom: [42:11–45:19]
• Closing Reflections: [45:19–end]

Episode Tone

The episode is humorous yet poignant, balancing absurdity with emotional gravity. Jonathan Goldstein’s warm, self-deprecating narration and Meredith’s good-natured candor carry the tone. There’s a running, lighthearted motif of misadventure, denial, and deadpan family skepticism, but also genuine longing for connection, self-awareness, and growth.

Takeaway

Meredith is a classic Heavyweight episode: an outlandish mishap becomes a doorway into family psychology and intergenerational patterns. Laughter, regret, and the slow work of learning to apologize (and mean it) make this episode a resonant listen for anyone who’s ever been trapped between yesterday’s mistakes and the hope for better tomorrows.

For more, follow Heavyweight on Instagram @HeavyweightPodcast or write to heavyweight@pushkin.fm.