Loading summary
Grainger Ad
For the ones who get it done, the most important part is the one you need now. And the best partner is the one who can deliver. That's why millions of maintenance and repair pros trust Grainger because we have professional grade supplies for every industry, even hard to find products. And we have same day pickup and next day delivery on most orders. But most importantly, we have an unwavering commitment to help keep you up and running. Call clickranger.com or just stop by Granger for the ones who get it done.
Brian
Osiris all right, we're live. We're keeping, keeping ourselves on track. Brian is reminding us what we're doing and I'm sorting through voicemails and Megan is just being awesome. So we're back guys. It is, it's Mount Rushmore time and today, today is a CDC bag. Before we get to that, we have to talk about stuff. Obviously we have, we have a couple voicemails. I don't think we have time to do them today, but again, I will, I'm storing these voicemails for, for a special occasion. And I just want to say, I want to acknowledge Tony's voicemail which I was not able to play, but he got to 380 followers on Instagram and then he did a bunch of photos and some some acting with the HF POD shirt. So, you know, props you get. You're the power Power listener of the week, Tony. So thank you for supporting us.
Megan
That was awesome. We also have some other power listeners of the week and those are the nerds from Blue sky who are making unbelievable graphs of the stats that we've been talking about on this podcast. Just want to shout them out. If you like math and you like nerdy fish stuff, you need to be following Age of POD on bluesky because we've just been getting into some really cool stuff and I just appreciate that people are taking our stats and going so far with them and I've learned so much about median versus average this week. So thank you.
Brian
Those are important things to know. And thank you guys for always, always being here with us and helping us out. It's cool. It's cool to see people creating content based on the content we create. It's always fun.
RJ
So.
Brian
Okay. One thing I want to say is that if you're in the northeast this weekend, you might want to go see Reprise. They are playing. There's a free show at Levitt Pavilion on Thursday, which is in Westport. It is, it is technically at capacity, but I think we'll continue to Release tickets. But it's exciting that so many people are going to come out and see Reprise at Levit Pavilion. They are going to be recreating a Fish album. So that. That's. The Fish album is called a live.
Megan
One, a kind of good one.
Brian
Yeah, yeah. Many may not be familiar with that one. It's an old one, but, yeah, they're playing there. They're on 15th, Friday, they're playing in Maine at the Grateful Campout. And then on 16th, they're playing in Worcester, Massachusetts. Those are the last shows until they come to Philly and. And go to Woodstock two nights. Thursday, September 4th is at Woodstock. Friday, September 5th is here in Philly at the Brooklyn Bowl. People in Philly and around Philly. Come, come hang out. It's going to be a great show here in Philly. And. Yeah, that's what I wanted to say. Is there anything else we need to say, guys? How's everybody doing? How we doing?
RJ
I just want to make sure that they're playing Fishes as we go show when they're at Woodstock.
Brian
They are not. They're playing Joyous Lake.
RJ
Okay. All right.
Brian
How do you feel about that?
RJ
It works. I just, you know, the parallels between them playing Woodstock and playing the Oswego second show. What is that, 7:18? I don't know. I feel like it would work, but who am I?
Brian
Well, we have many, many, many, many shows at the Bearsville Theater, which is now, you know, reopened, revamped. There's going to be many, and I think that will be there eventually, Brian. So I'm going to put it on the wish list, run it up the chain, and it has the Brinkman seal of approval, which, you know, what else do you need, really?
RJ
That's it right there.
Brian
Not much. That's it. Okay. What else you guys got to say?
Megan
I just am excited to get back into Rushmore. I was a little rusty doing these notes. I was like, what is this? I feel like we haven't done this in so long. I feel like summer tour was really long. Or just we've been busy. I don't. I don't know why. It feels like it's been a long time. It was. What was it, June, the last time we did one?
RJ
Yeah, the last one we did was. What would that be? It was Carini the first week of June. Cause then we did that.
Megan
It was like a hundred years ago.
RJ
Summer 25 venue draft. And then we were off while RJ was gallivanting across Europe. And then we had six weeks plus a overall tour recap we had a lot. This was a long summer tour, all things considered.
Brian
Yeah. Yeah. Took a break for the tour. I think it's. I think we've set ourselves up in a little bit of an unfair way, actually. I think it's hard to go back into Rushmore after this summer tour when everything seems to be hitting at a level we haven't seen in a long time. And I think hitting these peaks that. That are. I'm not going to say they're unprecedented, but I'm going to say that it's. I think it's notable and makes me think about Rushmore in a little bit of a different way. But I. I feel like it's a little. It's putting us at a disadvantage because we have to go from these. You know, we have to go from these shows that we just heard, which are. So. Many of them are so incredible, and we're. We got to jump back in, and. I wasn't ready for it. I wasn't mentally prepared for it.
Megan
I wasn't either. I feel like that's. It's so interesting listening to, like, really sophisticated 4.0 jams and then jumping back into jams that are amazing, but also from a long time ago and just sound a lot different. I started on next week's Mount Rushmore, and just the difference in a few years is pretty wild.
RJ
Yeah. Stylistically, we'll talk a bit about that through a couple of the gems, a couple of the versions we're going to include here today. But, yeah, I think that we all can agree, coming out of last week's episode, we're in a very special place with Fish right now. And whereas certain unnamed past tours, they would end, and I would always kind of be like, all right, let's go listen to, like, great Fish. We just got finished listening to Great Fish. So you go back and you listen to even, like, different eras of Fish, and it hits a little bit differently now. It's a little strange.
Brian
We got to keep rolling on, guys. I do want to say that we. What's. Next week? Is next week Ghost?
Megan
Next week is Sigma Oasis.
Brian
Sigma Oasis. Good.
Megan
Yeah. Yeah. New song? Yeah. So, you know, we're gonna be listening to some contemporary fish.
Brian
Okay, great.
RJ
And you know what's after that Ghost? Well, that's the next Brushmore. But, you know it's after Sigma.
Megan
I do.
Brian
Is it? It's the episode that nobody knows why we're doing exactly.
RJ
The Dicks Schloss and Jams draft.
Megan
How did the Jams get squeezed in there too Like, I was looking at it, and I was like, okay, we're doing shows. Like, I like how you structured it. How there's like, a Thursday, Friday, Saturday, potentially Sunday, I don't remember. But day of the week draft, like, shows that we're drafting, which I think is super cool. But then there's also, like, another one. I think that's just, like, any show, anytime. And then there's jams, too, which it just seems like it's, like, bulking it up a bit. No, I think at all.
RJ
I think you. You want us to explain. I think we're in a little bit of a rush here, so maybe I shouldn't get into the nuances of the dick's draft. But we're combining shows and jams to give us a full breakdown of the best shows you should go after to listen to if you're missing dicks. And also the best jams that you should check out if you're missing dicks. I think it's pretty fair. But, you know, who am I? Just a guy.
Megan
All right, well, we'll see.
Brian
Just a guy. I will. Megan, I can't comment on your. On your question about the dick's draft because I haven't looked at the document yet. But when I do, I'm gonna have thoughts, and it's gonna be. It's gonna be great.
