Hillsdale Dialogues: Churchill’s The Second World War, Part Nine
Podcast: Hillsdale Dialogues
Host: Hugh Hewitt
Guest: Dr. Larry P. Arnn (President, Hillsdale College)
Date: October 27, 2025
Episode Overview
In this episode, Hugh Hewitt and Dr. Larry Arnn delve deeper into Winston Churchill’s The Second World War, focusing on the end of Chapter 9 and progressing into Chapters 10 and 11 of "The Gathering Storm." Major themes include the interplay between technological and industrial capacity in wartime, the dangers of appeasement, parallels between the 1930s and current geopolitics, the role of leadership and national resolve, and the lessons contemporary America and Europe can draw from Churchill’s era. They also touch on modern issues like the revival of manufacturing, demographic decline, and the state of Western alliances.
Key Discussion Points and Insights
1. Churchill, Science, and Military Readiness
- Radar Development and Quality vs. Quantity
- Churchill’s insistence on radar exemplified his belief that, when properly motivated, science can meet pressing military needs (00:30).
- Hewitt compares past British radar supremacy with the current U.S. advantage in military "quality," cautioning about adversaries’ "quantity."
"We have a qualitative edge in everything, but they have a quantitative edge in almost everything." – Hugh Hewitt (00:45)
- Dr. Arnn stresses that both quality and quantity are essential, and the resilience not to despair is crucial for leadership.
"If we try hard enough and we're willing to die for it, we can find a way to beat them. And that will involve both quality and quantity." – Dr. Arnn (02:32)
2. Manufacturing, Tech Leadership, and U.S. Revitalization
- American Revival and Industrial Policy
- Dr. Arnn reflects on recent American policy changes to boost manufacturing, reduce taxation, and foster independence and labor (03:22).
"There’s a major revival ... a revival of independence and energy and labor." – Dr. Arnn (03:27)
- Dr. Arnn reflects on recent American policy changes to boost manufacturing, reduce taxation, and foster independence and labor (03:22).
- Silicon Valley and Defense Tech
- Discussion of tech leaders (Marc Andreessen, Peter Thiel, Palmer Luckey) who bring innovation critical for U.S. competitive edge (04:40-09:55).
"China can't produce people like that because they just start inventing stuff ... They decided the important thing is to defend the country." – Dr. Arnn (07:17)
- The unique culture that enables American entrepreneurship contrasted with the stifling environment in autocratic rivals.
- Discussion of tech leaders (Marc Andreessen, Peter Thiel, Palmer Luckey) who bring innovation critical for U.S. competitive edge (04:40-09:55).
3. The Italian Problem, the Hoare-Laval Pact, and Weakness in Diplomacy
- Appeasement and Modern Parallels
- The Hoare-Laval Pact is likened to recent diplomatic blunders, notably the Iran nuclear deal, signaling Western weakness and emboldening adversaries (12:01).
"The bad guys watch the allegedly strong good guys, and they plan accordingly." – Hewitt (14:03)
- The Hoare-Laval Pact is likened to recent diplomatic blunders, notably the Iran nuclear deal, signaling Western weakness and emboldening adversaries (12:01).
- Modern Ukraine and Detaching Russia from China
- Arnn draws lessons for United States policy regarding how to manage Russia and China, advocating for the strategy of dividing adversaries rather than driving them together (12:53).
"Obviously it should be a high object of American policy to detach Russia and China from one another." – Dr. Arnn (12:56)
- Arnn draws lessons for United States policy regarding how to manage Russia and China, advocating for the strategy of dividing adversaries rather than driving them together (12:53).
- Public Sentiment and Moral Action
- Churchill’s observation that Britain sometimes acts out of pure principle—without material gain—a trait paralleled in America (16:15).
"The British nation from time to time gives way to waves of crusading sentiment. ... ready to fight for a cause or a theme just because it is convinced in its heart and its soul that it will not get any material advantage out of the conflict." – Churchill, quoted by Hewitt (16:15)
- Churchill’s observation that Britain sometimes acts out of pure principle—without material gain—a trait paralleled in America (16:15).
4. National Weakness, Leadership, and Accountability
- The Perils of Unpreparedness: Lessons from Baldwin and Merkel
- Comparisons between 1930s appeasers and recent leaders (Angela Merkel), critiquing their lack of vision (18:15).
"[Baldwin] was very devious, very calculating ... deeply aware of the things within her scope of understanding, but her scope of understanding is not wide enough." – Arnn (18:52-19:03)
- Comparisons between 1930s appeasers and recent leaders (Angela Merkel), critiquing their lack of vision (18:15).
- Churchill’s Recognition of Will and Gumption
- Even Baldwin recognized Churchill’s unique resolve, unlike Chamberlain or Halifax who failed to grasp the necessity of strong leadership.
5. British Politics, Farage, and the Future of Populism
- Churchill’s Presence in the British Consciousness
- Dr. Arnn recounts a meeting at the British embassy where historical knowledge of Churchill impresses the British political elite (20:43-22:50).
