Podcast Summary: History As It Happens – "D-Day in Film" Episode Released on June 6, 2025

Host: Martin Di Caro
Guest: Kevin Ruane, BI Fellow of Churchill College, University of Cambridge, and Professor Emeritus at Canterbury Christ Church University
Contributor: Julie Andrews

Introduction

In the June 6, 2025 episode of History As It Happens, host Martin Di Caro delves into the cinematic portrayal of one of history’s most pivotal events: D-Day. Joined by historian Kevin Ruane and acclaimed actress Julie Andrews, the discussion navigates the intersection of film, history, and public perception, exploring how movies shape our understanding of war and its realities.

The Role of War Films in Shaping Historical Perception

Martin Di Caro opens the conversation by posing critical questions about the nature of war films: “Can movies mirror the reality of war? Should war movies be entertaining? In what ways does film influence our attitudes or perceptions of the past as individuals, as a culture?”

Julie Andrews reflects on her upbringing in the 1960s and 70s, highlighting the dominance of World War II narratives in media:

“Nearly all those movies will have heroic World War II exploits at the heart of them. … It was kind of subliminally, kind of like osmosis.”
(02:45)

Kevin Ruane adds that films like "The Longest Day" and "Saving Private Ryan" have significantly influenced public interest in World War II, particularly the "Greatest Generation." He reminisces:

“The first D Day movie I saw was, yep, you guessed it, The Longest Day. … It seems so realistic, so convincing.”
(04:00)

Analysis of Key War Films

"The Longest Day"

Julie Andrews praises "The Longest Day" for its epic scope and authenticity:

“It was an all-star cast … I still think it holds up and it would be in my top six.”
(15:05)

Ruane appreciates the film’s realistic portrayal, contrasting it with more fantastical representations:

“They treat the Germans like intelligent people. They’re not just a bunch of oafs and incompetent bumblers.”
(16:00)

"Saving Private Ryan"

The discussion shifts to Steven Spielberg’s "Saving Private Ryan", noted for its graphic depiction of D-Day:

“The opening battle sequence is simply unforgettable. The closing battle sequence was also scintillating.”
(03:45)

Ruane critiques the film’s focus on small unit combat, arguing it misrepresents the broader scope of World War II:

“World War II, the largest war ever fought … Small unit combat does not decide the outcome of war.”
(27:31)

Julie Andrews acknowledges Spielberg’s intention to convey anti-war sentiments through intense realism:

“The movie is black, it’s cynical, it’s very funny. … It’s in the vanguard of anti war movies.”
(24:00)

The Complexity of Historical Representation in Cinema

Ruane and Andrews explore the balance between historical accuracy and cinematic appeal. Andrews asserts:

“Filmmakers who make films about history … have some obligation … to get things as right as possible.”
(52:25)

Conversely, Ruane highlights the challenges filmmakers face in portraying the multifaceted nature of war without oversimplifying:

“Imagine a D Day film that focuses solely on the suffering of French civilians. … Directors are making choices about the message they want to send.”
(25:00)

Exploration of Anti-War Films

The conversation delves into films that challenge traditional war narratives. Ruane mentions "Overlord" (1975) as an example of an early anti-war film:

“It is about the utter bleakness of sacrifice … it’s dark and it’s troubling.”
(20:42)

Andrews introduces "The Americanization of Emily" (1964), highlighting its unconventional stance for its time:

“One of the main themes of the movie is that cowardice can sometimes be a noble thing.”
(55:30)

British versus American Perspectives in War Films

Ruane raises questions about the British role in World War II as depicted in films:

“How important was it for your people to look back on this war the way it's often depicted?”
(35:34)

Andrews provides historical context, explaining Britain’s post-war reluctance to join European federal constructs and how this influenced cinematic narratives:

“Movies coming out after 1945 are supportive of ‘we are still a great power’ narrative … nobody was ready to accept the reality of decline.”
(36:28)

Personal Narratives and Emotional Impact

The speakers emphasize the power of personal stories in war films to evoke emotional responses. Andrews discusses the impact of "The Great Escaper" (2023), portraying a poignant tale of an elderly British sailor’s journey to Normandy:

“It is poignant, it is beautifully observed … it is about dealing with the past, past trauma, but it is also full of hope.”
(59:29)

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of D-Day Films

Martin Di Caro wraps up the episode by acknowledging the continued relevance of D-Day films in shaping historical consciousness:

“We’re seeing a lot of gore … Saving Private Ryan makes any list of the best D Day movies.”
(25:47)

Ruane agrees, noting that while films often emphasize heroism and sacrifice, they sometimes overlook the broader and more chaotic realities of war:

“War should always disgust us. … We’re seeing a lot of gore, … but that’s only part of the picture.”
(20:14)

Julie Andrews concludes by highlighting the diverse range of war narratives and their reflection of contemporary societal moods:

“Movies clearly reflect the popular mood in which they are made … So we need to be mindful of when these movies are made.”
(48:17)

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Julie Andrews (02:45): “It was kind of subliminally, kind of like osmosis.”
• Kevin Ruane (05:26): “But what's left out of these movies is what I think about now as much as what's in them.”
• Julie Andrews (15:05): “… I still think it holds up and it would be in my top six.”
• Kevin Ruane (16:00): “They treat the Germans like intelligent people. They’re not just a bunch of oafs and incompetent bumblers.”
• Julie Andrews (24:00): “It’s in the vanguard of anti war movies.”
• Kevin Ruane (25:00): “Directors are making choices about the message they want to send.”
• Julie Andrews (55:30): “The main theme is that cowardice can sometimes be a noble thing.”

Final Thoughts

The episode intricately weaves historical analysis with cinematic critique, offering listeners a comprehensive understanding of how D-Day has been represented in film. By examining both mainstream and anti-war movies, History As It Happens provides valuable insights into the enduring legacy of World War II cinema and its role in shaping collective memory and perception.

For more detailed discussions and historical insights, subscribe to Martin Di Caro's newsletter at historyasithappens.com or find the podcast on your preferred platform, with new episodes airing every Tuesday and Friday.