RJ
Send a breakdown text thread of how to approach this. And RJ's like, I just didn't even look the day before.
Megan
He'll be like, maybe I'll take a look now. I don't even promote things, guys.
RJ
Meanwhile, I'm getting. Hey, this is version 2.16 of my updated short story. Can you read it before tomorrow night?
Megan
Totally.
Brian
I said yet. Yet is an important word in that sentence because I will eventually read everything then. That is just, you know, it's all about. It's just all about. It's just all about sequencing. As you guys know, it's all about sequencing. Okay, so let's get into it. We got a guy. Yeah. Brian. Brian is always inventing drafts to lose to make. It's true. It is becoming. It's becoming a parody.
Megan
It feels like he's trying to invent them in order to make me lose, is what some of these feel like. But it's okay. I always rise to the challenge.
RJ
You know what? By preparing and drafting, we win already.
Megan
It's true. It's all just, you know, fun, no matter what.
Brian
Ev. Dude has a good qu. Point here. Can we get an official draft leaderboard? That would Be interesting.
Megan
Oh, sure.
Brian
Why not?
Megan
We should put that in our document. Like, who wins each one, Because I've kind of forgotten.
RJ
Sure you have.
Brian
I want to do. I mean, we know, we know. Why doesn't someone tell us? Can one of our listeners who's followed all of our drafts just tell us who's won them? I, I, I, I believe you.
RJ
I can tell you who's won all of them. It's okay. I keep track of it.
Megan
You do? On, like a secret doc?
RJ
No, like, in my head. I know these things.
Megan
You can't remember that I watched Moneyball the week before and we had a conversation about it, but you can remember everything about which draft.
RJ
I didn't lose anything when you watched Moneyball and I had already seen it.
Brian
All right, well, here's the deal, guys. We're getting into this for our friends who are driving to work. This is, we're only 9 minutes and 30 seconds, 38 seconds into the episode. So I would say we are extremely ahead of schedule here. We barely talked about sports, Brian. We could talk about the NL standings and the upcoming pennant race if you want. Or we can, we can talk about movies, TV shows, books.
RJ
You're going to a Cubs game. Probably will be a very sad Cubs game based on the state of affairs. Five game series against the brewers at home, and we're currently seven back. I want to say in the standings, we're still up in the wild card, but, like, man, Tom Ricketts and his whole, like, nail salon ownership bullshit of this team, I'm just like, I can't handle it. But I did watch a great movie last night, Caught by the Tides on Criterion. It is directed by the same guy who directed Mountains Made Apart, which we will be talking about in a future Blockbuster Card episode. So if you, anyone out there is a Criterion subscriber, I cannot recommend it enough. Tracks Chinese history since the entrance into the World Trade Organization through the story of one young woman. Unbelievable. Moving stuff. Brought me to tears at times, which anyone who knows me knows that's a very difficult thing to do.
Brian
Wow, this is, that's really interesting to know and thank you, Brian, for, for saying, okay, let's get this show on the road. Glenn Russell says, I don't know, I still have some thoughts about, about this stretch here with the Phillies and the others in the, in the, in the nl, but we'll just, we'll just keep, we'll just keep it rolling, as they say. All right. I have some stuff to say about this song before we get into. Was the opener at my first show and I have strong feelings about it generally, but I think that's not the first thing that happens. The first thing that happens is that Megan, do you tell us about this song? Do you tell us what the deal is with the song, especially if you've never heard it before?
Megan
Yeah, absolutely. I'm going to tell you about ACDC Bag. I just remembered that this is what I do during Mount Marshmallow episodes at about 2 o' clock today, so ACDC Bag is one of the earliest Gamehenge tunes to debut in their live shows. It was first played on April 1, 1986 at Hunts in Burlington, and that's about two years before Trey's thesis. The man who Stepped Into Yesterday was complete and in the final version it was the fourth song of the rock opera following Wilson and before Colonel Forbin's Ascent. The song was a standalone song first and it appeared on the band's 1986 with a white tape. The music and lyrics are written exclusively by Trey, and it is said he used the dictionary of cliches to help write the many cliches found in the song, which is woven in between the story of Mr. Palmer, who's about to be hanged by Wilson's robotic hangman. ACDC Bag. The song is a conversation between Wilson and Palmer. Originally the song had an intro that was eventually dropped, but for the most of its first decade of its life it stuck to form as a short rock tune, but in 1995 it started to stretch to about twice as its length and finally it graduated to jam vehicle status in 1997 at Hampton. Specifically by stretching out past the 20 minute mark, it inspired a handful of big jams throughout the end of 1.0 and 2.0, but was mainly shelved as a jam vehicle. I say mainly because There were some 9 to 12 minute versions in 3.0 and early 4.0, but it didn't reach Monster Jam status again until as recently as 12 hours, 31 minutes and 23 seconds in a big Jam. That was the soundtrack to the March of the Multi Beast through MSG as part of the first Gamehenge in almost 30 years. It's been performed 338 times, so on average every six shows since its debut and it's been on the jam chart 32 times, so it has an under 10% chance of jamming. Brian curated 12 versions for us that started as early as 1993 and went all the way to 2024.
RJ
What a song.
Brian
What a song. Yeah, I would say that so for me, this is like, it's my favorite opener. It's a reliable rocker to get things started. It's kind of like gone away from this as like, you know, sort of like a runaway gym or like all those songs that used to open shows so frequently back in the day. Now it just is like, who knows? You don't know what's going to happen. But it feels like that looking at the jam list that Brian compiled, we really go, what, 19 years into the future after Coventry, before we have our next jam chart version. So I don't know because I haven't looked ahead at everything that Brian's done. And he has a lab that he does all these Rushmore planning sessions in. It's like a. You wear a coat and get like special clearance to get into the lab. So I haven't been in there, but I got. I kind of assume this is going to be the biggest jam gap that we'll encounter in a Rushmore, like 19 years. It's a really long time. And I wonder if there are any other songs that will. That will have that sort of gap. But, you know, only time will tell because we, you know, we don't know yet. Everything's moving.
RJ
I mean, we did an episode on 2001 back in May and we have a 21 year gap there. Not to burst your bubble. Facts gotta be facts, you know.
Brian
But I said from here. I said. I meant from here forward.
RJ
From here. Sorry, I gotta be listening. Sorry.
Brian
It's one of those. It probably is one of those. That was a convenient phrasing on my part. All right, so we're going to just. I guess we should just get into it. Brian, do you have any preamble before you start getting into, you know, presenting your. Your pick. Your first pick, your. Your first Rushmore.