- Rise of Nigel Farage and European Realignments
- Discussion about Farage as a populist leader, his exceptionalism, and parallels to Trump’s political movement in the United States.
"He’s amazing. ... you can see why he's popular with ordinary folk and you can see why Tory people don't take him seriously." – Dr. Arnn (24:13)
- The prospect of coalition-building between right-populist and traditional conservative factions in Britain as a necessary strategy (23:06-25:10).
- Discussion about Farage as a populist leader, his exceptionalism, and parallels to Trump’s political movement in the United States.
6. The Rhineland Crisis and the Failure to Resist
- Why the Rhineland Mattered
- Explanation of the strategic and symbolic importance of the Rhineland (28:06), how Hitler’s gambit emboldened Nazi expansion, and how lack of resistance increased his power.
"If they were resisted, they were to retreat. ... Hitler was very tentative about it and many thought he was being foolish." – Dr. Arnn (28:06)
- Explanation of the strategic and symbolic importance of the Rhineland (28:06), how Hitler’s gambit emboldened Nazi expansion, and how lack of resistance increased his power.
- Churchill’s Record and Legacy
- Clarification that Churchill was not in power during the key Nazi aggressions, countering revisionist history (29:23-30:09).
7. Courage, Weakness and Treason
- France’s Failed Response and Churchill’s Principle
- Flandin, the lone French voice for resistance during the Rhineland crisis, is praised by Churchill postwar, who distinguishes between weakness and treason.
"Weakness is not treason, though it may be equally disastrous." – Churchill, quoted by Hewitt (31:37)
- Dr. Arnn underlines the fragmentation and lack of unity among the Western democracies that enabled Nazi aggression (31:44-33:07).
- Flandin, the lone French voice for resistance during the Rhineland crisis, is praised by Churchill postwar, who distinguishes between weakness and treason.
8. Demographics, Decline, and Revival
- Collapse and Regeneration of the West
- Arnn and Hewitt discuss Mark Steyn’s demographic warning: that Western societies are not reproducing and risk irrelevance, while societies with hope have more children (33:46-37:24).
"The people in the world who are having babies are Arabs and all over Africa. ... Europeans and Americans are not having babies." – Dr. Arnn, paraphrasing Steyn (33:46)
- Hope and faith are cited as sources of vitality; revival in work, family, and faith are necessary for the West’s future.
"The west is a challenge to people to live fully human lives in light of the commandments of God and the natural law. And if we don't live that way, we won't keep or deserve our freedom." – Dr. Arnn (36:24)
- Arnn and Hewitt discuss Mark Steyn’s demographic warning: that Western societies are not reproducing and risk irrelevance, while societies with hope have more children (33:46-37:24).
Notable Quotes and Memorable Moments
-
On Americans and Doing the Right Thing
"Churchill said the Americans will always do the right thing after they've tried everything else." – Dr. Arnn (05:45)
-
On Innovation and Freedom
"China can't produce people like [Thiel, Lucky, Karp] because they just start inventing stuff ... They decided the important thing is to defend the country." – Dr. Arnn (07:30)
-
On Weakness vs. Treason
"Weakness is not treason, though it may be equally disastrous." – Churchill, quoted by Hewitt (31:37)
-
On Demographics and the Future
"Countries that are alive with hope have many, many children. They just do. And countries that despair don't." – Hewitt (37:24)
Key Timestamps for Important Segments
- 00:45 – Hewitt introduces the radar discussion, military quality vs. quantity
- 02:32 – Dr. Arnn responds on the necessity of both quality and quantity
- 04:40-09:55 – Dialog on American industrial revival and Silicon Valley innovation
- 12:01 – Hoare-Laval Pact compared to modern diplomatic blunders
- 14:03 – Hewitt on signaling strength and appeasement
- 16:15 – Churchill’s observation on British and American selfless action
- 18:15-19:03 – Analysis of Stanley Baldwin, Merkel, and the perils of narrow vision
- 20:43-22:50 – Dr. Arnn’s British embassy encounter and Churchill scholarship
- 23:06-25:10 – Farage, Tory coalition discussion, and European populism
- 28:06 – Importance of the Rhineland
- 29:23-30:09 – Clarification of Churchill’s role before WWII
- 31:37 – Churchill’s distinction between weakness and treason
- 33:46-37:24 – Demographic decline and Western revival
Tone and Style
The conversation is candid, intellectually robust, occasionally humorous, and steeped in historical analogies. Both speakers use contemporary references and draw lessons from history while remaining conversational and approachable.
Next Up
The next episode promises a deep dive into the Spanish Civil War and the British abdication crisis, linking these events to Churchill’s wilderness years and his eventual return to power.
For more episodes and resources, visit Hillsdale Dialogues or search “Hillsdale Dialogues” wherever you get your podcasts.