RJ
I just have a couple of things. I mean, I think Meghan just perfectly laid that out there for us. I think a couple fun things about this song, you're absolutely right, is it is one of the best openers, if not the best opener that the band has. It was one of the earliest Fish songs I remember discovering. I love how the chords to the song are essentially the title of the song, except you replace the B with the F. Clearly why they named it a STC Bag. But it's always like a funny, you know, little like Trey, way too in his head music theory guy of just like, well, why don't we just name it after the chords? You know, so you have that. There's like a schmaltzy kind of cheesiness to this song that I don't know if I would really like this song if it wasn't a Fish song with as much history as it has. But that's kind of like the nature of loving Fish is the fact that like they're gonna play songs that are kind of objectively bad by other bands status. But here, this is one of everyone's favorite songs. Plus it has the jamming history to it. I think beyond that you basically have three ways that this song can be utilized. Let's get the show on the road. It kicks the show into high gear. If it opens up a show, even if it falls in like the second or third song of the show, it does a great job of just like, we're here, we've arrived, we've got, we're in the show at this point. There's also this kind of mysterious dive into the underworld. And then there's one version in particular that I think just exemplifies the way too inside baseball nature of the fan base, which is the Velvet version from 72317 where it opens set two. They've hinted over the last week that they are jamming everything. So of course a set 2 opening ACDC bag on Velvet Night is going to take us into the underworld. No, it's just a seven minute version that then dives into Wolfmans and Twist and some great stuff within that set overall. But when I was thinking about this, someone noted this in the chat. I think it was Ed and it brings up a very good point that it is hard to compile a Mount Rushmore version for a song like this when the vast majority of this song is type one and is seven minutes long. And I certainly considered a few seven minute versions to slot in there just to because there are some great like from 95, 94, 96, there's some just like fantastic very straight ahead rock versions of this song. But then I kind of stepped back and I thought about the idea behind this series and what this ultimately is is to capstone Fish at their best. And I think I just fully accepted Fish at their best. The 12195 down, the Z's notwithstanding, is when they take a jam vehicle or a song deep in this sort of way that they would take ACDC back. And I think we can all agree there will be some songs to come that don't jam as heavy. But a lot of the songs that we have listed here for Mount Rushmore have potential for future Mount Rushmore episodes. All have the jamming Nature. They're all going to embrace that unknown quality that kind of is one of the requirements here for the series. So I went with jamming versions. I'm just going to put that out here. There's some excellent, excellent jamming versions of this song. And it's one of those songs that whenever it leaves the structure, it's in that rare category of no matter how many times it's done it, the entire crowd loses their mind. Because like you said, Meg, there's a less than 10% chance that you're ever going to see type 2 version of ACDC Bag. When you see it. It's one of the most exciting things that you could experience in a Fish show.
Megan
Yeah, I was thinking a lot about how, when you're talking about how it usually goes type one, how many great, like, tight, like, mid-90s versions there are of this song and just how it's, like, perfectly encapsulates like Fish at its best when it's, like, punchy and silly, but it's also narrative and so steeped in history. And for this one, I really struggled because there's some versions that I wanted to pick musically, but they have less, like, historical context. And this song is such an important part of fish history and fish lore that it is. The context weighed very heavy and I. I struggled with that. You'll see where I landed. But it's interesting because this song does have such a big part of fish history.
Brian
Brian, I don't want to take any weight out of this exercise because it's important and it's the theme of the year, after all. And it might be the theme of the year for years to come. So that's my caveat. But I found a lot of these historical versions that I, in my head, hold up as the best versions, kind of paling in comparison to some of the jams I heard on this most recent summer tour. And I wonder, as you went through, if you felt any of that and if you felt any pressure of, like, choosing these because they're classic versions, even though they might not have felt as powerful to you at this exact moment.
RJ
In one instance in particular, which we will get into, we do have to shout out, ecw. Who is just crushing the comments section right now? You know, it would have helped. Mondegreen Day four A jammed out ACC bag. Look, it helps out literally any show. One of the versions we're going to talk about in particular would not be a live Fish release show were it not for this version of ACDC Bag. In that show, I Mean, I think to your larger question, and I'll talk about this as we get into it, there's one jam in particular that I have here that stylistically, you listen to it and it is a pretty unanimously praised ACDC bag and it contains one of my favorite moments in fish history. And you listen to that jam now compared to what we just got and what we got last summer as well, and it really makes you happy that the band is able to play with so much more diversity in their jamming than they did back in the day. We'll get into that. Should I just dive into this here? Should I just kick us off?
Megan
Okay, yeah, let's go.
Brian
Yeah.
RJ
So for my first version, so like I said, if someone wants to come back at me with four 7 minute AC bags that I should have had instead of the four jammed out versions, I'm here for it. I will celebrate those with you. But we going, what can ACDC Bag do when. What is this? Mr. Palmer actually gets hung, but like he's like dangling there for 25 minutes and he's like going on his own like psychedelic mind trip. Like whatever happens when we leave the song and we go into the unknown, that's what's happening right now. So, first version, this is, I think, one of like the most stark breaking with the past performances that we've ever heard the band play. This is the 112197 version from Hampton Coliseum in Hampton Roads, Virginia. I say that because, you know, leading up through 1997, obviously the band had adjusted their sonic output and the way that they were jamming, it was much more rhythmic, groove oriented, funk oriented. And throughout the summer we were getting scatters of songs that had not been jammed before that were being jammed. But it really wasn't until this second set on night one in Hampton that we go from a really lush, beautiful, very underrated, minimalistic ghost into ACDC bag. And the band jumps off into a 25 minute long jam vehicle that goes through Machine Gun, Hendrix tray into groove based jamming into open ended, ambient textures. Jamming in a shoegaze fashion that harkens back to My Bloody Valentine, in an acid jazz fashion that harkens to In a Silent Way, Miles Davis. This is some of the best music I've ever heard in my entire life. Some of the most wild, open ended, let's just go for it. Jamming a song that could literally only be resolved by fading into Slave to the Traffic Light, a song that the band knew how to play in 1997 as opposed to 2025. And this version really represents what's about to happen on in fall tour of 1997 where any song is now jammable. Any song can now be, you know, explored in the way that Tweezer and Bowie and Mike's and Jin were explored before this. Anything is of it. Anything is possible. There's nothing off the table except maybe bouncing around the room, which we're still waiting for the 20 minute version of that. But this version just in a way that like you remember the first time they played a type 2 sample to open the jam filled show. It was very cool and it was an amazing moment, but it definitely felt like we're still within the reins of sample. A lot of the time when they jam out a song that they don't typically jam out, you're still kind of within the range of it. This is something that we'll talk about with Bag as we evolve is there were versions that were still kind of within the pocket. It is shocking that the first time they jam this song, they jam it in the same way that they would have jammed Tweezer or they would have jammed Bowie just two years prior. Just open ended. Unbelievable exploration. I can't say enough about this, so I'm going to let you guys, you know, jump in and say something about it too.
Brian
I mean, I just want to say that. Well, first of all, this is like Fish in peak power era. It's just unbelievable and significant because it's really the first time it's really stretched out like that. I think there's a couple before this that we might talk about, but this one really, to me as I was listening back, I agree that it belongs here, but it definitely was. What? Why is this so great? I didn't. When I listened back to it twice, I was like, this doesn't really like do that much, but I think it's because my brain is in the mode of like. There's so much that I've listened to over the past three months where like there's just so many layers and so many textures and so many like tempo changes and so many everything that just like, like I feel like my brain is. Has been reprogrammed, which I did not. I never intended. And as recently as a year ago I was like, fish is not that great anymore. I've told. I said that probably on this podcast, but now it's all different. So I don't know if that happened to you guys, but I still think it belongs here and it's an. It's an amazing jam But I found myself with some dissonance, like between that and. And where I am now.
Megan
Yeah, I felt very similar. It's interesting because when I went through my listening for the first time, I was like, of course this one has to be on there. You know, the Winston Salem Hampton, just that live Fish release is like one of my favorite things ever. And listening back to this, you know, the way that it moves between sections is so effortless. And how it has this like rocking, funky, delicate, all these different sections, but still has the like driving bag rhythm underneath it, but then it kind of blows out into this like ambient, spacious section. It's great, but I found it meandering a little bit and compared to some of the other versions. And I think maybe rj, you're right. Maybe it's because of what I've been listening to lately. I did have it on my list as well, though. I think historically it's like super important for this song. I don't know if it would have. If they would have jammed, you know, I don't know if 123097 would have happened if this hadn't. So I think it's really important.
RJ
I. I'll talk about this in a couple, when we get. There are a couple HTC bag jams that felt very meandering. This one particularly feels very focused to me. This. This feels. I think this and the Haley's are the two strongest jams from the Hampton run of 97. And I think this one, I think it's that much more shocking that it came out of ACDC back like. I mean, I guess even like, yeah, Haley wasn't. Wasn't a huge jam vehicle. I'm struggling to think of a. There was Nothing like the 112297 version before that, but I'm struggling to think of another one that jammed before that. But. Oh, of course, 12, 14, 95, I'm an idiot. But like, those two songs were kind of in the pocket, fun openers to a set or transition within a set. And then to have them hold down second sets at this point in time said so much about where the band was at at this point in time and what they're willing to do. I think it is challenging your larger points to go back now. Whereas where they're at a point modern day, where they can kind of play anything, they're willing to play anything, and they've clearly put in the work to be as. To be as tight as they could possibly be in this era. Whereas 97 is very clearly a break from the Tightness of the early 90s. And they're trying to loosen things up, which is why you get a little bit more.
Brian
A little.
RJ
A few issues here and there and. And then you get these, these open ended jams as a result of it. But that is number one. 1121, 1997, Hampton's ACDC bag. Anything else we have to say about this?
Megan
No.
Brian
You said it. You did it.
RJ
Do you want to go to number two?
Brian
Yeah, we do.
Megan
Let's do it.
RJ
All right. There was a joke there from Ed earlier. A lot of wind up for the most predictable first picks in ancient pod Mount Rushmore history. Which is true. I'm going to give you a lot of wind up here for the second most predictable pick in Rushmore history. RJ did text us over the weekend and said this is a bit of a straightforward Rushmore, isn't it? And I agree. Until this morning, everything was set in stone and then it threw me off on one of them. But the first three were always going to be the first three for me. So this one, this comes from what I consider the best Fish show of all time. It is 12:30, 1997 MSG. The thing that's shocking to me about this version of ACE DC bag is whereas 112197 is so much sprawl and it's led by Trey really kind of showing off his machine gun nature and then what he can do when he steps back and uses effects more than solos, this one is a single minded groove machine. This is the whole band locked in. Trey's playing chords for the first 15 minutes of this jam. Paige is kind of like the standout star here. Mike has a ton of leads. Fishman is keeping things incredibly tight, incredibly locked in everything that they were talking about or they will talk about in two songs from now during the harpua about how the stage is rising and moving up and down. You can hear them getting to that, this whole jam. You can hear them just trying to like get the whole floor and stage into a rhythm that rises up and down. There's a moment around, I think it's like 1321, where they're building, building, building. Then Fishman hits a snare and they all change on a dime. And it's like one of my like 5 favorite moments in Fish history. It's completely locked in. The band is so tight at this point in time while also being as loose as they possibly could be. This is like autobahn fish. It's, it's, it's like craft work fish. It's you know, this is Fish almost in the way that, like, U2 reinvented themselves around Octun Baby. This is Fish, like, taking on Euro dance grooves and applying them to a quartet in a live rock setting. I've said so much about this show and probably about this jam before, so I will. I will hold it there and let you guys speak. Meg, I know you're very passionate about this show as well. I think we have the same feelings about this show at large. But this, to me, where you get the sprawl in Hampton. Here you get this very locked in, tight, focused. And it's amazing that just one month later, they could take this song that had not jammed at all prior to this and turn it into two of the best jams that we heard of. One of the best years in Fish history.
Megan
I love hearing you talk about it in a sort of, like, analytical, academic way, because I have no ability to separate this show from its context and my attendance bias. And I remember so much about this show in this moment. And I actually, this week was looking at pictures of the old msg because I remember where I was standing when this set started. And that's unfortunate. I wouldn't do it. You end up seeing a lot of pictures of, like, old Nazi rallies, but. Or, like, the one infamous huge Nazi rally. But I did want to see it because I. You know, the first set was crazy, obviously, like, opening with the Sally and everything. But when this set opened, and of course, we knew it had happened in Hampton and I wasn't there, but I knew it. I'd heard it. And when we realized they were jamming it again, my friend and I were just. We were like, this show is crazy. And I remember dancing so hard to this jam. And it's one of those moments that I will never forget in my whole entire life. And we didn't even know, like, what was coming. That's. What's so crazy is that we didn't even know Magrop is coming next. And then Harpua, like, one of the best harpooas ever. And it just felt so magical. And it had to be on my Mount Rushmore, too, just because of that moment for me. But I'm just glad to hear that it actually is good outside of that, because when I hear it and listen to it, all I can think of is that moment.
RJ
Do you know how long set one at that show was?
Megan
Sorry, no, I don't.
Brian
I do. Only because Reaper has just played it. So we had to. We had to. We had to plan.
Megan
I know set two is really long.
Brian
Yeah. Are they. Go ahead, go ahead, Brian.
RJ
What were you gonna ask?
Brian
I think they're both like. Well, I think they're. The second set in encore is like two and a half hours and the. The first set's like one hour.
RJ
The first set is according to Life Fish is one hour, one minute. And so like you get that. You get the probably 40 minute set break. Because it was the 90s.
Megan
Yeah.
RJ
And then they come out, it's an hour 52 minute second set and a 29 minute encore.
Megan
We were going all night in the 90s. We were like, let's go. Let's just keep going. We had all this, all the stuff we needed. We were good.
RJ
You know what they said in the 90s about that?
Megan
What?
RJ
We were going all night in the 70s.
Brian
Anyway.
RJ
Carry on, Archie.
Megan
It's so true.
RJ
So old.
Megan
I'm like aging myself. It's horrible.
Brian
I mean, this. So we're like still peak. Still in the peak power era here. They still are at their peak powers, I think.
Megan
Yeah.
Brian
It's interesting to me. One thing I was thinking about is like. Like they're remembering like the 93, 94. And I know other. Other bands do this too, where like long jams are almost like an amalgam of other songs. Like in some ways I feel like this jam has that there's like a Psycho Killer kind of like segment. There's like an Isabella kind of segment. It's almost like there's. And then in between there's like those tray, trays, like swirling solos around like 16 minutes. It's just like, you know, they tie those together, but they're. They are like. I felt like listening to this most recent time like they were. They're definitely going into Psycho Killer right here. And then they just like decided not to. But it's cool. They just stayed on it and brought in all these other songs that had, I think, like inspired by other jams that had happened on the tour. That they were just probably still in their minds and like, you know, inside their brains. And man, this, this show is outrageous. Really.
RJ
I don't know if you intended to do this, but like, it's. I want to go down a rabbit hole about 1230, 97 now because, like, please, let's do it like at their best. New Year's shows are our summation of the year and of like the themes of the year. And I don't think there's any place better than 1230, 97 where you get the shock bust out of Sneak and Sally, which Then turns into a fall 97 jam and segues perfectly into taste. Like every tweezer seemed to do pretty solid first set. Like not the greatest, but pretty solid. But then the second set, you get this jam, which to your point, rj, so, so well, so well said. Like this is a fall 97 jam, like encapsulated here in a CDC bag. You get a maghreb bust out, you get harpua for the first time since the halfway went one. This is really the first harpua since I think sometime in 95. I want to say, like this is. That's why they hadn't done this in a long time. Like a full narration. You get to like, we don't really care, we'll pay, whatever because we just want to keep playing. Which is just such a vibe of 97. And then the encore is just like basically a fall 97 jam with four songs. The Psycho killer comment is really interesting because I was thinking about this. One of the sections we have here for the Rushmore is are there any versions around here that kind of hint at or like, you know, build off of what this song, what this jam did? And I kept thinking about 12797 Ghost opens with ACDC bag. And almost immediately after they finish the course they go into a jam. And you can almost envision that 12797 is going to open with a 15, 20 minute HDC bag. But they find psycho killer and they go into psycho killer then. So you can almost think here. Well, we've done that, so we're not going to do it again, but we're at least going to give you a hint at that. What a way to cap off a year. What a way to kick off the second set of the best fish show that's ever been played. Don't come at me with your hate and your anger here. I don't want to fight you on this. It just is.
Megan
I feel like it's like 10th or 12th on net or something. Absolutely ridiculous right now. I don't even want to talk.
Brian
No, no, no, no, no. It's like third. It's like third or fourth. No, you guys are good.
Megan
It was like way down for a while because all those contemporary shows were.
Brian
Up, but now it's fourth. So don't worry. Everyone just settle down. Just calm down.
RJ
Isn't 9 12, 25 the best show ever at this point?
Brian
7 7, 25.
RJ
I was thinking everyone was just like, the next show is going to be the best.
Brian
Oh, the next show. Got it.
Megan
Yeah, yeah.
Brian
727 is is definitely number two. So number second best show of all time.
Megan
Outrageous.
RJ
But yeah, no, this, this, this jam. When I think about my favorite aspects of fall 97, it's all contained in this. It's the, it's that just very tight but really just beautiful melodic groove that they fall into and then the ambient space on the back end of it. It just has everything.
Brian
It has everything. Just like the helping friendly podcast. We're going to take a break and then we're going to come back and Brian's going to reveal his next two Mount Rushmore editions for ACDC bag. You're going to hear Megan's picks and mine and the fans, and it's going to be just glorious. So we'll be right back.
Grainger Ad
This episode is brought to you by Lifelock. When you visit the doctor, you probably hand over your insurance, your ID and contact details. It's just one of the many places that has your personal info and if any of them accidentally expose it, you could be at risk of for identity theft. Lifelock monitors millions of data points a second. If you become a victim, they'll fix it, guaranteed or your money back. Save up to 40% your first year@lifelock.com podcast terms apply. This is Lawrence Lanahan, journalist, musician, and host of Rearranged, an Osiris Media podcast about music arranging. Once a song is written, arrangers make musical decisions that shape how we end up hearing the song. We're not just talking about adding orchestral accompaniment like horns and strings, or doing a cover version of a song. Arrangement can be putting happy music over dark lyrics, using samples, recording all acoustic, even tiny decisions like putting an electronic loop into an acoustic song to draw your attention to an important turn of phrase. It's all arranging. Rearranged Episodes are documentary essays where I use arrangements to answer some big questions, like what is a song and what can a song become? And how can the sound of a song change the meaning you take from it? Listening this way has changed my relationship with music. Tune in to Rearranged and maybe it'll happen for you, too. Learn more@reranged podcast.com.
Brian
OSIRIS all right, Brian, bridge. Bridge us to number three here.
RJ
Bridge us to number three. So, you know, one of the fun things about this show is the competitive nature that we all have within our drafts. But, you know, that can also be our undoing.
Megan
Our undoing? Oh, no.
RJ
Yeah. I mean, the show's over at this point. You know, this is my favorite fish jam that has ever been played. I don't think that there's anything. Well, there's a couple that come close, but I don't think that there's any jam that, like, I could just sit down right now and like, in my head, go through the entire jam. I've heard it so many times. This was the second tape I ever received. The first tape was 11:17. 94. Not 97. 94. And then I received this show on CD and the guy who gave it to me said, the second set is perfect, and went through all the highlights, none of which meant anything to me at the time, but all of which sounded so cool. And so I went into this show with like, like my first ever Fish expectations. And they were completely like, every, every second of this set is perfect. But nothing is as perfect as this jam where I don't think the band misses a note even when the fans screw with Paul Anguadox Soundboard. It adds to the aura around this jam and adds to, you know, the magic of what makes this jam so incredible. I got to stand in the room where this jam was played last October for a work event and I had my colleague, who knows nothing about Fish, take a picture for me and he was like, why are you taking a picture in here? And I explained it and he was like, okay, whatever.
Megan
But I was over with.
RJ
I could feel it. I could feel it. And that is the. I'm getting emotional. The 91499 Boise bag. This jam goes through like eight different styles of music. You have that like CD groove based, 97 Hades energy to it. You've got trance bass jamming. You got the start stop jamming. You have all members of the band taking various steps as leads. You've got just like the start stop at the end where Fishman is just completely on and playing riff after riff after riff. And Paige has those zones going across the stage. Just weird, weird sounds, crazy feedback. And then they stop and then they come back and they completely reinvent the groove. And then they stop and they come back and they do it again. There's a picture of me from, like my second week of college. I'd become friends with all these kids on my floor who were all Fish fans as well. And they all really liked eating mushrooms as well. And we put this on like, I don't know, two o' clock in the morning on a Friday night, all just out of our heads. And I realized I still remember the feeling that I wasn't close enough to the music. So I picked up my speakers and I, like held them next to my head. My friend snapped a Picture really quickly and it, like, it's a defining shot of me from college. I'm gonna keep gushing off the rails. So I'm just gonna pause and let you guys take this because I love this jam so much. It killed me when I lost this jam in the 25 minute jam draft. I still haven't gotten over it. But, Meg, what do you have to say about this? I think you like this jam too.
Megan
Oh, God, I feel so bad hearing you talk about it now, Brian. If you had given me that soliloquy prior to the jam draft, I probably wouldn't have taken it. That was beautiful. I'm not going to say anything about this jam except that it has, I think, the most perfect narrative arc of any jam that Fish has ever played. So that is all I'm going to say because you said it perfectly. It's epic. It's perfect. And I'm sorry I took it in the draft.
Brian
That was amazing. I mean, that was just an amazing way of just making Meg feel bad. It was like the most creative way I could think of, of getting her to feel bad about taking that in the draft. It was perfect. I mean, just incredible. Great work. Yeah, good job.
RJ
Nobody else was doing the bag, Rushmore. I'll just tell you that when I. When I made this list, nobody else was doing it.
Megan
It's fair.
Brian
Okay, Brian, here's where we step. We. We only had four more versions to choose from after this. Assuming you're going chronologically, which I hope you are. So where. Where do we go after. After 19.
RJ
You need to say something about this jam. Come on.
Brian
I make. There's nothing I can really say. You said it. You said it all. I mean, it does have. It has everything. I mean, the, the ending. Ambient space, you know, is just awesome. Like, it's just a perfect way to end such a. I mean, it's just a really, really amazing. Yeah. Multisectional jam that is. Yeah, it's up there. It's up there with the best of all time, for sure. You know, I think it's. And I don't. I don't know what happened. Gave them that ability. Incredible.
RJ
Yeah.
Brian
It's interesting.
RJ
If you look at the 1999 fall 99 jam charts, even 99 as a whole, there's a lot of like very solid 18 minute jams throughout the year. And then there's this Back to back 91299 Ghost and 91499 HTC Bag that Touch on very similar themes. And then from there, like the remainder of the tour there's some really great moments, but they hit something. These two shows out west, they hit something. And they haven't been back to Boise since. And Boise is a cool town. I would. I would encourage Fish to go back there. They could still play the Boise State Pavilion. I'd be very into it. Yeah. The last thing I'll say about this jam before I move on is we had Jake Cohen on Beyond the Pond to cover this jam back in 2018, and he did a really great job. He brought some, like, Euro trash dance music to cover the back half of it. But then he said, there's one. There's one artist that we have to focus on because this is what Fish is channeling, and that's Mahler. And anytime I can get really, really smart, way smarter than anything I can do, music lovers and Fish fans, to sit down and talk to me and talk about Fish jams as classical musicians, I'm here for it. That's my thing. So, Meg, I hope you learned your lesson. It seems like.
Megan
Oh, my God. Yeah. Well, I have. Let's just say that I'm totally still going to take anything you love. Just FYI. Just because I like to see you.
RJ
Get mad, I hope you do. Amazing jam. Thank you guys for letting me spend all this time gushing about it. Okay.
Megan
You know, it's actually funny. I don't even know if I won that draft. Did I win that draft?
RJ
I'm pretty sure you won that draft. And.
Megan
Okay, just want to make sure.
RJ
And you won it on the backs of taking that.
Megan
That's not the only reason I won it. I wouldn't have been able to win if I just had that.
RJ
I'll look back and that. That. That you picking that, like either. Round one, around two, completely threw my strategy off. And we still have jokes about it to this day because that's the draft where I picked the 85 whipping post. Yeah, I'm pretty sure that Ed made a joke about that earlier. All right, this is the last one.
Megan
Interesting. I think.
RJ
This is where it gets really interesting, because if you notice, because I'm going in chronological order, I've skipped over 11, 7, 98, which I know a lot of people are really big fans of. I felt it was a touch, one note. I think in hindsight, I'm just not a huge ball 98 guy when it comes down to it. Unless there's a truly monumental version of a song. I think I like Fish with a little bit more dynamics than they were doing then. So, you know, 2000, we don't really have a lot of options. 2003, we've got a couple nice 11 minute versions. 2004, one of the coolest things that the band did was they brought back ACC bag as a jam vehicle. It opened 8, 10, 2004, and then opened the second set of 8 14, 2004. And for the longest time, the last pick I was going to have here was 8:14, 2004. If there's anyone in this podcast that will defend Coventry, it is me. And I think the ACDC bag is the most defensible argument for listening back to Coventry. But we've been talking so much as a group about what Fish is doing today and how unprecedented it is and how it really shocks us that they are able to play the way that they are. And so with that context in mind, I was listening back to a more recent version that made me realize, you know what, the legacy of ACD's bag did not end at Coventry for the longest time. That was the last jammed out version. And then we started to get versions throughout the 4.0 era. We got Philly 720 22, MPP 731, 22, Berkeley 4, 19, 23, MSG 730.23, Dick's 92 23. And then we got that fantastic 18 minute version on 1231, 23. But we got another version at a show that and a run that I. I don't know if it's been forgotten, I don't get a ton of like, texts about it, but a run that I think really set Fish up very nicely heading into Mondegreen, Day one, days two through four notwithstanding, and Dicks, that really helped to elevate once again the tour. That's a joke. I love Monda Green. Day two and three, day four is, you know, whatever bad Trey was wearing, all black in the sun. What the hell is going to happen? But this run of Fish, if you listen back to it, I mean, there's just some stunning, stunning plane. And this version really caps off the weekend. And that is 8, 11, 24 from Bethel, New York. This is deep. Well, the other thing I was thinking about and I texted with good friend of the pod, Justin Bruce, about this and he said it perfectly. The Bethel version is the modern equivalent to what they were doing during the Coventry jam. They're just a tighter and better band now than they were then. And that ultimately is what pushed over the edge. Because as great as that version from Coventry is, as stunning as it was to see, I mean, I still Remember standing there as a little boy, just in a, like, mud up to my knees and going, holy shit, dude. Like, the second tape you ever got was 9.14.99. Your favorite jam ever is the Boise Bag. You're seeing a 20 minute AC bag right now. What the fuck? And, like, shaking myself, like, with excitement, even though I was so sad about what happening. It goes the back that far, Meg. You know, as much as I love that commentary ACDC Bag, this one is just a much tighter, much more dynamic band than they were in 2004. It's just. It's not. That's not a controversial statement. But this is like subterranean jam sessions. This is like, what does the minor key do to a man? Well, listen to this jam. You'll hear what happens when artists drop into the minor key. This is like fish channeling Mogwai. Like, this is post rock fish in such a fantastic way. So, Bethel 8:11, 20, 24.
Megan
Yes. This is, to me, total command. And this is 4.0 jamming at its finest. To me, this is one of the strongest thematically behind the Boise Bag. It just has such a narrative arc, such a strong perspective. The way that they use repetition in this jam is so commanding. And that riff that Trey discovers, like, halfway through, that's so driving. And it's so much force behind it. It's so authoritative and propulsive and Fishman is just relentless. And then they have that kind of cool, spacey romp at the end, and Mike is doing that juicy bass line and Paige and Trey are just shooting across over him. It's just. This is. I kind of forgot about this jam. I don't know why. Maybe there's just been so much since then, but I couldn't believe how good it was. And it's on my list, too. I think it's incredible. Obviously there's others, Coventry, you know, the Gamehenge that are historically important, but musically, this one is just so far above those. I think.
RJ
The helicopter segment. Yeah.
Brian
I just. I just want to say so just to like, expedite my role here. I have the same four as Brian. I think that you did it perfectly. I'm so proud of you. I do. Oh, well, then look at that.
Megan
This is crazy, but I do too.
RJ
I just want to bag Trifecta.
Megan
I mean, change this morning, too.
Brian
Okay, well, I want to hear about that. And Brian mentioned seven versions in his build up to this version, so I just wanted to comment on a couple of those quickly as he. As he made his way to this one. I think that The. Just going back to 11, 7, 98, which I think we'll talk about the fan votes in a few minutes, but that it's really pretty. Like, that version is like much more of an ambient kind of thing, rhythmic and ambient than I. Than I remembered it being. Even though we just listened to it, you know, whenever we did. 98. Fall 98. But I. Yeah, I agree with what you were saying. It felt a little more like one note Coventry. During this. You do not feel that way.
Megan
No, I. This one's not as big or sweeping as the others, but I love this jam musically, and this was a hard one for me to leave off and I just. I find it so beautiful and I love how minimal it is and it's so patient and quiet and it's so melancholy. And I think there's just something about this jam that is unbelievably patient and sets it apart from some of the others because there's always such a driving, propulsive quality to most of the bag jams. And this one is just. I think it's. You just float in this way that fish can find a floating space. I love it. And. And I absolutely just. I really love this jam. And it killed me not to have it on there. And it was. What I was going back and forth with a lot was this in 1121 97.
Brian
Well, we did our best here. There were some other things I was going to say, but I think we're. I think we're. I think we.
Megan
Sorry, I interrupted. Well, I just want to jam.
Brian
That's okay. I think I just wanted to shout out the first version that we listened to, which was a tape that I had that I still have the COVID for up there. 812 93, which is the. Had the old intro and a really great jam and a great show. And I was kind of surprised. I thought that that show had been released, but I think it's just that it should be released because that show is awesome. There's like so many Great Moments from 812 93. So they should release that show.
Megan
Gad has a great breakdown outro, too. It's really cool.
RJ
Yeah, like four or five shows in a row. August 93. We should release the whole month at this point in time.
Brian
Yeah, yeah, they did St. Louis. Right. So just like do the. Do the rest. The rest of August.
RJ
We've got Marat 8, 13, 8 14.
Brian
8, 15 oh, 814 and 15 7. Jesus.
RJ
Is that right? I think that.
Brian
What are we doing?
RJ
And then 825. Yeah, there's and then 8, 7 and 8 2. I mean, so much.
Brian
And just real quick, let me talk about the fan vote. We did have a lot of responses, which is so fun to. To hear from everybody. We had the 1120, 197, 1230, 97. And then there was a tie for third, but. But the fourth was 9, 1499. But the tie was between 11, 7, 9, 8 and 1231 23, if you can believe.
Megan
Yeah, so a lot of people, I think, are going to stand for that gamehenge one just because the context is so epic. But yeah, yeah, yeah, I think that's fair.
Brian
I think that's fair. It seems like, I guess we got, we got Tony here. We got people just telling us that if we didn't choose that, it's because we weren't there. Tila riding through msg. This is just, you know, we're. We, you know, we're gonna get yelled at for doing something. But yeah, I may listen back to it. I think it's, it's great. It's. It's the best part of that set musically. But, you know, I, I don't think it makes the top four versions of all time. And, and if I'm, you know, that's just my personal opinion, you know, not qualified. No, here I am.
RJ
I agree. I mean, I, I think it's fantastic. This is. No, not throwing any shade at the 123123 version. I mean, they played freaking Gamehenge in at Madison Square Garden on New Year's eve on their 40th anniversary. Like, and then they jammed a CC bag deeper than they had since Coventry. Like, that was one of the best moments in all fish history. Whenever you, like, compile them. Yeah, I think if you're listening back, trying to figure out the four versions where the band did the most that they possibly could with this song in hand, which I think as we're going through this exercise, I'm realizing, like, that is what the Rushmore thing is about, is like, what did you do with the song? Not like the tightest, most, you know, compact, great version of it. That version is admittedly far too singularly tray heavy to compete with the 81124 version. If we're going to talk about, like, because the, the first three, I don't see how they're. They're off. So it's really between like 11, 7, 98, 8001424 or 814 04. And then 1231, 23 is the potential fourth version. I can totally understand someone's argument. I Don't personally agree with it.
Brian
Okay, first of all, I think if you're listening, you know, we got. We got some in the chat. But if you're listening and you want to say, like, man, you weren't there, bro. You weren't there at msg. You didn't see the dancers and the Gamehenge. And like, that's totally true, but it's still not a top four version. Jackson says. Can someone point me in the direction of any other jam that resembles the first. First segment of the Boise Bag? There's really nothing like it. Hey, Jackson.
RJ
I can't. Part of the reason it's, I think the best Fish jam ever is it's so singular. The. The only other jam that has segments that are close to it is the 91299 Ghost. Like, those two jams hang together as kind of like Fish was out west, wanted to jam really deep and found this kind of like, rhythmic space that is akin to what they were doing in 97, akin to what they were doing in 99. Some of the ambience from 98, a bit of the, you know, bloated big groove jams from 2000. I say that as a compliment, but, like, nothing really sounds like that. Like, it's. I'm gonna get a lot of from RJ for what I'm about to say, so I apologize in advance. I mean, no ill will here. This is not trying to undercut your favorite jam of all time, but like the Providence Bowie sounds like fall 94 jamming just applied to David Bowie. This is like a very singular thing. Like, they. They. A lot of the long jams in fall 99 are, like, wide open and vast and spacious, but none of them really have this, like, balance between tightness and groove and urban. 777, sir. My family is from Game Edge, bro. Hilarious comment of the year. But, like, this is. It is really singular.
Megan
Well, and it's so hard to compare a jam from 94 to 99 because so much had happened in between then that influenced their jamming in 99.
RJ
Yeah, I just. I'm more saying that like, there's nothing really around there that, like. Yeah, yeah, you can compare to it.
Brian
I do want to say just quickly, I wanted. Megan, I want to see if what else you want to say about this. But first, I want to tell you we're. We're hopping over to Library Card in a minute to talk about Crossroads by Jonathan Franzen, which we're going to do in a minute. But, Megan, is there anything acdc Bag wise That, that you want to say that we haven't already discussed.
Megan
No, I'm just surprised. We all had the same. My honorable mentions were just the 98UIC Coventry and the, the 2423 Gamehenge. So that's. I kind of landed there too.
Brian
Yeah.
Megan
But I feel really good about our list.
Brian
Yeah, it's a good list. It's a good list. Good gems. We got like one of the best jams of all time and for. And a couple from maybe the best show of all time. We got, you know, we got a, we got two representatives from the best tour of all times. So we're like, we're really, we're really.
Megan
Rocking and rolling and we've got like contemporary finish. Like, I really love that. I mean, this Bethel jam, listening to it, it's. When you put it up against any of these others, it deserves its spot.
Brian
Exactly. I agree. Okay, so next week we're going to be back with Sigma Oasis Rushmore. We've already, we've already updated all the links in the computer lab. We are. If you go to osarispot.com Rushmore you will see your Sigma Oasis voting form. So please join in the fun and, and vote, vote there and give us a review on Apple Podcasts. If you don't know how to do that. If you look on Instagram and look at Megan's account, she made a tutorial. I don't know if that's still up there, but it was a good tutorial.
Megan
Yeah, it's on the HFPOD account.
Brian
Hfpod. Great. Otherwise, I think we're going to just, we're going to end it there and we're going to see you guys next week for another exciting edition of the Helping Friendly podcast. Episode number 792 or something. But we're going to, we're going to keep it rolling, guys. Anything else?
Megan
No. Can't wait to do Sigma. It's gonna be fun.
RJ
Can we do Sigma and the Dicks show and jam draft?
Megan
Can't wait. It's coming, guys. It's. Can't wait.
Brian
I can't wait. According to Apple podcasts, we have 795 episodes of the Helping Friendly Podcast in Apple Podcasts. I think there's like maybe 20 that aren't in there. So we're already, we're over 800, guys. We're gonna keep going. Enjoy your book club, nerds. Thank you, Jackson. Thanks everybody in the chat. That was fun. All right, we'll see you all next week, guys.
Megan
Bye, everyone.
RJ
Sam.
Brian
Osiris.
Megan
Thanks for selling your car to Carvana. Here's your check.
Brian
Whoa. When did I get here?
Megan
What do you mean?
Grainger Ad
I swear it was just moments ago that I accepted a great offer from Carvana online. I must have time traveled to the future.
Megan
It was just moments ago. We do same day pickup. Here's your check for that great offer.
Brian
It is the future.
Megan
It's.
RJ
It's the present.
Megan
And just the convenience of Carvana. Sorry to blow your mind.
RJ
It's all good.
Brian
Happens all the time.
Megan
Sell your car the convenient way to Carvana, pick up. Times may vary and fees may apply.
Helping Friendly Podcast - Episode: Mt. Rushmore: AC/DC Bag
Release Date: August 13, 2025
The episode begins with the hosts, Brian, Megan, and RJ, welcoming listeners back to the Helping Friendly Podcast (HFPod). They acknowledge their dedicated listeners and power listeners of the week, highlighting Tony for reaching 380 Instagram followers and giving a shoutout to the Blue Sky community for creating impressive statistical graphs related to the podcast's discussions.
Brian [00:32]: "It is Mount Rushmore time and today, today is a CDC bag."
Megan [01:39]: "If you like math and you like nerdy fish stuff, you need to follow Age of POD on Blue Sky."
The primary focus of the episode centers on selecting the top four performances of the song "AC/DC Bag" by Phish, effectively creating a "Mount Rushmore" of the song's best renditions. The hosts delve deep into the history, variations, and significance of different live performances, aiming to determine which versions deserve a spot on this prestigious list.
This version is lauded as a groundbreaking performance where "AC/DC Bag" transitions into an expansive 25-minute jam. The band explores diverse musical landscapes, incorporating elements reminiscent of Machine Gun, Hendrix, and Miles Davis. This rendition signifies a pivotal moment where Phish showcased their ability to transform a straightforward rock tune into an intricate, exploratory jam.
Brian [14:26]: "This is like Fish in peak power era. It's just unbelievable and significant because it's really the first time it's really stretched out like that."
Megan [04:12]: "It feels like we've been busy. It feels like it's been a long time."
Considered by the hosts as one of the best Phish shows ever, this version contrasts the sprawling jam of Hampton with a more rhythmically tight and groove-oriented performance. The band exhibits exceptional cohesion, blending elements of Euro dance grooves with live rock dynamics, creating a seamless and captivating experience for the audience.
RJ [31:31]: "This is number second best show of all time. So number second best show of all time."
Megan [34:39]: "This is like subterranean jam sessions. This is like, what does the minor key do to a man?"
The Boise Bag is celebrated as one of Phish's most beloved jams. This rendition is praised for its multi-sectional approach, blending various styles and maintaining a perfect narrative arc. The hosts recount personal anecdotes and emotional connections to this version, highlighting its significance in both musical complexity and fan impact.
RJ [45:47]: "This jam goes through like eight different styles of music. You've got that like CD groove based, 97 Hades energy to it."
Megan [48:01]: "It has the most perfect narrative arc of any jam that Fish has ever played."
Representing the modern era, the Bethel version showcases Phish's evolved tightness and dynamic range. This performance is lauded for its commanding presence, intricate repetition, and seamless blend of melodic grooves with ambient sections. The hosts emphasize how this version encapsulates Phish's growth and their ability to maintain excellence over decades.
Brian [57:45]: "This was a hard one for me to leave off and I just find it so beautiful and I love how minimal it is."
Megan [58:52]: "It's on my list, too. I think it's incredible."
The episode addresses the fan voting process for selecting the top four versions. While some listeners advocate for including specific performances due to their historical context or personal significance, the hosts maintain their selections based on musical excellence and the transformative nature of each jam. They discuss the challenges of balancing fan expectations with their criteria for the Mount Rushmore selections.
RJ [64:42]: "I can't. Part of the reason it's, I think the best Fish jam ever is it's so singular."
Brian [62:01]: "We had the 11/21/97, 12/30/97, and then there was a tie for third."
As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on the exceptional nature of "AC/DC Bag" and its role in Phish's legacy. They tease the next episode, which will focus on "Sigma Oasis," and encourage listeners to participate in voting and leave reviews on Apple Podcasts. The hosts express excitement for upcoming discussions and continue to engage with their passionate fanbase.
Brian [68:03]: "So next week we're going to be back with Sigma Oasis Rushmore."
Megan [68:35]: "Can't wait. It's coming, guys. It's. Can't wait."
Brian [00:32]: "It is Mount Rushmore time and today, today is a CDC bag."
Megan [01:39]: "If you like math and you like nerdy fish stuff, you need to follow Age of POD on Blue Sky."
RJ [31:31]: "This is number second best show of all time. So number second best show of all time."
Megan [48:01]: "It has the most perfect narrative arc of any jam that Fish has ever played."
Brian [62:01]: "We had the 11/21/97, 12/30/97, and then there was a tie for third."
"AC/DC Bag" is a seminal song in Phish's live repertoire, with multiple versions that have left significant impacts on both the band and its fans.
The Hampton (11/21/97) and MSG (12/30/97) versions are celebrated for their expansive jamming and tight, groove-oriented performances, respectively.
The Boise (09/14/99) rendition is revered for its multi-sectional narrative and emotional depth, solidifying its place as a fan favorite.
The modern Bethel (08/11/24) performance showcases Phish's continued evolution and mastery in live jamming.
The selection process for the Mount Rushmore editions balances musical quality with fan engagement, highlighting the intricate relationship between the band and its audience.
This episode of the Helping Friendly Podcast offers an in-depth exploration of one of Phish's most iconic songs, "AC/DC Bag." Through passionate discussions, personal anecdotes, and detailed analyses of various live performances, the hosts provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the song's legacy and its essential moments. Whether you're a long-time fan or new to Phish's music, this episode is a treasure trove of insights and reflections on what makes "AC/DC Bag" a cornerstone of Phish's live shows.